Full Order Text
Final Order 1 · 11 Jan 2023 · CNR MHCC010087812021
Order Details: Notice of Motion Pdf Text: MHCC010087812021 CNR NO. MHCC010087812021 IN THE BOMBAY CITY CIVIL COURT AT BOMBAY NOTICE OF MOTION NO.2675 OF 2021 IN SUMMARY SUIT NO.4517 OF 2011 (HIGH COURT SUIT NO.2543 OF 2011 M/s. Ferro Steels ]… Plaintiff. V/s. M/s. Godavari Edible Bran Oil Limited ]... Defendants. Appearances : Ld. Adv. Mr. Saxena for plaintiff. Ld.Adv. Lanjekar for defendant. CORAM : HER HONOUR JUDGE SMT. R.K. KSHIRSAGAR (C.R.No.13) DATED : 11th January, 2023 ORAL ORDER 1. The present Notice of Motion is taken out by the plaintiff for permission to adduce additional evidence by producing relevant entries in the Books of Accounts maintained by the plaintiff. -- 1 of 5 -- 2 NM 2675/2021 in Sum Suit 4517/2011 2. It was submitted by the plaintiff that the plaintiff examined his representative as P.W.1 and filed his affidavit of evidence dated 01.12.2014. During the crossexamination of P.W.1, a typographical error occured in the crossexamination for which the advocate for plaintiff taken out an application vide Exh.25. The said application was rejected as per order dated 06.02.2017. The plaintiff filed a writ petition before the Hon'ble High Court challenging the said order. The said Writ Petition bearing No.2600 of 2018 is pending before the Hon'ble High Court. The plaintiff further submitted that he had been advised that to produce additional documents i.e. relevant entries in the Books of Accounts and therefore, permission be given to adduce additional evidence so that the typographical error in the cross examination dated 28.11.2016 may be corrected and hence, Notice of Motion be allowed. 3. The Advocate for defendant strongly opposed the contention of the plaintiff. It was submitted that during the cross examination P.W.1 certain admissions were given and now he cannot be allowed to withdraw the same by way of this Notice of Motion. Further already the same prayer of plaintiff was rejected as per Order below Exh.25 and hence, the Notice of Motion be rejected. 4. Heard the Learned Advocate for plaintiff and defendant. 5. The Learned Advocate for plaintiff filed citation as follows: 1. (2011) 11 Supreme Court Cases 275 in the case of K.K. Velusamy Vs. N. Palanisamy, in Civil Appeal No.279596 of 2011, dated 30.03.2021. -- 2 of 5 -- 3 NM 2675/2021 in Sum Suit 4517/2011 6. Also perused the Order Below Exh.25. P.W.1 filed his affidavit of evidence and during his crossexamination on 28.11.2016 the plaintiff was asked regarding the entries in Exh.13. The plaintiff admitted the same. Subsequently upon relying the same the Advocate for plaintiff filed an application vide Exh.25. The prayer of correction in the Crossexamination was rejected by my Learned Predecessor on merits after hearing both the advocates. The plaintiff himself contended that a Writ Petition is pending before the Hon'ble High Court against the Order dated 06.02.2017 below Exh.25. It therefore seems that the contention of plaintiff is still open and subjudiced before the Hon'ble High Court. Pending the same the plaintiff had filed the present application for adducing additional evidence. It seems that the plaintiff under the pretext of adducing additional evidence is seeking the setting aside of order below Exh.25. As such since, the issue is already pending before the Hon'ble High Court, the plaintiff cannot file the application seeking the same relief. Even though plaintiff is seeking the relief of adducing additional evidence, it will amount to fill up the lacuna in respect of the admission given in the crossexamination. With due respect to the observations laid in the rulling cited supra plaintiff can be allowed to adduce additional evidence but it should not amount to filling of lacuna by removing admission given in the earlier cross examination. The plaintiff therefore, cannot be allowed to adduce additional evidence to fill up the lacuna and once the said prayer of plaintiff has been rejected this Court cannot again sit in an appeal over its own order and therefore, I, proceed to pass the following order: -- 3 of 5 -- 4 NM 2675/2021 in Sum Suit 4517/2011 ORDER 1. The Notice of Motion No.2675 of 2021 is rejected. 2. Parties to bear their own costs. ( Smt. R. K. Kshirsagar ) Judge, (C.R.No.13) Dt.: 11012023 City Civil Court, Gr. MUMBAI Dictated on : 11012023 Transcribed on : 13012023 checked on : 13012023 Signed on : 13012023 ( Smt. R. K. Kshirsagar ) Judge, (C.R.No.13) City Civil Court, Gr. MUMBAI -- 4 of 5 -- 5 NM 2675/2021 in Sum Suit 4517/2011 “CERTIFIED TOBE TRUE AND CORRECT COPY OF THE ORIGINAL SIGNED JUDGMENT/ORDER” 18.01.2023 at 11.25 a.m. UPLOAD DATE AND TIME (VARSHA U. PAWAR) NAME OF STENOGRAPHER Name of the Judge H.H.J.Smt.R.K.Kshirsagar (COURT ROOM NO.13) Date of pronouncement of judgment/order 11.01.2023 Judgment/order signed by P.O. on 13.01.2023 Judgment/order uploaded on 18.01.2023 -- 5 of 5 --
