Full Order Text
Final Order 2 · 04 May 2024 · CNR MHCC010094712023
Order Details: Copy of Judgment Pdf Text: S.C. SUIT NO. 2208-2023 1 Judgment MHCC010094712023 Presented on : 06-09-2023 Registered on : 13-09-2023 Decided on : 04-05-2024 Duration : 0 years, 7 months, 28 days IN THE BOMBAY CITY CIVIL COURT AT MUMBAI S.C. SUIT NO. 2208 OF 2023 Exhibit No.: Kalpana Nikesh Pandya. ] age 70 years, Occ:Retired, ] Residing at 30 Banganga Cross Lane, ] Opp. Sanskrit Pathshala, Walkeshwar,] Mumbai-400 006. ] ...Plaintiff Versus 1. The State of Maharashtra ] 2. The Senior Inspector of Police ] Missing Person Bureau, ] Crime Branch, Crawford Market ] Mumbai. ] 3. The Senior Inspector of Police ] Gandhi Nagar Police Station ] Gujarat. ] 4. Municipal Corporation of Gr. ] Mumbai, Mahapalika Bhavan, ] Mahapalika Marg, C.S.T. Mumbai, ] Through Asst. Municipal ] Commissioner, F/South Ward, ] M.C.G.M, Mumbai . ] ...Defendants. -- 1 of 8 -- S.C. SUIT NO. 2208-2023 2 Judgment Appearances:- Ld. Advocate R.A. Shaikh for Plaintiff. Ld. Advocate Khatib for Defendant No.1,2 and 3. Ld. Advocate Chandramore for Defendant No.4. CORAM : V. G. RAGHUWANSHI JUDGE, (C.R.NO.08) DATE : 04/05/2024 JUDGMENT 1) This is a suit for declaration that Jagdish Krishnaprasad Joshi is dead. Plaintiff submits that Jagdish Krishnaprasad Joshi was her brother. He was residing at 30, Banganga Cross Lane, Opp. Sanskrit Pathshala, Walkeshwar, Mumbai-06. Jagdish Krishnaprasad Joshi left home on 5-6-1994 to visit his cousin at Rashmikkananbhai Ochhavalal Derasari, resident of Sector 16, Block 95/1, Gandhi Nagar in Gujarat. He travelled through a bus of Punjab travel company having its office at Khetwadi. Plaintiff's brother Jagdish boarded the bus, but he did not reach his cousin's house in Gandhi Nagar, Gujarat. Therefore, husband of plaintiff's cousin Rashmikkananbhai lodged missing report at Gandhi Nagar police station, Gujarat on 16-6-1994. Police recorded missing report bearing No.249/1994. 2) Thereafter, police tried their best to search Jagdish. They could not find him. Plaintiff submitted that vigorous and continuous efforts were made to search Jagdish by plaintiff and her relatives, but his whereabouts are not known till today. Police issued certificate of missing person on 16-6-1994. Plaintiff made all possible efforts to search her brother, but all went in vein. Now she lost hope of her brother returning home and she believes that her brother may not be alive. Plaintiff made up her mind to -- 2 of 8 -- S.C. SUIT NO. 2208-2023 3 Judgment accept the fact that her brother may not be alive and applied for declaration of his death. 3) Plaintiff is only legal heir/representative of class I mentioned in schedule to Hindu Succession Act 1956, by which missing person and plaintiff were governed. Her brother Jagdish went missing on 5-6-1994, he is not found and heard of by plaintiff or other persons who would naturally have heard of Jagdish if he had been alive. Therefore, presumption under section 108 of Indian Evidence Act would arise about death of Jagdish. Plaintiff served notice upon State and Mumbai Municipal Corporation before filing this suit. She prayed for declaration of civil death of Jagdish Krishnaprasad Joshi and mandatory injunction to Municipal Council of Greater Mumbai to take entry about civil death of Jagdish Krishnaprasad Joshi and issue his death certificate. 4) Defendant No. 1 to 3 filed their written statement (Exh.8). Defendant No.4 did not file its written statement. Defendant No.1 to 3 submitted that this court has no jurisdiction to try this suit. Suit is misconceived and bad in law. It is not maintainable as plaintiff failed to serve notice under section 80 of C.P.C. There is no cause of action against plaintiff. Missing complaint was lodged in Gandhi Nagar police station, Gujarat bearing registration No.249/1994 dtd. 16-6-1994. No missing complaint was lodged with defendant No. 3. If such complaint had been lodged with defendant No.3, it would have been forwarded to defendant No.2 and telecasted on Doordarshan channel. As complaint is not lodged in any local police station there is no record with these defendants. Defendants prayed for dismissing the suit. 5) Having perused rival contentions following issues were framed. I have recorded my findings against each of them for the reasons to -- 3 of 8 -- S.C. SUIT NO. 2208-2023 4 Judgment follows:- SR.NO. ISSUES DECISION 1. Whether plaintiff proves that, Jagdish Krishnaprasad Joshi is missing from 5-6- 1994? In The Affirmative 2. Whether the plaintiff proves that Jagdish Krishnaprasad Joshi was not traceable in spite all efforts? In The Affirmative 3. Whether the plaintiff proves that Jagdish Krishnaprasad Joshi was not heard of by the people who would have heard of him for more than 7 years? In The Affirmative 4. Whether plaintiff is entitled to reliefs claimed? Partly In The Affirmative 5. What order? As Per Final Order 6) Plaintiff in order to prove her contentions examined herself as witness. She filed her ration card (Exh.12), second original LTC certificate dtd.5-6-1994 (Exh.13), original certificate dtd.19-6- 1994 issued by Sr. PI of Gandhi Nagar police station, Gujarat (Exh.14), original notice under section 80 of C.P.C. and original reply dtd 7-10-2023 sent by Sujit Pawar, PI of Malbar Hill police station and statement recorded by Sujitkumar Pawar of Malbar -- 4 of 8 -- S.C. SUIT NO. 2208-2023 5 Judgment Hill police station (Exh.15 Colly), copy of notice under section 527 of Mumbai Municipal Corporation Act (Exh.16) alongwith original reply dtd.11-7-2023 and 7-11-2023 (Exh.16 Colly and Exh.17), original certificate issued by Gandhi Nagar police station alongwith its translation (Exh.18). Defendants did not enter witness box to support their defence. AS TO ISSUE NO.1 TO 3:- 7) Plaintiff Kalpana reiterated her contentions in her affidavit of examination in chief. She stated that she is sister of Jagdish Krishnaprasad Joshi. They were residing at 30, Banganga Cross Lane, Opp. Sanskrit Pathshala, Walkeshwar, Mumbai-06. He went missing while traveling from Mumbai to Gandhi Nagar on 5-6- 1994. Plaintiff made all efforts to search him. Plaintiff's brother in law lodged report in police station Gandhi Nagar on 16-6-1994 and a missing case No.249/1994 was registered in Gandhi Nagar police station. Inspite of all efforts by family and police Jagdish Joshi could not be fished out. He was not seen or heard of during this entire period and therefore, a presumption would arise that he is no more. 8) Plaintiff was cross examined by Ld. Counsel for State and Ld. Counsel for Mumbai Municipal Corporation. Nothing was brought on record to show that she was deposing falsely. On the contrary, documents filed by plaintiff proved that plaintiff's brother in law lodged report that Jagdish Joshi was missing and inspite of all efforts police could not search him. Thus, it is proved that Jagdish is missing from 5-6-1994 and he is not traceable inspite of all efforts. He has not been heard of by the people who would have heard of him in the natural course of events for more than 7 years. Thus, I answer issue No.1 to 3 in -- 5 of 8 -- S.C. SUIT NO. 2208-2023 6 Judgment affirmative. AS TO ISSUE NO.4:- 9) Plaintiff has prayed for relief of declaration, they proved that Jagdish is missing for more than 7 years and he has not been heard of by the people who would have heard of him in the natural course of events. Therefore, plaintiffs are entitled to relief of declaration. Defendants opposed this suit on the ground that mandatory notices were not served, but record shows that mandatory notices were served by plaintiff. Therefore, there is no substance in this defence. Plaintiff also prayed for mandatory injunction directing defendant No.4 to register death of Jagdish Joshi. However, presumption under section 108 of Indian Evidence Act is about the death and there is no presumption as to time and date of death of said person. Plaintiff did not lead any evidence about the date and time of death of her brother. Moreover, special provision/remedy is available for registration of delayed births and deaths under Registration of Births and Deaths Act. 1969. In view of such provision this court finds that there is implied bar to jurisdiction of civil court for directing defendant No.4 to register death of Jagdish Krishnaprasad Joshi and to issue death certificate. 10) Considering the matter on record and above discussion plaintiff is not entitled to mandatory injunction as prayed. Therefore, issue no. 4 is answered partly in affirmative. AS TO ISSUE NO.5:- 11) In view of above discussion and reasons mentioned above this suit deserves to be partly decreed. Therefore, I proceeds to pass the following order :- -- 6 of 8 -- S.C. SUIT NO. 2208-2023 7 Judgment ORDER 1) Suit is partly decreed with proportionate cost. 2) It is hereby declared that Jagdish Krishnaprasad Joshi is dead. 3) Decree be drawn up accordingly. (V. G. RAGHUWANSHI) Judge Dt.:04/05/2024. City Civil Court, Gr. Mumbai Dictated & directly typed on computer : 04/05/2024. Signed on:04/05/2024. -- 7 of 8 -- S.C. SUIT NO. 2208-2023 8 Judgment “CERTIFIED TO BE TRUE AND CORRECT COPY OF THE ORIGINAL SIGNED JUDGMENT/ORDER.” UPLOAD DATE AND TIME NAME OF STENOGRAPHER 04/05/2024 Mrs. S.A. Shekade. Name of the Judge (With Court room no.) SHRI V.G. RAGHUWANSHI (Court Room No.08) Date of Pronouncement of JUDGMENT/ORDER 04/05/2024 JUDGMENT/ORDER signed by P.O. on 04/05/2024 JUDGMENT/ORDER uploaded on 04/05/2024 -- 8 of 8 --
