Full Order Text
Order 2 · 10 Sept 2025 · CNR MHCC010062662020
Order Details: Notice of Motion Pdf Text: NM No. 2042 / 2025 Topworth Vs. Central Bank Order 1 of 6 MHCC010051702025 City Civil and Sessions Court, Mazgaon Greater Mumbai Court Room No. 31 – Commercial Court Notice of Motion No. 2042 / 2025 in Commercial Suit No. 209 / 2021 Topworth Tollways Bela Pvt. Ltd. … Applicant (Original plaintiff) IN THE MATTER BETWEEN Topworth Tollways Bela Pvt. Ltd. … Plaintiff Vs. Central Bank of India … Defendant Appearances : Plaintiffs : Adv. Pranjali Khemnar Adv. Vikrant Pandey i/b. Hedgehog and Fox LLP Defendant : Adv. Arsh Misra CORAM : PRASAD P. KULKARNI COURT ROOM NO.31. DATE : 10.09.2025 *************************************************************** ORDER (Delivered on this 10th day of September, 2025) -- 1 of 6 -- NM No. 2042 / 2025 Topworth Vs. Central Bank Order 2 of 6 1. Plaintiff moved this Notice of Motion with a prayer to set aside order imposing cost of Rs.25,000/- on plaintiff. Notice of Motion is supported by an affidavit. Defendant filed reply affidavit at Exh.21. I have heard both parties at length. 2. Plaintiff contended that in view of Special Case No. 1706/2023, plaintiff was in judicial custody. During his custody, plaintiff suffered serious health complications and was unable to file affidavit in present suit. In all, there are five suits filed by plaintiff and evidence affidavit could be filed only in two suits because of serious health condition of plaintiff and as he was in jail. So, plaintiff submits that the cost of Rs.25,000/-, which was imposed by the then Presiding Officer while granting time to adduce evidence may be set aside. 3. Defendant strongly objected Notice of Motion on ground that many opportunities were granted to plaintiff to tender evidence. However, despite of specific order on Exh.15, plaintiff not filed evidence affidavit on record. For the very reason, the then Presiding Officer of this Court has rightly imposed cost of Rs.25,000/- on plaintiff. Advocate for defendant submits that said cost was not deposited within one week as ordered and immediately after lapse of one week, present Notice of Motion is moved. Advocate for defendant in order to point out strong financial capacity of plaintiff has placed reliance on two orders of Hon’ble Bombay High Court, which are placed below Exh.22. 4. Considering rival submissions, I have gone through record and proceeding. It is a suit of year 2021. Detail roznama of this suit indicates that for want of steps, suit was posted for dismissal on 12.03.2024 and again it was posted for steps on 15.06.2024. On -- 2 of 6 -- NM No. 2042 / 2025 Topworth Vs. Central Bank Order 3 of 6 27.06.2024, Advocate for plaintiff moved an application Exh.15 with a prayer to issue direction to Arthur Road Prison to allow plaintiff to sign on evidence affidavit in jail. The then Presiding Officer on 13.08.2024 allowed Exh.15. However, even after lapse of three dates, plaintiff not tendered evidence affidavit. 5. On 25.03.2025, again oral adjournment was sought and because of that cost of Rs.25,000/- was imposed by the then Presiding Officer and adjournment was granted for filing evidence affidavit. As a matter of record, plaintiff not deposited cost nor challenged said order. On this backdrop, Advocate for plaintiff vehemently argued that plaintiff was ill and as he was in jail, it was not possible for him to file evidence affidavit. 6. However, copy of order Dt. 24.06.2025 in I.A. (L) 16152/2025 in Writ Petition (L) 15187/2025 of Hon’ble Bombay High Court is placed on record by Advocate for defendant. This is an Interim Application filed by plaintiff relating to one Criminal Case wherein plaintiff sought permission of Hon’ble Bombay High Court to travel to United Kingdom, Croatia and Greece during 30.06.2025 to 24.07.2025. Said period is just three months after the order of cost in this case Dt. 25.03.2025. 7. Order of Hon’ble High Court is placed on record to show that plaintiff is financially very strong and Hon’ble High Court recorded undertaking of plaintiff that he will deposit Rs.15,00,000/- on or before 27.06.2025 as an indemnity. So far as second order in Writ Petition (L) No. 15187/2025 is concerned, it is yet another application moved by plaintiff for permission to travel abroad. These two orders though not -- 3 of 6 -- NM No. 2042 / 2025 Topworth Vs. Central Bank Order 4 of 6 directly connected with this suit, but it says that plaintiff is frequently flying abroad and to that end he is depositing huge amount as indemnity. 8. So, in view of above, it is very hard to digest that only because plaintiff was ill, he was unable to file evidence affidavit. If plaintiff was suffering from serious ailment, it would not have been possible for him to travel between these many countries. Here, this Court would like to clarify that similar Notice of Motion No. 2024/2025 filed by plaintiff in Commercial Suit No. 426/2020 was partly allowed and amount of cost was modified only. However, equally it is true that at that point of time Advocate for defendant not filed orders of Hon’ble Bombay High Court before this Court. 9. In such circumstances, I do not find it fit to give a second thought to this Notice of Motion and set aside order Dt.25.03.2025. Sufficient time was granted to plaintiff to tender evidence affidavit. It is only because of delay on the part of plaintiff, matter could not be proceeded further. If plaintiff is ready to deposit huge amount as indemnity for the purpose of traveling abroad, then certainly plaintiff is having capacity to deposit the cost, which was imposed by the then Presiding Officer. 10. Hence, I find no substance in this Notice of Motion. Grounds are not satisfactory. Notice of Motion deserves to be dismissed. Hence, order : ORDER 1. Notice of Motion No. 2042 of 2025 is dismissed. -- 4 of 6 -- NM No. 2042 / 2025 Topworth Vs. Central Bank Order 5 of 6 2. No order as to cost. 3. Order is dictated and pronounced in Open Court. 4. Record of Notice of Motion No. 2042 / 2025 shall form part of Commercial Suit No. 209 / 2021. Mumbai Dated : 10.09.2025 (Prasad P. Kulkarni) Judge, City Civil & Sessions Court, Court Room No.31 - Commercial Court, Mazgaon, Greater Mumbai -- 5 of 6 -- NM No. 2042 / 2025 Topworth Vs. Central Bank Order 6 of 6 CERTIFIED TO BE TRUE AND CORRECT COPY OF THE ORIGINAL SIGNED JUDGMENT/ORDER” UPLOAD DATE TIME NAME OF STENOGRAPHER 10.09.2025 5.45 p.m. Prachi Y. Potdar Stenographer - Grade I Name of the Judge HHJ Shri. Prasad. P. Kulkarni (C.R.NO. 31) Date of Pronouncement of Judgment/Order. 10.09.2025 Judgment/order signed by P.O on 10.09.2025 Judgment/order uploaded on 10.09.2025 -- 6 of 6 --
