Full Order Text
Final Order 1 · 14 Jan 2026 · CNR MHCC010095372025
Order Details: Copy of Judgment Pdf Text: ... 1 … Judgment in Misc. Appeal 117 of 2025 MHCC010095372025 Presented on : 14.07.2025 Registered on : 16.07.2025 Decided on : 14.01.2026 Duration : 00 06 00 Years Months Days Exh.10 IN THE COURT OF CITY CIVIL FOR GREATER BOMBAY, AT BOMBAY MISCELLANEOUS APPEAL NO. 117 OF 2025 Guruprasad M. Lahoti, Age : 61 years, Government Residence, Sub-Overseers Quarters No.5, Kaularu Baithi Chawl, Ganpat Jadhav Marg, Worli, Mumbai. …. Appellant Versus 1 2 Executive Engineer, Central Mumbai, Division (South Bombay), Ganpat Jadhav Marg, Worli, Mumbai. Deputy Collector and Competent Authority, Brihanmumbai Competent Authority u/s.2(a) of the Maharashtra Government Premises (Eviction) Act, 1955, Office No.404, 4th Floor, New D.D. Building, Old Custom House, S.B.S. Road, Fort, Mumbai. …. Respondents CORAM : HIS HONOUR THE PRINCIPAL JUDGE, SHRI SAMEER S. ADKAR . COURT ROOM NO.19 DATE : 14th DAY OF JANUARY, 2026 -- 1 of 10 -- ... 2 … Judgment in Misc. Appeal 117 of 2025 Appearance :- Ms. Devyani Kulkarni, learned Advocate for the appellant. Mr. Sachin Kadam (Govt. Pleader), learned Advocate for the respondents. J U D G M E N T 1. This is an appeal u/s.7 of the Maharashtra Government Premises (Eviction) Act, 1955. 2. By way of present appeal, the appellant is challenging the order passed by the respondent No.2-Competent Authority in Eviction Case No.26311 on 18.06.2025 allowing the application filed by the respondent No.1 for eviction of the appellant. 3. In brief, the facts of the case are that the property namely Quarter No.5, Kaularu Baithi Chawl, Ganpat Jadhav Marg, Worli, Mumbai (Hereinafter referred to as the “Enquiry premises”) belongs to the respondent No.1. The appellant was employed as a Deputy Engineer with the PWD Department. He was allotted the Enquiry premises as he was a Government servant. He retired on 30.11.2021 on attaining the age of superannuation. As per the rules, after the retirement, the appellant was entitled to retain the possession of the Enquiry premises for upto three months only on concessional rent. However, the appellant continued to remain in possession of the Enquiry premises even after his retirement. As the appellant was in unauthorized possession of the same, the respondent No.1 filed the eviction proceedings bearing Eviction Case No. 26311 u/s.4 r/w. Section 5 of the Maharashtra Government Premises (Eviction) Act, 1955 before the respondent No.2. The respondent No.2 issued the show-cause notice u/s.4(2) -- 2 of 10 -- ... 3 … Judgment in Misc. Appeal 117 of 2025 of the Maharashtra Government Premises (Eviction) Act, 1955 to the appellant. But the appellant failed to comply with the requirements of the same. Thereafter, the further proceedings were conducted by the respondent No.2. 4. After hearing both the sides and after considering the evidence on the record, the respondent No.2 allowed the Eviction Case No.26311. The appellant was directed to vacate the Enquiry premises and to pay penalty of Rs.32,68,075/- towards unauthorized occupation charges. Hence, this appeal. 5. Heard both the sides. Perused the record. 6. In the light of the facts of the case and the submissions made on behalf of the parties, following points arise for consideration and the findings thereon are recorded as under for the reasons to follow: SR.NO. POINTS FINDINGS 1. Whether it is proved that the appellant is in unauthorized possession of the Enquiry premises ? Yes. 2. Whether the order passed by the respondent No.2 in Eviction Case No.26311 on 18.06.2025 calls for any interference ? Yes. To the extent of amount towards penalty. 3. What order ? As per final order. -- 3 of 10 -- ... 4 … Judgment in Misc. Appeal 117 of 2025 REASONS AS TO POINT NOS.1 TO 3 : 7. It is not in dispute that the Enquiry premises belongs to the respondent No.1. It is also not in dispute that the Enquiry premises was allotted to the appellant as he was a Public Servant and he retired from his service on 30.11.2021. It is further not in dispute that after retirement the appellant was entitled to retain possession of the Enquiry premises for maximum of three months i.e. upto 28.02.2022 on making payment of the rent amount at concessional rate. 8. The appellant has challenged the order passed by the respondent No.2 on the following grounds : (i) that the appellant was entitled to retain the possession of the Enquiry premises till the alternate premises was allotted to the appellant as was proposed in the case of the other public servants who were residing in the adjoining building by name Savli Apartment in view of the Government Resolution dated 13.03.2016, 09.07.2021 and 28.01.2022. (ii) that the appellant and similarly situated persons had filed Writ Petition No.4874/2024 before the Hon’ble High Court of Bombay challenging the above Government Resolutions and praying that similar relief should be granted to them. The said Writ -- 4 of 10 -- ... 5 … Judgment in Misc. Appeal 117 of 2025 Petition was pending and a statement was made on behalf of respondent No.1 that the proposal of the appellant and others was under consideration by the State Government. (iii) that while imposing penalty, the respondent No.2 failed to appreciate the fact that the appellant had already paid the occupation charges amounting to Rs.19,375/- for the period from 01.12.2021 to 31.12.2022. (iv) that the respondent No.2 failed to consider that the respondent No.1 did not lead any evidence justifying the calculations for arriving at the amount of penalty which the appellant was directed to pay. (v) that the respondent No.2 could not have decided the proceedings as the Writ Petition No.4874/2024 filed by the appellant and others was pending before the Hon’ble High Court of Bombay. (vi) that no proper opportunity of hearing was given to the appellant before the impugned order was passed. (vii) that the appellant was victimized in the sense that the eviction proceedings were initiated against him only after he filed the Writ Petition No.4874/2024 before the Hon’ble High Court of -- 5 of 10 -- ... 6 … Judgment in Misc. Appeal 117 of 2025 Bombay. 9. It is not in dispute that earlier in view the Government Resolution dated 28.01.2022, it was decided to redevelop the Savli Apartment while carrying out the redevelopment of the Worli BDD Chawls. It was also decided that the Government Officers/Employees who were staying in the said Apartment as on 01.01.2011 shall be allotted redeveloped units of 500 sq.ft area on ownership basis for which only the construction cost would be charged. However, vide the Government Resolution dated 29.07.2025 which was filed on the record, the earlier Government Resolution dated 28.01.2022 has been cancelled. Therefore, the appellant cannot claim allotment of alternate premises on the basis of Government Resolutions which were issued earlier as the same are cancelled by a subsequent Government Resolution. 10. Insofar as the filing of Writ Petition No.4874/2024 by the appellant and similarly situated persons is concerned, it may be stated that in the said Writ Petition, the prayers were that the benefit of the Government Resolution dated 28.01.2022 be extended to the appellant and the other petitioners therein. As stated earlier vide Government Resolution dated 29.07.2025, the earlier Government Resolution dated 28.01.2022 has been cancelled. Further, the proceedings which were filed u/s. 4 and 5 of the Maharashtra Government Premises (Eviction) Act, 1955 before the respondent No.1 were independent proceedings. Therefore, the respondent No.2 had the jurisdiction to decide the same. -- 6 of 10 -- ... 7 … Judgment in Misc. Appeal 117 of 2025 11. Insofar as the contention of the appellant that the respondent No.2 failed to consider that there was no material to justify the calculations for arriving at the amount of penalty which the appellant was directed to pay is concerned, it may be stated that the Enquiry premises is situated at Worli, Mumbai. As per the Government Resolution dated 16.12.2016 which was filed on the record, this area falls under ‘X’ category of the cities (MCGM). As per the Government Resolution dated 01.06.2018 which was filed on the record, the penalty for unauthorized occupation in that area is @ Rs.150/- per sq.ft per month. The perusal of the order passed by the respondent No.2 shows that the penalty has been imposed by taking into consideration the provisions of the Government Resolution dated 01.06.2018. Therefore, the contention raised by the appellant has no merit. 12. Insofar as the contention that no proper opportunity of hearing was given to the appellant before the impugned order was passed by the respondent No.2 is concerned, the perusal of the impugned order shows that the written arguments were filed on behalf of the appellant and thereafter on 16.06.2025 arguments of both the sides were heard. Therefore, there is no merit in the contention raised by the appellant. 13. The learned Advocate for the appellant also submitted that the appellant was victimized as the proceedings were filed against him only after he alongwith others had filed Writ Petition No.4874/2024 before the Hon’ble High Court seeking extension of benefit of the Government Resolution dated 28.01.2022. The -- 7 of 10 -- ... 8 … Judgment in Misc. Appeal 117 of 2025 said submission has no merit because as stated earlier, the Government Resolution dated 28.01.2022 has now been cancelled by the subsequent Government Resolution dated 29.07.2025. 14. The perusal of the impugned order shows that the appellant has been directed to pay total penalty of Rs.32,68,075/- for the unauthorized possession of the Enquiry premises for the period from 01.12.2021 to 31.05.2025. However, while calculating the said amount the respondent No.2 failed to take into consideration the fact that the appellant had already deposited an amount of Rs.19,375/- as occupation charges for the period from 01.12.2021 to 31.12.2022. Therefore, the respondent No.2 could not have directed the appellant to pay the penalty for the period for which the amount was already paid. Hence, that part of the order passed by the respondent No.2 cannot be sustained. 15. In view of the above, it is clear that the appellant is in unauthorized possession of the Enquiry Premises. Therefore, the respondent No.2 rightly directed the eviction of the appellant from the Enquiry premises. Insofar as the amount of penalty to be paid by the appellant is concerned, the respondent No.2 failed to appreciate the fact that the appellant had already paid the amount of penalty for the period from 01.12.2021 to 31.12.2022. Therefore, that part of the order passed by the respondent No.2 will have to be interfered with. Hence, Point No.1 is answered in the affirmative, Point No.2 is answered partly in the affirmative and the following order is passed : -- 8 of 10 -- ... 9 … Judgment in Misc. Appeal 117 of 2025 O R D E R 1. Misc. Appeal No.117 of 2025 is partly allowed. 2. The order passed by the respondent No.2 directing the eviction of the appellant from the Enquiry premises is confirmed. 3. The appellant is directed to pay the amount of Rs.32,48,700/- (Rupees Thirty Two Lakhs Forty Eight Thousand and Seven Hundred only) (Rs.32,68,075/- - Rs.19,375/-) as penalty towards the unauthorized possession of the Enquiry premises. 4. Record and Proceedings be returned to the respondent. DATE : 14.01.2026 (S. S. ADKAR) PRINCIPAL JUDGE CITY CIVIL COURT, MUMBAI. -- 9 of 10 -- ... 10 … Judgment in Misc. Appeal 117 of 2025 "CERTIFIED TO BE TRUE AND CORRECT COPY OF THE ORIGINAL SIGNED JUDGMENT/ORDER" UPLOAD DATE AND TIME NAME OF STENOGRAPHER (Grade-I) Date : 14.01.2026 at 06.00pm Mr. Mohit M. Patange Name of the Judge (with Court no.) : SHRI S. S. ADKAR. C.R.NO.19. Date of pronouncement of judgment/order : 14.01.2026 Judgment/order signed by the P.O. on : 14.01.2026 Judgment/order uploaded on : 14.01.2026 -- 10 of 10 --
