Full Order Text
Final Order 1 · 02 Jan 2024 · CNR MHCC010081722023
Order Details: Copy of Judgment Pdf Text: 1 Lodged on : 05.08.2023 Registered on : 17.08.2023 Decided on : 02.01.2024 Duration : 00 Y : 4 M : 28 D EXHIBIT-18 IN THE BOMBAY CITY CIVIL COURT AT BOMBAY SUIT NO. 1936 OF 2023 (C.N.R. NO. MHCC-01008172-2023) 1. Pravin Pandurang Palkar ] Age 55 years, Occ. : Service, ] 2. Pradeep Pandurang Palkar ] Age 51 years, Occ. : Service, ] 3. Ravi Pandurang Palkar ] Age 56 years, Occ.: Financial Advisor ] 4. Anita Pandurang Palkar ] Age 55 years, Occ. : Housewife ] All are residing at C-603, Shubham ] CHS, Khandagale Compound, ] Kokan Nagar, Bhandup, Mumbai-78. ] ... Plaintiffs. V/s. 1. THE STATE OF MAHARASHTRA, ] Through the Marine Lines Police ] Station, Mumbai-400 032. ] 2. The Senior Inspector of Police ] Missing Person Bureau, Crime Branch] Crawford Market, Mumbai ] -- 1 of 8 -- 2 3. The Senior Inspector of Police ] Bhandup Police Station, Mumbai ] 4. THE BRIHAN MUMBAI ] MUNICIPAL CORPORATION ] a body incorporated under the ] Provisions of MBC Act having its ] Office at Mahapalika Bhavan, ] Mahapalika Marg, C.S.T., Mumbai ] Through Assistant Municipal ] Commissioner of “S Ward”, Mumbai. ] ...Defendants. Advocates Mr. S. S. Redekar for the plaintiffs. Advocate Mr. Amit Kapse Defendant Nos.1 to 3/State. Advocate Mrs. Chandramore for BMC/defendant No.4. CORAM : HIS HONOUR JUDGE SHRI VAIBHAV V. PATIL (C.R.No.09). DATE : 2nd JANUARY 2024. JUDGMENT Present suit is instituted for the relief of death declaration that Shri Pandurang Tukaram Palkar is presumed to be Civil dead as he has not been heard of for more than 7 years. 2. It is the case of plaintiffs that plaintiff Nos. 1 to 3 are sons and No.4 is married daughter of Shri Pandurang Tukaram Palkar who went missing on 18.12.2000 from Bhandup, Mumbai. The plaintiffs took search of their father but they could not find him. Hence they lodged missing complaint of their father on 18.12.2000 with Bhandup Police Station, Mumbai and the police registered said complaint and recorded AMR No.128/2000. Thereafter, plaintiffs, as well as police made every possible efforts to trace Shri Pandurang Tukaram Palkar however, he could not be found even-after due and diligent search. Bhandup Police Station issued missing certificate on 27.12.2000. -- 2 of 8 -- 3 3. It is further contention of the plaintiffs that their father’s whereabouts are not known for last more than seven years. The cause of action has arisen at Mumbai. Hence, this Court has jurisdiction to entertain, try and dispose of this Suit. Hence, the plaintiffs have sought declaration that this Hon’ble Court be pleased to make an order of presumption of death of Shri Pandurang Tukaram Palkar who is not heard of for more than seven years under section 108 of Indian Evidence Act, 1908. 4. The Defendant Nos. 1 to 3 filed their written statement and resisted the claim of plaintiffs vide Exh.05. Defendant No.4 failed to file written statement. Hence, suit came to be proceeded without written statement of defendant No.4. 5. In view of pleadings, following issues arises my determination, I have recorded my findings to each of them for the reasons stated below. Sr. No. ISSUES FINDINGS 1. Whether the plaintiff is entitled to a decree for declaration that Shri Pandurang Tukaram Palkar is presumed to be dead as per Sec. 108 of the Indian Evidence Act? In the Affirmative 2. Whether the plaintiff is entitled for a Death Certificate of Shri Pandurang Tukaram Palkar to be issued by B.M.C.? In the Affirmative -- 3 of 8 -- 4 3. Whether the plaintiff is entitled for the relief of declaration as prayed ? In the Affirmative 4. What Order and decree ? As per Final Order R E A S O N S AS TO ISSUE NOS.1 TO 3 : 8. As all the points are related with each other, they are discussed together to avoid repetition. 9. The plaintiff No.2 Pradeep Pandurang Palkar has filed affidavit of evidence in lieu of Examination-in-Chief at Exhibit-7 and deposed on oath and he has reiterated all the contentions in his plaint in the Affidavit of Evidence. He was cross-examined by the advocates of defendants. In cross examination he has stated that he has not produced on record copy of newspaper published. He had approached BMC for issuing Death Certificate of his father, but they asked him to go to the Court. 10. In support of the suit claim, the plaintiff has produced on record list of documents vide Exh.8. The plaintiff has produced on record copy of A.M.R.No.128/2000 alongwith copy of check list issued by Bhandup police station (Exh.09), Copy of Complaint of missing person dated 27.12.2000 issued by Sr. Inspector of Police, Missing Persons Centre, Crime Branch (Exh-10), Certificate dated 05.12.2009 issued by the Sr. Inspector of Police, Missing Persons Centre, Crime Branch (Exh.11), Letter dated 10.05.2022 written by Plaintiff No.1 to MCGM (Exh.12), Notice u/s. 80 of C.P.C. dated 19.04.2023 (Exh.13), Notice u/s. 527 of the MMC Act dated 19.04.2023 (Exh.14). -- 4 of 8 -- 5 11. The learned advocate for defendants submitted that the suit is barred by law of limitation. It is further submitted that the father of the plaintiffs went missing since 18.12.2000. Therefore, they ought to have instituted the suit within three years from the date of cause of action, to which they failed. Hence, suit is barred by law of limitation. In reply, the learned advocate for the plaintiffs submitted that the plaintiffs did not hear anything about their father Shri Pandurang Tukaram Palkar since 18.12.2000 and the cause of action for institution of the suit is recurring one and until the plaintiffs realized that their father Shri Pandurang Tukaram Palkar cannot be traced, they cannot be compelled to institute the suit for declaring him dead. Therefore, the suit is within limitation. I find substance in the argument advanced on behalf of the plaintiffs. The cause of action for filing the present suit is recurring one and there is continuous cause of action and therefore, it cannot be said that the suit is barred by law of limitation. Therefore, submission made by the learned advocate for the defendants in this regard cannot be accepted. Thus, it is crystal clear that the suit is very well within limitation. 12. Here reference needs to be made to section 108 of the Indian Evidence Act which runs as under; Section 108: Burden of proving that person is alive who has not been heard of for seven years - Provided that when the question is whether a man is alive or dead, and it is proved that he has not been heard of for seven years by those who would naturally have heard of him if he had been alive, the burden of proving that he is alive is shifted to the person who affirms it. -- 5 of 8 -- 6 13. In the present case, it is evident that the father of the plaintiffs went missing since 18.12.2000. The plaintiff has deposed on oath that he took all the efforts to find him and he also lodged missing complaint with police, but police also could not trace him. Despite of their efforts, they could not find the missing person. Thus, it is proved from the evidence produced on record by the plaintiffs that their father was missing since 18.12.2000 and despite all the efforts to find them, he could not be found. Therefore, presumption under section 108 of the Indian Evidence Act comes into play. Section 108 of the Indian Evidence Act enables the Court under the circumstances stated therein to draw the statutory presumption that a man is not alive unless the contrary is proved by the opposite party. In the present case, nobody has come forward to state that the missing person is alive. Even the defendants have not raised contention that the missing person is alive. Therefore, in such circumstances, presumption under section 108 of the Indian Evidence Act can be raised in this case. 14. In view of above documents and the oral evidence, plaintiffs have proved that Shri Pandurang Tukaram Palkar went missing since 18.12.2000. The defendants have not disputed the said fact that he is still missing and his whereabouts are not traced. As stated above, the legal presumption is attracted under section 108 of the Evidence Act that he is dead. I therefore, hold that the plaintiffs are entitled for declaration to that effect. 15. The State is under statutory obligation to maintain the record of birth and death of citizens. Therefore, in view of above discussion, the plaintiffs are entitled for death certificate of Shri Pandurang Tukaram Palkar to be issued by the defendant No.4. -- 6 of 8 -- 7 16. In the circumstances above, I have come to the conclusion that plaintiffs are entitled to the declaration as prayed for. Accordingly, I answer Issue Nos.1 to 3 in the affirmative and in answer to Issue No. 4, I proceed to pass following order. ORDER 1. The suit is hereby decreed. 2. It is hereby declared that the father of the plaintiffs Nos. 1 to 4 Shri Pandurang Tukaram Palkar is not being heard of for more than last seven years and he is Civil Dead. 3. The defendants are directed to register the death of Shri Pandurang Tukaram Palkar and to issue death certificate accordingly. 4. No order as to costs of the suit. 5. Decree be drawn up accordingly. 6. The original documents, if any, be returned to the plaintiff after the appeal period is over. 7. The suit stands disposed of accordingly. (VAIBHAV V. PATIL) Judge, City Civil Court, Date: 02.01.2024 Gr.Mumbai. Dictated on : 02.01.2024 Typed on : 02.01.2024 Signed on : 02.01.2024 -- 7 of 8 -- 8 CERTIFIED TO BE TRUE AND CORRECT COPY OF THE ORIGINAL SIGNED JUDGMENT/ORDER.” 02/01/2024 At 5.30 P.M. Ms. Manisha Hirole UPLOAD DATE AND TIME NAME OF STENOGRAPHER Name of the Judge (With Court Room Number) HHJ MR. VAIBHAV V. PATIL (C.R.NO.09) Date of pronouncement of Judgment/ Order 02.01.2024 Judgment/Order signed by P.O. on 02.01.2024 Judgment/Order uploaded on 02.01.2024 -- 8 of 8 --
