Skip to main content
Court Order

Final Order 2

CNR MHCC01006180202020 Mar 2024
Fort, City Civil Court
Mumbai · Maharashtra (MH)
Back to Case

Full Order Text

Final Order 2 · 20 Mar 2024 · CNR MHCC010061802020

Order Details: Copy of Judgment
Pdf Text: 1 Judgment in Comm. SU 042021
MHCC010061802020 Presented on : 16/12/2020
Registered on : 15/01/2021
Decided on : 20/03/2024
Duration : 03Y/02M/05D
Exh.69
IN THE CITY CIVIL COURT AT MAZGAON, MUMBAI.
(COURT ROOM No.32)
COMMERCIAL SUIT No.04 OF 2021
UltraMedia & Entertainment Private
Limited, a company registered under the
provisions of the Companies Act, 1956
and having its registered office at 2C,
Thakkar Industrial Estate, N. M. Joshi
Marg, Lower Parel, Mumbai400 013.
…PLAINTIFF
VERSUS
1. M/s. Penta Enterprises,
Proprietor, Mr. Nandu Vichare, GLACIS
5/502, Main Linking Road, Opp.
Vandana Sarees, Above Indusland Bank,
Next to Anita Dongre, Khar(West),
Mumbai400 052.
2. Mr. Nandu Vichare
Age not known.
M/s. Penta Enterprises, Proprietor,
Residential address : Eversun, 801/8, “A”
Wing, Sahakar Nagar, Andheri(West),
Mumbai400 053.
…DEFENDANTS
Shri. Jash Gandhi i/b. Dua Associates, learned advocate for plff.
Shri. K. M. Kadam, learned advocate for def.
CORAM : H. H. JUDGE SHRI VISHAL SADASHIVRAO GAIKE,
COURT ROOM NO.32.
J U D G M E N T
(Delivered on 20/03/2024)
1. This is a suit for recovery of sum of Rs.10,00,000/
-- 1 of 27 --
2 Judgment in Comm. SU 042021
together with further interest @ 24% p.a. from the date of registration
of suit till realization of entire amount.
2. The case of the plaintiff, in brief is that, it is a company
incorporated under the provisions of Companies Act, 1956 and engaged
in the business of acquisition, exploitation of copyright and distribution
of various media rights of films, television programmes, animated series
etc. in English, Hindi and other regional languages. The defendant No.1
is a proprietary concern of defendant No.2 and also claims to be
engaged in the business of selling and exploitation of various media
rights of films.
3. That, plaintiff is filing the present suit for recovery of a sum
of Rs.10,00,000/ due and payable by the defendants to the plaintiff. In
the normal course of business, the defendants approached to the
plaintiff and represented that they are the sole and exclusive owners of
the copyrights with respect to the 16 films in Hindi and/or Gujarati
languages respectively which are stated herein below (hereinafter
referred to as 'the said films').
i) “Kehte Hai Mujhko Raja” (starring : Biswajeet, Hema
Malini, Dharmendra And Ors.) in Hindi language.
ii) “Buniyaad” (Starrring Shatrughan Sinha, Raakesh Roshan,
Yogita Bali And Ors.) in Hindi language.
iii) “Swarg Jaisa Ghar” (Starring : Raj Babbar, Sumit Sagal,
Anita Raj and Ors.) in Hindi Language.
iv) “Aansoo Aur Muskaan” (Starring : Hema Malini , Ajay
Sahni, Om Prakash and Ors.) in Hindi language.
v) “Ek Alag Mausam”(Starring : Nandita Das, Rajit Kapoor,
Renuka Sahane and Ors.) In Hindi language.
-- 2 of 27 --
3 Judgment in Comm. SU 042021
vii) “Hum Tum Aur Mom” (starring : Krishna Abhishek, Rima
Lagoo and Ors.) in Hindi language.
vii) “Woh Jo Hasina” (starring : MoithunChakraborty, Ranjeeta
and Ors.) in Hindi language.
viii) “Khanjhar” (starring : Sunil Shetty, Tabu and ors.) in Hindi
language.
ix) “Deewane” (starring : Shekhar Suman, Padmini Kolhapure
and ors.) in Hindi language
x) “Naach Govinda Naach” (starring : Govinda, Mandakini
and ors) in Hidi language.
xi) “”Yahan Wahan” (starring : Faraque Shaikh, Surinder Kaur,
Aruna Irani and ors.) in Hindi language.
xii) “Ghar Mein Raam Ga;lli Mein Shyam” (starring Govinda,
Neelam and ors.) in Hidi language.
xiii) “Raat Ke Baad” (starring : Farooque Shaikh, Priya
Tendulkar and ors.) in Hindi language.
xiv) “Trupti” (starring : Tiku Talsania, Virutti Thakar and Ors.)
in Gujarati language.
xv) “Swarg Thi Sunder” in Gujarati language.
xvi) “Radha Ni Badha” (starring : Naresh Kanodia, Purvi, Jitu
Pandya, Minakshi and Ors. in Gujarati language.
4. That, based on the above representations made by the
defendants, the parties entered into a Deal Memo dtd.19.04.2018
(hereinafter referred to as “the said Deal Memo”) whereby the
defendants assigned Negative Rights/Electronic Media Rights
(hereinafter referred to as “said rights”) in and to the said films to the
plaintiff for the consideration of Rs.77,00,000/ upon the terms and
conditions contained therein.
-- 3 of 27 --
4 Judgment in Comm. SU 042021
5. That, it was agreed in the said Deal Memo by the
defendants that they will provide HDD containing DPX/MOV files,
prints negatives (picture and sound) dig beta/beta tapes, DATS, HI8,
Intl sound track, mix/unmix track, songs track, music tracks etc. and all
other material available and also all original censor certificates, link
documents, banner agreement, lab Letters, previous assignment
agreements, License Agreements including all documents which are
related to the said films etc. It was further agreed that long form
agreement will be executed towards the said films in due course. Said
Deal Memo dtd.19/04/2018 duly signed by the defendant No.2 on
behalf of the defendant No.1 (which constitutes a valid assignment
under the Copyright Act, 1957(as amended) in favour of the plaintiff
even though the same was not signed by the plaintiff but was accepted
and acted upon by the plaintiff and constitutes a valid contract.
6. That, thereafter plaintiff has issued a Public Notice dtd.
5.5.2018 in the trade magazine 'Complete Cinema' inviting claims, if
any, in respect of the said films. The plaintiff received various objections
from third parties through various letters and notices with respect to the
said films. The plaintiff had forwarded the said objections and notices of
third parties received by them to the defendants via various emails but
the defendants failed and neglected to reply to the said notice. The copy
of the letter dtd.8.05.2018, 30.05.2018, 16.04.2018 and email dated
27.06.2018 respectively.
7. That, after scrutiny of the said documents, the plaintiff
realised that the defendants did not have rights with respect to 2 films
i.e. Buniyaad and Aansoo Aur Muskan (hereinafter referred to as 'said
two films') therefore defendant No.2 requested to withdraw said two
films from the purview of the said long form agreement hence, it was
-- 4 of 27 --
5 Judgment in Comm. SU 042021
decided that proposed agreement will be only for 14 films excluding the
said two films and hence the consideration was also reduced from
Rs.77,00,000/ to Rs.66,00,000/. As far as the remaining films are
concerned, plaintiff informed the defendants that link documents in
respect of the said films are not completed and requested defendant
No.2 to provide the same so as to prepare long form agreement. In reply
defendant No.2 requested the plaintiff to prepare long form agreement
and defendant No.2 assured to comply with all deliveries of material
and documents by signing the long form agreement and accordingly
said agreement was prepared by plaintiff.
8. That, as agreed in the said Long Form Agreement plaintiff
paid signing amount of Rs.5,00,000/ to the defendant as under :
i. Rs.3,00,000/ less TDS was paid to the defendant No.1.
ii. Rs.2,00,000/ was paid to M/s. Star Traders at the request
and on behalf of defendant No.2 evidencing the above
payment and a copy of mail/request of defendant No.2.
The balance of Rs.61,00,000/ was to be paid after a notice period of 30
days subject to no claim or objection received against the said films
from any person or any third party and on receipt of the physical
delivery of the quality check thereof and receipt of all material and the
documents from the defendants which the defendants failed to provide.
9. That, the plaintiff, to its utter shock and surprise, received
a letter dated 5.9.2018 from the defendants whereby the defendants
have purported to terminate the said Deal Memo and the Long Form
Agreement and the said purported termination is unlawful and illegal.
10. That, the plaintiff was in process of replying to the above
-- 5 of 27 --
6 Judgment in Comm. SU 042021
notice, the plaintiff came across a public notice published in the
magazine Complete Cinema dated 13.10.2018 which was issued by one
Ms George for the alleged acquisition of negative rights by her client
with respect to 11 feature films which included :
i. Yahan Wahan, ii. Who Jo Hasina, iii.Khajar, iv.Deewane, v.Ghar
Mein Ram Gali Mein Shyam, vi. Naach Govinda Naach, vii. Raat
ke Baad, viii. Kehta Hai Mujhko Raaja.
and which were the subject matter of the said Deal Memo and the said
Long Form Agreement in favour of the plaintiff.
11. That, the plaintiff was shocked and surprised by the above
claim and by their letter dtd.17.10.2018 addressed to Ms. George that
they have acquired sole and exclusive rights for the 8 films as
mentioned hereinabove. The plaintiffs also brought the said facts to the
notice of defendants.
12. That, plaintiff was in the process of sending a reply to the
purported letter of termination as issued by the defendant but,
thereafter defendant no.2, alongwith Mr. Aakari Jafri and Mr. Pradeep
Rai visited plaintiff's office and expressed his inability and failure to
deliver the good materials and documents as per the said Deal Memo
and said Long Form Agreement. Further defendants informed the
plaintiff that they have assigned rights to another party and hence, the
notice dtd.13.10.2018 was published by Ms. George. In addition to this
defendants offered for settlement and was expressed their willingness to
pay a sum of Rs.15,00,000/ of which Rs.5,00,000/ which was refund
of signing amount paid by the plaintiff upon execution of Long Form
Agreement and a sum of Rs.10,00,000/ would be paid towards
expenses incurred by the plaintiff. In the said meeting defendants
-- 6 of 27 --
7 Judgment in Comm. SU 042021
agreed and admitted that a sum of Rs.15,00,000/ is due and payable
by them to the plaintiff. The plaintiff by letter dtd. 26.11.2018
addressed to the defendants, placed on record the above facts. Upon
receipt of the said amount, it was agreed that, the plaintiff will issue No
Objection Certificate to the defendants for their further exploitation of
the said films. It is further stated that, till the said amount is received,
the plaintiff's right will not be affected as per the Long Form agreement
and the plaintiff was free to use and exploit the same in any manner
whatsoever. The said letter dated 26.11.2008 was signed by both the
parties and pursuant to the said understanding the defendants have
issued two cheques bearing Nos.524643 dated 10.12.2018 and undated
cheque No.524644 for the sum of Rs.10 lakhs. The said letter contains
an absolute admission of liability on the part of the defendants to make
payment to the plaintiff in the sum of Rs.15,00,000/.
13. That, when plaintiff presented the said cheque bearing
No.524643 dated 10.12.2018 for Rs.5 Lakhs to their bankers for
encashment the same was dishonouored with the remark “Funds
Insufficient”. The plaintiff by their letter dated 31.12.2018 have
informed the said fact to the defendants. Thereafter as part of
arrangement and in discharge of its obligations the plaintiff issued a
conditional NOC in favour of Ms George however, he was not satisfied
with the same and demanded another NOC which it refused to provide
for non payment of the dues by the defendant.
14. That, on 21.01.2019 the defendants visited the office of the
plaintiff alongwith two political leaders and threatened the plaintiff's
Managing Director with dire consequences and demanded that the
plaintiff should issue unconditional NOC to Ms. George. Therefore,
plaintiff had no alternative to issue unconditional NOC to Ms. George.
-- 7 of 27 --
8 Judgment in Comm. SU 042021
Accordingly, a fresh settlement through letter dated 21.01.2019 was
executed on the same day whereby the defendants agreed to pay a sum
of Rs.15 Lakhs to the plaintiff. The said letter constitutes a written
agreement. Pursuant to the said settlement letter, the defendants have
issued pay order for Rs.5 Lakhs and cheque bearing No.524639 dated
8.3.2019 for Rs.10 Lakhs.
15. That, the plaintiff by their letter dated 29.1.2019 placed on
record about the said settlement letter and further recorded that they
have handed over to the defendant the materials in the same condition
which was received by plaintiff for quality checking and transfer
purpose. Defendant alongwith Mr. Pradeep Rai have visited the
plaintiff's office and physically checked the material before receiving the
same and signed the letter dated 29.01.2019.
16. That, again to the utter shock of the plaintiff, the plaintiff
received defendants advocate notice dated 18.2.2019 wherein they have
made false allegations against the plaintiff and alleged that the material
was damaged by the plaintiff. The plaintiff by their advocate’s letter
dated 06.03.2019, placed on record the true and correct facts. The
cheque bearing No.524639 for Rs.10,00,000/ was presented for
encashment on 8.3.2019 to their bankers viz. Yes Bank, Worli, but the
same was dishonoured and returned with the remark 'payment stopped
by the drawer'. Therefore, plaintiff through its advocate, issued a notice
dated 26.3.2019 under Section 138 r/w. 141 of the Negotiable
Instruments Act, 1881. The defendants by their advocates letter dated
8.4.2019 have falsely denied their liability.
17. That, the plaintiff then filed a complaint under Section 138
of the Negotiable Instruments Act, 1881(as amended) in the 7th Court of
-- 8 of 27 --
9 Judgment in Comm. SU 042021
Ld. Metropolitan Magistrate at Dadar, Mumbai. Thereafter, defendants
have filed a false complaint with the Wester India Film Producers
Association against the plaintiff with a view to evade their liabilities and
the said Association by their letter dated 5.4.2019 called upon the
plaintiff to give their comments and plaintiff by their letter dated
15.04.2019 has duly replied to the said complaint.
18. That, the defendants, with ulterior motive defrauded the
plaintiff and duped it for a sum of Rs.10,00,000/ after inducing it to
execute NOC in favour of Ms. George. Therefore, the plaintiff was
constrained to file the present suit. The settlement letter was signed by
the parties in Mumbai and the cheque was issued by the defendant in
Mumbai and the same was payable in Mumbai. Hence, this Court has
jurisdiction to try and decide the suit. Therefore, suit may be decreed as
prayed for.
19. The defendants appeared in response to the Writ of
Summons and filed their Written Statement at Exh.4. The
contention/defence of the defendants, in brief is that, they deny each
and every allegation, submission and averments made in the plaint as
they are false and frivolous. The suit of the plaintiff is liable to be
dismissed with exemplary costs. There is no cause of action against the
defendants as they have already repaid the signing amount to the
plaintiff and received material of the said films from the plaintiff.
20. That, there is no valid and subsisting contract terms which
were agreed or executed between the plaintiff and the defendants
therefore, there is no question of making any payment to the plaintiff by
the defendants. Plaintiff is attempting to extort money from the
defendants when the defendants has already suffered losses due to
-- 9 of 27 --
10 Judgment in Comm. SU 042021
conduct of the plaintiff while performing terms and conditions agreed
between them in respect of the alleged films. The defendants realized
that the plaintiff under false pretext of restorage work on material of 2
films had taken cheque of Rs.10,00,000/ from the defendant No.2 and
such the present suit ought to have dismissed with compensatory costs
on ground of misleading to the Court with false claim.
21. The present suit is devoid of any merits as there was no
privity of contract between the plaintiff and the defendants at any
point of time as the alleged agreements placed on record by the
plaintiff in support of his claim or got unilaterally signed by the
defendant No.2 by playing fraud upon the defendant No.2 by the
plaintiff therefore, the present liable to be dismissed with
compensatory cost.
22. That, during the course of business, the defendant No.2 got
acquainted with the plaintiff and he informed it that he was possessing
sole and exclusive negative rights including all rights and copyrights,
intellectual property rights, all derivative rights and other rights for the
sake of said sixteen films. Therefore, the plaintiff showed its willingness
and interests to acquire sole and exclusive negative rights including all
rights and copyrights, etc. of the said films. Therefore, the defendants
allowed the plaintiff to take inspection in respect of material and it was
confirmed that defendant was having absolute right of the said films.
23. That, due to negotiations, the defendants agreed to assign
sole and exclusive negative rights including all rights and copyrights,
etc. of the said films upon the plaintiff for total consideration of
Rs.66,00,000/. The plaintiff played fraud upon the defendants and
received the signature of defendant No.2 on the alleged Deal Memo
-- 10 of 27 --
11 Judgment in Comm. SU 042021
dated 19.04.2018. The contents in the said Deal Memo are denied by
the defendants.
24. That, as per prevailing practice the plaintiff had given
public notice in the magazine namely “Complete Cinema” for inviting
objections of any person in respect of acquisition of any right in respect
of the said films. After giving the said notice there was no
objection/claim received disputing acquisition of rights hence, plaintiff
further proceeded for acquiring rights of the said films. That, from the
beginning the defendants represented that they had rights of only
fourteen films and the list of those films was given to the plaintiff.
25. That, even after lapse of more than five months, the
plaintiff failed to pay agreed consideration under the said Long Form
Agreement hence, the defendant through its Written Notice dated
05.09.2018 duly terminated the Long Form Agreement and called upon
the plaintiff to return the said rights and material in respect of the said
films specified in Schedule I to III to the said Long Form Agreement.
After issuance of the said notice, the defendants entered into agreement
with third party in respect of the eleven films out of the said fourteen
films. After experiencing adamant conduct of the plaintiff, the
defendants took decision to enter into agreement with third party.
26. That, after receiving the termination letter, the managing
director of the plaintiff called Mr. Jafri who is a common friend and
informed that if the defendants are ready to return its earnest money
paid on execution of Deal Memo then, it would return all rights and
material of the said films to the defendants. Therefore, the defendant
No.2 alongwith Mr. Jafri and Mr. Pradeep Rai visited the office of
plaintiff on 21.09.2019. In the said meeting, after negotiations it was
-- 11 of 27 --
12 Judgment in Comm. SU 042021
realized that plaintiff was not interested to pay remaining balance
consideration amount. Hence, it was mutually agreed that the plaintiff
would return the material of all the said films and the defendants would
repay the earnest amount of Rs.5,00,000/ to the plaintiff. It was
represented by the plaintiff in the said meeting that, while having
custody of the material of the said films, the plaintiff had done
restoration work upon material of two films namely Khanjar and Who
Jo Hasina Thi.
27. That, after raising the said issue of restoration work, the
plaintiff had pressurized the defendant No.2 warning him that, the
material of said films would be returned only after the receipt of
adjustable amount of Rs.10,00,000/. After, due negotiations on the
said issue it was mutually agreed that defendants would handover a
post dated cheque of Rs.10,00,000/ as security and plaintiff would
return the restored material of the said two films alongwith no
objection certificate. Thus, the plaintiff had given NOC in the said
meeting dated 21.01.2019.
28. That, in the above said meeting, the defendants had repaid
Rs.5,00,000/ earnest money to the plaintiff and had also handed over
postdated cheque of Rs.10,00,000/. It was agreed between the parties
that the defendants would verify the restored material of the said two
films through a laboratory and thereafter on satisfaction on
determination of nature of work, the said amount of post dated cheque
would be released. But, after taking custody of the material of films, the
defendants realized that the plaintiff has not given custody of two hard
disks of films namely Ghar me Ram Gali Mai Sham and Nach Govinda
Nach. The said two hard disks were not returned back despite of
agreement that all the material of films would be returned.
-- 12 of 27 --
13 Judgment in Comm. SU 042021
29. That, the defendants had sent the received material of films
to a laboratory for examination of quality of material and on receipt of
report of the said laboratory it was revealed to them that the plaintiff
had handed over damaged material of the said films. Therefore, as per
advise of experts, the defendants had done restoration process upon
material of some films for which he incurred expenses of about
Rs.15,50,000/. It was further informed to the defendant that, plaintiff
had handed over 40% damaged material of the remaining films in the
said fact was informed by third party when it took the material to
laboratory.
30. That, as the plaintiff handed over the damaged material to
the defendants hence, the defendant No.2 through his letter dated
05.03.2019 requested to stop payment of the said cheque hence, the
said cheque was dishonoured. The contents of demand notice sent by
the plaintiff under Section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act, 1881,
are false and incorrect. Therefore, the plaintiff is not entitled for any
claim as alleged in the present suit and the suit deserves to be dismissed
with compensatory costs.
31. On the above facts, following issues were framed at Exh.10
by my learned predecessor for determination and I have recorded my
findings thereon for the reasons stated thereunder.
ISSUES FINDINGS
1. Whether the plaintiff proves that, the
defendants by Deal Memo dated
19.04.2018 assigned negative rights/
electronic media rights in respect of the
films to the plaintiff for consideration of
Rs.77,00,000/
…In the
Affirmative.
-- 13 of 27 --
14 Judgment in Comm. SU 042021
2. Whether the plaintiff proves that, as the
defendants did not have rights in respect of
to films, the consideration was reduced
from Rs.77,00,000/ to 66,00,000/ ?
…In the
Affirmative.
3. Whether the plaintiff proves that,
Rs.5,00,000/ were paid to the defendant
as signing amount ?
…In the
Affirmative.
4. Whether the plaintiff proves that, for the
breach of contract, the defendant has
admitted his liability to pay Rs.15,00,000/
to the plaintiff ?
…In the
Affirmative.
5. Whether the plaintiff proves that, out of
the agreed amount the defendants have
failed to make payment of Rs.10,00,000/
to the plaintiff ?
…In the
Affirmative.
6. Whether the plaintiff is entitled to recover
the amount of Rs.10,00,000/ with further
interest @ 24 % p.a. ?
…@ 9 % p.a. only.
7. What order and decree? ...As per final
order.
REASONS
AS TO ISSUE NO.1 :
32. The affidavit of evidence in lieu of examinationinchief as
(PW1 Neelkanth Banarjee) is filed at Exh.5 alongwith list of documents
Exh.6. The PW1 has repeated and reiterated in his evidence affidavit,
the contents of the plaint and he is crossexamined by the learned
advocate of defendants. Nothing untrustworthy or contradictory has
come on record in the crossexamination of the PW1. He has relied
upon the following documents. Exh.11 Copy of Deal Memo dated
19.04.2018, Exh.12 Original copy of the objection letter (wrongly dated
16.04.2018 issued by Purabi Telefilms., Exh.13 Original objection letter
-- 14 of 27 --
15 Judgment in Comm. SU 042021
dated 08.05.2018 of Tarun Films International, Exh.14 Office copy of
reply dated 19.05.2018 of the plaintiff to Tarun Films International,
Exh.15 Office copy of reminder dated 12.06.2018 by the plaintiff to
Tarun Films, Exh.16 original copy of the objection letter dated
10.05.2018 from Venus Worldwide Entertainment Pvt. Ltd. to the
plaintiff, Exh.17 Copy of the reply dated 15.05.2018 addressed by the
plaintiff to Venus Worldwide Entertainment Pvt. Ltd., Exh.18 Copy of
the objection letter dated 30.05.2018 from U. K. Films to the plaintiff,
Exh.19 Copy of the letter dated 01.06.2018, Exh.20(colly.) copy of
letter dated 18.05.2018 issued by advocate Manish Singh Nair, Exh.21
Copy of Long Term Agreement (page No.35 to 56), Exh.22(colly.)
Original payment voucher alongwith receipt dated 07.06.2018 amount
of Rs.3,00,000/, Exh.23(colly.) Original payment voucher alongwith
receipt dated 07.06.2018 amount of Rs.2,00,000/ paid by plaintiff to
defendant No.1, Exh.24(colly.) Office copy of letter dated 17.10.2018,
Exh.25 Office copy of letter dated 26.11.2018 addressed by plaintiff to
the defendants, Exh.26 Office copy of the letter dated 31.12.2018
addressed by plaintiff to the defendants, Exh.27 Copy of NOC dated
21.01.2019 as issued to Ms. George, Exh.28(colly.) copy of settlement
dated 21.01.2019 duly signed by defendant No.2 on behalf of the
defendant No.1 and Mr. Sushilkumar Agarwal on behalf of the plaintiff
and two witness Mr. Pradeep S. Rai and Mr. Askari Jafri, Exh.29 Copy
of letter dated 29.01.2019 duly signed by the defendants and one Mr.
Pradeep Rai., Exh.30 copy of letter dated 06.03.2019, Exh.31 Cheque
return memo dated 11.03.2019, Exh.32(colly.) Office copy of notice
dated 26.03.2019 alongwith postal receipts and AD card and returned
packets, Exh.33 Copy of defendant's advocate letter dated 08.04.2019,
Exh.34 Admitted photocopy of cheque No.033552 of Rs.5,00,00/
issued by the defendants and Exh.35 admitted Cheque No.524639
-- 15 of 27 --
16 Judgment in Comm. SU 042021
dated 08.03.2019 issued by the defendant.
33. As per order dated 08.04.2022 passed in Notice of Motion
No.596 of 2022, the plaintiff was allowed to file additional affidavit of
evidence and additional documents as follows : Exh.43 Minutes of
meeting of Board of Directors of plaintiff held on 15.10.2019, Exh.44
original Extract of Board Resolution dated 15.10.2019, Exh.45
Certificate under Section 65B of Evidence Act, Exh.46 Form No.16A of
Income Tax, Exh.47 Public notice dated 05.05.2018, Exh.48 Public
notice dated 13.10.2018, Exh.52 notice dated 18.02.2019 issued by
advocate of defendants.
34. The claim of the plaintiff is that, the defendants by Deal
memo dated 19.04.2018 assigned the said rights in respect of said 16
films to the plaintiff for consideration of Rs.77 lacs. The defendants
have, in their Written Statement denied the said claim but, in paragraph
No.7 (e) of their Written Statement admitted that during the course of
business, the defendant No.2 got acquainted with the plaintiff and he
disclosed that the defendants posses all rights and copy rights,
intellectual property rights, etc. for 13 Hindi Films and 13 Gujrathi
Films. Interestingly, in the table given below the said paragraph have
stated the names of only 11 Hindi Films and three Gujrathi Films have
been stated by the defendants.
35. That, the defendants have denied the contents of Deal
Memo dated 19.04.2018 i.e. Exh.11 and have denied that they had
assigned negative rights/electronic media rights of the said films for
Rs.77 Lacs and has contended that the said rights were assigned for
Rs.66 Lacs only. The defendants have pleaded that, by playing fraud
upon the defendants, the plaintiff had obtained signature of defendant
-- 16 of 27 --
17 Judgment in Comm. SU 042021
No.2 on the Deal Memo Exh.11. It is pertinent to note here that, the
defendant No.2 has admitted his signature on Exh.11 and the said
document dated 19.04.2018 shows that the said rights as claimed by
the plaintiff for the said 16 films i.e. 13 Hindi and 3 Gujrathi Films were
assigned by the defendants to the plaintiff for total consideration of
Rs.77 Lacs. Besides that, the defendants through their notice dated
18.02.2019 i.e. Exh.52 clearly admitted that the said Deal Memo dated
19.04.2018 was executed between the plaintiff and the defendants.
Further, it is the defence of the defendants that, through termination
notice dated 05.09.2018 Exh.51 they had rightly terminated the Long
Term Agreement Exh.21. The said Long Term Agreement mentions the
Deal Memo Exh.11 therefore, it appears that, the defendants have taken
contradictory defence by denying the contents of Deal Memo Exh.11
and admitting the contents of Long Term Agreement Exh.21 and
thereafter claiming to have terminated the said contract.
36. That, in view of the documents Exh.11 and Exh.21 proved
by the plaintiff and in view of the admission of the defendants in their
pleadings and in their admitted notice issued to the plaintiff, I hold that,
plaintiff has proved that, through the Deal Memo dated 19.04.2018 the
defendants had assigned the said rights i.e. negative rights/electronic
media rights, etc. in favour of the plaintiff for total consideration of
Rs.77 lacs. Consequently, I answer issue No.1 in the affirmative.
AS TO ISSUE No.2 :
37. As discussed hereinabove, the plaintiff has proved Deal
Memo Exh.11 executed between the plaintiff and the defendants and it
has also proved Long Term Agreement Exh.21. The said Long Term
-- 17 of 27 --
18 Judgment in Comm. SU 042021
Agreement clearly states that, the said rights of defendants for the said
14 films are assigned to the plaintiff for total consideration of Rs.66
lacs. The Deal Memo Exh.11 is prequel to Long Term/Form Agreement
Exh.21. The notice dated 16.04.2018 Exh.12 issued by Purabi Tele
Films to the plaintiff refers the public notice dated 05.05.2018 given by
the plaintiff in magazine namely “Complete Cinema”. Through the said
notice an objection was raised to the exclusive and perpetual copyrights
of distribution, execution etc. regarding two Hindi Films namely
“Khanjar” and “Who Jo Hasina”. The plaintiff also received notice
Exh.13 from Tarun Films International and notice Exh.16 from Venus
Worldwide Entertainment Private Limited on dated 08.05.2018 and
10.05.2018 respectively pertaining to other Hindi Film in the said list of
films included in the agreements between the plaintiff and defendants.
The plaintiff had further received notice Exh.18 also regarding other
titles of Hindi films of which, the defendants were claiming exclusive
rights. That, after scrutiny of all the notices/objections received from
the third party it was found that, defendants were not having any rights
with respect to two films namely “Buniyaad” and “Aansoo Aur
Muskaan” therefore, the defendant No.2 requested to withdraw the said
two films from the purview of their agreements and hence, the total
consideration in the Long Form Agreement Exh.21 was reduced from
Rs.77 lacs to Rs.66 lacs only.
38. The defendants have denied the claim of absence of the
said rights of the said two films out of total 16 films, with them but, as
already discussed hereinabove that, the plaintiff have proved the Deal
Memo Exh.11 wherein the total consideration was 77 lacs for 16 films
besides that, the defendant No.2 admits his signatures on Exh.11 and
21 respectively. Therefore, in view of the above discussion on evidence
led by the plaintiff, I hold that plaintiff has proved that the defendants
-- 18 of 27 --
19 Judgment in Comm. SU 042021
did not have rights in respect of said two films hence, the total
consideration for the exclusive rights of said films was reduced to Rs.66
lacs for total 14 films only. Consequently, I answer issue No.2 in the
Affirmative.
AS TO ISSUE NO.3 :
39. This issue pertains to plaintiff's claim regarding payment of
Rs.5 lacs to the defendants as signing amount. The defendants contend
that they had repaid the said Rs.5 lacs to the plaintiff and thus, have not
disputed its earlier receipt from the plaintiff hence, I answer issue No.3
in the Affirmative.
AS TO ISSUE No.4 AND 5 :
40. Both of these issues are interconnected therefore, they are
being discussed here together to avoid repetition of discussion on
evidence. These issues pertain to the claim of the plaintiff regarding
breach of contract by the defendants and their admission of liability to
pay Rs.15 lacs to the plaintiff and the defendants failure to make
payment of Rs.10 lacs. The receipt of Rs.5 lacs as signing amount by the
defendants is proved by the plaintiff and it has admitted that the
defendants had repaid the amount of Rs.5 lacs but, the dispute is
regarding the defendants alleged liability to pay additional amount of
Rs.10 lacs and their subsequent failure due to dishonour of the said
cheque of Rs.10 lacs to pay the said additional amount.
41. That, it is the claim of the plaintiff that, the Long term
Agreement Exh.21 was executed for total consideration of amount of
Rs.66 lacs for the said rights of said 14 films. Admittedly, Rs.5 lacs were
paid to the defendants and remaining balance amount of Rs.61 lacs
-- 19 of 27 --
20 Judgment in Comm. SU 042021
were to be paid after a notice period of 30 days subject to no objections
received from third parties against the said 14 films and on receipt of
the physical delivery of the quality check and receipt of all the material
and documents from the defendants. It is alleged by the plaintiff that,
as agreed the said material and documents were not received from the
defendants and they received a letter dated 05.09.2018 Exh.51 from the
defendants thereby terminating the Deal Memo Exh.11 and the Long
Term Agreement Exh.21.
42. That, thereafter plaintiff came across public notice dated
13.10.2018 Exh.48 published in “Complete Cinema” magazine by one
Ms. George for the alleged acquisition of negative rights by her clients
with respect to 11 films which were the subject matter of Deal Memo
Exh.11 and Long Term Agreement Exh.21. The plaintiff had proved
their reply dated 17.10.2018 Exh.24 to the said Ms. George and their
letter dated 26.11.2018 Exh.25 to the defendants. The said letter
Exh.25 bears the signatures of the authorised signatory of the plaintiff
and the signature of the defendant No.2. The said letter Exh.25,
according to the plaintiff, was an understanding arrived between it and
the defendants. The authorised signatory of the plaintiff had conveyed
to the defendants that they had expressed their inability to deliver the
material, documents etc. (of the said films) to the plaintiff as per its
requirements and therefore, the defendants had agreed willingness to
pay Rs.15 lacs to the plaintiff. It is also stated that, the defendants
acknowledged that, they are liable to pay the said amount of Rs.15 lacs
to the plaintiff which was due and payable.
43. The said letter/settlement agreement Exh.25 further
stipulated that, the defendants shall issue postdated cheques of Rs.10
lacs and Rs.5 lacs shall be immediately paid at the time of signing of the
-- 20 of 27 --
21 Judgment in Comm. SU 042021
said letter/agreement. It was stipulated that after receipt of said
amount, the plaintiff shall issue no objection certificate for defendant's
further exploitation of said films.
44. The plaintiff has further relied on its letter dated
21.01.2019 Exh.28 which also bears the signature of authorised
signatory of the plaintiff and the signature of the defendant No.2.
Through the said letter/agreement the defendant had agreed that they
shall pay Rs.15 lacs to the plaintiff and the plaintiff had issued separate
NOC letter dated 21.01.2019 to the said Ms. George. It is further
specifically stipulated that the payments by the defendants are the
essence of agreements between the parties and in case of non payment,
the NOC separately issued shall stand automatically cancelled till
receipt of full and final payments as agreed. That, the said agreement
supersedes any and all oral and written arrangements towards the
settlement. The said agreement is subject to arbitration and jurisdiction
of Court in Mumbai only. Thus, the contents of the said
letters/agreements Exh. 28 and 29 are crystal clear.
45. The learned advocate of plaintiff argued that, though the
word “Arbitration” is used in Exh.28 but, the defendants did not raise
this issue in their Written Statement. Therefore, they have forfeited
their right for applying to the Court under Section 8 of the Arbitration
and Conciliation Act, 1996 (hereinafter referred as “the said Act” for the
sake of brevity). He relied on the Judgment of Hon'ble Delhi High Court
in the matter of M/s. SPML Infra Ltd. Vs. M/s. Trisquare Switchgears
Pvt. Ltd., dated 06.07.2022 FAO(COMM) 81/2022 and CM
No.24865/2022. In the said matter the Hon'ble Delhi High Court had
held that, “once the proceedings before the Court or Judicial Authority
progresses beyond the initial stage, it would no longer be permissible
-- 21 of 27 --
22 Judgment in Comm. SU 042021
for a party to then turn around and seek recourse to arbitration. Once,
the proceedings have progressed beyond the stage of completion of
pleadings, such an application would not lie”.
46. The learned advocate of defendant, on the other hand
relied on the Judgment of Hon'ble Bombay High Court in the matter of
USP Studios Pvt. Ltd. Vs. Ganpati Enterprises and Ors., Summons
for Judgment No.21 of 2020 in Commercial Suit No.1420 of 2019
with Interim Application No.834 of 2020. He argued that, under
Section 8 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 the parties ought
to have been referred for arbitration. In the said matter of USP Studios
(Supra), the Hon'ble Bombay High Court held that, “if there is a
semblance of dispute, which is covered by an arbitration agreement, the
judicial authority is statutorily enjoined to refer the parties to
arbitration”.
47. That, at this juncture, it would be profitable to refer to the
provision of Section 8 of the said Act.
“8. Power to refer parties to arbitration where there is an
Arbitration Agreement. (1) A judicial authority, before which an action
is brought in a matter which is the subject of an Arbitration Agreement,
if a party to the Arbitration Agreement or any person claiming through
or under him, so applies not later than the date of submitting his first
statement on the substance of the dispute, then, notwithstanding any
Judgment, decree or order of the Supreme Court or any Court, refer the
parties to arbitration unless it finds that primafacie no valid arbitration
agreement exists”.
48. That, in the present suit, admittedly, the defendants, their
-- 22 of 27 --
23 Judgment in Comm. SU 042021
written statement have not raised the issue of any arbitration clause in
the agreement executed between the parties. No separate application
was been filed by the defendant for referring the parties for arbitration.
This issue of Arbitration Clause has been argued during the final
arguments only. Therefore, in view of the above stated provision of
Section 8 of the Said Act, there arises no question of referring the
parties to arbitration after the defendants have submitted their first
statement on the substance of dispute. Hence, in my humble opinion,
the case laws relied upon by the defendant’s learned advocate are not
applicable in the facts of the case.
49. That, the plaintiff has further relied on Exh.29 i.e.
letter/agreement dated 29.01.2019 which bears the signature of the
authorised signatory of the plaintiff and the defendant No.2 on behalf of
defendant No.1. The contents of the said letter/agreement clearly refers
to settlement arrangement between the parties wherein the defendants
have agreed to pay a sum of Rs.15 lacs towards the settlement for
termination of the said agreement. It is further stated that, the
defendants acknowledged that they have received the materials of the
said 14 films stated in the said agreement, in the condition delivered by
the defendants and no other material are pending with the plaintiff for
delivery. It is further stated that, henceforth the plaintiff will not be
liable for any material in any manner.
50. The plaintiff has also proved the cheque No.524639 dated
08.03.2019 for Rs.10 lacs issued by the defendant No.2 in favour of the
plaintiff and Bank Memo dated 11.03.2019 which states that the said
cheque has been returned unpaid due to “payment stopped by the
drawer”. The plaintiff has further proved its notice Exh.32(colly.)
alongwith RPAD receipts and RPAD acknowledgment card. The said
-- 23 of 27 --
24 Judgment in Comm. SU 042021
notice was issued by the plaintiff under Section 138 r/w. Section 141 of
the Negotiable Instrument Act, 1881 for the dishonour of the said
cheque No.524639 dated 08.03.2019 issued by the defendants. The
defendants have admitted the fact of dishonour of said cheque due to
stop payment instructions given by him to its banker.
51. That, it is the contention of the defendants that, in the
meeting dated 21.01.2019, the plaintiff had alleged that it done
restoration work upon material of two films namely Khanjar and Who
Jo Hasina Thi and had pressurized the defendant No.2 warning him
that, the material of said films would be returned only after the receipt
of adjustable amount of Rs.10,00,000/. After, due negotiations on the
said issue it was mutually agreed that defendants would handover a
post dated cheque of Rs.10,00,000/ as security and plaintiff would
return the restored material of the said two films alongwith no
objection certificate. According to the defendants it was further agreed
that, after verifying through laboratory the claim of restoration work on
the said films, the defendants would release the payment of Rs.10 lacs
to the plaintiff but, it was later on revealed from a lab report that,
plaintiff had handed over 40% damaged material of remaining other
films to the defendants therefore, they incurred expenses of
Rs.15,50,000/ to do the restoration process. Hence, it had stopped the
payment of the said cheque of Rs.10 lacs given as security to the
plaintiff. Therefore, it is not liable to pay any amount to the plaintiff.
52. That, the defendants have pleaded that, playing fraud upon
them the plaintiff obtained the signature of defendant No.2 on Deal
Memo Exh.11 and other agreements but, the defendant No.2 in its
notice Exh.52 has alleged that the plaintiff had arbitrarily asked him to
pay Rs.10 lacs towards compensation and forced him to issue the said
-- 24 of 27 --
25 Judgment in Comm. SU 042021
cheque No.524639. Thus, at the same time, the defendants are pleading
fraud and arbitrariness or undue influence by the plaintiff. The
defendant No.2 examined himself at Exh.59 and proved its termination
notice dated 05.09.2018 at Exh.57 which was already proved by the
plaintiff at Exh.51. Similarly, DW1 proved notice dated 18.02.2019 and
reply dated 08.04.2019 at Exh.58 and 59 respectively which were
already proved by the plaintiff at Exh.33 and 52 respectively.
53. Thus, the defendants have pleaded that, there was a breach
of contract by the plaintiffs therefore, they are not liable to pay the
amount of Rs.10 lacs to the defendants. The learned advocates of
defendants has relied on the Judgments of Hon'ble Supreme Court of
India in the matter of Fateh Chand Vs. Balkishan Dass dated
15.01.1963, Civil Appeal No.287 of 1960 and in the matter of Maula
Bux Vs. Union of India in Civil Appeal No.851 of 1966 dated
19.08.1969.
54. That, there is absolutely no material placed on record by
the defendants or no document relied upon by the plaintiff which
proves that the said cheque of Rs.10 lacs was issued by the defendants
in favour of plaintiff as security. The said agreements i.e. letters dated
26.11.2018 at Exh.25, letters dated 21.01.2019 at Exh.28 and 29
nowhere states that the said cheque No.524639 dated 08.03.2019 for
Rs.10 lacs was issued as security by the defendants and it will only be
honoured after the defendants verify the restoration work done by the
plaintiff. Though, the defendants have alleged that they had received
40% damaged material of its films from the plaintiff and the said fact
was allegedly revealed to it from the lab report but, no such report is
proved on record. In fact, the defendant No.2, letter/agreement dated
29.01.2019 at Exh.29 has acknowledged that he had received the
-- 25 of 27 --
26 Judgment in Comm. SU 042021
material of 14 films in the condition delivered by him to the plaintiff. It
had also accepted that, henceforth, the plaintiff will not be liable for the
said material, in any manner whatsoever.
55. That, there is no material/evidence on record which proves
that the plaintiff had played fraud or pressurized the defendant No.2 to
issue the said cheque of Rs.10 lacs in its favour. There is no evidence of
any contract between the parties that the defendants would release the
said amount of Rs. 10 lacs only after their verification regarding
restoration work expenses. There is no evidence regarding alleged lab
report regarding damaged material received by the defendants from the
plaintiff and no evidence that the defendants incurred cost of Rs.
15,50,000/ for alleged restoration work due to damaged caused by the
plaintiff to its film material. Therefore, the defence of the defendant
that, plaintiff has breached the contract between them, cannot be
accepted. Thus, in view of the above discussion, I hold that, the plaintiff
has proved that the defendants breached the contract of paying the
additional amount of Rs.10 lacs to the plaintiff as agreed between them
through Exh.28 and Exh.29 dated 29.01.2019. Consequently, I answer
issue Nos.4 and 5 in the affirmative.
AS TO ISSUE No.6 :
56. This issue is regarding entitlement of plaintiff to recover
further interest @ 24% p.a. on the amount of Rs.10 lacs of the
dishonoured cheque of defendants. If the documents Exh.28 and 29
relied upon by the plaintiff are perused then there is no stipulation of
payment of any interest on the said amount of Rs.10 lacs if, it is unpaid
by the defendants as per their agreement. Therefore, it would be just
and proper to grant further interest @ 9% p.a. which is current rate of
-- 26 of 27 --
27 Judgment in Comm. SU 042021
interest, on the said unpaid amount of Rs.10 lacs. Consequently, I
answer issue No.6 accordingly and proceed to pass the following order.
ORDER
1. Commercial Suit No.04 of 2021 is hereby decreed with
costs.
2. The defendant Nos.1 and 2 are directed to pay, jointly
and severally, to the plaintiff an amount of
Rs.10,00,000/ alongwith interest @ 9 % p.a. from the
date of filing of the suit till realization of the said amount
in full.
3. Decree be drawn up accordingly.
Date : 20/03/2024.
(VISHAL SADASHIVRAO GAIKE )
JUDGE, CR NO.32
CITY CIVIL COURT, MAZGAON
MUMBAI.
-- 27 of 27 --

TrustJury presents public court-record information for legal discovery and reference. Record availability and detail can vary by source and case.