Full Order Text
Final Order 1 · 12 Feb 2024 · CNR MHCC010088122022
Order Details: Other Pdf Text: ..1.. SJ No.232/2022 MHCC010088122022 IN THE BOMBAY CITY CIVIL COURT, GREATER MUMBAI AT MAZGAON SUMMONS FOR JUDGMENT NO.232 OF 2022 (CNR NO.MHCC01-008812-2022) IN SUMMARY CIVIL SUIT NO.195 OF 2022 Mr. Ashok Bodmal Bohra )...Plaintiff VERSUS Mr. A. P. Maheshwara )...Defendants Appearance :- Learned Advocate Paras Vira alongwith Advocate Mayur Sonawane for plaintiff. Learned Advocate Virendra Kanojia alongwith Adv. Vishwanath Singh for defendant. CORAM : HIS HONOUR JUDGE SHAIKH AKBAR SHAIKH JAFAR COURT ROOM NO.84 DATE : 12/02/2024. ORDER 1 The plaintiff has filed this suit for recovery of amount contending that the defendant has placed 3 purchase orders for supplying goods and in response to the purchase orders, the plaintiff has supplied the goods and raised 3 invoices of Rs.6,75,545/-. But the defendant failed to pay the amount under the invoices. The defendant issued 3 cheques in repayment of these invoices after repeated requests -- 1 of 5 -- ..2.. SJ No.232/2022 made by the plaintiff. However, these 3 cheques returned dishonoured for reason “FUNDS INSUFFICIENT”. Consequently, plaintiff issued legal notice calling upon the defendant to pay the amount, but in vain. Hence, plaintiff has filed the instant suit for recovery of amount algonwith interest and prayed for passing decree for Rs.9,22,456/- with future interest @ 18% per annum. 2 In response to the writ of summons, defendant appeared and tendered his appearance. Plaintiff took out summons for judgment. The defendant replied to the summons for judgment denying the contention of the plaintiff. Defendant denied the receipt of goods as contended by the plaintiff. It is the contention of defendant that plaintiff raised invoices without delivering the goods as per the purchase order and called upon the plaintiff to prove the delivery of goods as claimed. It is further contended that the plaintiff has misused the cheques which were tendered to the plaintiff alongwith purchase orders. The defendant claimed that suit is not tenable as a summary suit and plaintiff has tried to act fraud and extort the amount. Lastly, prayed for dismissal of summons for judgment and grant of unconditional leave to defend. 3 Heard rival parties at length. The defendant has basically denied receipt of the goods, thus, it is incumbent on the part of plaintiff to prima facie show the delivery of goods. The plaintiff is relying on the E-way bill dated 23/10/2019 which is pertaining to the goods delivered to the plaintiff having value of Rs.2,87,625/-. It is supplied to the defendant through Sri Balaji Roadlines Transport Company. The E-way -- 2 of 5 -- ..3.. SJ No.232/2022 bill shows that the defendant is a recipient of the goods, therefore, the plaintiff is in position to prove the delivery of goods of purchase order pertaining to the amount of Rs.2,87,625/-. During the argument, defendant has admitted the receipt of goods under E-way challan. The delivery challan or the E-way bill is not filed on record pertaining to the other 2 orders, therefore, I am of the view that the defendant is entitled to leave to defend as it is incumbent on the part of the plaintiff to establish the delivery of goods regarding other 2 purchase orders. 4 The defendant is claiming unconditional leave to defend contending that the suit in question is not tenable as a summary suit as well as there is difference regarding the amount claimed in the notice issued by the plaintiff. However, I am of the view that where the defendant has admitted during the argument the receipt of goods of Rs.2,87,625/- of which E-way slip is filed on record. It is incumbent on the part of the defendant to deposit the said amount as a condition to leave to defend. Hence, I proceed to pass the following order :- ORDER 1. Summons for Judgment No.232 of 2022 in Summary Civil Suit No.195 of 2022, is disposed of in terms of following order - 2. Leave is granted to the defendant to defend the suit subject to the defendant depositing in this Court a sum of Rs.2,87,625/- within a period of one month from the date of order and shall file written statement within 30 days, thereafter. 3. After depositing the amount, the PLA Section is directed to invest the same into Fixed Deposit, till disposal of the suit or till further order. -- 3 of 5 -- ..4.. SJ No.232/2022 4. If this conditional order of deposit is not complied within the stipulated period, as mentioned hereinabove, the plaintiff shall be entitled for an ex- parte decree against the defendants after obtaining a non-deposit certificate from the PLA Section. 5. Summons for judgment is disposed of accordingly. (Order dictated and pronounced in open Court) (Shaikh Akbar Shaikh Jafar) Judge, City Civil Court, Mazgaon Mumbai Date: 12/02/2024. Court Room No.84 Dictated on : 12/02/2024. Transcribed on : 12/02/2024. Signed by HHJ on : 13/02/2024. -- 4 of 5 -- ..5.. SJ No.232/2022 “Certified to be true and correct copy of the original signed order”. 14/02/2024 at about 11.00 a.m. (Ms. Sonali S. Sawant) Stenographer (Grade-III) Name of the Hon'ble Judge : Shaikh Akbar Shaikh Jafar, Judge, City Civil Court & Addl. Sessions Judge, Court Room No.84, Mazgaon, Mumbai Date of pronouncement of Order : 12/02/2024 Order signed by Hon'ble Judge on : 13/02/2024 Order uploaded on : 14/02/2024 at about 11.00 a.m. -- 5 of 5 --
