Skip to main content
SUIT - SHORT CAUSE CIVIL SUIT

Mr. M. R. VanaVsThe State of Maharshtra +4 more

CNR MHCC0100524420198-COURT 08 ADDL SESSIONS JUDGE
Fort, City Civil Court
Mumbai · Maharashtra (MH)
CASE DISPOSED
Contested--DISMISSED
Decision Date: 30th October 2025

TrustJury record updated 20 Sept 2026

Case Overview

Registration Number
101507/2019
Registration Date
24 May 2019

Advocates

2

For Petitioner

For Respondent

Parties

6

Acts & Sections

1
Protection of Women from Domestic Violence Act · Sec 9

Case Timeline

Newest first65 dates/groups
Case disposedCompletion recorded

30 Oct 2025

2 records
Court Proceeding

Adv. Hetal Patel for plaintiff present. Adv. Martina Sapkal for defendant No.1 to 3/State present. Adv. Apurva Dalal for defendant No.4 and 5/BMC present.…

Read full proceeding
Business: Adv. Hetal Patel for plaintiff present.
Adv. Martina Sapkal for defendant No.1 to 3/State present.
Adv. Apurva Dalal for defendant No.4 and 5/BMC present.
Exh.50 - Judgment.
F.R.S.R. following judgment passed
ORDER
1. The Suit is dismissed with cost.
2. Decree be drawn accordingly.
Judge
Adv. Hetal Patel for plaintiff filed application for under Order 41 Rule 5 (2) of C.P.C. Application is taken on record and marked as Exh.51.   O-Other side to say.
Adv. Martina Sapkal for defendant No.1 to 3/State endorsed say on appliaction Exh.51.
Adv. Apurva Dalal for defendant No.4 and 5/BMC endorsed say on appliaction Exh.51.
Order below Exh.51
  Heard Ld. Adv. for plaintiff, Ld. Adv. for defendant No.1 to 3 and Ld. Adv. for defendant No.4 and 5.
  By this application the plaintiff has pointed out order dated 29.11.2021 passed by Honble High Court in Appeal from Order No.414/2021 with Interim Application No.3238/2021 and submits that, as per observation in para 3 of the said order, the plaintiff/applicants were permitted to have their hoardings on their respective places mentioned in the plaint, subject to condition that, the neon-signs/hoardings should not be flickering in the residential zone/localities and the said order is in force till today as it is not vacated by further specific order and the matter not yet reached. If that is the fact, in that circumstances it is not necessary for this Court again to grant stay. The suit of the plaintiff is already dismissed on merits. Therefore when the above referred order passed by the Honble High Court is in force as per the say of the plaintiffs Ld. Advocate, in that circumstances this Court do not found any substential loss to the plaintiff. So also it is not necessary to grant stay when my Ld. Predecessor has already rejected notice of motion to that effect and no stay order passed by him/her is in force as on today. Thus I did not find any substance in this application and same is liable to be rejected. Hence, Application Exh.51 is rejected.
Nature Of Disposal: DISMISSED
Disposal Date: 30-10-2025
Final Order 1

Order Details: Copy of Judgment Pdf Text: Judgment L.C.SUIT NO.1507/2019 1 Date : 30.10.2025 MHCC010052442019 Presented on : 24.05.2019 Registered on : 24.05.2019 Decided on : 30.10.2025 Duration : 06 05 07 Years Months…

Read Full Order →

15 Oct 2025

1 record
Court Proceeding

Adv. Suraj Shete h/f Adv. Hetal Patel for plaintiff present. Adv. Namrata Kharat h/f Adv. Martina Sapkal for defendant No.1 to 3/State present. Adv.…

Next purpose: JUDGMENT
Read full proceeding
Business: Adv. Suraj Shete h/f Adv. Hetal Patel for plaintiff present.
Adv. Namrata Kharat h/f Adv. Martina Sapkal for defendant No.1 to 3/State present.
Adv. Apurva Dalal for defendant No.4 and 5/BMC present.
Matter adjourned for reply argument/Judgment to 30.10.2025.
Next Purpose: JUDGMENT

07 Oct 2025

1 record
Court Proceeding

Adv. Hetal Patel for plaintiff present and compilation of citation. Taken on record. Adv. Martina Sapkal for defendant No.1 to 3/State present. Adv.…

Next purpose: ARGUMENT P.H.
Read full proceeding
Business: Adv. Hetal Patel for plaintiff present and compilation of citation. Taken on record.
Adv. Martina Sapkal for defendant No.1 to 3/State present.
Adv. Apurva Dalal for defendant No.4 and 5/BMC present.
Mr. Jagdish Prabhakar Patil, Senior Inspector, License, BMC present.
Mr. Pravin Balkrushna Mane, Inspector, License, BMC present.
Heard Ld. Adv. for plaintiff, defendant No.1 to 3 and Ld. Adv. for defendant No.4 and 5.
Matter adjourned for reply argument to 15.10.2025.
Next Purpose: ARGUMENT P.H.

06 Oct 2025

1 record
Court Proceeding

Adv. Hetal Patel for plaintiff present. Adv. Martina Sapkal for defendant No.1 to 3/State present. Adv. Apurva Dalal for defendant No.4 and 5/BMC present.…

Next purpose: ARGUMENT P.H.
Read full proceeding
Business: Adv. Hetal Patel for plaintiff present.
Adv. Martina Sapkal for defendant No.1 to 3/State present.
Adv. Apurva Dalal for defendant No.4 and 5/BMC present.
Heard Ld. Adv. for plaintiff.
Heard partly argument of Ld. Adv. for defendant No.1 to 3.
Matter adjourned for argument by defendants to 07.10.2025.
Next Purpose: ARGUMENT P.H.

04 Oct 2025

1 record
Court Proceeding

Adv. Suraj Shety for plaintiff present. Adv. Apurva Dalal for defendant Nos.4 and 5/BMC present. Adv. Martina Sapkal for defendant No.1 to 3 present.…

Next purpose: ARGUMENTS
Read full proceeding
Business: Adv. Suraj Shety for plaintiff present.
Adv. Apurva Dalal for defendant Nos.4 and 5/BMC present.
Adv. Martina Sapkal for defendant No.1 to 3 present.
Later on at 01.50 p.m.
Adv. Hetal Patel for plaintiff present.
Adv. Martina Sapkal for defendant No.1 to 3 present.
Matter adjourned for argument to 06.10.2025.
Next Purpose: ARGUMENTS

03 Oct 2025

1 record
Court Proceeding

None present for plaintiff. Adv. Namrata Kharat h/f Adv. Martina Sapkal for defendant No.1 to 3 present. Adv. Apurva Dalal for defendant Nos.4 and 5/BMC…

Next purpose: ARGUMENTS
Read full proceeding
Business: None present for plaintiff.
Adv. Namrata Kharat h/f Adv. Martina Sapkal for defendant No.1 to 3 present.
Adv. Apurva Dalal for defendant Nos.4 and 5/BMC present.
KB
LO at 11.25am
Adv. Himanshu Vyas for plaintiff present.
Adv. Martina Sapkal for defendant No.1 to 3 present.
Adv. Apurva Dalal for defendant Nos.4 and 5/BMC present.
KB
Exh.17 is marked twicely in roznama dated 17.03.2025 and 25.07.2025. Hence, Exh.17 in roznama dated 17.03.2025 is now corrected as Exh.16-A.
Ld. advocate for plaintiff and defendant nos.1 to 3 requested for adjournment. Hence, Time granted.
Matter adjourned for argument to 04.10.2025.
Next Purpose: ARGUMENTS

20 Sept 2025

1 record
Court Proceeding

None present for plaintiff. Adv. Martina Sapkal for defendant No.1 to 3 present and filed evidence closed pursis Exh.49.. Taken on record. Adv. Chaitanya…

Next purpose: ARGUMENTS
Read full proceeding
Business: None present for plaintiff.
Adv. Martina Sapkal for defendant No.1 to 3 present and filed evidence closed pursis Exh.49.. Taken on record.
Adv. Chaitanya Dalvi h/f. Adv. Apurva Dalal for defendant Nos.4 and 5/BMC present.
Matter adjourned for final argument to 03.10.2025.
Next Purpose: ARGUMENTS

03 Sept 2025

1 record
Court Proceeding

Adv. Hetal Patel for plaintiff present and tendered compilation of document Exh.34. Taken on record. Copy already served on other side. Adv. Martina…

Next purpose: RECORDING EVIDENCE P.H.
Read full proceeding
Business: Adv. Hetal Patel for plaintiff present and tendered compilation of document Exh.34. Taken on record. Copy already served on other side.
Adv. Martina Sapkal for defendant No.1 to 3 present.
Adv. Apurva Dalal for defendant Nos.4 and 5/BMC present.
Heard advocates for parties on the point of marking documents.
Document at Sr. No.1,2 and 7 is NOC issued by Police Authority, document at Sr. No.3 is original copy of permit, document at Sr. No.4 is payment receipt, document at Sr. No.5 is copy of order dated 31.03.2010, document at Sr. No.6 is copy of letter dated 12.05.2010, document at Sr. No.8 are photographs, document at Sr. No.9 is copy of certificate issued by MCMG, document at Sr. No.10 is copy of notice issued by Police department, document at Sr. No.11 is copy of letter of police department, document at Sr. No.12 is map by private Engineer, document at Sr. No.13 is copy of letter of police department, document at Sr. No.14 is order passed by P.I. (Planning) Assistant Commissioner of Police, Traffic, Mumbai, document at Sr. No.15 is certificated under section 65B of Evidence Act. Documents relied on behalf of plaintiff are issued by the office of MCGM and or office of defendants. The contents are proved from evidence of PW-1. Hence, document at Sr. No.1 to 7, 9 to 11 and 13 to 15 are admitted in evidence and marked as Exh.35, Exh.36, Exh.37, Exh.38, Exh.39, Exh.40, Exh.41, Exh.42, Exh.43, Exh.44, Exh.45, Exh.46 and Exh.47 respectively.
PW-1 Murtazza Hussaiin  present.
Cross examination of PW- 01 Murtazza Hussaiin  by Adv. Martina Sapkal for defendant No.1 to 3/State is commenced and completed.
Cross examination of PW- 01 Murtazza Hussaiin by Adv. Apurva Dalal for defendant No.4 and 5/BMC is commenced and completed.
The advocate for plaintiff filed evidence closing pursis Exh.48. Taken on record.
Matter adjourned for evidence of defendant to 20.09.2025.
Next Purpose: RECORDING EVIDENCE P.H.

12 Aug 2025

1 record
Court Proceeding

Adv. Hetal Patel for plaintiff present. Adv. Martina Sapkal for defendant No.1 to 3 present. Adv. Apurva Dalal for defendant Nos.4 and 5/BMC present. The…

Next purpose: RECORDING EVIDENCE
Read full proceeding
Business: Adv. Hetal Patel for plaintiff present.
Adv. Martina Sapkal for defendant No.1 to 3 present.
Adv. Apurva Dalal for defendant Nos.4 and 5/BMC present.
The plaintiff has tendered document along with list at Exh.12
The document at Sr. No.1 is xerox copy of NOC dated 01.04.1969, document at Sr. No.2 is xerox copy of NOC dated 11.09.2001, document at Sr. No.3 is xerox copy of bearing old permit No.3841, document at Sr. No.4 is xerox copy of licence fees paid by the plaintiff for month of July-2023, document at Sr. No.5 xerox copy of order dated 31.03.2010, document at Sr. No.6 is xerox copy of letter  dated 12.05.2010, document at Sr. No.7 is xerox copy of NOC issued by Assistant Commissioner of Police dated 13.07.2011, document at Sr. No.8 is copy of photograph showing the exact location of suit hording, document at Sr. No.9 is xerox copy of certificate dated 20.03.2019, document at Sr. No.10 is xerox copy notice dated 06.04.2019, document at Sr. No.11 is copy of letter dated 16.04.2019, document at Sr. No.12 is xerox copy of top survey prepared by registered structural Engineer, document at Sr. No.13 xerox copy of letter dated 22.04.2019, document at Sr. No.14 is  copy of order dated 29.04.2019, document at Sr. No.15 is certificate of 65-B under Evidence Act.
The plaintiff has challenged the order passed by traffic department. The documents filed on record are relevant for decision of issue between the parties. It is pointed out that, original documents are not in the custody of plaintiff. The Ld. Adv. requested to grant permission to lead secondary evidence. The defendants have filed say to the documents. The admissibility of documents is denied mainly on the ground that, original are not filed on record. However the existence of documents is not denied on behalf of defendants. Considering the statements made in the evidence affidavit, the document at Sr. No.1 to   Sr. No. are admitted in evidence subject to objection of defendants and marked Exh.18, Exh.19, Exh.20,Exh.21, Exh.22, Exh.23, Exh.25, Exh.26, Exh.27, Exh.28, Exh.29, Exh.30  Exh.31, Exh.32 and Exh.33 respectively.
Matter adjourned for cross-examination of PW-1 to 03.09.2025.
Next Purpose: RECORDING EVIDENCE

25 Jul 2025

1 record
Court Proceeding

Adv. Himanshu Vyas for plaintiff present and filed evidence affidavit Exh.17 along with documents. Taken on record. Plaintiff is directed to submit list…

Next purpose: ADMISSION DENIAL
Read full proceeding
Business: Adv. Himanshu Vyas for plaintiff present and filed evidence affidavit Exh.17  along with documents. Taken on record. Plaintiff is directed to submit list of document on or before next date. Copy served on defendant No.1 to 5.
Adv. Martina Sapkal for defendant No.1 to 3 present.
Adv. Apurva Dalal for defendant Nos.4 and 5/BMC present.
PW-1 Mr. Murtazza Husaain present and admit the contents of evidence affidavit on S.A. Hence, read and recorded.
Matter adjourned for admission/denial to 12.08.2025.
Next Purpose: ADMISSION  DENIAL

Additional Case Details

Additional Case Details
Filing Number: 105713/2019
Filing Date: 24-05-2019
First Hearing Date: 24th June 2019
Decision Date: 30th October 2025
Court Number And Judge: 8-COURT 08 ADDL SESSIONS JUDGE

TrustJury presents public court-record information for legal discovery and reference. Record availability and detail can vary by source and case.