Skip to main content
NOTICE OF MOTION

New India Construction Co. Through Nilesh Amratlal ShahVsThe Brihanmumbai Municipal Corporation +2 more

CNR MHCC01009302202532-COURT 32 ADDL SESSIONS JUDGE
Fort, City Civil Court
Mumbai · Maharashtra (MH)
CASE DISPOSED
Contested--ALLOWED
Decision Date: 04th September 2025

TrustJury record updated 06 Nov 2026

Case Overview

Registration Number
103616/2025
Registration Date
09 Jul 2025

Advocates

2

For Petitioner

For Respondent

Parties

4

Acts & Sections

1
CODE OF CIVIL PROCEDURE · Sec 9

Case Timeline

Newest first3 dates/groups
Case disposedCompletion recorded

04 Sept 2025

2 records
Court Proceeding

POA of plaintiff is present. Mr. Vaibhav Dattatraya Borkar, Asst. Engineer is present. Adv. Ankur Jain present for plaintiff. Adv. Kajal Solanki present…

Read full proceeding
Business: POA of plaintiff is present.
Mr. Vaibhav Dattatraya Borkar, Asst. Engineer is present.
Adv. Ankur Jain present for plaintiff.
Adv. Kajal Solanki present for defendant and filed written notes of arguments in NM. TOR. Marked as Exh.7.
Heard both sides on NM No. 3616/2025.
Order in Notice of Motion No. 3616/2025.
            By the present motion, original defendant nos. 1 to 3 prayed to condone un-intentional delay of total 119 days including first 30 days in filing Written Statement filed Written 25.11.2024. However, W.S was tendered without motion subsequently motion taken out Dt.30.06.2025 with supporting affidavit of Assistant Engineer (Bridges) i.e. Mr. Vaibhav Dattaraya Borkar is tendered contended that Written statement could not be tendered within prescribed period of limitation of 30 days for the reasons that time was consumed for collecting required papers from different departments and to verify and find out those papers.
                    Thus, the delay is not deliberate and intentional and cogent reasons are sufficiently explained.  This court has power to condone the delay, after prescribed the period of limitation of 30 days. Hence, prayed to allow the motion as W.S is tendered on 119th day  within maximum period.
                    Vide reply at Exh.6, Dt. 03.09.2025, the motion is strongly resisted by POA Nilesh Amritlal Shah, authorized representative of plaintiffs company contending that as per sec. 16 of Commercial Courts Act, 2015 r/w order VIII of CPC, the Written Statement is required to be tendered within 30 days. The maximum period of limitation with grace period of 90 days is total 120 days. The leave of the court is necessary which is sought initially by filing up motion.
              In M/s. SCG Contracts India Pvt. Ltd. v/s K. S. Chamankar Infrastructure Pvt. Ltd. 2019 (12 SCC 210), after expiry of 120 days court can not accept or allow to tender Written Statement. Hence, prayed to dismiss the motion.
Following points arises -
      1. Whether court has power
      to condone the delay after            -   Yes.
      maximum period of 120 days.

      2. Whether delay of 119
      days deserve to be condoned       -      Yes.
      and sufficiently explained ?
      3. What order ?                          -      Notice of motion is
                                                               Allowed.
REASONS
1.                Heard Adv. Kajal Solanki i/b Adv. Parshurami for defendants/MCGM/applicants.
              Gone through the written synopsis of arguments of defendant.  The bone of contention of the ld. Counsel is that the facts of the present case are very peculiar. Therefore, it is necessary to brought those facts on record. It is contended that this court has sufficient powers to condone un-intentioal delay which is non deliberate.
                   The summons was served on 24.07.2024 (at this juncture the ld. Adv. Ankur Jain pointed out that it is 30.07.2024 and not 24.07.2024).  The Written Statement was presented on 25.11.2024 without motion inadvertently. Hence, prayed to condone the delay being unintentional and non-deliberate and subsequently the present motion is tendered within maximum period of 120 days.
2.                   Per contra, according to Adv. Ankur Jain, this court have no powers to accept the written statement beyond maximum period of 120 days as per sec. 16 of the Commercial Courts Act. This is a Commercial Suit. Therefore, the commercial courts act 2015 was enacted by the legislature with avowed aims and object to see that Commercial disputes should not be lingered, like ordinary civil courts in 21st century when the entire world is looking towards India as flourishing nation as a progressive century.
                If the ratio of SCG Contracts Pvt. Ltd. (supra) are carefully perused it would indicate that court have no powers to extend the period of limitation beyond the maximum period of 120 days.  Hence, prayed to dismiss the motion as there is no prayer to set-aside the order Dt. 25.11.2024 whereby the suit is proceeded without written statement.
3.                After considering rival submissions, I have carefully gone through the ratio of Honble Apex Court.  It is observed that on failure to file Written statement within first 30 days and if not tendered with the leave of the court within next further  grace period of 90 days, the right of the defendant to file written statement would automatically forfeited. The court has no power to allow to present Written statement after maximum period of 120 days. However, in the present case the written statement was filed without motion and obtaining leave of the court W.S. was presented on 25.11.2024.  However, it was within the further grace period of 90 days. Hence, it is within maximum period of 120 days.
4.                   True it is that Advocate of plaintiff have rightly pointed out that there is no prayer to set-aside order Dt. 25.11.2024.  However, by virtue of prayer clause ‘C’, this court can set-aside the order of ‘suit to proceed without written statement’ however,  subject to costs of Rs. 30,000/-. to be paid to the plaintiff within four weeks.
5.                The court is empowered  to condone delay of 89 days.  After first 30 days which comes to 119 day.   Hence, I have no hesitation,  but to record my positive findings to the point nos. 1 and 2 and proceed to pass following order-
ORDER
      1. Motion is allowed subject  to costs of Rs. 30,000/- to be paid to the plaintiff within four weeks.
      2. If the costs is not paid within stipulated time, order shall revoked automatically without further reference of this court.
 Motion is disposed off accordingly.
Nature Of Disposal: ALLOWED
Disposal Date: 04-09-2025
Final Order 1

Order Details: Other Pdf Text: 04/09/2025 Commercial Suit 1260/2024 @ NM No. 3616/2025 Exh. 6 & 7 Coram: H.H.J. SHRI. S. P. PINGLE JUDGE, (C.R.No 32) POA of plaintiff is present. Mr. Vaibhav Dattatraya Borkar, Asst.…

Read Full Order →

03 Sept 2025

1 record
Court Proceeding

POA of plaintiff Nilesh Shah is present. Adv. Ankur Jain present for plaintiff and filed reply to NM No. 3616/2025. Vaibhav Borkar, Assistant Engineer is…

Next purpose: NM FOR HEARING
Read full proceeding
Business: POA of plaintiff Nilesh Shah is present.
Adv. Ankur Jain present for plaintiff and filed reply to NM No. 3616/2025.
Vaibhav Borkar, Assistant Engineer is present.
Adv. Kajal Solanki i/b Adv. Vikrant Parshurami present for defendant/MCGM and pointed out  that though she was present on previous date her presence was not marked therefore, prayed to mark her presence today accordingly her presence is marked toady.
Matter is adj. for NM hearing to 04.09.2025 (urgent case).
Next Purpose: NM FOR HEARING

19 Aug 2025

1 record
Court Proceeding

Plaintiff present. Defendant absent. Adv. R. V. Singh @ Ankur Jain present for plaintiff. None present for defendant. There is heavy rain hence,…

Next purpose: NOTICE OF MOTION
Read full proceeding
Business: Plaintiff present.
Defendant absent.
Adv. R. V. Singh @ Ankur Jain present for plaintiff.
None present for defendant.
There is heavy rain hence, adjourned.
Matter is adj. for Notice of Motion to 03.09.2025.
Next Purpose: NOTICE OF MOTION

Additional Case Details

Additional Case Details
Filing Number: 109539/2025
Filing Date: 09-07-2025
First Hearing Date: 19th August 2025
Decision Date: 04th September 2025
Court Number And Judge: 32-COURT 32 ADDL  SESSIONS JUDGE

TrustJury presents public court-record information for legal discovery and reference. Record availability and detail can vary by source and case.