Full Order Text
Final Order 1 · 01 Aug 2025 · CNR MHCC010098602025
Order Details: Notice of Motion Pdf Text: MHCC010098602025 IN THE BOMBAY CITY CIVIL COURT AT BOMBAY. NOTICE OF MOTION NO.3926 OF 2025 IN L. C. SUIT NO.1604 OF 2025 M/s. Sweet Bengal Through its proprietor Mr. Deepak Kumar Chopra … PLAINTIFF Versus Municipal Corporation of Greater Mumbai and others. … DEFENDANTS APPEARANCES : Mr. Shobhit Shukla, Advocate for the Plaintiff. Mrs. Sangita Honmane, Advocate for Defendants/MCGM. CORAM : AMIT ANANT LAULKAR, JUDGE COURT ROOM NO.04 DATED : 01st AUGUST, 2025 ORDER 1. In instant sequel proceeding, being disgruntled with notice dated 08.07.2025 issued in pursuance of earlier notice dated 20.04.2024 vide section 351 of the MMC Act, and subsequent speaking order dated 19.09.2024, the plaintiff herein preferred present suit for declaration and injunction wherein instant notice of motion was moved vide Order 39 Rule 1 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908. -- 1 of 7 -- (2) 2. Per plaintiff, as regards suit property is concerned, they were cited with notice under section 351 of the MMC Act, followed by speaking order for demolition thereto. Subsequently, they bounced back with their reply to the MCGM and eventually, placed their proposal for regularization of notice structure. Said proposal was placed online with building proposal department by following all mandatory requisites. It is urged by the plaintiff that, the building proposal department issued further particular letter dated 23.10.2024 and returned the regularization proposal to the architect of the plaintiff. The plaintiff submits that his proposal for regularization is still pending with AE (Maintenance) of defendant and thus, it is not rejected with reasoned orders. The pendency of said proposal is highlighted on the official portal of defendant/MCGM. The file is displayed and thus, the regularization proposal is still pending. In the backdrop, issuance of impugned notice for removal of notice structure is bad in law. On all these counts, plaintiff knocked the doors of this court with instant suit. 3. As on today, Mr. Shobhit Shukla, learned Advocate for the plaintiff, submitted that without indulging into merits of the impugned notice, at the outset, it is to be seen and verified that his/her proposal for regularization is still pending and in view of ad-interim order passed in earlier round of litigation, the notice structure is protected. Said order is annexed with the plaint. On that count, he implored that regularization proposal is still pending and thus, defendant/MCGM cannot initiate any action as regard notice structure is concerned. Eventually, he prayed for ad-interim reliefs in terms of prayer clauses 'b' and 'c' of the Motion and oblige. -- 2 of 7 -- Order (3) Notice of Motion No.3926/2025 In L.C. Suit No.1604/2025 4. Post service of notice, defendant MCGM caused appearance before this Court and tendered short reply cum affidavit along with documents to oppose ad-interim reliefs. Learned Advocate Mrs. Sangita Honmane, appearing for the defendant loudly pinpointed letter dated 23.10.2024, addressed to the architect of the plaintiff thereby informing the rejection of his/her proposal for regularization so also the screen shot of status-flow of said regularization proposal appearing on the official portal of the defendant i.e. AutoCAD followed by recent letter dated 13.06.2025, issued by Executive Engineer (Building Proposal Department) thereby informing that regularization proposal of the plaintiff is already rejected and same is uploaded on online AutoDCR system. Finally, she prayed for rejection of the reliefs in liminee. 5. Heard both sides. I have pore over entire record minutely. 6. Having considered rival submissions made across the bar, it is apparent that both parties are in juxtaposition as regards pendency of regularization proposal of the plaintiff with defendant/MCGM. To that effect, upon inquiry, Mr. Pankaj Meher, Sub Engineer, (SE) Building and Factory Department, M-West Ward, who was present in the court, clarified that due to non-compliances the regularization proposal moved by the plaintiff is rejected by Building Proposal Department vide their order dated 23.10.2024 which is duly communicated to the architect of the plaintiff. He further highlighted that said proposal is not pending with building proposal department and to that effect, they have fortified with their recent letter dated 13.06.2025. Learned Advocate for the defendant also conceded to the fact that the plaintiff's proposal is duly rejected long way back for the want of compliances. Barring all -- 3 of 7 -- (4) assertions, the letters referred hereinbefore, are also not disputed by the plaintiff. Those letters categorically suggest the factum of rejection of plaintiff's proposal for regularization of notice structure. However, at the same time, if the winding up lines of the said letter dated 23.10.2024 are scanned minutely then it gives short set back to the contention of the defendants that the proposal is out-rightly rejected on all counts. For better understanding those lines are reproduced hereinbelow “The proposal submitted with all requisite documents and compliance will only be considered and process as per its merits.” In letter dated 23.10.2024, Building Proposal Department intimated rejection of the regularization proposal of the plaintiff for the non compliance of the points detailed in the said letter at Serial Nos.1 to 10. While concluding said letter they quoted aforesaid lines. Those lines primarily suggest and carried inference that if the plaintiff submit all requisite documents as detailed in aforesaid letter at Serial Nos.1 to 10 and if, he/she complies then it will be considered and processed as per its merits. If the proposal is already rejected, then under what contingency such requisite documents as well as compliances are expected by the Building Proposal Department, is having shades of doubt suggestive of nothing but condition for revival of the proposal. If the proposal is not alive and rejected then it must leave such impression upon online AutoDCR system, which surprisingly not visible in instant case in hand. The file for proposal must show finality upon online AutoDCR system and none would get access furthermore, but it is not the factual position so far. If the proposal is pending with certain other departments of the defendant for securing different sanctions, then it cannot be said that proposal is out-rightly rejected, specially -- 4 of 7 -- Order (5) Notice of Motion No.3926/2025 In L.C. Suit No.1604/2025 when it gets revived and shows reflection in status flow over online AutoDCR system. Thus, having considered entire scenario so also the recent screen shots of the status of plaintiff's proposal for regularization derived from official domain of MCGM as displayed and uploaded on online AutoDCR system annexed herewith the plaint, I believe, there is no other inference can be drawn than that the proposal is still pending awaiting for certain compliances to be done by the plaintiff and eventually evaluated by Building Proposal Department and process it as per its merits. Aforesaid screen shot of online AutoDCR system annexed herewith the plaint, unveils that recently on 20/03/2025 the Survey Department of the defendant has cleared the survey approval. This aspects speaks for itself . Be that it may be, a chance needs to be given to the plaintiff to reveal in what manner his /her proposal for regularization is still pending or else the very purpose of the suit as well as of earlier protection would get infractuous. 7. In such peculiar contingency, especially when the notice structure is protected in earlier round of litigation till final disposal of regularization proposal, prima facie, I perceive there is iota of merit in the version posed by the plaintiff. Without indulging into merits of the Notice of Motion, on its prima facie evaluation of status of regularization proposal, the notice structure deserves protection. Even there is no separate order passed by the Building Proposal Department thereby declaring that said proposal is rejected without leaving behind any off-shoots thereof. 8. Indeed, Pending such proposal, it cast equal duty/ obligation upon the plaintiff or proposer to comply all relevant -- 5 of 7 -- (6) formalities along with documentation within stipulated period and act vigilantly. 9. At the moment, this Court is of the opinion to put time limits and allied cap's upon the parties for considering the regularization proposal to which learned Advocate for the defendant/ MCGM fairly agreed and conceded to that effect. 10. As regards, regularization proposal of the plaintiff is concerned, if any, he/she is directed to submit with all requisite documents and carry out compliances within Twelve Weeks from the date of this order. Subject to the filing of all requisite documents and considering those compliances, the defendants/MCGM shall decide the same within four weeks thereafter. Till that period, no effect shall be given to the impugned notice dated 08.07.2025. In the event, result of the regularization application is adverse to the plaintiff, the impugned notice and the order impugned in the suit shall not be implemented for a period of two weeks from the date of decision of regularization application. Both parties shall place status report of said proposal before this Court on next date. Deviation, if any, in preceding time frame would entail adverse action against notice structure, without any further reference to this court. 11. The Notice of Motion is disposed of in aforesaid terms as there remains nothing to ponder over further. Both parties to take note of this order. (Amit Anant Laulkar) Judge, Date : 01.08.2025 City Civil Court, Mumbai. -- 6 of 7 -- Order (7) Notice of Motion No.3926/2025 In L.C. Suit No.1604/2025 “CERTIFIED TO BE TRUE AND CORRECT COPY OF THE ORIGINAL SIGNED ORDER.” 02.08.2025 3.45 p.m. Shilpa P. Pawar Stenographer - Grade IUPLOAD DATE TIME Name of the Judge (With Court Room No.) H. H. Judge Shri. Amit A. Laulkar Court Room No. 4. Date of Pronouncement of ORDER 01.08.2025 ORDER signed by P. O. on 02.08.2025 ORDER uploaded on 02.08.2025 -- 7 of 7 --
