Full Order Text
Interim Order 1 · 22 Apr 2025 · CNR MHCC010058642025
Order Details: Notice of Motion Pdf Text: 1 Draft N.M. in L.C. Suit No.908 of 2025 CNR:MHCC01-005864-2025 IN THE BOMBAY CITY CIVIL C0URT AT BOMBAY DRAFT NOTICE OF MOTION IN L.C. SUIT No.908 OF 2025 Lata Suresh Thakur .. Plaintiff V/s. 1. The Municipal Corporation of Greater Mumbai & Anr. .. Defendants Appearance:- Adv. Parshuram Puria a/w Adv. Rohit Bamne for plaintiff. Adv. G. V. Jawale for MCGM/defendants. CORAM : HIS HONOUR ADDL. SESSIONS JUDGE SHRI. R. S. ARADHYE CITY CIVIL COURT, GR. BOMBAY (C.R. NO.05). DATE : 22/04/2025. AD-INTERIM ORDER By this Notice of Motion, plaintiff has challenged the notice Dtd.09/10/2024 issued under Section 351 of the MMC Act 1888 and consequent speaking order Dtd.09/04/2025 for the demolition of notice structure/suit premises. 2. Defendants/MCGM have filed their written statement at Exh.5 alongwith documents i.e. inspection report Dtd.09/10/2024, impugned notice and speaking order. I have gone through the affidavit -- 1 of 5 -- 2 Draft N.M. in L.C. Suit No.908 of 2025 in support of Notice of Motion filed by the plaintiff and heard both the sides. 3. On behalf of plaintiff, reliance has been placed mainly on the documents i.e. letter Dtd.22/02/1962 issued by the Corporation to one Milind Sunil Pawar in respect of repairs of shed at Room No.23, behind Chowpatty Market, Babulnath Temple, Dadi Seth Lane, Mumbai;400 007. It is the contention of plaintiff that the subject letter of granting of permission for repairs itself shows that the notice structure/suit premises is in existence since prior to datum line. Therefore, the impugned notice and speaking order obviously become null and void, so under such circumstances, ad-interim protection be granted in favour of plaintiff by restraining defendants/MCGM from taking further action on the basis of notice Dtd.09/10/2024 and speaking order Dtd.09/04/2025 of demolition/removal of notice structure/suit premises. 4. Amongst other various grounds, defendants/MCGM have first of all raised the legal objection about tenability of the suit in view of Section 515(A) of the MMC Act 1888 and Judgment in the case of Abdul Razzaq Sunesra V/s. Municipal Corporation of Greater Mumbai & Ors., Writ Petition (L) No. 1709 of 2013, delivered on 17/07/2013. Against which, plaintiff has relied upon the Judgments in the cases 1) Municipal Corporation of Greater Mumbai V/s. Rajendra Phulchand Gupta and Ors. 2022 SCC OnLine Bom 398 and and Zenith Mataplast Private Limited V/s. State of Maharashtra and Ors. (2009) 10 SCC 388. The Hon’ble Parent High Court in earlier case has decided the question of existence/erection of suit structure before the datum line and if it is -- 2 of 5 -- 3 Draft N.M. in L.C. Suit No.908 of 2025 proved by the aggrieved party, then under such facts, protection can be granted in favour of the plaintiff from demolition/removal of notice structure/suit premises. However, in the second case, the Hon’ble Apex Court has considered the different parameters that when interim protection should be granted and it is held that prima facie case, balance of convenience and irreparable loss are the three basic principles which governs the relief under Order 39 Rule 1, 2 of Code of Civil Procedure 1908. 5. It is true that the plaintiff has solely relied upon the letter Dtd.22/02/1962 issued by the Corporation to her predecessor in title namely Milind Sunil Pawar. No doubt, permission was granted for the repairs of shed at room No.23 but subject to certain terms and conditions. The subject of that letter is regarding repairs of shed, whereas schedule of the impugned notice and speaking order is something different means unauthorised construction of structure with brick masonry wall and A.C. Sheet roof adm. 8.2m in length x 3.2m width at back side and 2.2m width at front side having height 2.8m backside and 2.4m at front side at Room No.23/24, beside B.M.C. Babulnath Market, Dady Seth Road, Babulnath, Mumbai;400 007 without permission from competent authority of B.M.C. as shown in rough sketch. 6. Whatever the documents filed by plaintiff those are considered by the defendants/MCGM while passing the speaking order. The main document i.e. letter Dtd.22/02/1962 is concerned, defendants/MCGM have submitted that this is not the original document and besides this, no any supporting document means -- 3 of 5 -- 4 Draft N.M. in L.C. Suit No.908 of 2025 assessment record is filed on record. It is the fact that except the letter Dtd.22/02/1962, plaintiff has not filed any other document in support of his contention. I have gone through the inspection report and copy of photographs annexed with the said report. Prima facie, structure appeared in the photographs not seems to be such an old structure which carried out during the period of 1960-1965. Therefore, in view of difference in the schedule of notice structure/suit premises mentioned in the schedule of notice and subject of letter Dt.22/02/1962, I do not find any consistency in both the documents, so ultimately come to the conclusion that plaintiff has miserably failed to prove prima facie case and balance of convenience lies in her favour and in absence of these two main ingredients, there will be no question of suffering of any irreparable loss. I am thus of the view that this is not a fit case wherein by exercising discretion, ad-interim protection can be granted. In the result, accordingly, following order is passed. ORDER Ad-interim relief asked by the plaintiff is hereby refused. Date:22/04/2025. (R. S. Aradhye) Dictated on :22/04/2025. Judge, City Civil Court, Typed on :23/04/2025. Gr.Mumbai. Signed on :23/04/2025. -- 4 of 5 -- 5 Draft N.M. in L.C. Suit No.908 of 2025 “CERTIFIED TO BE TRUE AND CORRECT COPY OF THE ORIGINAL SIGNED JUDGMENT/ORDER.” 23/04/2025. 05.05 p.m. (Santosh B. Sawant) UPLOAD DATE AND TIME NAME OF STENOGRAPHER Name of the Judge (With Court room No.) HHJ Shri. R. S. Aradhye (C.R.No.05) Date of Pronouncement of JUDGMENT/ORDER 22/04/2025. JUDGMENT/ORDER signed by P.O.on 23/04/2025. JUDGMENT/ORDER uploaded on 23/04/2025. -- 5 of 5 --
