Full Order Text
Final Order 2 · 17 Apr 2025 · CNR MHCC010048922025
Order Details: Notice of Motion Pdf Text: Common Order in N. M. No.1869 of 2025 -: 1 :- and N. M. No.1870 of 2025 MHCC010048922025 IN THE BOMBAY CITY CIVIL COURT AT MAZGAON, BOMBAY COMMON ORDER IN NOTICE OF MOTION NO. 1869 OF 2025 (OLD H. C. I. A. (L) NO.21398 OF 2021) IN COMMERCIAL SUIT NO.1056 OF 2024 (OLD H.C. COMMERCIAL SUIT (L) NO.21256 OF 2021) Crosslink Food & Farms Pvt. Ltd and Anr. … Applicant / (Orig. Plaintiffs) IN THE MATTER OF:- 1. Crosslink Food & Farms Pvt. Ltd., (Earlier known as ‘Cheerful Trade and Realty Developers Pvt. Ltd.,) Through its authorised representative Mr. Nandaram Ghogare, A Companies Act, 1956, an having its registered office at A2, 2nd Floor, Madhu Estate, Pandurang Budhkar Marg, Lower Parel, Mumbai- 400 013. Plaintiff No.1. 2. Lloyds Realty Developers Ltd., (Earlier Known as ‘Aristo realty Developers Ltd.) Through Its Authorised representative Mr. Sharad Bissa, A Company incorporated under the Companies Act, 1956, and having its registered office at A2, 2nd Floor, Madhu Estate, Pandurang Budhkar Marg, Lower Parel, Mumbai- 400 013. Plaintiff No.2. -- 1 of 27 -- Common Order in N. M. No.1869 of 2025 -: 2 :- and N. M. No.1870 of 2025 V/s. 1. DBS Bank India Limited, (Laxmi Vilas Bank Ltd., now part of DBS Bank India Limited), A company incorporate under the Companies Act, 1956, having address at Baba Kharak Singh Marg, Connaught Place, New Delhi-110 001. Also at the ruby, 6th Floor, Senapati Bapat Marg, Tulsi Pipe Road, Dadar (West), Mumbai- 400 028. Defendant No.1 2. Superways Enterprises Pvt. Ltd., A Company incorporated under the Comapnies Act, 1956, having its office at # 91, Mahashri Karve Raod, 1, Pearl Mansion (N), 1st Floor, Mumbai- 400 020. Defendant No.2 3. Shubhkaran & Sons, A Partnership Firm having its office at # 91, Maharshi Karve Road, 1, Pearl Mansion (N), 1st floor, Mumbai- 400020. Defendant No.3 4. Ashok Investors Trust Limited, (Assignee of DBS Bank of India Limited) A Company incorporated under the Companies Act, 1956, and the Reserve Bank of India Act, 1934, having its address at 701, The Capital, G Bloc, Bandra Kurla Complex, Behind ICICI Bank, Plot C-70, Bandra (East), Mumbai- 400 051. Defendant No.4 -- 2 of 27 -- Common Order in N. M. No.1869 of 2025 -: 3 :- and N. M. No.1870 of 2025 AND MHCC010049022025 ORDER IN NOTICE OF MOTION NO. 1870 OF 2025 (OLD H. C. I. A. NO.13622 OF 2022) IN COMMERCIAL SUIT NO.1056 OF 2024 (OLD H.C. COMMERCIAL SUIT (L) NO.21256 OF 2021) Crosslink Food & Farms Pvt. Ltd and Anr. … Applicant / (Orig. Plaintiffs) IN THE MATTER OF:- 1. Crosslink Food & Farms Pvt. Ltd., (Earlier known as ‘Cheerful Trade and Realty Developers Pvt. Ltd.,) Through its authorised representative Mr. Nandaram Ghogare, A Companies Act, 1956, an having its registered office at A2, 2nd Floor, Madhu Estate, Pandurang Budhkar Marg, Lower Parel, Mumbai- 400 013. Plaintiff No.1. 2. Lloyds Realty Developers Ltd., (Earlier Known as ‘Aristo realty Developers Ltd.’) Through Its Authorised representative Mr. Sharad Bissa, A Company incorporated under the Companies Act, 1956, and having its registered office at A2, 2nd Floor, Madhu Estate, Pandurang Budhkar Marg, Lower Parel, Mumbai- 400 013. Plaintiff No.2. -- 3 of 27 -- Common Order in N. M. No.1869 of 2025 -: 4 :- and N. M. No.1870 of 2025 V/s. 1. DBS Bank India Limited, (Laxmi Vilas Bank Ltd., now part of DBS Bank India Limited), A company incorporate under the Companies Act, 1956, having address at Baba Kharak Singh Marg, Connaught Place, New Delhi-110 001. Also at the ruby, 6th Floor, Senapati Bapat Marg, Tulsi Pipe Road, Dadar (West), Mumbai- 400 028. Defendant No.1 2. Superways Enterprises Pvt. Ltd., A Company incorporated under the Comapnies Act, 1956, having its office at # 91, Mahashri Karve Raod, 1, Pearl Mansion (N), 1st Floor, Mumbai- 400 020. Defendant No.2 3. Shubhkaran & Sons, A Partnership Firm having its office at # 91, Maharshi Karve Road, 1, Pearl Mansion (N), 1st floor, Mumbai- 400020. Defendant No.3 4. Ashok Investors Trust Limited, (Assignee of DBS Bank of India Limited) A Company incorporated under the Companies Act, 1956, and the Reserve Bank of India Act, 1934, having its address at 701, The Capital, G Bloc, Bandra Kurla Complex, Behind ICICI Bank, Plot C-70, Bandra (East), Mumbai- 400 051. Defendant No.4 CORAM: HIS HONOUR JUDGE SHRI A. S. KAZI (COURT ROOM NO.14) DATE : 17.04.2025. -- 4 of 27 -- Common Order in N. M. No.1869 of 2025 -: 5 :- and N. M. No.1870 of 2025 -: Appearances: - Ld. Adv. Dinesh Purandare a/w. Adv. Mallikarjun a/w. Adv. Manorama Mohanty for the plaintiffs. Ld. Adv. Atharva Dandekar for defendant No.1. Ld. Adv. Neerav Merchant for defendant Nos.2 and 3. Ld. Adv. Akanksha Agarwal a/w. Adv. Palash Mulchandanit for defendant No.4. O R A L O R D E R Remand of the present Notice of Motion by the Hon’ble Bombay High Court for decision afresh:- 1) At the outset, it needs to be pointed out here that, earlier these notice of motions were decided by a Single Bench of the Hon’ble Bombay High Court (Coram HIS Lordship Milind N. Jadhav, J.) on 05th June 2023. Thereafter, the Commercial Appeals (L) No.21452 of 2023, Commercial Appeal (L) No.21524 of 2023, Commercial Appeal (L) No.21538 of 2023 were preferred before the Hon’ble Division Bench of the Hon’ble Bombay High Court and by order dated 06th March 2025, their Lordships were pleased to remand the matter back for decision afresh. Hence, the above notice of motions have arisen for decision before me. I accordingly, heard all the concerned parties i.e. plaintiff and the defendants and proceed to decide the same as under:- 2) Heard both sides through their respective counsels. 3) In view of the above, the following points arise for determination before me and I record my findings thereon for the reasons enumerated hereinafter; -- 5 of 27 -- Common Order in N. M. No.1869 of 2025 -: 6 :- and N. M. No.1870 of 2025 Sr. No. Points Findings 1. Whether the plaintiff has made out a prima-facie in its favour for grant of Temporary Injunction as prayed? In the Affirmative. 2. In whose favour balance of convenience tilts? In Favour of the Plaintiffs. 3. To whom irreparable loss will result in granting the relief or in refusing to grant the same? To the Plaintiffs if refused. 4. What Order? As per final order R E A S O N S As to point no.1 to 3:- 4) At the outset, it needs to be clarified here that, during the pendency of the suit, the defendant No.1 has assigned its rights to defendant No.4 and hence, it was joined as a party to the suit. 5) Now, it is well settled that, for claiming a temporary injunction three pronged requirement is that, the plaintiff must prove are a prima-facie case, balance of convenience in his favour and also that, refusal to grant the same will result in irreparable loss or injury to him. In the present case, before discussing whether, the plaintiff has fulfilled the said requirements, it would be pertinent to narrate a brief background against which the above suit and notice of motions have been filed. -- 6 of 27 -- Common Order in N. M. No.1869 of 2025 -: 7 :- and N. M. No.1870 of 2025 BRIEF BACKGROUND OF THE DISPUTE:- PLAINTIFFS’ CASE:- 6) The suit is filed for a declaration that, no valid pledge is created between the parties and that the transactions are without consideration. A further relief of permanent injunction return of shares / Sale Proceeds of Shares already sold along with complete disclosure is also sought by the plaintiff. 7) Now, it is the contention of the plaintiffs that, around the year 2008, the defendant Nos. 2 and 3 availed recurring credit facilities from Laxmi Vilas Bank Ltd., which was subsequently merged with or acquired by present defendant No.1 i.e. DBS Bank India Ltd. The credit facilities were sanctioned on the condition that, a certain percentage of the credit facilities should be covered the shares of ‘M/s. Shree Global Tradefin Ltd.’ 8) As per the case of the plaintiffs, on 01st August 2008, the plaintiff No.1 addressed a letter to defendant No.1 communicating its intent to pledge 2,25,000 shares (now after sub division they are 11,25,000 shares) of ‘M/s. Shree Global Tradefin Ltd.’ In pursuant thereof, in the years 2008, 2009, 2011 and 2012, the plaintiffs executed numerous other pledges / hypothecating forms in favour of the defendant No.1. However, it is contended that, no other documents or instruments were executed between the parties. 9) According to the plaintiffs, they did not receive any lawful or valid consideration from defendant No.1 in exchange for executing the -- 7 of 27 -- Common Order in N. M. No.1869 of 2025 -: 8 :- and N. M. No.1870 of 2025 pledges / hypothecation forms between the years 2008 and 2013. Hence, it is contended that, there existed no valid relationship between the plaintiffs and defendant No.1, where by the rights and / or obligations could be claimed by the defendant No.1. 10) Another stance taken by the plaintiff is that, they have annexed nine pledge / hypothecation forms to the suit plaint and it is contended that no pledge agreement / transaction documents / mortgage documents were entered into and executed between the parties thereafter. Further no stamp duty on any instruments / agreement / pledge forms governing the alleged pledge of shares was paid by either party in pursuant of the pledges. Hence, in the absence of any valid and lawful consideration to the plaintiffs, it could not be construed that, there was creation of a valid and subsisting pledge in favour of defendant No.1. 11) Moving ahead the principal contention of the plaintiff is that, the pledge of shares is in fact invalid and void ab-initio. The plaintiffs can never be treated as Guarantors on behalf of the defendant Nos.2 and 3, i.e. the Borrowers in the present case. This they state because according to them, there is no ‘Guarantee Deed’ executed between the plaintiffs on the one hand and the defendant Nos.1 to 3 on the other hand creating a valid and legally sustainable relationship between the parties. Therefore, the defendant No.1 has no right to claim any amount from the plaintiffs or to sell the shares pledged with it for recovery of dues of defendant Nos.2 and 3. -- 8 of 27 -- Common Order in N. M. No.1869 of 2025 -: 9 :- and N. M. No.1870 of 2025 12) Another contention of the plaintiffs is that, even if, it is assumed that, the pledge of shares created was valid and subsisting between 2008 and 2013, the same cannot be treated as in force today, as the “Closure Date”, provided on each of the Pledge / Hypothecation Form has in fact lapsed more than 8 years ago. 13) However, in the notice dated 16th June 2021 received by them from the defendant No.1, the plaintiffs for the first time learnt about the date of declaration of the above borrowers i.e. defendant Nos.2 and 3 as NPAs i.e. on 31st March 2018. Therefore, the limitation of three years had lapsed for making any claim by defendant No.1 against defendant Nos.2 and 3 from the date of declaration of their accounts as NPAs. This being so, even the defendant No.1 cannot proceed to recover the outstanding dues by selling pledged shares to the detriment of plaintiffs. 14) Hence, the above suit is filed in which it is stated that, the total shares allegedly pledged with defendant No.1 by way of pledges / hypothecation forms annexed to the plaint are 12 Lakhs shares (16 Lakhs Shares as on date after subdivision on 22nd December 2016) and another 3 Lakhs shares (15 Lakhs Shares as on date after subdivision on 22nd December 2016) of ‘M/s. Shree Global Tradefin Ltd.’ 15) Lastly, it is contended that, the closure dates on all the pledges / hypothecation forms governing the alleged pledges of shares range from 13th March 2011 to 31st January 2013 and hence, there is no -- 9 of 27 -- Common Order in N. M. No.1869 of 2025 -: 10 :- and N. M. No.1870 of 2025 subsisting pledge between the plaintiffs and the defendant No.1. Hence, they are constrained to file the above suit. DEFENDANTS CASE :- 16) By filing the affidavit in reply dated 02nd December 2021, the defendant No.1 opposed the notice of motion No.1869 of 2025 on the ground of material suppression of facts and documents executed by defendant Nos.2 and 3 with the predecessor in title of the defendant No.1 i.e. Laxmi Vilas Bank Ltd., in the year 2017. The documents on the basis of which the suit has been filed never formed part of the security documents. 17) It is further contended that, the closure dates mentioned in the documents at Exh.H1 to H9 annexed to the plaint has been transacted only between the plaintiff and their DP Cell and defendant No.1 has no concern with the said closure dates and same does not relate to the pledge of securities created by the plaintiffs. 18) It is further contended that, the defendant No.2 availed aggregate facility of Rs.77 Crores whereas the defendant No.3 availed aggregate facility of Rs.57 Crores from the said erstwhile Laxmi Vilas Bank Ltd., and to secure the enhanced / adhoc / one time ILC / FLC loan limit granted to defendant Nos.2 and3, two separate supplemental agreements of pledge of stock, shares / debentures and other securities held in demat from dated 27th June 2017 and 07th August 2017 were subsequently executed by the plaintiffs along with other security holders in the year 2017. The supplemental agreements are appended -- 10 of 27 -- Common Order in N. M. No.1869 of 2025 -: 11 :- and N. M. No.1870 of 2025 as Exh.C and D to the affidavit in reply by the defendant No.1. It is contended that, plaintiffs and defendant Nos.2 and 3 are signatories to the two supplemental agreement and therefore, plaintiffs are estopped from disputing the transaction of pledge of shares and in that view of the matter, defendant No.1 is entitled to enforce the pledged security for realization of its secured debt. 19) It is further contended by defendant No.1 that, the facilities granted to the defendant Nos. 2 and 3 by the said erstwhile Laxmi Vilas Bank Ltd., was initially secured by pledge of shareholding of defendant No.3 by executing agreement o f pledge of stock / shares / debentures and other securities held in demant form dated 11th February 2010 in the Company and subsequently thereafter by pledge of shares by entering into the two supplemental agreements dated 27th June 2017 and 07th August 2017. the agreement dated 11th February 2010 is appended as Exh.B, to the affidavit in reply of defendant No.1. 20) Regarding the contention of the plaintiffs with respect to the closure dates on the pledge forms ranging between 30th March 2011 to 31st March 2013, it is contended by defendant No.1 that, in pursuant there to, the parties executed two separate supplemental agreements for pledge dated 27th June 2017 and 07th August 2017, whereby, plaintiffs extended the pledge of its shareholdings by way of extension of pledge for securing repayment of loan / credit facility sanctioned in favour of defendant Nos. 2 and 3. The pledge created by the plaintiff in the year 2008 is a continuing security notwithstanding the payments made by defendant Nos.2 and 3 in the interregnum period. It is also submitted -- 11 of 27 -- Common Order in N. M. No.1869 of 2025 -: 12 :- and N. M. No.1870 of 2025 that, if the pledge of shares was created for a limited period of time and the closure dates had lapsed way back in 2013, then, the very fact that the plaintiffs have till date not sought return of its pledge shares clearly raised a question on the conduct of the plaintiffs leading to the inference that the pledge shares were indeed secured with the defendant No.1 towards repayment of the credit facilities sanctioned in favour of the defendant Nos.2 and 3. 21) It is also contended that, in paragraph No.20 to 26 of its affidavit in reply spelt out the entire details of borrowings by the defendant Nos.2 and 3 and execution of various security documents by the parties and more especially plaintiff No.1 having pledged 60 Lakhs shares of the plaintiff Nos.1 and 2 having pledged 15 Lakhs shares of plaintiff No.2 in ‘M/s. Global Tradefin Ltd.’, in the year 2008. It is also contended that, the defendant Nos.2 and 3’s account were declared as NPAs and recalled vide statutory notices dated 25th July 2018 and 13th August 2108 respectively. Defendant No.1 thereafter filed Original Application against the defendant No.2 for recovery of outstanding dues in the sum of Rs.89,83,50,692.22/- with further interest thereon in the Debts Recovery Tribunal, Mumbai, being Original Application No.607 of 2018. Simultaneously, Original Application No.607 of 2108 was filed against the defendant No.3 for recovery of outstanding amounts in the sum of Rs.66,54,24,625.89/- along with further interest. Hence, it is contended that, adequate steps have been taken by the defendant No.1 against the principal borrowers within limitation and therefore, the present action of defendant No.1 is not barred by limitation or bad in law as alleged by the plaintiffs. Hence it is prayed that the notice of motion be dismissed with costs. -- 12 of 27 -- Common Order in N. M. No.1869 of 2025 -: 13 :- and N. M. No.1870 of 2025 REJOINDER OF THE PLAINTIFFS’:- 22) In Rejoinder filed on behalf of the plaintiffs, the main ground of attack is regarding the supplemental agreement dated 27th June 2017 at Exh.C and dated 07th August 2017 annexed at Exh.D to the Affidavit of reply of defendant No.1. It is contain forged signatures of Mr. Viresh Sohoni and Mr. Subhash Singh, who are shown as authorized signatories of the plaintiff Nos.1 and 2. The stamp and common seal affixed on the said documents is also denied. It is submitted that, no such supplemental agreement of pledge of stock, shares / debentures and other securities held in dematerialized form were ever exhibited by the plaintiffs at any point of time. 23) It is further contended that, the signatures appearing on the last page of the agreement at Sr. No.3 as authorized signatory for ‘M/s. Prawas Leasing and Finance Pvt. Ltd.’, is neither of its director nor of its authorized signatory. Similarly, the signature of Mr. Viresh Sohoni, the erstwhile Director of plaintiff no.1, is of a Director who resigned on 30th July 2012 and thus on 27th June 2017 was not in employment of the plaintiff No.1. The agreements are neither notarized nor bears signatures of any witnesses. Both the documents at Exh.C and D are got up documents due to various factual in accuracies while creating the same including the forged signatures. The affidavits of said Mr. Viresh Sohoni and Mr. Subhash Singh are annexed at Exh.B1 and B2 to the rejoinder to show that, Mr. Viresh Sohoni had resigned from the plaintiff No.1 company on 30th July 2012 and Mr. Subhash Singh had resigned from the plaintiff No.2 company on or around 10th January 2011 and it is contended that, both of them were neither authorized nor could have -- 13 of 27 -- Common Order in N. M. No.1869 of 2025 -: 14 :- and N. M. No.1870 of 2025 executed any documents on behalf of the plaintiff Nos.1 and 2 Company. 24) It is further submitted that, Mr. Subhash Singh was not even in the country at the relevant time and period, during which they alleged execution of documents is attempted. Thus, the agreement dated 27th June 2017 and 07th August 2017 are forged and fabricated and plaintiffs are the victims of such forgery. 25) In the light of above pleadings detailed arguments are advanced on behalf of the plaintiffs orally and also by way of written submissions as under:- PLAINTIFFS’ SUBMISSIONS :- a) the past relationship of pledger and the pledgee between the plaintiffs and the defendant No.1 has come to an end because the pledge of shares had been created with a closure date, which is duly reflected in the DP accounts statement and also in the pledge form and a considerable amount of time had lapsed since the closure date relevant to the alleged pledge, which had closed in the years 2011 and 2013. This fact was communicated to the defendant No.1 by two reply letters dated 12th July 2021 and 03rd August 2021 in respond to the defendant No.1 three notices dated 16th June 2021. b) As per the notices dated 16th June 2021, the accounts of both the borrowers i.e. defendant Nos.2 and 3 were declared NPA on 31st March 2018, the period of limitation to file proceedings for recovery of the loan amount arose from the date of default are at the latest from declaration of the account as NPA. -- 14 of 27 -- Common Order in N. M. No.1869 of 2025 -: 15 :- and N. M. No.1870 of 2025 c) In continuation to the reply dated 03rd August 2021, the plaintiffs again requested to the defendant No.1 to provide the documents and agreements on the basis of which they have based their claim and requested inspection of those documents. d) The pledge of secured assets by the plaintiffs by the pledge forms itself has closure dates (Exh.H-1 to H-9 ). These forms also indicate that, there was no other Agreement as there is no agreement date or agreement number and the same has been mentioned as N. A. A chart of these Pledge Forms with all relevant details is also annexed in the plaint including the date of execution and the date of closure of the pledge. It is pertinent to note that, the said Pledge Invocation Form at Exh.E / Pgs No.128-151 of WS of D. I. Also shows that the closure dates which were mentioned in the plaintiffs pledge Form at Exh. H., of the plaint and further there is no mention of the Agreement or Agreement number and the sale is mentioned as NA. Similarly, the Pledge Master Report (Exh.G /Pgs. No.153 of the WS), which is relied upon by the defendant No.1 and Defendant No.4 also shows the same closure dates as set out by the plaintiffs at Exh.H & I . e) The defendants have not produced any agreement which can be co- related to the pledge represented by Exh.H. Thus, the contract of pledge was only for a definite period. The defendant No.1 never exercised its right to ask for extension of the closure dates to keep the pledge alive. f) Instead of admitting the documents of Exh.H1 to H9 filed by the plaintiffs, defendant NO.1 has come with a case that, they are internal to the plaintiffs and do not form part of the security documents and they are not the documents creating pledge and instead have come with a come two supplemental agreements dated 27th June 2017 and 07th -- 15 of 27 -- Common Order in N. M. No.1869 of 2025 -: 16 :- and N. M. No.1870 of 2025 August 2017 respectfully at Exh.C and D, which according to them form and constituted the contract of pledge. But those documents are suspicious and are denied vide rejoinder dated 04th January 2022 to the defendant No.1’s reply. The plaintiffs have filed on record the affidavits of Mr. Viresh Sohoni and Mr. Subhash Singh about their forged signatures thereon. 26) It is further submitted on behalf of the plaintiffs that, the signatures appearing on the last page of the agreement at Sr. No.3 as authorized signatory for ‘M/s. Prawas Leasing and Finance Pvt. Ltd.’, is neither of its director nor of its authorized signatory. Similarly, the signature of Mr. Viresh Sohoni, the erstwhile Director of plaintiff no.1, is of a Director who resigned on 30th July 2012 and thus on 27th June 2017 was not in employment of the plaintiff No.1. The agreements are neither notarized nor bears signatures of any witnesses. Both the documents at Exh.C and D are got up documents due to various factual in accuracies while creating the same including the forged signatures. The affidavits of said Mr. Viresh Sohoni and Mr. Subhash Singh are annexed at Exh.B1 and B2 to the rejoinder to show that, Mr. Viresh Sohoni had resigned from the plaintiff No.1 company on 30th July 2012 and Mr. Subhash Singh had resigned from the plaintiff No.2 company on or around 10th January 2011 and it is contended that, both of them were neither authorized nor could have executed any documents on behalf of the plaintiff Nos. 1 and 2 Company. 27) It is further submitted that, Mr. Subhash Singh was not even in the country at the relevant time and period, during which they -- 16 of 27 -- Common Order in N. M. No.1869 of 2025 -: 17 :- and N. M. No.1870 of 2025 alleged execution of documents is attempted. Thus, the agreement dated 27th June 2017 and 07th August 2017 are forged and fabricated and plaintiffs are the victims of such forgery. 28) The plaintiffs rejoinder affidavit is dated 04th January 2022, however, till date none of the defendants have filed any affidavit denying or dealing with the plaintiffs rejoinder regarding the forged signature as above. This new fact, therefore, specifically disproved claim of the defendant Nos.1 and 4 and has remained uncontroverted. This fact within the special knowledge of the defendant Nos.1 to 3 as per Section 106 r/w. Section 102 and 103 of the Evidence Act, and hence, the burden lies upon them to explain or prove prima-facie the documents which are the foundation of their defence. 29) Hence, they submitted that, the plaintiffs has made out a prima-facie case in their favour. The NSDL handbook and relevant entries therein produced by the defendant No.1 in fact support the plaintiff’s case and shows that the procedure had not be followed by the defendant No.1 for invocation of pledge. 30) Exh.D to defendant No.4’s reply clearly shows that the closure dates is set out in the duration of the pledge, the forms at Exh.H1 to H9 of the plaint and Exh.E to the WS are the forms to be filled by the parties to the pledge while creating and invoking the pledge. Both these forms have record the same closure dates. -- 17 of 27 -- Common Order in N. M. No.1869 of 2025 -: 18 :- and N. M. No.1870 of 2025 31) On the one hand, the defendants have alleged that, the closure date does not mean that, the pledge has ceased to exist and on the other hand they have relied upon forged and fabricated supplemental agreements for extension of the pledge. 32) So far as the limitation for the filing the suit is concerned, Ld. Advocate for the plaintiff submits that, Section 14, 101, 103, 114 and 114(f) fortify the submissions made by the plaintiffs. Further Article 70 of the Limitation Act is complete answer in favor of the plaintiffs on the argument of limitation. Further even Article 58 as argued by the defendant No.4 does not come their rescue because even under this Article, the right to sue for the declaration accrued to the plaintiffs for the first time when the defendant No.1 sought to claim a right to sell the shares on the basis of an undisclosed requested pledged in 2021.The decision of the Supreme Curt in Jawantrai Manilal Akhaney V/s. State of Bombay AIR 1956 SC 7575 also supports the case of the plaintiff. 33) So far as, the objection about joinder of causes of action is concerned, it is submitted that, the plaintiffs causes of action are interlinked and arise from the same transaction and even if, plaintiffs would have filed separate suits, common question of law and fact would have arisen, which warrants the joining of their causes of action. Hence, said contention of defendants is without any merit. 34) Hence, it is submitted that, the balance of convenience is lies in favour of the plaintiff and irreparable loss will also result to the plaintiffs, if the notice of motion is not allowed. Therefore, it is prayed -- 18 of 27 -- Common Order in N. M. No.1869 of 2025 -: 19 :- and N. M. No.1870 of 2025 that, the notice of motion be made absolute. DEFENDANTS’ SUBMISSIONS:- 35) As against this, on behalf of the defendant No.1, the Ld. Advocate Atharva Dandekar submitted that, the plaintiffs have suppressed the pledge agreement from the court and approached the court only on the basis of pledge forms. The Pledge Agreement expressly records that the pledge had been created in consideration for defendant No.1 providing to the borrower and enhancement of Rs.7,00,00,000/- as credit. Hence, it cannot be contended that the pledge was without consideration. A pledger may, in consideration for the pledgee doing an act benefiting a third party, agree to pawn this property to the pledgee. Thus the said submissions cannot be said to be lawful. 36) It is further submitted that, the pledge was invoked on 16th June 2021. Upon invocation of the pledge under Section 176 and 177 of the Contract Act, the pledgee has an option either to retain the pawn and sue for the amounts due or sell the goods and adjust the proceeds against the amounts due. To suggest that, the closure dates mentioned in the said forms operates against the defendant No.1 tantamount to permit to the party to take advantage of his own wrong. In short, the pledge is co-extensive with the loan. It is further submitted that, if the pledge had been closed, then what prevented to the plaintiffs since the year 2013 to remove the noting of pledge for a period more than eight year, until defendant No.1 invoked the pledge on 16th June 2021 and transferred the subject shares in his own name on 20th September 2021. -- 19 of 27 -- Common Order in N. M. No.1869 of 2025 -: 20 :- and N. M. No.1870 of 2025 Even the plaintiffs depository participant (DP) acted on the enforcement request and transfer the shares to the defendant No.1. If the unilateral insertion of closure dates as being 31st March 2013 meant that the pledge stood extinguished and that there was no extension of closure dates, there will be no reasons for the plaintiffs DP to act on the invocation of the pledge by defendant No.1 more than eight years later. Hence, this fact indicates that the insertion of closure dates would not extinguish charge created by way of pledge on those shares. 37) On behalf of defendant Nos.2 and 3, the Ld. Advocate Mr. Merchant, adopted the above arguments and the emphasis laid on the submissions that the pledge is co-terminus with the release of security. It survives the so called “Closure Dates” mentioned on the forms unless the pledge is revoked. The final relief of cancellation of pledge is therefore, prayed for in the suit. Hence, the notice of motion needs to be dismissed. 38) On behalf of the defendant No.4, the Ld. Advocate Ms. Agarwal also filed written submission and in addition made oral arguments. First of all, according to her, the suit is barred by limitation, because it is one for declaration and consequential reliefs and therefore, under Article 58 of the Limitation Act, 1963, it ought to have been filed within 3 years from when the right to sue first accrued. The right therefore accrued to the plaintiffs, when the pledge was created between 2008 to 2011 and alternatively when the pledge ceased to exist on lapses of closure dates in the year 2011 to 2013 and hence, the suit ought to have been filed within a period of three years and latest by -- 20 of 27 -- Common Order in N. M. No.1869 of 2025 -: 21 :- and N. M. No.1870 of 2025 the year 2016, but it is filed in the year 2021 and is barred by limitation. 39) She relied upon the following judgments of the Hon’ble Apex Court:- a) Asma Lateef & Anr. V/s. Shabbir Ahmad & Ors. (2024) 4 SCC 696; and b) Arun Bhoomi Corp & Anr. V/s. Jagruti Developers & Ors. (2024 SCC Online Bom 380). The broad proposition laid down in the above judgments is that, “even at stage of hearing of interim application if the suit is barred by law, the court can assigned such opinion for refusing interim relief.” 40) According to her, the plaintiffs case for declaring the pledged as not validly created is not supported by any provisions of law or legal justification, whatsoever. She submits that, as per Section 172, creating a valid pledge requires delivery of the possession of goods by the pawnor to the pawnee by way of security upon the promise of repayment of a debt or the performance of a promise, thereby, creating an estate that vests with the pawnee. Hence, there is no requirement of governing documents for creation of pledge. It has been created to secure repayment of loan by defendant No.1 to defendant Nos.2 and 3. Hence, once it is validly created, the pledge creates an estate and right that vests with the pledgee to retain possession till the debt is repay. In support of her above submissions, she placed her reliance on the judgment in the case between PTC India Financial Services Ltd. V/s. Venkateswarlu Kari & Anr. (2022) 9 SCC 704. Hence, it is submitted -- 21 of 27 -- Common Order in N. M. No.1869 of 2025 -: 22 :- and N. M. No.1870 of 2025 that, the plaintiffs have failed to make out a prima-facie case in his favour and the balance of convenience tilts in favour of the defendants. Irreparable loss will also be caused to the defendants, especially defendant No.4, if temporary injunction is granted in favour of the plaintiffs. Hence, she prayed for dismissal of the above notice of motions. THE FINDINGS:- 41) After hearing the parties at length, first of all it needs to be pointed out here that, a prima-facie case means a case in respect of which something can be said in favour of the plaintiffs and which is not apparently barred by any law or statute for the time being in-force. In the present matter, on the one hand the plaintiffs are contending that, the pledged forms at Exh.H-1 to H9 of the plaint clearly mentioned closure dates ranging from the year 2011 to 2013 and hence, the pledge was offered for a limited period without executing any guarantee deed or other documents. On the other hand, the defendants particularly, the defendant No.1, has come with two supplemental agreement dated 27th June 2017 and 07th August 2017. These supplemental agreements are annexed at Exh.C & D with the affidavit in reply. However, the plaintiffs have filed the affidavit in rejoinder to the said reply on 04th January 2022 and denied the execution of these agreements and have expressly taken a stand that, the signature and seals thereon are forged. Thus raising suspicion and doubt about their genuineness. 42) It is true that, mere raising of defence of forgery may be to substantiate their own case to obtain a temporary injunction. But, in the -- 22 of 27 -- Common Order in N. M. No.1869 of 2025 -: 23 :- and N. M. No.1870 of 2025 present case, the plaintiffs have appended the affidavits of the signatories on those two agreements namely of Mr. Viresh Sohoni and Mr. Subhash Singh on record with the rejoinder dated 04th January 2022. 43) It is further contended by defendant No.1 that, the facilities granted to the defendant Nos. 2 and 3 by the said erstwhile Laxmi Vilas Bank Ltd., was initially secured by pledge of shareholding of defendant No.3 by executing agreement o f pledge of stock / shares / debentures and other securities held in demant form dated 11th February 2010 in the Company and subsequently thereafter by pledge of shares by entering into the two supplemental agreements dated 27th June 2017 and 07th August 2017. the agreement dated 11th February 2010 is appended as Exh.B, to the affidavit in reply of defendant No.1, but those supplemental agreements have been prima-facie shown to be doubtful by the plaintiffs. 44) It is submitted that, the signatures appearing on the last page of the agreement at Sr. No.3 as authorized signatory for ‘M/s. Prawas Leasing and Finance Pvt. Ltd.’, is neither of its director nor of its authorized signatory. Similarly, the signature of Mr. Viresh Sohoni, the erstwhile Director of plaintiff no.1, is of a Director who resigned on 30th July 2012 and thus on 27th June 2017 was not in employment of the plaintiff No.1. The agreements are neither notarized nor bears signatures of any witnesses. Both the documents at Exh.C and D are got up documents due to various factual in accuracies while creating the same including the forged signatures. The affidavits of said Mr. Viresh -- 23 of 27 -- Common Order in N. M. No.1869 of 2025 -: 24 :- and N. M. No.1870 of 2025 Sohoni and Mr. Subhash Singh are annexed at Exh.B1 and B2 to the rejoinder to show that, Mr. Viresh Sohoni had resigned from the plaintiff No.1 company on 30th July 2012 and Mr. Subhash Singh had resigned from the plaintiff No.2 company on or around 10th January 2011 and it is contended that, both of them were neither authorized nor could have executed any documents on behalf of the plaintiff Nos. 1 and 2 Company. 45) It is further submitted that, Mr. Subhash Singh was not even in the country at the relevant time and period, during which they alleged execution of documents is attempted. Thus, the agreement dated 27th June 2017 and 07th August 2017 are forged and fabricated and plaintiffs are the victims of such forgery. 46) Hence, the plaintiffs have raised a triable issue that on the one hand the defendants are denying the pledge forms having a closure dates vide Exh.H1 to H9, which plaintiffs have annexed with the plaint and on the other hand, contending that such closure dates are not amounting to an extinguishment of pledge and on the other hand, coming up with two supplemental agreements, the validity of which is doubtful in view of the affidavits of the signatories as discussed above. This contention of the plaintiffs has remained uncontroverted, because, though the rejoinder to the reply of defendant No.1 was filed on 04th January 2022, till today no sur-rejoinder is filed to controvert the same and there is no whisper in any reply of any of the defendants regarding the same or to explain the same. Therefore, one of the triable issue in the suit would be whether the original pledge forms having closure -- 24 of 27 -- Common Order in N. M. No.1869 of 2025 -: 25 :- and N. M. No.1870 of 2025 dates resulted in ending the pledge and whether the supplemental agreements produced on record by the defendants are valid and subsisting or are bogus and forged documents. Thus, the Plaintiffs have established a prima-facie case in their favour about validity of very pledge. Hence, I hold that the plaintiffs have a prima-facie case in their favour. So I answer point No.1 in the affirmative. 47) So far as, the balance of convenience is concerned, it tilts in favour of the plaintiffs because if the temporary injunction is not granted, the comparative mischief will result to the plaintiffs as the defendants may act upon the pledge and dispose off the pledged shares and then it will be difficult for the plaintiffs to get the said holding in future. Therefore, I answer point No.2 in favour of the plaintiffs. Consequently, I also hold that, irreparable loss will be caused to the plaintiffs, if the temporary injunction is refused and answer point No.3 also in favour of the plaintiffs. 48) Before parting with the order, the decision also has to be taken about the 16 lakhs shares already sold by the defendant No.1 and which is the subject matter of Notice of Motion No.1870 of 2025. Meanwhile, it is an admitted position that newly added defendant No.4, is an assignee of defendant No.1. Therefore, the relief claimed in Notice of Motion No.1870 of 2025 needs to be moulded against defendant Nos.1 and 4. The simple prayer made therein is that, the defendant Nos.1 be directed to disclose the quantum of shares sold by it belonging to the plaintiffs and deposit to proceeds received from the sell of such pledge shares with the plaintiffs and further to restrained defendant -- 25 of 27 -- Common Order in N. M. No.1869 of 2025 -: 26 :- and N. M. No.1870 of 2025 No.1 from selling the pledged shares. In my opinion, it will serve the ends of justice, if defendant No.1 and its assignee i.e. defendant No.4 are directed to file a statement of disclosure of the shares sold out of the pledged shares and to give an undertaking that it will abide by any order passed in future in the suit with respect to those sold pledged shares and its price in case the suit is decreed. Hence, I proceed to pass the following order:- O R D E R 1) Notice of Motion No.1869 of 2025 stands allowed in terms of prayer clause (a) and (c). 2) Notice of Motion No.1870 of 2025 stands allowed to the limited extent, thereby directing the defendant Nos.1 and 4 to file a statement of disclosure of the shares sold out of the pledged shares and to give an undertaking within Sixty days from today that, it will abide by any order passed in future in the suit with respect to those sold pledged shares and its price in case the suit is decreed. 3) Notice of Motion No.1869 of 2025 and Notice of Motion No.1870 of 2025 stands disposed off accordingly. 4) Original Order kept in Notice of Motion No.1869 of 2025. (A. S. KAZI) Additional Sessions Judge, City Civil & Sessions Court, Date:.17.04.2025. Mazgaon, Gr. Mumbai (C. R. No.14) Direct Typed On : 17.04.2025. Signed on : 17.04.2025. -- 26 of 27 -- Common Order in N. M. No.1869 of 2025 -: 27 :- and N. M. No.1870 of 2025 “CERTIFIED TO BE TRUE AND CORRECT COPY OF THE ORIGINAL SIGNED JUDGMENT/ORDER.” UPLOAD DATE: 21.04.2025. NAME OF STENOGRAPHER TIME: 04.00 p.m. Mr. Ashok Sudhakar Patil Name of the Judge (With Court room no.) HHJ Shri A. S. Kazi (Court Room No.14) Date of Pronouncement of JUDGEMENT/ORDER 17.04.2025. JUDGMENT/ORDER signed by P. O. on 19.04.2025. JUDGEMENT/ORDER Re-uploaded on 21.04.2025. (Note: As per Roznama dated 21.04.2025, typing mistake in the year of Notice of Motion No.1869 and 1870 is corrected as ‘2025’ instead of ‘2024’ and the corrected copy be uploaded accordingly.) -- 27 of 27 --
