Full Order Text
Final Order 1 · 24 Nov 2022 · CNR MHCC010070752022
Order Details: Notice of Motion Pdf Text: 1 NM No.23212022 in Comm. Suit No.12832021 MHCC010070752022 IN THE CITY CIVIL COURT AT MUMBAI. (Court Room No.32) NOTICE OF MOTION No.2321 OF 2022 IN COMMERCIAL SUIT No.1283 OF 2021 M/s. Damani Shipping Pvt. Ltd. …PLAINTIFF VERSUS M/s. Mira Supply Chain Management Ltd. …DEFENDANT Shri. H. R. Shetty, learned advocate for plaintiff. Ms. S. S. Tikare, learned advocate for defendant. CORAM : JUDGE SHRI. N.P. TRIBHUWAN (C.R.NO.32) O R D E R (Delivered on 24/11/2022) This Notice of Motion is filed by plaintiff for : (a) directing defendant to deposit a sum of Rs.6,70,291/ with interest @ 21% p.a. from the date of suit till realisation of the amount. (b) for directing defendant to disclose on oath their movable and immovable properties. 2] Plaintiff contended that it has filed this suit for recovery of sum of Rs.6,70,291/ against defendant. Defendant has admitted to pay bill/invoice amount. Plaintiff has sent legal notice to defendant on 17/7/2021 and called upon him to pay outstanding dues of -- 1 of 8 -- 2 NM No.23212022 in Comm. Suit No.12832021 Rs.6,70,291/ with interest @ 21% p.a. There is every likelihood that defendant may vanish with the amount payable to the plaintiff and hence, plaintiff has taken out this notice of motion. 3] Defendant has filed reply at Exh.7 and contended that a suit is time barred and therefore, liable to be dismissed. Hence, no such direction as prayed in notice of motion be passed. Thus, there is no need of disclosure of movable/immovable properties. 4] In view of above facts following points arise for determination of this court and recorded findings thereon for the reasons stated as under. Points Findings 1 Whether plaintiff prima facie proved that defendant will defeat the decree that may be passed against him? ...No 2 Whether plaintiff prima facie proved that defendant is required to deposit outstanding amount as prayed ? ...No 3 What order ? As per final order. R E A S O N S As to point nos. 1 and 2 : 5] Heard Ld. Counsel of plaintiff. Perused written argument (Exh.13) filed by learned advocate of plaintiff. Advocate of defendant remained absent and therefore, there is no argument on behalf of defendant. -- 2 of 8 -- 3 NM No.23212022 in Comm. Suit No.12832021 6] Advocate of plaintiff relied on following case laws. i) Smt. Sudesh Madhok Vs. M/s. Paam Antibiotics Limited : I A No.5733/2010, dtd.25/10/2010, Delhi HC. 24. In this case, Ex.P1 and Ex.P2 that neither the receipt (Ex.p 1) and promissory note (Ex.P2) mentions any agreement between the plaintiff and second defendant. The first Defendant has failed to disclose the date of oral agreement between the parties. Its director who deposed to the written statement, is not aware of existence of such an agreement. Therefore, the defense is contrary to the admittedly executed written documents. Such defense is not permissible under section 92, Indian Evidence Act, 1872. 25. Ex. P17 established that the first defendant issued TDS certificates showing deduction under Form.16A. The certificate of the chartered accountants in Ex.DW6 dated 12.01.2005 clearly shows that defendant has debited the loan amount of Rs.50 lakhs and its interest of Rs.3,32,877 to the plaintiffs account. This clearly indicates that first defendant admitted to the utilization of the said loan. The first defendant has submitted its ledger extracts which clearly establish the transfer of Rs.50 lakhs to its account by cheque no.670544 dated 04.07.1996. This shows that the money was with it for 6 months. As far as the circumstance that the second defendant issued cheques, which the plaintiff accepted, and sought encashment of, but proceeded to seek remedies through a criminal complaint are concerned, in the absence of any agreement tripartite, between all parties, or between the first and second defendant, transferring the former s ‟ liability vis àvis the plaintiff to the second defendant (with the plaintiff s consent), such fact CS (OS) 1356/1999 Page 14 ‟ cannot amount to estoppel by the plaintiff in asserting its legal rights to recover the amounts from the first defendant. 26. In the light of the above discussion, the court is of the opinion that the materials and pleadings are sufficient to draw a decree on admissions against the first defendant, for the suit claim. It is clarified that in the event the plaintiff secures the decretal amount, it shall not press the criminal proceedings against the second defendant. The suit is decreed in terms of relief clause (a) for the sum of Rs.71,30,822 with pendent lite and future interest at 15% per annum, against the first defendant. The said -- 3 of 8 -- 4 NM No.23212022 in Comm. Suit No.12832021 defendant shall also pay costs, and counsel s fee, quantified at ‟ Rs.75,000/. ii) Delhi Jal Board Vs. Surendra P. Malik : 2003 III AD Delhi 419. 15. The answer to this has to be in the negative. Because Trial court had rightly proceeded on the admissions of fact arising in the suit which left no scope for doubt that tenancy had expired by efflux of time. There was nothing to suggest that the Lease had continued thereafter or any new tenancy was created between the parties to warrant its termination by service of notice under Section 106 TPA. The other issue related to notice under Section 478 DMC Act was also answered rightly. The court was, therefore, within its competence and justified to render the judgment on the admissions of fact that tenancy had expired by efflux of time and to leave aside the other issues even though these may have been determinable. There was also nothing wrong in its doing so though the suit was at evidence stage because it could enter such judgment at any stage of the suit in the mutual interest of both parties. It is also not that if objections taken by Appellant were entertained, it would have altered the result or the course of the suit anyway. 16. Therefore, looking at it in the right perspective and from any angle, we find nothing wrong in the Trial court judgment which is affirmed and this appeal dismissed. iii) M/s Sundaram Finance Limited and another Vs. T. Thankam : Civil Appeal no. 2079/2015 dt.20/02/2015, SC 15. Once an application in due compliance of Section 8 of the Arbitration Act is filed, the approach of the civil court should be not to see whether the court has jurisdiction. It should be to see whether its jurisdiction has been ousted. There is a lot of difference between the two approaches. Once it is brought to the notice of the court that its jurisdiction has been taken away in terms of the procedure prescribed under a special statue, the civil court should first see whether there is ouster of jurisdiction in terms or compliance of the procedure under the special statute. The general law should yield to the special law – generalia specialibus non derogant. In such a situation, the approach shall not be to see whether there is still jurisdiction in the civil court under the general law. Such approaches would only delay the -- 4 of 8 -- 5 NM No.23212022 in Comm. Suit No.12832021 resolution of disputes and complicate the redressal of grievance and of course unnecessarily increase the pendency in the court. iv) Masters Management Consultants and Nitesh Estate limited : WP no. 12297/2016, dt. 01/07/2022, Kar HC. 17. On reading of clauses 12.1 and 12.2 coupled with definition of 'nonbinding', this Court would find that there is absolutely no intention on the parties to enter into arbitration agreement and if there is no intention on the part of the parties to the agreement to refer their disputes to Arbitrator for adjudication and if there is no willingness to be bound by a decision of such Tribunal, the present suit instituted before the Court is very much maintainable. The impugned order under challenge has to be examined in the light of the principles laid down by the Hon'ble Apex Court in the case of Jagdish Chander (supra). The Hon'ble Apex Court in the judgment cited supra was of the view that mere clause in an agreement will not make it an arbitration agreement where a further clause is found in the agreement indicating a further fresh consent of the parties for reference to arbitration. The Hon'ble Apex Court was of the view that the main attribute of an arbitration agreement is consensus of the parties to refer the dispute to an arbitration. Therefore, the principles laid down by the Hon'ble Apex Court in the case of Jagdish Chander (supra) are squarely applicable to the present case on hand. 18. Clause 12.2 clearly contemplates that dispute will be immediately submitted to nonbinding arbitration under the Act. It further contemplates that if parties are unable to satisfactorily resolve the disputes pursuant to such non binding arbitration, either party may initiate litigation. It is in the background of clause 12.2, this Court is of the view that the agreement cannot be termed as an arbitration agreement. Therefore, clause 12.2 clearly demonstrates that the parties are at liberty to ventilate their grievances by initiating litigation before the Civil Court and therefore, clause 12.2 clearly detracts from an arbitration agreement and therefore, the agreement which is the subject matter of the suit cannot be treated as an arbitration agreement. The present agreement does not impliedly either spells out or contemplates a clause providing reference of dispute to arbitration. 19. In the light of long line of authorities rendered by the Hon'ble Apex Court, clause 12.2 clearly demonstrates that there is no -- 5 of 8 -- 6 NM No.23212022 in Comm. Suit No.12832021 arbitration agreement between the parties and the clause incorporated in the agreement does not contain the attributes that are required to be present for an agreement to be considered as an arbitration agreement. Therefore, the Court below grossly erred in returning the plaint by invoking Section 8 of the Act. Therefore, the order under challenge is not at all sustainable. Accordingly, point No.2 formulated above is answered in the affirmative. 7] Advocate of plaintiff mentioned in written argument that the present notice of motion is under order 12 rule 6 of CPC for judgment on admission. Pertaining to mentioned here that plaintiff has not mentioned order 12 Rule 6 of CPC in the present notice of motion. He prayed in the notice motion for directing defendant to deposit Rs.6,70,291/ and for directing defendant to disclosed their movable and immovable properties. He has not claimed and judgment on admission. The plaintiff has mentioned ground for taking out this notice of motion in the affidavit that defendant may vanish with the amount payable to plaintiff. Thus it seems that the present notice of motion is under Order 38 Rule 2 of CPC for security. 8] However, plaintiff has not brought on record any such fact to primafacie come to the conclusion that defendant is trying to frustrate the decree that may be passed against him. It is not case of plaintiff that defendant is intending to dispose of their movable and immovable properties. He has not specifically mentioned any instance of attempt of defendant to dispose of the said property with intend to delay the execution of decree that may be passed. There must be some material like third party affidavits or other material to satisfy that the defendant is going to avoid or caused delay for execution of decree. Hence, in view of above facts and case laws it is not desirable to direct the defendant to deposit the amount or furnish security deposit. -- 6 of 8 -- 7 NM No.23212022 in Comm. Suit No.12832021 Therefore, I answer point nos. 1 and 2 in the negative and passed following order. ORDER Notice of Motion No.2321 of 2022 stands rejected. Date : 24/11/2022. (N.P. Tribhuwan) Judge, City Civil Court, C.R.No.32. -- 7 of 8 -- 8 NM No.23212022 in Comm. Suit No.12832021 Dictated on : 24/11/2022 Checked on : 24/11/2022 Signed on : 24/11/2022 CERTIFIED TO BE TRUE AND CORRECT COPY OF THE ORIGINAL SIGNED JUDGMENT/ORDER” 25/11/2022 Mrs.Rupali S. Bhor UPLOAD DATE AND TIME NAME OF STENOGRAPHER Name of the Judge(with CR No.) HHJ SHRI. N. P. TRIBHUVAN (C.R.No.32) Date of pronouncement of Order 24/11/2022 Order signed by P.O. on 24/11/2022 Order uploaded on 25/11/2022 -- 8 of 8 --
