Full Order Text
Final Order 1 · 23 Sept 2025 · CNR MHCC010097122025
Order Details: Copy of Judgment Pdf Text: ... 1 … Order on TA No.209-2025 MHCC010097122025 Presented on : 16.07.2025 Registered on : 22.07.2025 Decided on : 23.09.2025 Duration : 00 02 07 Years Months Days IN THE CITY CIVIL AND SESSIONS COURT FOR GREATER BOMBAY, AT BOMBAY TRANSFER APPLICATION NO. 209 OF 2025 IN SUIT NO. 3341 OF 2015 ALONG WITH SUIT NO. 1457 OF 2024 (HIGH COURT SUIT NO.398 OF 2019) (CNR NO.MHCC010097122025) 1 1(a) 1(b) 1(c) 1(d) Hubert Fonseca Aged : 85 years (since deceased) Through his legal heirs Sharon Maria Pinto Nee Fonseca Aged : 55 years, Occ : Service Residing at 10, Fluer Close, west Pennant Hills, NSW 2125, Australia Neil Nicholas Fonseca Aged : 54 years, Occ : Service 25, Grangewood Pl, West Pennant Hills, 2125, Australia Sheena Dorothy Elizabeth Gonsalves Nee Fonseca Aged : 48 years, Occ : Service. Residing at 47, Brendon Avenue, West Pennant Hills, 2125, Australia Mr. Norman Hubert Fonseca Residing at 6, Northwood way, Cherrybrook, NSW, 2126, Australia …. Applicants -- 1 of 5 -- ... 2 … Order on TA No.209-2025 Versus 1 2 Fausta Sathyasilan Aged : 47 years, Occ : Service. Anil Kumar Aged : 47 years, Occ : Service. Both residing at 13, Bandra Olympic CHSL, 3rd Floor, 16th Road, Bandra, Mumbai 400 050. ….Respondents CORAM : HIS HONOUR THE PRINCIPAL JUDGE, SHRI A.SUBRAMANIAM C.R.NO.. : 19 DATE : 23rd DAY OF SEPTEMBER, 2025 Appearances :- Ld. Adv. Mihir Kakade instructed by Jayakar Partners for applicants. Mr. Anil Kumar, Respondent/plaintiff No.2 in person ORAL ORDER 1. By present application the applicant is praying for consolidation of suit as well as for transfer of the suit from Mazgaon Court to Main Branch at Mumbai. 2. It is contended that the parties are same, the dispute of ownership of premises as well as execution of agreement is a common issue on both suits. It is contended that in such circumstances, there would be contrary findings. The nature of evidence is same in both the suits. Hence, it is pointed that suit should be consolidated. One of the suit came to be transferred to City Civil Court, Main Branch and another to Dindoshi Branch. 3. By reply and written arguments, it is contended that the suit cannot be transferred. It is nothing but diliatary tactic. Plaintiffs are vigilantly pursuing their rights. It is contended that there are different stages. Prayers are different. There is absence of legal -- 2 of 5 -- ... 3 … Order on TA No.209-2025 and factual issues. Considering same, they cannot be consolidated together. 4. Perused the application and reply. Heard both the sides and considered the submissions. 5. Having considered arguments and pleadings involved. After perusal of pleadings, it is seen that the issue involved is about Flat and its occupancy. There are issues of injunction and specific performance filed of the said flat and pleadings although are of different reliefs relate to the same. In such circumstances, two suits are pending before two courts. Parties are same, property is the same. In such circumstances, it is necessary to consider the Judgment of Chitivalasa Jute Mills V/s Jaypee Rewa Cement (2004) 3 Supreme Court Cases 85 wherein Hon’ble High Court held that if two suits are such that it saves multiplicity of proceedings, delay and expenses and similar documentary and oral evidence are there, suits can be consolidated as it is a practice. I keep this aspect of clubbing or consolidating of suits to Ld. Trial Court for consideration where the suits are pending. This is so because the trial court is which can properly assess as to whether nature of evidence is common or not. From the present pleadings, it is clear that parties are same and issues involved are of same property and relate to right of occupancy of the said property on different grounds or defence to occupation of said property. In such circumstances, the matters are required to be placed before one court as it will convenient for parties and for court to consider various aspects together and avoid different view in the orders passed. It will also restrict parties running to two courts for this litigation. Hence, both suits should be placed together. With this, I pass the following order. -- 3 of 5 -- ... 4 … Order on TA No.209-2025 O R D E R 1. Transfer Application No.209 of 2025 is allowed. 2. Suit No. 3341 of 2015 along with Notice of Motion and connected applications, if any, are herewith assigned to Court Room No.02 at Mumbai Main Br where Suit No.1457 of 2024 is pending. 3. It is clarified that this Court has not tagged or clubbed the suits together and discretion of tagging or clubbing the suits shall be with the Ld. Trial Court as per law. 4. Inform concerned courts. 5. Transfer application is disposed off accordingly. DATE : 23.09.2025 (A.SUBRAMANIAM) PRINCIPAL JUDGE CITY CIVIL COURT, MUMBAI. (JO CODE MH01711). Dictated and transcribed on : 23.09.2025 Checked and signed on : 23.09.2025 -- 4 of 5 -- ... 5 … Order on TA No.209-2025 "CERTIFIED TO BE TRUE AND CORRECT COPY OF THE ORIGINAL SIGNED JUDGMENT/ORDER" UPLOAD DATE AND TIME NAME OF STENOGRAPHER (Grade-III) DATE : 23.09.2025 at 06.00pm Mr. Mohit M. Patange Name of the Judge (with Court no.) : SHRI A.SUBRAMANIAM. C.R.NO.19. Date of pronouncement of judgment/order : 23.09.2025 Judgment/order signed by the P.O. on : 23.09.2025 Judgment/order uploaded on : 23.09.2025 -- 5 of 5 --
