Full Order Text
Final Order 1 · 14 Oct 2026 · CNR MHCC010091742023
Order Details: Notice of Motion Pdf Text: MHCC010091742023 Presented on : 30-08-2023 Registered on : 30-08-2023 Decided on : 14-10-2026 Duration : 03 Y, 01 M, 14 D IN THE BOMBAY CITY CIVIL COURT AT GR. BOMBAY NOTICE OF MOTION No.3215 OF 2023 IN L.C. SUIT No.2185 OF 2023 Mr. Mohamed Husein Umer Rathod ) .. Plaintiff V/s. The Municipal Corporation of Greater Mumbai & Anr. ) ) .. Defendants Appearance : Ld. Adv. N.A. Ghatte a/w Adv. Dorajiwala, for plaintiff. Ld. Adv. V.G. Shinde, for defendants/MCGM. CORAM : HIS HONOUR AD-HOC JUDGE SHRI VAIBHAV V. KULKARNI CITY CIVIL COURT, GR. BOMBAY (C.R. No.05) DATE : 14/10/2026. -- 1 of 16 -- ..2.. O R A L O R D E R By way of this notice of motion the plaintiff seeking temporary injunction restraining the defendants, their officers, servants, agents and all persons claiming them from taking any coercive action by the mode of removing or demolishing the notice structure of suit premises i.e. Ground Floor, Banatwala Building, 112/114/116, Shaida Marg, Dongri, Mumbai-400 009 (hereinafter referred as ‘suit premises’) pursuant to the impugned notice issued under Section 55 of the Maharashtra Regional and Town Planning Act, 1966 (for short, ‘MRTP Act’) bearing reference No.B/DOB/223/55-MRTP ACT/B74N01/23-06- 2023 dated 23/06/2023, Reference No.170899 issued by defendants/MCGM and the speaking order dated 17/08/2023 passed by the defendants/MCGM. Facts responsible for the germination of this notice of motion can be stated as under : 2. The plaintiff is sole and absolute holder of suit premises. It is stated that more than half century before one Mr. Safiq Miyan Aman Sulah @ Mr. Mohamed Shafiq Amanatullah was holder of the suit premises and running his tailoring business under the name and style ‘Libas Tailors’. It is stated that the original holder of the suit premises on 16/07/1979 executed Deed of Assignment in favour of Shri. Sultanali Mohammedali Allahrakhia Mahimwala. Thereafter, in the year 2009 said Sultanali Mohammedali Allahrakhia Mahimwala executed Affidavit of Surrender of Tenancy, NOC for Electricity, Power of Attorney and legally transferred suit premises to the plaintiff for valuable consideration. -- 2 of 16 -- ..3.. 3. It is stated that suit premises is basically commercial tenanted premises and therefore, governed by the provisions of erstwhile the Bombay Rent Control Act, 1947 and now under the provisions of Maharashtra Rent Control Act, 1999. As per the provisions under erstwhile Rent Act it was lawful to transfer the running and going business along with goodwill and tenancy of the tenanted premises as incidental thereto by way of registered Deed of Assignment and as such the holders were adopting the same provisions to avoid exorbitant transfer charges of the landlord or regularization of the tenancy. The landlord therefore were maintaining non-cooperation, inimical and loggerheads relationship with such incoming tenants and not issuing them rent bills and not accepting rental amount. It was also common tendency of landlord as not to file any suit on that grounds as it was permissive transaction. 4. It is stated that prior to 1971 one M.S. TANK was installed on the terrace at 5th floor of the building and used to supply of water to the tenants/occupants of 3rd, 4th and 5th floor of the Banatwala building as other floors of the building i.e. ground to 2nd floor were getting direct water supply from the pipeline of MCGM during water time. It is stated that tenants/occupants of the said 3rd, 4th and 5th floor had taken separate Electric Meter No.A043062, Installation No.457160 dated 02/02/1971 for using the electricity consumption at water pump for filling as well pulling and supplying water from the said M.S. Tank. The plaintiff has obtained letter from the B.E.S. & T. It is stated that somewhere in the year 1980 one occupant by name Mr. Masha Khan removed the said M.S. Tank from -- 3 of 16 -- ..4.. the 5th floor terrace and brought it down and kept in the suit premises as the suit premises was not in use. It is stated that when erstwhile owner of the suit premises purchased the property on 16/07/1979 there was no shutter to the suit premises and there was no other place to keep it temporary and since then it is lying in the suit premises. The M.S. Tank is so weak in its dimension that it occupies major part of suit premises and as such cannot be used for any other suitable purpose and no need of shutter as the said M.S. Tank blocks whole shop. It is stated that Mr. Masha Khan later on expired and as such the said M.S. Tank remain in possession of erstwhile tenant/occupant of the suit premises. Shri. Sultanali Mohammedali Allahrakhia Mahimwala since its installation in the year 1980 and since the year 2009 same in possession of plaintiff in suit premises. 5. It is stated that suit premises is not at all “open space” or common passage of the building as projected by the defendants. On the other hand, the complainant himself submitted rent receipt of the year 2021 issued by the landlord, which is apparently disputed document. It is stated that plaintiff is in possession of suit premises since 2009. The M.S. Tank is in existence in the building since 1971 and in the suit premises since the year 1980. Therefore, contents in the notice under dispute about unauthorized erection of M.S. Tank are not correct. Therefore, no question would arise to issue notice under Section 55 of the MRTP Act and speaking order. However, in present case defendants/MCGM issued notice under dispute on 23/06/2023 and subsequently passed speaking order on 17/08/2023, which is contrary to the procedure established by the -- 4 of 16 -- ..5.. law. It is stated that said act of the defendants/MCGM is nothing but abuse of process of law. Therefore, plaintiff constrained to challenge the legality of both the actions of defendants/MCGM by way of present suit. It is stated that considering the nature of suit reasonable time is required to dispose of suit on its own merit. Therefore, the plaintiff pressed into service interim relief by way of present notice of motion and requested to grant said interim relief till decision of the suit. 6. The defendants/MCGM have filed affidavit in reply to this notice of motion. The defendants/MCGM denied all the averments in toto. Besides the categorically denial, it is contended that before institution of suit plaintiff was duty bound to issue statutory notice under Section 527 of MMC Act, 1888. However, the plaintiff failed to comply said mandatory provision, therefore, the suit itself is not maintainable in the eye of law. It is stated that plaintiff is not entitled for seeking final relief therefore, no question would arise about the entitlement of the interim relief. It is contended that plaintiff has suppressed the material facts and not come before the Court with clean hands, therefore, plaintiff is not entitled for seeking any equitable relief like injunction. 7. It is stated that by way of present suit plaintiff has challenged the notice under Section 55 of MRTP Act which is issued by the defendants/MCGM by following the mandates of law, therefore, there is express bar to try and entertain the present suit vide Section 149 of MRTP Act. -- 5 of 16 -- ..6.. 8. It is stated that defendants/MCGM received complaint from Mr. Mubeen Dhokadwala in respect of rusted water storage tank on the ground floor of suit premises. On receipt of the letter cum complaint dated 13/06/2023 from Advocate of legal heirs of landlord of suit premises the officer of defendants/MCGM inspected the suit premises. After inspection of the suit premises said officer observed unauthorized erection of M.S. Tank at open space of the suit premises without permission from competent authority. After noticing of the said fact the concerned officer asked the owner/occupier to produce authenticate document such as plan, permission granted in favour of erection of structure, but owner failed to produce the same. Therefore, the inspecting officer took measurements, drawn sketch, also took photographs and accordingly prepared the inspection report on 23/06/2023. 9. It is stated that the inspecting officer placed the inspection report and other documents before Designated Officer i.e. Assistant Engineer (B&F) B-Ward for further action. After perusal of inspection report and documents the Designated Officer prima facie formed the opinion about the erection of temporary structure is unauthorized and therefore, he pleased to issue notice under Section 55 of MRTP Act, 1966. By way of said notice plaintiff was called upon to remove the unauthorized development, more particularly described in notice under dispute. It is stated that on 27/06/2023 and 06/07/2023 the plaintiff submitted certain documents through Advocate. In said reply it was the stand of plaintiff that M.S. Tank was installed as per permission form No.C/886/B(W) of 19/12/1970 issued by Assistant Engineer (WW) B-Ward. Therefore, -- 6 of 16 -- ..7.. Assistant Engineer (B&F) made correspondence with Assistant Engineer (WW) B-Ward on 12/07/2023 for the purpose of seeking remarks on certain points. It is stated that in response to letter dated 12/07/2023 issued by the Assistant Engineer (WW) B-Ward, Assistant Engineer (WW) B-Ward replied vide letter dated 09/08/2023 giving remarks on each and every point. 10. It is stated that after close scrutiny of the entire record the Designated Officer B-Ward passed final speaking order on 17/08/2023 which was duly served upon plaintiff. It is stated that while passing the said order Designated Officer, B-Ward has given specific remark on each and every documents submitted by plaintiff. It is stated that plaintiff fails to submit documents on record to prove the authorization of notice structure and therefore, the Designated Officer constrained to issue notice under dispute to the plaintiff. It is stated that while taking action against the plaintiff the concerned Designated Officer followed the due process of law and directed plaintiff to remove unauthorized structure, more particularly described in the notice under dispute. It is stated that Section 149 of MRTP Act explicitly bars Civil Courts from entertaining suits or granting injunctions that question or stay orders and directions passed by planning authorities acting in their official capacity. On these counts defendants/MCGM urged for dismissal of the notice of motion with costs. 11. I have heard the Ld. Advocate of both the parties at great length. Gone through the documents available on record. -- 7 of 16 -- ..8.. 12. The following points emerges for my discussion. I have recorded my findings thereon for the reasons to follow; Sr. No. POINTS FINDINGS. 1. Whether plaintiff proves that he has made out a prima facie case as alleged? No 2. Whether plaintiff proves that balance of convenience is also lies in his favour as alleged? Redundant 3. Whether plaintiff proves that if the interim relief of temporary injunction is refused, he will suffer irreparable loss? Redundant 4. What Order ? Notice of Motion stands dismissed. REASONS 13. Before adverting to discuss pros and cons of this application it is fitness of things to emanate the dispute between the parties. It is the grievance of the plaintiff that, initially M.S. Tank was installed on the terrace i.e. 5th floor of the building before 1971. Somewhere in the year 1980 one occupant namely Mr. Masha Khan removed the said Tank from 5th floor terrace and brought it down and kept in the suit premises. According to plaintiff, suit premises is not at all open space or common passage of the building as projected by defendants/MCGM. Therefore, notice under dispute issued by the defendants/MCGM is not governed under Section 55 of MRTP Act, 1966 and therefore, any action initiated against the plaintiff is arbitrary, illegal in the eyes of law. Per contra, it is the stand of defendants/MCGM that on 19/05/2023 the defendants/MCGM -- 8 of 16 -- ..9.. received complaint letter from Shri. Mubeen Dhokadwala on receipt of the said complaint the responsible officer of the defendants/MCGM taken the site inspection. During the said visit it reveals unauthorized erection of M.S. Tank at open space without permission in suit premises. 14. It is well settled that Section 149 of MRTP Act creates express bar to try and entertain the suit were finality of orders passed or notice issued by any Regional Court, Planning Authority or Development Authority by exercising the power conferred under the said Act. Even though there is express bar provided under Section 149 of MRTP Act the rider is given that, if plaintiff come with the case of nullity of order or notice then to that limited extent suit is maintainable. Herein this suit and notice of motion plaintiff alleges that action initiated by the defendants/MCGM is contrary to the provisions of the law and therefore, notice and order under challenge is in nullity. Therefore, campus of controversy lies in respect of whether plaintiff prima facie succeed to demonstrate that the action under challenge of defendants/MCGM is in nullity and plaintiff is entitled for interim protection till conclusion of trial. As to Point No.1 :- 15. It is settled law that the relief of temporary injunction stands on three pillars namely; [a] Prima facie case. [b] Balance of convenience. [c] Irreparable loss. -- 9 of 16 -- ..10.. 16. Besides all these three factors, one step ahead Hon'ble Apex Court in the case of Mandali Ranganna and others etc. Vs. T. Ramchandra and others, AIR 2008 SC 2291, observed that - "while considering an application for grant of injunction, the Court will not only take into consideration the basic elements in relations thereto, viz existence of prima facie case, balance of convenience and irreparable injury, it must also take into consideration the conduct of the parties. Grant or refusal of injunction has serious consequences depending upon the nature thereto. The courts dealing with such matters must make all endeavors to protect the interest of the parties". 17. Taking a cue from the above proposition of law the facts and circumstances arise in present case are required to be taken into consideration. 18. The first litmus test which is required to be apply on the facts while deciding interim application is existence of prima facie case. As per settled practice and procedure of law, prima facie case implies probability of the plaintiff obtaining a relief on the material placed before the Court. Every piece of evidence produced by either party has to be taken into consideration in deciding existence of prima facie case. It is well settled that for establishing prima facie case, it is necessary for the party to prove his case to the hilt and if fair question is raised for determination, it should be taken that a prima facie case is established. As per settled practices and procedure of law, it is expected on the part of plaintiff to prove said aspect by affidavit or otherwise. -- 10 of 16 -- ..11.. 19. In order to establish the prima facie case the plaintiff has not filed affidavit of other witnesses in terms of Rule-1 of Order-39 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 (CPC). However, he has placed his reliance upon numerous documents which consists copy of the Inspection Extract of 1971-72, copies of the reply letter dated 20/11/2013 of B.E.S & T. undertakings, copies of the Deed of Assignment duly registered on 16/7/1979 along with the Government receipt, copy of the Electric bill of 19/03/1981, copies of the said Affidavit, Power of Attorney, Deed of Assignment and Cancellation receipt of the year 1995, copies of the Agreement, Affidavit of Surrender of Tenancy, Affidavit of NOC Electricity, Power of Attorney of the year 2009, copy of application dated 06/02/2014, copy of the letter showing Electric Meter and Installation dated 02/02/1971, copy of the notice under Section 55 of the M.R.T.P. Act, 1966 dated 23/06/2023, copy of reply dated 6th day of July, 2023 and copy of the impugned speaking order dated 17/08/2023. 20. As against this the defendants/MCGM also placed their reliance on following documents to disprove the claim of plaintiff :- (i) Copy of complaint letter from Shri. Mubin Dhokadwala dated 19/05/2023. (ii) Letter of Adv. Nandesh A. Manek on behalf of landlord dated 13/06/2023. (iii) Copy of M.B.R. & R. Board Repair plan of building 112-114- 116 Shayda Marg. (iv) Copy of Inspection Report dated 23/06/2023 along with photographs. -- 11 of 16 -- ..12.. (v) Copy of notice under Section B/DOB/223/55MRTP ACT/B74No.1 dated 23/06/2023. (vi) Copy of letter under No.ACB/SR/156/BF/22-23 dated 12/07/2023. (vii) Copy of letter A.E. (W.W.) ‘B’ Ward A.E.W.W. ‘B’ SR/751/dated 09/08/2023. (viii) Speaking Order dated 17/08/2023. (ix) Copy of memo for demolition on dated 31/08/2023 U/No. ACB/SR/228/BF/23-24/DATED 25/08/2023. 21. I have pondered over the submissions of Ld. Advocate of respective parties. Gone through the documents on which they have placed their reliance. Before we proceed further, it is just and proper to understand the purport of Section 55 of MRTP Act, 1966. Section 55 of MRTP Act empowers planning authorities to order demolition or removal of unauthorized constructions. Said provision is a powerful tool for urban planning enforcement. As per settled practice and procedure of law burden of proof lies on the occupant to establish lawful existence of notice structure. Thus, taking cue from above proposition of law facts and circumstances arises in present case are required to be looked into. 22. The fact is not seriously in dispute that on 19/05/2023 defendants/MCGM received complaint letter from Shri. Mubeen Dhokadwala. On receipt of the said complaint inspection officer visited the suit premises on 23/06/2023 at about 11.42 hours to verify the correctness of the allegations in the complaint letter. Fact -- 12 of 16 -- ..13.. is not seriously in dispute that on the basis of inspection report notice under Section 55 of MRTP Act was served upon the plaintiff. The fact is also not seriously in dispute that the plaintiff submitted his reply along with photocopies of certain documents on 27/06/2023 and 07/06/2023 before Designated Officer. I find reference of these documents in speaking order along with remarks of Designated Officer. Record prima facie show that the plaintiff basically placed his reliance on total 13 documents while submitting his reply before Designated Officer. The plaintiff while pressing this application also placed his reliance on same documents, more particularly described at serial Nos.1 to 13 of speaking order. Time and again Hon’ble Bombay High Court held that evidence like Rent Receipt, Electricity Bill, registered Deed of Assignment is not considered as sufficient evidence to prima facie establish the fact of existence of structure before datum line or non violation of mandates given under Section 55 of MRTP Act. 23. The Ld. Advocate of the plaintiff much harp on the point that already Hydraulic Engine Department accorded permission for installation of M.S. Tank on 19/12/1970, therefore, said notice structure not governed under Section 55 of MRTP Act. I find reference of said document at serial No.2 of speaking order under challenge. At this juncture judicial note is required to be taken about remarks passed by the Designated Officer. In said remarks it is specifically observed that his office was called remark from Assistant Engineer (WW) B-Ward and it is informed that said permission is valid for water connection to the building and not for installation of M.S. Tank. The xerox copy of reply of Assistant Engineer (WW) -- 13 of 16 -- ..14.. B-Ward dated 09/08/2023 is also available on record in the compilation of defendants/MCGM submitted at the time of filing affidavit in reply to the notice of motion. In the said reply, it is specifically clarified that his office has issued a water connection to the building and not to the M.S. Tank situated at ground floor. It is worthwhile to note here that the plaintiff on affidavit or otherwise failed to produce such documentary evidence on record which prima facie shows that defendants/MCGM was accorded permission to the plaintiff or erstwhile owner of the suit premises for installation of M.S. Tank. Thus, after considering the matter before the Court the record prima facie shows that sufficient opportunity was given by the defendants/MCGM to the plaintiff to produce documents to show authenticity of notice structure. However, the plaintiff or affidavit or otherwise failed to prima facie prove authenticity of notice structure. 24. Thus, having regard to the facts and circumstances of the case and after giving anxious consideration to the proposition of law, I am of the opinion that the acts of the defendants/MCGM for sending notice under Section 55 of MRTP Act, 1966 and subsequent speaking order under challenge found to be prima facie justifiable. In the circumstances, no interference is required. In view of the above state of affairs, I am of the opinion that plaintiff failed to made out prima facie case in his favour. Therefore, I answer point No.1 in the negative. -- 14 of 16 -- ..15.. As to Point Nos.2 and 3 :- 25. In view of the findings recorded as to point No.1, point No.2 to 3 needs no consideration and become redundant. Therefore, I answer point Nos.2 and 3 accordingly. As to Point No.4 :- 26. In view of the findings recorded as to point Nos.1 to 3 the notice of motion pressed in the service by the plaintiff deserves to be dismissed. Therefore, in answer to point No.4, I pass the following order. O R D E R Notice of Motion No.3215/2023 is hereby dismissed and stands disposed of accordingly. (Pronounced in open Court) Date : 14/10/2026. (Vaibhav V. Kulkarni) Judge, City Civil Court, Gr. Bombay (CR.5) Dictated on : 14/10/2026 Transcribed on : 14/10/2026 Checked on : 14/10/2026 Signed on : 15/10/2026 -- 15 of 16 -- ..16.. “CERTIFIED TO BE TRUE AND CORRECT COPY OF THE ORIGINAL SIGNED JUDGMENT/ORDER” UPLOAD DATE TIME NAME OF STENOGRAPHER 15/10/2026 04.46 p.m. Sanjay Baliram Kaskar (Stenographer Grade-I) Name of the Judge H.H.J. Shri. Vaibhav V. Kulkarni (C.R. No.5) Date of Pronouncement of Judgment/Order. 14/10/2026 Judgment/order signed by P.O on 15/10/2026 Judgment/order uploaded on 15/10/2026 -- 16 of 16 --
