Full Order Text
Order 2 · 05 Jan 2024 · CNR MHCC010071952018
Order Details: Other Pdf Text: CS No. 100281 / 2021 Kirti – Vipul Exh.18 1 / 4 Further Examination in chief of plaintiff witness Kirti Sawant on oath by Adv. Kavita Shah, for plaintiff. Adv. Purvi Palkar present with defendant Vipul Rodrigues Witness is being examined by the plaintiff as per permission granted, vide Order Dt.08.11.2023 in Notice of Motion No.102783 / 2023. 1) Affidavit now shown to me bears my signature. Its contents are true. It is already marked as Exh.18. I have filed following document on record. Same be allotted Exhibit mark. Exh.30 : Original certificate of registration of Marriage Dt. 07.01.2010. Exh.31 : Office copy of Invoice No.135, Dt. 05.10.2014. Exh.32 : Email Dt. 07.05.2015 by plaintiff to defendant. Exh.33 : Office copy of Invoice No.180, Dt. 25.11.2014. Exh.34 : Email Dt. 27.11.2014 by plaintiff to defendant. Exh.35 : Office copy of Invoice No.197, Dt. 04.12.2014. Exh.36 : Email Dt. 04.12.2014 by plaintiff to defendant. Exh.37 : Office copy of Invoice No.283, Dt. 06.02.2015. Exh.38 : Office copy of Invoice No.286, Dt. 06.02.2015. Exh.39 : Office copy of Invoice No.287, Dt. 06.02.2015. Exh.40 : Office copy of Invoice No.288, Dt. 06.02.2015. Exh.41 : Office copy of Invoice No.289, Dt. 06.02.2015. Exh.42 : Office copy of Invoice No.290, Dt. 06.02.2015. Exh.43 : Office copy of Invoice No.291, Dt. 06.02.2015. Exh.44 : Office copy of Invoice No.292, Dt. 06.02.2015. Exh.45 : Office copy of Invoice No.293, Dt. 06.02.2015. Exh.46 : Office copy of Invoice No.294, Dt. 06.02.2015. Exh.47 : Office copy of Invoice No.295, Dt. 06.02.2015. Exh.48 : Office copy of Invoice No.296, Dt. 06.02.2015. Exh.49 : Office copy of Invoice No.297, Dt. 06.02.2015. Exh.50 : Office copy of Invoice No.298, Dt. 06.02.2015. Exh.51 : Office copy of Invoice No.299, Dt. 06.02.2015. -- 1 of 4 -- CS No. 100281 / 2021 Kirti – Vipul Exh.18 2 / 4 Exh.52 : Office copy of Invoice No.300, Dt. 06.02.2015. Exh.53 : Office copy of Invoice No.301, Dt. 06.02.2015. Exh.54 : Carbon Copy of Challan No. 258, Dt.09.01.2015. Exh.55 : Carbon Copy of Challan No. 267, Dt.09.01.2015. Exh.56 : Office copy of Invoice No.302, Dt. 06.02.2015. Exh.57 : Email Dt.06.11.2014 by defendant to plaintiff. Exh.58 : Office copy of Invoice No.303, Dt. 06.02.2015. Exh.59 : Office copy of Invoice No.304, Dt. 06.02.2015. Exh.60 : Office copy of Invoice No.305, Dt. 06.02.2015. Exh.61 : Office copy of Invoice No.306, Dt. 06.02.2015. Exh.62 : Office copy of Invoice No.307, Dt. 06.02.2015. Exh.63 : Office copy of Invoice No.308, Dt. 06.02.2015. Exh.64 : Office copy of Invoice No.309, Dt. 06.02.2015. Exh.65 : Office copy of Invoice No.310, Dt. 06.02.2015. Exh.66 : Office copy of Invoice No.311, Dt. 06.02.2015. Exh.67 : Office copy of Invoice No.312, Dt. 06.02.2015. Exh.68 : Office copy of Invoice No.313, Dt. 06.02.2015. Exh.69 : Office copy of Invoice No.327, Dt. 18.02.2015. Exh.70 : Office copy of Invoice No.354, Dt. 18.02.2015. Article A : Photocopy of Invoice Dt. 28.04.2015. Exh.71 : Carbon Copy of Challan No.56, Dt. 30.04.2015. Exh.72 : Carbon Copy of Challan No.60, Dt. 09.05.2015. Exh.73 : Certified Bank Statement for period Dt.01.04.2014 to Dt.31.03.2015. Exh.74 : Ledger Account maintained by plaintiff regarding transaction with defendant. Article B : Printout of Return submission receipt, for period 01.04.2015 to 30.09.2014. Article C : Printout of Return submission receipt, for period 01.10.2014 to 31.03.2015. Exh.75 : Original Invoice No.014, Dt. 27.06.2014. Exh.76 : Original Invoice No.015, Dt. 27.06.2014. Article D : Photocopy of Invoice No. 016, Dt.28.06.2014 Exh.77 : Original Invoice No.017, Dt. 28.06.2014. -- 2 of 4 -- CS No. 100281 / 2021 Kirti – Vipul Exh.18 3 / 4 Article E : Photocopy of Invoice No. 018, Dt.28.06.2014 Article F : Photocopy of Invoice No. 019, Dt.28.06.2014 Exh.78 : Original Invoice No.020, Dt. 28.06.2014. Article G : Printout of Invoice No. 021, Dt.28.06.2014. Article H : Printout of Invoice No. 022, Dt.28.06.2014. Article I : Printout of Invoice No. 023, Dt.28.06.2014. Article J : Printout of Invoice No. 040, Dt.28.06.2014. Article K : Printout of Invoice No. 041, Dt.28.06.2014. Article L : Printout of Invoice No. 042, Dt.28.06.2014. Article M : Printout of Invoice No. 043, Dt.28.06.2014. Article N : Printout of Invoice No. 044, Dt.28.06.2014. Article O : Printout of Invoice No. 045, Dt.28.06.2014. Article P : Printout of Invoice No. 046, Dt.28.06.2014. Article Q : Printout of Invoice No. 034, Dt.11.09.2014 Article R : Printout of Invoice No. 071, Dt.14.01.2015. Article S : Printout of Invoice No. 072, Dt.14.01.2015. Article T : Printout of Invoice No. 073, Dt.14.01.2015. Article U : Printout of Invoice No. 074, Dt.14.01.2015. Article V : Printout of Invoice No. 075, Dt.14.01.2015. Article W : Printout of Invoice No. 076, Dt.14.01.2015. Article X : Printout of Invoice No. 077, Dt.14.01.2015. Article Y : Printout of Invoice No. 078, Dt.14.01.2015. Article Z : Printout of Invoice No. 079, Dt.14.01.2015. Article Z1 : Printout of Invoice No. 080, Dt.14.01.2015. Article Z2 : Printout of Invoice No. 081, Dt.14.01.2015. Article Z3 : Printout of Invoice No. 082, Dt.14.01.2015. Article Z4 : Printout of Invoice No. 083, Dt.14.01.2015. Article Z5 : Printout of Invoice No. 084, Dt.14.01.2015. Article Z6 : Printout of Invoice No. 085, Dt.14.01.2015. Article Z7 : Printout of Invoice No. 086, Dt.14.01.2015. Article Z8 : Printout of Invoice No. 087, Dt.14.01.2015. Exh.79 : Email Dt. 14.05.2015 by defendant to plaintiff. Exh.80 : Ledger Account maintained by plaintiff regarding transaction with defendant for period 01.04.2015 to -- 3 of 4 -- CS No. 100281 / 2021 Kirti – Vipul Exh.18 4 / 4 31.03.2016. Exh.81 : Email Dt.05.08.2015 by defendant to plaintiff. Exh.82 : Printout of Ledger Account maintained by defendant regarding transaction with plaintiff for period 01.04.2014 to 17.03.2015. Exh.83 : Office copy of notice sent by Advocate of plaintiff to defendant Dt. 02.06.2018. Exh.84 : Reply Dt 13.06.2018 by Counsel of defendant to the counsel of plaintiff. Court observation : It is made clear to both parties that, documents are marked as Exhibit (in accordance with contents from evidence affidavit) for identification purpose. Both sides are at liberty to prove and disprove the contents of the documents, in accordance with various provisions, pertaining to Commercial Courts Act, Code of Civil Procedure, Indian Evidence Act and Information Technology Act. Further examination in chief is adjourned on oral request of Adv. Kavita Shah for plaintiff. ROAC Mumbai Dated : 05.01.2024 (Vijay S. Hingne) Additional District Judge, Court Room No.31 - Commercial Court, City Civil & Sessions Court, Mazgaon, Greater Mumbai -- 4 of 4 --