Full Order Text
Final Order 5 · 23 Dec 2024 · CNR MHCC010052852021
Order Details: Copy of Judgment Pdf Text: CS No.101121 / 2021 Parasmal – APM Judgment (Exh.41) 1 of 14 MHCC010052852021 Suit Filed on : 15.06.2021 Arguments Heard : 22.11.2024 Decided on : 23.12.2024 Duration : 03 Y, 06 M, 08 Days City Civil & Sessions Court, Mazgaon, Greater Mumbai, India Court Room No. 31 – Commercial Court (Additional District Judge : Vijay S. Hingne, LL. M.) Commercial Suit No. 101121 / 2021 Exhibit No. 41 Plaintiff : Parasmal Danmal Jain Proprietor : M/s. Kanak Industrial Corporation, Office address : 105, Ratan Sadan, 2nd Pathan Street, 5th Kumbhar Wada, Mumbai 400 004. VERSUS Defendant : M/s. APM Terminals Pvt. Ltd. Block No. 5-18, Sector 6, Dronagiri Warehouse Complex, Navi Mumbai – 400707. Appearances Plaintiff : Adv. Shri H. R. Shetty Defendant : Adv. Ms. Apurva Mehta Suit for Recovery of ₹. 10,31,986.01/- ************************************************************************ -- 1 of 14 -- CS No.101121 / 2021 Parasmal – APM Judgment (Exh.41) 2 of 14 J U D G M E N T (Delivered on this 23rd Day of December, 2024) Plaintiff has filed two Suits for recovery. One suit is filed against the Shipping Company Maersk and other Suit is filed against the Container Freight Station, APM Terminal. Admitted Facts : 2) Parasmal Danmal Jain, Mumbai, Maharashtra, is proprietor of Kanak Industrial Corporation (hereinafter, plaintiff). Maersk Line India Pvt. Ltd., (hereinafter, Maersk) is shipping Company. APM Terminal (Hereinafter, APM) is Container Freight Station (hereinafter, CFS). 3) Vide, Commercial Invoice No. Mazole / ki / 1149, Dt. 30.12.2020, plaintiff imported Carbon Steel Stainless Secondary Pipes, from Mazole Minerals and Metals FZE, UAE. Said goods were to be shipped in 9 containers from Houston, USA to JNPT, Mumbai, India. Accordingly, Bill of Lading No. 911614880 was generated on 29.01.2021. Shipping Company was, Maersk. Name of the Vessel was, Atlanta. Loading Point was Houston, USA. Port of Discharge was JNPT Mumbai, India. Plaintiff paid amount as stated in the Bill of Lading. Container Freight Station / CFS : 4) According to plaintiff and defendant, admitted business practice is as follows : 1. In Mumbai, containers are to be unloaded at JNPT. 2. However, containers causes congestion at JNPT. 3. To avoid said congestion, Shipping Company has to immediately transport containers to distant place, -- 2 of 14 -- CS No.101121 / 2021 Parasmal – APM Judgment (Exh.41) 3 of 14 known as Container Freight Station (CFS). 4. CFS may be of Shipping Company or of other company. 5. From such CFS, customer take its consignment. 6. Before Ship reaches JNPT, customer has to nominates / inform about its CFS to the Shipping Company. 7. If Customer fails to nominate CFS within time, then, Shipping Company shifts the containers to its own CFS. Disputed Facts : 5) According to plaintiff, he had informed the shipping company Maersk that, CFS is Gateway Distriparks Ltd. However, Maersk transported containers to its own CFS APM Terminals. 6) Hence, plaintiff was required to pay extra ₹.8,52,881/- to APM Terminal. It was thereafter, APM Terminal released the 9 Containers on 22.02.2021 to plaintiff. Further, plaintiff was required to pay ₹.4,24,800/- to Maersk for getting containers from APM to Gateway Distriparks. 7) After making said payments, plaintiff, on 22.02.2021, took delivery of containers, removed its goods and kept empty containers with M/s. Kunal Movers Pvt. Ltd., at JNPT. Two Suits : 8) Hence, plaintiff filed two Suits, as follows : Commercial Suit No. 101121 / 2021, against APM Terminal, for recovery of . 10,31,986.01/- with interest @ 21 % p. a. ₹ Commercial Suit No. 101123 / 2021, against Maersk Line, for recovery of . 4,75,416/- with interest @ 21 % p. a. ₹ Written Statement (Exh.3) of APM in CS No. 1121 / 2021 : Written Statement (Exh.3) of Maersk in CS No. 1123 / 2021 : 9) In both Suits, respective defendants raised identical defenses and sought dismissal of suit, on following grounds : 1. Cut off time for plaintiff to nominate CFS was -- 3 of 14 -- CS No.101121 / 2021 Parasmal – APM Judgment (Exh.41) 4 of 14 09.02.2021. However, plaintiff nominated its CFS on 11.02.2021. 2. As plaintiff failed to provide its CFS nomination within time. Hence, containers were shifted to APM Terminal. 3. Cause of action, if any, for plaintiff is with its Custom House Agent i.e. Sairaj Logistics, who failed to file the CFS nomination within the cut off date. 4. Suit is bad for non-joinder of Sairaj Logistics. 5. Plaintiff was asked to pay as per prevailing rates. Hence, APM or MAERSK is not liable for refund. 6. Plaintiff has not returned the 9 containers. 7. There is non-compliance of Sec. 12-A of Commercial Courts Act. 8. Suit is barred by limitation. Additional defenses of Maersk Line : 9. Plaintiff was required to re-deliver containers to Dyaneshwar Shipping Services, Jambhulpada, JNP. However, plaintiff unlawfully detained the containers, as ransom for its illegal demand of refund. 10. Through Notice Dt. 21.04.2021, Maersk Line asked the plaintiff to return the containers and to pay the detention charges of . 40,95,000/-. However, plaintiff defaulted. ₹ 11. Maersk is only Port agent of carrier Maersk A / S i.e. being agent of disclosed principal, Maersk is not liable. Evidence in both Suits : 10) In both Suits, plaintiff examined Parasmal Jain. In Commercial Suit No. 101121 / 2021, defendant examined its Constituted Attorney Isha Vishwakarma. In Commercial Suit No. 101123 / 2021, defendant examined its employee Vaibhav Prabhuajgaonkar. Issues : 11) Perused Record. Heard Adv. Shri H. R. Shetty for plaintiff. -- 4 of 14 -- CS No.101121 / 2021 Parasmal – APM Judgment (Exh.41) 5 of 14 Heard Adv. Ms. Apurva Mehta for defendant. Issues framed by my Learned Predecessor are reproduced here. My findings and reasons are as follows : Issues Findings 1 Whether plaintiff proves that an amount of ₹. 10,31,986.01/- is outstanding from defendant ?...... In the Affirmative. 2 Whether plaintiff prove that they have suffered the loss of ₹.8,52,881/- alongwith interest and defendant is liable for the said loss?...................................... In the Affirmative. 3 Whether defendant prove that due to fault / omission of the plaintiff agent Sairaj Logistic Pvt. Ltd. the dispute has been raised ? ....................................... In the Negative. 4 Whether defendant prove that suit is liable to be dismissed for non compliance of provision of Section 12 A of Commercial Courts Act?.................................. In the Negative. 5 Whether plaintiff prove that they have cause of action against the defendant ?.................................. In the Affirmative. 6 Whether suit is bad on the ground of misjoinder of parties? In the Affirmative. 7 Whether suit is bad on the ground of nonjoinder of parties?. In the Negative. 8 Whether suit is within limitation?.................................... In the Affirmative. 9 Whether plaintiff is entitled to recover amount of ₹. 10,31,986.01/- from defendants? If yes, at what rate of interest?....................................... In the Negative. 10 What Order?................................ As per final order. R E A S O N S Admitted Dates : 12) From pleadings, evidence, cross-examination and -- 5 of 14 -- CS No.101121 / 2021 Parasmal – APM Judgment (Exh.41) 6 of 14 arguments, the admitted dates are as follows : Date Business 30.12.2020 Plaintiff booked the consignment with Maersk 01.01.2021 Ship Atlanta (9 containers) started from Houston 14.02.2021 Ship Atlanta reached Navha Seva 14.02.2021 All 9 Containers unloaded at JNPT Port 14.02.2021 MAERSK transported containers to its CFS, APM Terminals 22.02.2021 Payment made by Plaintiff with APM 22.02.2021 Payment made by Plaintiff with MERKS 22.02.2021 Plaintiff took possession of Containers at APM 22.02.2021 Plaintiff took out the goods from Containers 22.02.2021 Plaintiff kept empty containers at Kunal Movers. 22.06.2021 Suits filed by plaintiff against APM 22.06.2021 Suits filed by plaintiff against Maersk August 2021 Empty Containers picked by defendant from Kunal Movers Reasons as to Issue No. 5 : 5 Does plaintiff have cause of action? 13) According to plaintiff, he had availed shipping services of Maersk from Houston, USA to Mumbai, India and had asked Maersk to transport the containers to CFS Gateway Distripark. According to defendant, plaintiff failed to exercise option of CFS within time. Hence, as per prevailing practice, Maersk transported containers to own CFS i.e. APM Terminal. In backdrop of above contentions, dispute between is : 1. Whether plaintiff has nominated CFS, within time? 2. Whether charges relating to CFS, which were subsequently levied by defendant, are valid or not? This dispute itself has given cause of action for plaintiff to prefer the Suit against both Maersk and also against APM Terminal. Therefore, Issue No. 5 is answered in Affirmative. Reasons as to Issue No. 4 : 4 Is Suit liable to be dismissed for non-compliance of Sec. 12 A of CCA? -- 6 of 14 -- CS No.101121 / 2021 Parasmal – APM Judgment (Exh.41) 7 of 14 Urgent Interim Reliefs : 14) Sec. 12 A of CCA dealing with Pre-Institution Mediatoin (in short, PIM) reads as : 12 A (1) – A suit which does not contemplate any urgent interim relief under this Act, shall not be instituted unless the plaintiff exhausts the remedy of pre-institution mediation in accordance with such manner and procedure as may be prescribed by rules made by the Central Government. It means, 1. All Commercial suits have to exhaust remedy of PIM. 2. Only after option of PIM is exhausted by plaintiff, its Commercial suit can be registered. 3. If Plaintiff satisfies the Court that he is seeking urgent interim reliefs, only then, court may grant exemption to such plaintiff from PIM and may permit such plaintiff to directly register his Commercial Suit. 15) In both Suits, relevant dates about PIM, are as follows : Date Court Business 15.06.2021 Plaintiff filed Plaint and contemplated urgent interim reliefs. Thereby, plaintiff sought exemption from PIM U / Sec. 12 A of CCA. 15.06.2021 Considering submissions of plaintiff, My Learned Predecessor, dispensed PIM for the Plaintiff. 22.06.2021 Accordingly, both Suits were registered. 30.08.2021 Defendant appeared. 23.09.2021 Defendant filed Written Statement. Defendant objected non-compliance of Sec. 12-A of CCA / PIM. Plaintiff tendered Notice of Motion, seeking interim reliefs. 23.02.2022 My Learned Predecessor, observing that, plaintiff is not pursuing Notice of Motion, disposed off said Notice of Motion as, dismissed in default. 02.11.2022 Plaintiff filed second Notice of Motion for restoration of dismissed Notice of Motion. 11.01.2023 Plaintiff withdrew the second Notice of Motion. 16) Thereby, roznama of both Suits, leads to following inferences : 1. On the ground of urgent interim reliefs, plaintiff sought -- 7 of 14 -- CS No.101121 / 2021 Parasmal – APM Judgment (Exh.41) 8 of 14 exemption from PIM. 2. Relying on his submission, Court granted the plaintiff, exemption from PIM. 3. Thereafter, plaintiff never pursued said interim relief. 4. Defendant, throught is contending that, suit is bad for non-compliance of Sec. 12 A of CCA / PIM. 17) Whenever plaintiff files application / Notice of Motion, seeking urgent interim relief and on that ground seeks exemption from Sec. 12 A of the CCA / PIM, and relying on such prayer, if Court grants an exemption from PIM, then, for such plaintiff, it is mandatory and compulsory to pursue, his application / Notice of Motion, to its logical conclusion. It is immaterial if, subsequently, if Court rejects such application / Notice of Motion. However, if Plaintiff seeks exemption from PIM and for that purpose files Notice of Motion and thereafter if do not pursue that Notice of Motion or withdraw such Notice of Motion, and gives no explanation for it, then such conduct of Plaintiff is sufficient to conclude that, Plaintiff had no intention to sought interim reliefs and that, he filed Notice of Motion, merely to counter Sec. 12 A of the CCA / PIM. In present Suits, plaintiff sought interim reliefs, but thereafter, plaintff withdrew said application. Such conduct of Plaintiff is sufficient to conclude that, plaintiff used the interim relief just to give counter Sec. 12 A of the CCA / PIM. 18) However, in Patil Automation Vs Rakheja Engineers, (2022) 10 SCC 1, the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India, held as : 113.1. We declare that Section 12-A of the Act is mandatory and hold that any suit instituted violating the mandate of Section 12-A must be visited with rejection of the plaint under Order 7 Rule 11. This power can be exercised even suo motu by the court as explained earlier in the judgment. We, however, make this declaration effective from 20-8-2022 so that stakeholders concerned become sufficiently informed. 19) In view of above observations, this Court, vide roznama -- 8 of 14 -- CS No.101121 / 2021 Parasmal – APM Judgment (Exh.41) 9 of 14 Order Dt. 25.10.2024, directed both parties to argue on these aspects. Parties argued on 22.11.2024. Plaintiff submitted that, he has not violated any mandatory provision. Defendant contended that, observations would not be helpful to plaintiff. 20) In view of observations of Hon’ble Supreme Court in case of Patil Automation, it is held that, PIM is applicable only to Suits, which are filed after 20.08.2022. Present Suit, being filed on 15.06.2021, then, it was not mandatory for plaintiff to have pursued the PIM. Therefore, there is no non compliance of Sec. 12-A of CCA / PIM. Hence, Issue No. 4 is answered in the Negative. Reasons as to Issue No. 8 : 8 Is suit within limitation? 21) Relevant dates in dispute are as follows : On 30.12.2020, plaintiff booked consignment with Maersk. The disputed Bill of Lading is dated 29.01.2021. Thereafter, dispute arose and plaintiff filed Suit on 15.06.2021. Irrespective from date when dispute arose between parties, plaintiff filed recovery Suit within three years from date of booking i.e. 30.12.2020. Hence, Suit is within limitation. Therefore, Issue No. 8 is answered in Affirmative. Reasons as to Issue No. 1 & No. 2 : 1. Whether plaintiff proves that an amount of ₹. 10,31,986.01/- is outstanding from defendant? 2 Does plaintiff prove that he suffered loss? 22) In both suits, plaintiff filed Bill of Lading No. 911614880, Dt. 29.01.2021. In both Suits, respective defendant admitted said Bill of Lading. Hence it is relied upon. For convenience relevant upper portion from Bill of -- 9 of 14 -- CS No.101121 / 2021 Parasmal – APM Judgment (Exh.41) 10 of 14 Lading, is scan here : Bill of Lading leads to following inferences : 1. It is on the letterhead of shipping company Maersk. 2. Bill of Lading is prepared by Maersk on 29.01.2021. 3. In said Bill of Lading, shipping company Maersk had stated, final Destination as Gateway Distriparks. 4. It means, on 29.01.2021 itself, Maersk had knowledge about CFS Gateway Distripark. 5. It is admitted that, Ship reached JNPT on 14.02.2021. 6. So, defense that, plaintiff nominated its CFS only on -- 10 of 14 -- CS No.101121 / 2021 Parasmal – APM Judgment (Exh.41) 11 of 14 11.02.2021, or that plaintiff failed to nominate the CFC, within time, is false. 23) It is not case of Maersk that, it was not aware of this Bill of Lading. 24) It is not case of Maersk that, in Bill of Lading, final destination i.e. Gateway Distripark is mentioned, inadvertently 25) It is also not case of Maersk that, it was plaintiff or Sairaj Logistics, who by misrepresentation or fraud, compelled Maersk to mention final destination as, Gateway Distripark. 26) It is not case of Maersk that, though Bill of Lading mentioned final destination as Gateway Distriparks, however for technical reasons, it was not possible for Maersk to use that CFS. 27) It is not case of Maersk that, it had informed plaintiff that, though Bill of Lading is stating CFS as Gateway Distriparks, however, Maersk is using CFS as, APM Terminal. 28) So, shipping company Maersk was bound to follow its own Bill of Lading and was required to transport the containers to CFS Gateway Distripark. Maersk had no authority to transport containers to CFS APM terminal. When Maersk transported containers to APM Terminal, then, it was fault of Maersk. It was not fault of plaintiff. 29) Hence - 1. Whatever charges were levid by Maersk for transporting containers from JNPT to APM Terminal 2. Whatever charges were levied by APM Terminal for storing those containers 3. Whatever charges were required to be paid by plaintiff for re-shifting 9 containers from APM to Gateway, -- 11 of 14 -- CS No.101121 / 2021 Parasmal – APM Judgment (Exh.41) 12 of 14 is actually loss sustained by Plaintiff. Hence, plaintiff is entitled for recovery of such amount. Therefore, Issue No. 1 & No. 2 is answered in Affirmative. Reasons as to Issue No. 3 : 3. Is dispute because of plaintiff agent Sairaj Logistic? 30) Defendant raised objection that, logistic agent of plaintiff i.e. Sairaj Logistics had not informed about CFS to defendant. Hence, Sairaj Logistics is liable to answer the claim. Plaintiff has not joined Sairaj Logistics as party. Hence, Suit is bad for its non-joinder. 31) Bill of Lading Dt. 29.01.2021 clearly mentions CFS as, Gateway Distriparks. It means, right from inception, Maersk Line, was aware of the CFS as, Gateway Distriparks. It is not case of defendants that, it wanted to mention final destination is APM Terminal, however Sairaj Logistics, by way of fraud and misrepresentation, compelled Maersk to mention final destination as Gateway Distripark. As Bill of Lading is prepared by Maersk itself and it is Maersk who mentioned final destination as, Gateway Distripark, then, no fault can be assigned to plaintiff’s agent Sairaj Logistic. Therefore, Sairaj Logistics is not responsible for transportation. It means, he is also not necessary party in the Suit. Hence, the Issue No. 3 is answered in the Negative. Reasons as to Issue No. 6 & No.7 : 6. Is suit is bad for misjoinder of parties? 7. Is suit bad for nonjoinder of parties?. 32) In Commercial Suit No. 101121 / 2021, Parasmal Jain Vs APM Terminal, defense is raised that, Suit is not maintainable against APM Terminal. In Commercial Suit No. 101123 / 2021, Parasmal Jain Vs Maersk Line India, defense is raised that, Maersk Line India is -- 12 of 14 -- CS No.101121 / 2021 Parasmal – APM Judgment (Exh.41) 13 of 14 agent of carrier Maersk A / S. Hence, defendant Maersk Line India cannot be joined as defendant. Hence, Suit is bad for mis- joinder of Maersk Line India. Commercial Suit No. 101121 / 2021, Parasmal Jain Vs APM Terminal : 33) There is no contract / document between plaintiff and APM Terminal. Record do not suggest that, it was APM Terminal who decided to transport containers to its own CFS. Using CFS / APM Terminal, was not decision of APM Terminal. It was Maersk, who transported containers to APM Terminal. So whatever charges are paid by plaintiff to APM Terminal, are recoverable from Maersk. Hence, in Commercial Suit No. 101121 / 2021, Parasmal Jain Vs APM Terminal, Maersk Line India is necessary party. However, in said Suit (filed against APM Terminal), plaintiff has not joined Maersk as party. Hence, Suit filed against APM Terminal will fail for non-joinder of Maersk as necessary party. Commercial Suit No. 101123 / 2021, Parasmal Jain Vs Maersk Line India : 34) As Maersk Line India was actively involved in subsequent transport from JNPT to APM Terminal, then, it is necessary party in both Suit. 35) Therefore, Commercial Suit No. 101123 / 2021, Parasmal Jain Vs Maersk Line India, will not halt even if the APM terminal is not a party to the suit. 36) Therefore, Issue No. 5 to No. 7 are so answered. Citations filed by Plaintiff : 37) Plaintiff has placed its reliance on following judgment of the Hon’ble Superior Court : 1. M/s. Gora Mal Hari Ram Ltd. Vs. M/s. Arebee Star -- 13 of 14 -- CS No.101121 / 2021 Parasmal – APM Judgment (Exh.41) 14 of 14 Maritime Agencies Dt. 13.12.2013. With humbleness and respect, I submit that, the facts from case-in-hand, being different, the observations from Cases- in-Supra, will not help the plainitff. Reasons as to Issue No. 9 & NO. 10 : 9. Is plaintiff entitled for recovery of ₹. 10,31,986.01/- 10. What Order? 38) As the Suit is bad for non-joinder of Maersk Line India Pvt. Ltd., plaintiff cannot be granted any relief from APM Terminal. Therefore, Issue No. 9 is answered in the Negative. Resultant, the Suit is disposed off, by following Order : ORDER 1. Commercial Suit No. 101121 / 2021, Parasmal Danmal Jain Vs M/s. APM Terminals Pvt. Ltd., is dismissed with costs. 2. Decree be drawn up accordingly. 3. Judgment pronounced in Open Court. 4. Plaintiff be informed about their right to challenge this Judgment and period of limitation. 5. After compliance and period of Appeal, Shirestedar and AS to consign Record of the Suit, to Record Room. Mumbai Dated : 23.12.2024 (Vijay S. Hingne) Additional District Judge, Court Room No.31 - Commercial Court, City Civil & Sessions Court, Mazgaon, Greater Mumbai Visit ecourts.gov.in for updates or download mobile app “eCourts Services” from Android or iOS -- 14 of 14 --
