Full Order Text
Final Order 2 · 12 Oct 2023 · CNR MHCC010063292023
Order Details: Notice of Motion Pdf Text: 1 N/M. No.2161/23 (L.C.S. No.1591/14) MHCC010063292023 IN THE CITY CIVIL COURT FOR GREATER BOMBAY AT MUMBAI NOTICE OF MOTION No.2161 OF 2023 IN LONG CAUSE SUIT No.1591/2014 Deepak Industries … Plaintiff - Versus - 1] The Asst. Municipal Commissioner 2] The Municipal Corporation of Greater Mumbai 3] Rita Anand Chauhan 4] Meenum Chandra Mohan ... Defendants Appearance :- Mr. Jagdale h/f. Mr. Dalal, Advocates for plaintiff. Mrs. Mhatre, Advocate for defendants No.1 and 2/M.C.G.M. Mr. Jain, Advocate for defendants No.3 and 4. CORAM : S. H. SALUNKHE, ADHOC JUDGE CITY CIVIL COURT, COURT ROOM NO.4. DATED : 12/10/2023. O R D E R . The plaintiff has taken out this Notice of Motion for condonation of delay caused in taking out Notice of Motion for -- 1 of 4 -- 2 N/M. No.2161/23 (L.C.S. No.1591/14) restoration of Notice of Motion No. 2173/2014 which is dismissed for default on 4/2/2023. 2] It is contended that present suit was stayed since 13/10/2019 pursuant to the order passed by the Hon'ble Apex Court in S.L.P. (C) No.13770 Of 2018 and in the meanwhile, the advocate for the plaintiff returned the brief to the plaintiff. On 11/8/2022 the plaintiff approached new advocate seeking representation and order of dismissal of S.L.P. was placed on record of this Court and matter was adjourned to [date withheld]. However, due to several health issues the plaintiff was prevented from pursuing suit. It is further stated that the plaintiff is a senior citizen and suffering from several health issues. He required to approach doctor regularly and was advised rest. Owing to this, he was not able to engage a new lawyer. It is further stated that on 18/10/2022 mother-in-law of the plaintiff passed away and on 22/11/2022 his sister passed way. The loss of the loved ones and health condition prevented him to engage a new lawyer. On 13/2/2023 he came to know about dismissal of Notice of Motion. He informed advocate that due to ill- health and death of near relatives, he could not remain present but the plaintiff was advised to provide document. Hence there is delay in taking out Notice of Motion. The delay is not intentional or deliberate. The plaintiff is having a good case on merit. If the delay is not condoned the plaintiff would suffer irreparable loss or injury which cannot be compensated in terms of money. 3] Defendants opposed Notice of Motion on the grounds that the plaintiff has not satisfactorily explained the delay. This court has dismissed Notice of Motion for want of prosecution. The plaintiff failed to assign reason why the erstwhile advocate not appeared in the matter. -- 2 of 4 -- 3 N/M. No.2161/23 (L.C.S. No.1591/14) The plaintiff is not interested with proceed to Notice of Motion and the reason given by the plaintiff are not satisfactory. 4] Heard learned advocates for the parties. Perused Notice of Motion, affidavit in support thereto. Perused record and proceeding. 5] The plaintiff has produced on record copies of documents of medical documents of Mr. Shah, one of the partners of the plaintiff firm since from 2016. It is matter of record that on 4/2/2023 Notice of Motion No.2173/2014 came to be dismissed for default. Notice of Motion for restoration has been tendered on 18/3/2023. Thus, there is hardly delay of 11 days. It is contention of the plaintiff that due to multiple health issues and death of near relatives of the partner of Mr. Shah, the plaintiff was unable to engage a new advocate and pursue the suit. It is further contention of the plaintiff that sometime is required for arranging the documents. It is well settled that the Court should be little more liberal in the matter of condonation of delay and take justice oriental approach. Too strict and hyper technical approach might defeat the cause of justice. In the case on hand, there is delay of 11 days. The plaintiff contended that due to long ill-health he could not engage a new advocate and sometime is required for documents. The grounds mentioned by the plaintiff found satisfactory and, therefore, Notice of Motion for condonation of delay deserves to be allowed. Therefore, considering the reason stated by the plaintiff and in the interest of justice I pass following order :- -- 3 of 4 -- 4 N/M. No.2161/23 (L.C.S. No.1591/14) O R D E R Notice of Motion is hereby made absolute in terms of prayer clause (a). Date : 12/10/2023. ( S. H. SALUNKHE ) Adhoc Judge City Civil Court, Court Room No.4, Gr. Mumbai. “CERTIFIED TO BE TRUE AND CORRECT COPY OF THE ORIGINAL SIGNED ORDER.” 13/10/2023 03:20 p.m. V. V. Kulkarni NAME OF STENOGRAPHERUPLOAD DATE TIME Name of the Judge (With Court Room No.) H. H. Judge Shri. S. H. Salunkhe, Court Room No. 4. Date of Pronouncement of ORDER 12/10/2023 ORDER signed by P.O. on 13/10/2023 ORDER uploaded on 13/10/2023 -- 4 of 4 --
