Full Order Text
Final Order 1 · 24 Nov 2020 · CNR MHCC010051182020
Order Details: Notice of Motion Pdf Text: DRAFT NM L.C. SUIT NO.1263/2020 IN THE BOMBAY CITY CIVIL COURT AT BOMBAY DRAFT NOTICE OF MOTION IN L.C. SUIT NO. 1263 OF 2020 (CNR NO : MHCC01-005118-2020) Mr. Haji Mohammed Yusuf Nagori ) S/o Mohammed Lukman Nagori ) Age 66 years “Nagori House” GNMD-68, ) Makka and Madina Hotel Dharavi, ) Mahim (East), Mumbai – 400 017 )….Plaintiff Vs. 1. The Assistant Municipal Commissioner ) (Building and Factory Department), ) G/North Ward office, Building, Near Plaza ) Theatre Harish Chandra Yevale Marg, ) Kesarawadi, Dadar (West), ) Mumbai – 400 028. ) 2. Designated Officer, The Assistant ) Engineer (Building and Factory Department), G/North Ward office, Building, Near Plaza ) Theatre Harish Chandra Yevale Marg, ) Kesarawadi, Dadar (West), ) Mumbai – 400 028. ) 3. The Colony Officer, (Building and Factory Department), ) G/North Ward office, Building, Near Plaza ) Theatre Harish Chandra Yevale Marg, ) Kesarawadi, Dadar (West), ) Mumbai – 400 028. ) 4. M/s. OSR Teleservices Pvt. Ltd. ) -- 1 of 5 -- DRAFT NM ..2.. L.C. SUIT NO.1263/2020 having mumbai address office No.7, ) BG Shukla Niwas, Carter Road No.8, ) Borivali (East), Mumbai – 400 066 )...Defendants APPEARANCE :- Ld. Adv. Mr. Ansari Asgar Kalim for the plaintiff. Ld. Adv. Mr. Sutar for the defendants/MCGM. CORAM : HER HONOUR AD-HOC JUDGE SMT. C. P. JAIN (C.R.NO.06) DATED : 24th NOVEMBER, 2020. O R D E R Plaintiff has taken out this draft notice of motion to restrain defendant from taking any action of demolition of mobile tower, dismantaling or disconnecting the electric supply in connection to the mobile tower situate in suit premises. 2. Description of suit premises - Mobile Tower situated at “Nagori House” GNMD-68, behind Gani Garage, Main Road, Makka and Madina Hotel Dharavi, Mahim (West) Mumbai – 400 017, commercial shop admeasuring area 15’x10’ sq.feet. 3. Both the learned advocates have conceded to dispose of the suit as well as notice of motion. Therefore, present order is passed. 4. According to plaintiff, he is owner of structure described in the aforesaid suit premises. Plaintiff in this suit has challenged the impugned notice dated 09.11.2020 which according to plaintiff was pasted on the site of the suit premises on 18.11.2020 by defendant BMC. According to plaintiff, defendants BMC is threatening to initiate action against the mobile tower described in aforesaid suit premises without following due proccess of law. -- 2 of 5 -- DRAFT NM ..3.. L.C. SUIT NO.1263/2020 5. The impugned notice dated 09.11.2020 was issued by Assistant Commissioner G North. Plaintiff has replied the aforesaid notice to the Designated Officer, Assistant Engineer (B & F) Department. The speaking order is passed by the defendants BMC on 23.11.2020. The aforesaid speaking order is without considering the reply of plaintiff. 6. It was argued by learned advocate for defendants BMC that the reply is not addressed to the officer who had issued the impugned notice. This argument has substance as the reply is addressed to Designated Officer, Assistant Engineer (B & F) Department instead of addressing to Assistant Municipal Corporation, G North. Therefore, the speaking order dated 23.11.2020 appears to be passed without considering the reply of plaintiff. Anyway the speaking order is not on merits. 7. Plaintiff has averred in plaint that he has made application for permission, regularization on 01.10.2020. It is pertinent to note that this application is also addressed to Designated Officer, Assistant Engineer (B & F) Department which is again not correctly addressed. 8. As the speaking order is not on merits i.e. without considering the reply (due to fault on part of plaintiff), learned advocate for plaintiff is directed to supply the copy of reply to the concerned officer who is present in court today. Learned advocate for plaintiff has supplied the copy which is received by the concerned officer. In interest of both the parties, for aforesaid discussion, it is appropriate that there is speaking order after considering reply of plaintiff. Both the learned advocates as well as the concerned officer has acceded for getting fresh speaking order after considering the reply -- 3 of 5 -- DRAFT NM ..4.. L.C. SUIT NO.1263/2020 of plaintiff. Similarly, in order to avoid multiplicity of proceedings directions can be given to plaintiff to make the online application for permission/regularization through licensed architect. 9. For all aforesaid discussion, in interest of justice, I proceed with following order. ORDER 1. The Assistant Municipal Commissioner of defendant corporation G North Ward shall consider the reply of plaintiff dated 09.11.2020 & the documents tendered by plaintiff and pass fresh speaking order. 2. Till then and in case of adverse order if any, four weeks thereafter, defendant is directed not to take any coercive action in respect of the suit premises. 3. Plaintiff is at liberty to make online application through licensed architect to Assistant Engineer, Building and Praposal Department for regularization/permission with respect to mobile tower described in suit premises. If plaintiff makes such application, the same shall be decided within six weeks from the date of application. The order passed on the application shall be communicated to plaintiff or his licensed architect. 4. In view of the above directions, Suit and Draft Notice of Motion is disposed of. 5. Suit and Draft Notice of Motion be registered for statistical purpose. (C.P. Jain) Ad-hoc Judge, (C.R.No.06) Date : 24.11.2020. City Civil Court, Gr. Bombay Directly Dictated on Computer:24.11.2020 Signed on :25.11.2020 -- 4 of 5 -- DRAFT NM ..5.. L.C. SUIT NO.1263/2020 “CERTIFIED TO BE TRUE AND CORRECT COPY OF THE ORIGINAL SIGNED JUDGMENT/ORDER.” UPLOAD DATE AND TIME : 26.11.2020, 12.28 pm. NAME OF STENOGRAPHER : Mr. Harshal D. Jagtap Name of the Judge (With Court Room No.) HHJ Smt. C.P. Jain C.R. No.06 Date of Pronouncement of JUDGMENT/ORDER 24.11.2020 JUDGMENT/ORDER signed by P.O. on 25.11.2020 JUDGMENT/ORDER uploaded on 26.11.2020 -- 5 of 5 --
