Full Order Text
Order 11 · 03 Jul 2025 · CNR MHCC010068742019
Order Details: Other Pdf Text: Commercial Suit 79/2019 Exh.56 1 / 2 Date : 03-07-2025 Cross examination of plaintiff witness PW-2 Rakesh Sharma resumed on oath by Adv. Sanjay Bhojwani, for defendant onVC. Adv. Arvind Giriraj on VC a/w Adv. Anjali Dhoot present for plaintiff. 1. I have not filed my affidavit Exh.56 at behest of some one else. It is not true that contains of my affidavit were written as instructed by Pankaj Surekha. It is correct that I am not concerned with business transaction I being an accountant. It is correct that I am not aware how are orders are placed and executed. There is no one in our company by name Sumeet Mahavariy. I do not have any document to show that invoice Exh.33 was accepted by defendant. I am not authorized to access email ID “etcpl1@hotmail.com”. Mr. Pankaj Surekha – Board Director is authorized to access said email ID. 2. There is no document except Bill to show that rate of interest would be 24% per annum and defendant agreed to make immediate payment. I am aware that on 01.07.2016 defendant has sent an email to company informing that invoice is wrong. I am not aware in that email it was mentioned that invoice was wrongly sent to Maruti Steel. I am not aware whether our company has replied that email or not. My company has not raised any grievance in respect of so called amount of net purchase Rs.2,49,912/- and VAT of Rs.14,532/- Total 2,64,444/- either with defendant or Sale Tax Department. 3. I am not aware about email dated 28.06.2016 sent by defendant to my company. Exh.37 notice dated 02.03.2017 doesn’t bear any signature. It is not true that I have this affidavit only to support a false claim. Cross examination is over. -- 1 of 2 -- Commercial Suit 79/2019 Exh.56 2 / 2 Re-examination- Nil BEFORE ME ROAC Mumbai Dated : 03-07-2025 (Shri P. P. Kulkarni) District Judge, Court Room No.31 - Commercial Court, City Civil & Sessions Court, Mazgaon, Greater Mumbai -- 2 of 2 --