Full Order Text
Final Order 1 · 06 Apr 2024 · CNR MHCC010048712022
Order Details: Notice of Motion Pdf Text: 1 NM 1671-22 in Suit 1790-13 MHCC010048712022 IN THE BOMBAY CITY CIVIL COURT FOR GREATER BOMBAY NOTICE OF MOTION NO.1671 OF 2022 IN S. C. SUIT NO.1790 OF 2013 Shri Vinod Gupta ] Pro.1M/s. Shree Krishna Steels ] 311, Navyapar Bhavan, 49 P. D.Mello ] Road, Carnac Bunder, ] Mumbai-400 009, through his ] Constituted Attorney Mr. Varun Gupta] .. Plaintiff. Versus Walchandnagar Industries Ltd. ] 3, Walchand Terrace, Tardeo Road, ] Mumbai-400 034. ] And also at: Walchand House, 167A, 2/9, Karve ] Road, Kothrud, Pune-411 038. ] .. Defendant. Appearance :- Ld. Adv A. K. Saxena for Plaintiff present. Ld. Adv. P. Shinde for defendant. CORAM : HER HONOUR JUDGE SMT. ANITA B. SHARMA COURT ROOM NO.03 DATE : 06/04/2024 ..1. -- 1 of 5 -- 2 NM 1671-22 in Suit 1790-13 ORDER 1. The present notice of motion has taken out by the plaintiff to recall the order dated 23.03.2022 and restore the suit. 2. In the affidavit in support, it is submitted that on 23.03.2022, the witness No.1 was not present due to year ending work of the business. It is further submitted that he was regularly attending the Court as and when called by this Court. But sometimes due to business exigencies it was not possible for him to remain present in the Court. It is also submitted that the plaintiff has filed the affidavit in evidence in the matter on 10.12.2015 and thereafter, documents were marked but as few documents were not marked by this Court and he has taken out Notice of Motion No.2784 of 2017 and the same was disposed of by an order dated 15.12.2017. It is also contended that thereafter, the plaintiff has taken out the Notice of Motion No. 2975 of 2018 which was disposed of by an order dated 04.03.2020 3. According to the plaintiff, after disposal of the Notice of Motion No.2975 of 2018 on 04.03.2020, due to pandemic, the plaintiff could not attend the Court till the end of 12.10.2021. It is further contended that on 17.01.2022, there were restrictions declared by the State Authorities for the COVID–19 and thus, he was not able to attend the Court. It is also contended that on 23.03.2022, due to urgent business work as the financial year was closing on 31.03.2022, he was unable to attend the Court on 23.03.2022 and due to which the suit came to be dismissed in default. It is also contention of the plaintiff that now he wants to contest the suit and if the order dated 23.03.2022 is ..2. -- 2 of 5 -- 3 NM 1671-22 in Suit 1790-13 not recalled and irreparable loss will be caused to him. Hence, he prays to allow the motion. 4. The defendant has resisted the notice of motion on the ground that on 02.12.2021, 17.01.2022 and 18.03.2022 the witness of the plaintiff was not present. Therefore, the matter was adjourned to [date withheld] with specific direction that “in the event of failure of the plaintiff to remain present suit will be dismissed for want of prosecution”. It is submitted that on 23.03.2022, the plaintiff’s witness was deliberately remained absent hence this Court has dismissed the suit for non-prosecution. 5. According to the defendant, the plaintiff has filed this notice of motion only with intent to harass the defendant and no case is made out by the plaintiff to recall the order passed by this Court on 23.03.2022. Therefore, he prays to dismiss the motion. 6. Perused the notice of motion, say and record. Heard learned advocate for both sides. 7. It is seen from the record that on 23.03.2022, the plaintiff remained absent when the matter was called out. The reason put forth by the plaintiff about his non appearance is that due to financial year ending he was busy in the official work, and he was unable to attend the Court. It is seen that this notice of motion is filed on 25.04.2022 before this Court and due to which the matter was dismissed for want of prosecution. Now the plaintiff wants to contest the matter and for ..3. -- 3 of 5 -- 4 NM 1671-22 in Suit 1790-13 that purpose he is seeking the restoration of the suit. Looking to the nature of the dispute between the parties, it is required to adjudicate the matter on merit and for that purpose, fair opportunity needs to be given to the plaintiff by compensating the defendant with costs. In the result, I proceed to pass following order; O R D E R 1. Notice of Motion No 1671 of 2022 is hereby made absolute in terms of prayer clause (a) subject to costs of Rs. 5000/- to be paid to the defendant with in one month from the date of order. 2. After paying amount of costs, Suit No. 1790/2013 be restored to its original stage. 3. Notice of Motion No 1671 of 2022 is disposed of accordingly. (Smt. Anita B. Sharma,) Judge, City Civil Court, Greater Bombay Dated : 06/04/2024 C.R. No.03 Dictated on : 06/04/2024 Typed on : 10/04/2024 Signed on : 15/04/2024 ..4. -- 4 of 5 -- 5 NM 1671-22 in Suit 1790-13 “Certified to be true and correct copy of the original signed order”. 15/04/2024 at about p.m. (Dastagir Babalal Mulla) Stenographer Grade-I (Gazetted) Court Room No.03, Gr. Bombay Name of the Hon'ble Judge : Smt. Anita B. Sharma, Judge, Bombay City Civil Court & Addl. Sessions Judge, Court Room No.03, Gr. Bombay Date of pronouncement of Order : 06/04/2024 Order signed by Hon'ble Judge on : 15/04/2024 Order uploaded on : 15/04/2024 ..5. -- 5 of 5 --
