Full Order Text
Final Order 1 · 23 Mar 2023 · CNR MHCC010047832021
Order Details: Ex-parte Judgement Pdf Text: 1/7 Judgment in Com. Suit No. 1103/2021 Lodged on : 29.11.2019 Admitted on : 07.07.2021 Decided on : 23.03.2023 Duration : Y M D 3 3 22 COMMERCIAL SUIT NO. 1103 of 2021 CNR NO. : MHCC010047832021 Exh.21 Mansi Hitesh Gutka @ ] Mansi Harsh Shah, through her ] P.A. Shri. Hitesh Gutka, having office ] at A2, 1 st floor, Unit No. 111, ] Shah N Nahar Industrial Estate, ] Dhanraj Mill Compound, Lower Parel (W), ] Mumbai 400 013. ] ...Plaintiff Versus 1. D.S. Kulkarni & Co. ] a partnership firm registered under the ] provisions of Indian Partnership Act, ] having its registered office at DSK ] House No. 1187/60, J.M. Road, ] Shivaji Nagar, Pune 411 005 ] 2. D.S. Kulkarni ] Partner of defendant no. 1 ] Having address at DSK House No. ] 1187/60, J.M. Road, Shivaji Nagar, ] Pune 411 005 ] 3. V.D. Kulkarni ] Partner of defendant no. 1 ] Having address at DSK House No. ] 1187/60, J.M. Road, Shivaji Nagar, ] Pune 411 005 ] ...Defendants -- 1 of 8 -- 2/7 Judgment in Com. Suit No. 1103/2021 Appearance: Adv. Mr. S.T. Manek for Plaintiff. Defendants exparte. CORAM : SHRI. A.S.SALGAR ADHOC JUDGE, (C.R.NO.31) DATED : 23rd MARCH 2023 J U D G M E N T (Delivered on : 23.03.2023) The plaintiff has filed the present suit against the defendants for the recovery of the amount of Rs.47,69,937/ from the defendants. 2. Brief facts of the plaintiff's case is as under: The defendant no. 1 is a partnership firm. The defendant nos. 2 and 3 are managing partners of the defendant no. 1. The defendant no. 1 through defendant no. 2 approached the father of the plaintiff and its sister concern and has projected scheme floated by the defendant no. 1 known as DSK Reinvestment Scheme. The plaintiff has showed desire to make investment in the scheme offered by the defendants at agreed rate of interest. The plaintiff on 16.09.2015 has invested amount of Rs.49,00,000/ in the scheme floated by the defendants. The plaintiff has issued a cheque of Rs.49,00,000/ in favour of defendant no. 1. The said cheque was encashed. The plaintiff during the period from 01.04.2015 to 31.03.2016 had invested and re invested the amount with the defendant no. 1. As on 31.03.2016, the defendants are liable to pay to the plaintiff an amount of Rs.39,25,000/. The defendants made several payments towards interest, but has not paid any amount of principal. -- 2 of 8 -- 3/7 Judgment in Com. Suit No. 1103/2021 3. According to the plaintiff, the defendants addressed one letter to the plaintiff and also handed over the cheque. The plaintiff also received the postdated cheques issued by the defendants in favour of the plaintiff. The plaintiff from time to time requested the defendants to pay the due amount. The defendants failed and neglected to pay to the plaintiff the amount due and payable to the plaintiff. The defendants not permitted the plaintiff to deposit post dated cheques, which were handed over to the plaintiff. The defendants are liable to pay to the plaintiff an amount of Rs.47,69,937/ as per particulars of claim. The plaintiff has filed the present suit for the recovery of the outstanding amount of Rs.47,69,937/ from the defendants with interest. 4. The suit summons was issued to the defendants by email. It was duly served to the defendants. The defendants remained absent. Hence, as per order passed on 04.01.2023, the suit proceeded exparte against the defendants. 5. In support of the pleading, the plaintiff examined her Power of Attorney holder namely Hitesh Chunilal Gutka at Exh.9. The plaintiff filed documentary evidence along with list Exh.10. The documentary evidence tendered by the plaintiff are at Exh.11 to 18. Evidence closure pursis of the plaintiff is at Exh.19. 6. After considering the pleadings of the plaintiff and evidence on record, following points arise for my determination and I have recorded my finding against each of them with the reasons to follows: -- 3 of 8 -- 4/7 Judgment in Com. Suit No. 1103/2021 POINTS FINDING 1) Whether plaintiff proves that an amount of Rs.47,69,937/ is outstanding from the defendants? In the affirmative 2) Whether plaintiff is entitled to recover an amount of Rs.47,69,937/ from the defendants? If yes, at what rate of interest? In the affirmative. At the rate of 9% per annum on the principal amount. 3) What order and decree? As per final order. R E A S O N S 7. Heard Learned Advocate Mr. S.T. Manek for the plaintiff at length. Advocate for the plaintiff also filed written arguments at Exh.20. As to Point Nos.1 & 2 8. It is the case of the plaintiff that the defendant no. 2 approached the father of the plaintiff and has projected scheme floated by the defendant no. 1 known as DSK Reinvestment Scheme. The plaintiff invested and paid an amount of Rs.49,00,000/ by cheque in favour of the defendant no. 1. As per Ledger Account, the defendants are liable to pay an amount of Rs.41,75,000/ as on 31.03.2017. According to the plaintiff, the defendants issued seven cancelled cheques. According to the plaintiff, an amount of Rs.47,69,937/ is outstanding from the defendants. At the outset, it is to be noted that the defendants were duly served the Writ of Summons. They failed to appear before the Court. The non appearance of the defendants goes to -- 4 of 8 -- 5/7 Judgment in Com. Suit No. 1103/2021 infer that they have admitted the claim of the plaintiff. 9. In support of the pleading, the plaintiff has examined her Power of Attorney Holder namely Mr. Hitesh Gutka at Exh.9. His evidence is in consonance with averments made in the plaint. He has specifically deposed in respect of the amount paid by cheque in favour of defendant no. 1. He deposed about TDS deduction from the interest amount. He specifically deposed that the principal amount of Rs.41,75,000/ is due from the defendants. This witness's evidence is not subjected to crossexamination. Hence, his evidence cannot be disbelieved. 10. The oral evidence of the plaintiff is supported by documentary evidence along with list Exh.10. The relevant documents submitted by the plaintiff are at Exh.11 to 18. The copies of bank pass book at Exh.13 shows that an amount of Rs.49,00,000/ was received by the defendant no. 1. The certified copies of the bank statement at Exh.14 also shows the interest amount received from the defendant no. 1. The letters received by the defendants shows that the defendants have admitted their liability. The copies of postdated cheques filed along with list Exh.10 also shows that the defendants have issued post dated cheques in favour of the plaintiff. By issuing postdated cheques, the defendants have admitted the due amount to the plaintiff. The copy of Ledger Account at Exh. 16 shows that an amount of Rs.39,25,000/ is outstanding from the defendants. The oral as well as documentary evidence tendered by the plaintiff is not challenged by the defendants. Therefore, I have no reason to disbelieve the documentary evidence adduced by the plaintiff. -- 5 of 8 -- 6/7 Judgment in Com. Suit No. 1103/2021 11. The plaintiff by leading documentary evidence sufficiently established that on 31.03.2016 an amount of Rs.39,25,000/ is outstanding from the defendants. So also, Ledger Account also shows that on 31.03.2017 an amount of Rs.41,75,000/ is outstanding from the defendants. The plaintiff has established their claim against the defendants. Hence, they are entitled to recover the outstanding principal amount of Rs.41,75,000/. The plaintiff also claimed an amount of Rs.5,94,937/ by way of interest from 01.04.2017 to 21.10.2019 at the rate of 9% per annum. The defendants have received the amount from the plaintiff, but they have not repaid the said amount to the plaintiff. Therefore, the defendants are liable to pay interest over the due amount. In my view, the defendants are liable to pay Rs.5,94,937/ by way of interest. 12. So far as the rate of interest is concerned, the plaintiff has claimed interest at the rate of 9% per annum. Considering the nature of transaction between the parties, the plaintiff is entitled to recover the amount with interest at the rate of 9% per annum. In short, the plaintiff is entitled to recover an amount of Rs.47,69,937/ from the defendants along with interest at the rate of 9% per annum on the principal amount from the date of filing of the suit till realization. Hence, I answer point no. 1 in affirmative and point no. 2 accordingly. 13. In the light of aforesaid discussion, it is concluded that the plaintiff has sufficiently proved his claim. Hence, the plaintiff is entitled to recover the outstanding amount of Rs.47,69,937/ from the defendants alongwith interest at the rate of 9% per annum on the principal amount from the date of filing of the suit till its realization. -- 6 of 8 -- 7/7 Judgment in Com. Suit No. 1103/2021 Hence, the suit needs to be decreed. Hence, I pass the following order: ORDER 1) Commercial Suit No. 1103 of 2021 is decreed with costs. 2) The defendant nos. 1 to 3 are jointly and severally liable to pay an amount of Rs.47,69,937/ (Rs. Forty Seven Lakhs Sixty Nine Thousand Nine Hundred Thirty Seven Only) to the plaintiff along with interest at the rate of 9% per annum on the principal amount from the date of filing of the suit till its realization within three months from the date of this decree. 3) Defendants shall bear the cost of the suit. 4) Court fee, if any, be refunded to the plaintiff as per rule. 5) Decree be drawn up accordingly. (Judgment pronounced in the open Court) Dated : 23.03.2023 (A.S. Salgar) Adhoc Judge, City Civil Court Gr. Mumbai. Dictated on : 23.03.2023 Transcribed on : 27.03.2023 Checked & signed on : 27.03.2023 -- 7 of 8 -- 8/7 Judgment in Com. Suit No. 1103/2021 CERTIFIED TO BE TRUE AND CORRECT COPY OF THE ORIGINAL SIGNED JUDGMENT/ORDER” UPLOAD DATE TIME NAME OF STENOGRAPHER 28.03.2023 11.55 a.m. Prachi Y. Potdar Stenographer Grade I Name of the Judge HHJ Shri. A.S. Salgar (C.R.NO. 31) Date of Pronouncement of Judgment/Order. 23.03.2023 Judgment/order signed by P.O on 27.03.2023 Judgment/order uploaded on 28.03.2023 -- 8 of 8 --
