Skip to main content
SUIT - SHORT CAUSE CIVIL SUIT

Jyoti Agarwal alias Jyoti Jagat MalkaniVsThe Municipal Corporation Of Greater Mumbai +1 more

CNR MHCC0100471520254-COURT 04 ADDL SESSIONS JUDGE
Fort, City Civil Court
Mumbai · Maharashtra (MH)
PENDING

TrustJury record updated 02 Nov 2026

Case Overview

Registration Number
100720/2025
Registration Date
25 Mar 2025
Case Stage
REPLY

Advocates

1

For Petitioner

For Respondent

    Not available

    Parties

    3

    Acts & Sections

    1
    CODE OF CIVIL PROCEDURE · Sec O39

    Case Timeline

    Newest first9 dates/groups
    Case ongoingFinal outcome awaited ···

    28 Sept 2026

    1 record
    Court Proceeding

    Court is on leave (second session )

    Next purpose: REPLY
    Read full proceeding
    Business: Court is on leave (second session )
    Next Purpose: REPLY

    22 Jun 2026

    1 record
    Court Proceeding

    None present for the plaintiff. Adv. Ms. Vidya Vyavhare for defendant/MCGM is present and sought time to file NM reply. Time is granted. Adjourned for NM…

    Next purpose: REPLY
    Read full proceeding
    Business: None present for the plaintiff.
    Adv. Ms. Vidya Vyavhare for defendant/MCGM is present and sought time to file NM reply. Time is granted.
    Adjourned for NM reply to 28.09.2026.
    Next Purpose: REPLY

    06 Mar 2026

    1 record
    Court Proceeding

    Coram: H.H.J. SHRI. C. S. DATIR (C.R. No. 04)

    None present for the plaintiff. Adv. Ms. Vidya Vyavhare for defendant/MCGM is present and seeks time to file NM reply. O- Time is granted. Adjourned for…

    Next purpose: REPLY
    Read full proceeding
    Business: CORAM : H.H.J. SHRI. C. S. DATIR (C.R. No. 04)
    None present for the plaintiff.
    Adv. Ms. Vidya Vyavhare for defendant/MCGM is present and seeks time to file NM reply. O- Time is granted.
    Adjourned for NM reply to 22.06.2026.
    Next Purpose: REPLY

    02 Feb 2026

    1 record
    Court Proceeding

    None for plaintiff. Adv. Ms. Vidya Vyavhare for defendant/MCGM is present. Adjourned for Reply to 06.03.2026.

    Next purpose: REPLY
    Read full proceeding
    Business: None for plaintiff.
    Adv. Ms. Vidya Vyavhare for defendant/MCGM is present.
    Adjourned for Reply to 06.03.2026.
    Next Purpose: REPLY

    28 Nov 2025

    1 record
    Court Proceeding

    Coram: H.H.J. SHRI. A. K. KALE (C.R. No. 04)

    None present for the plaintiff. Adv. Vidya Vyavhare for defendant/MCGM is present and sought time to file NM reply. Time is granted. Adjourned for NM…

    Next purpose: REPLY
    Read full proceeding
    Business: CORAM : H.H.J. SHRI. A. K. KALE (C.R. No. 04)
    None present for the plaintiff.
    Adv. Vidya Vyavhare for defendant/MCGM is present and sought time to file NM reply. Time is granted.
    Adjourned for NM Reply to 02.02.2026
    Next Purpose: REPLY

    26 Sept 2025

    1 record
    Court Proceeding

    Coram: H.H.J. SHRI. A. K. KALE (C.R. No. 04)

    Adv. Mr. Viraj Singh for the plaintiff is present and tendered registered NM No. 2656/2025 with affidavit. Adv. Ms. Sangita Honmane for defendant/MCGM is…

    Next purpose: NM REPLYREJOINDER
    Read full proceeding
    Business: CORAM : H.H.J. SHRI. A. K. KALE (C.R. No. 04)
    Adv. Mr. Viraj Singh  for the plaintiff is present and tendered registered NM No. 2656/2025 with affidavit.
    Adv. Ms. Sangita Honmane for defendant/MCGM is present and sought time to file NM reply. Time is granted.
    Adjourned for tendering registered NM/NM Reply .to 28.11.2025.
    Next Purpose: NM REPLYREJOINDER

    18 Aug 2025

    1 record
    Court Proceeding

    Coram: H.H.J. MR. AMIT A. LAULKAR (C.R. No. 04)

    None present for the plaintiff to tender registered NM. Adv. Ms. Sangita Honmane for defendant/MCGM is present and sought time to file NM reply. Time is…

    Next purpose: NM REPLYREJOINDER
    Read full proceeding
    Business: CORAM : H.H.J. MR. AMIT A. LAULKAR (C.R. No. 04)
    None present for the plaintiff to tender registered NM.
    Adv. Ms. Sangita Honmane for defendant/MCGM is present and sought time to file NM reply. Time is granted.
    Till date registered NM is not tendered on record. The plaintiff is hereby directed to tender the same or else suitable adverse order would be passed.
    Adjourned for NM Reply to 26.09.2025.
    Next Purpose: NM REPLYREJOINDER

    26 Jun 2025

    1 record
    Court Proceeding

    Coram: H.H.J. SHRI. A.A LAULKAR (C.R. No. 04)

    None present for the plaintiff. Adv. Ms. Rupali Patil for defendant/MCGM is present. Adjourned for tendering registered NM/NM reply/writ of summons to…

    Next purpose: NM REPLYREJOINDER
    Read full proceeding
    Business: CORAM : H.H.J. SHRI. A.A LAULKAR (C.R. No. 04)
    None present for the plaintiff. Adv. Ms. Rupali Patil for defendant/MCGM is present.
    Adjourned for tendering registered NM/NM reply/writ of summons to 18.08.2025.
    Next Purpose: NM REPLYREJOINDER

    25 Mar 2025

    1 record
    Court Proceeding

    Coram: H.H.J. SHRI. A.G. SANTANI (C.R. No. 04)

    Not on Board Taken on Board – By praecipe Plaint Vakalatnama Memorandum of Registered Address List of documents. Production praecipe Adv. Mr. Pratap…

    Next purpose: NM REPLYREJOINDER
    Read full proceeding
    Business: CORAM : H.H.J. SHRI. A.G. SANTANI (C.R. No. 04)
    Not on Board Taken on Board – By praecipe
    Plaint
    Vakalatnama
    Memorandum of Registered Address
    List of documents.
    Production praecipe
    Adv. Mr. Pratap Singh for the plaintiff is present and tendered draft Notice of Motion, along-with affidavit in support. O- Leave is granted to register within 7 working days. In default, the draft NM would stand dismissed. Copy is supplied to the other side. Adv. Ms. Sangita Honmane for defendant/MCGM is present and filed  affidavit in support of list of documents. Taken on record. It is marked as Exhibit 6. O- Filed. Copy is supplied to other side.
    Following Order is passed after hearing the parties on ad-interim relief :
    01.		Considering their submissions, at the outset, it is to be noted that admittedly, in this matter, initially the defendant issued the notice of dtd. 13.06.2023, U/s. 351 of the MMC Act, which was replied by this plaintiff on 23.06.2023 and later, on 10.08.2023 the Speaking Order, directing demolition of the structure, was passed (Exhibits M, N and O of the plaint compilation). On inquiry, the ld. Advocate for plaintiff fairly conceded that the said notice and final Order were never questioned till date. In view of this position, this suit, which is mainly filed for relief of declaration, as regards such notice and the Order as nullity, is apparently barred by limitation in view of the provisions of Section 527(b) of the MMC Act. True it is that the plaintiff is also questioning the notice, recently issued U/s. 488 of the MMC Act. However, the fact remained that in absence of his timely challenge to the earlier notice and the Order, his anxiety about this notice U/s. 488 of the MMC Act cannot be considered.
    02.		The record shows that considering the reliefs claimed on trial, the suit came to be registered keeping open the objection about jurisdiction of this Court U/s. 515A of the MMC Act. In this reference, the ld. Advocate for defendant relied upon the matter of Abdul Razzaq Sunesra V/s. MCGM, in WP (L) No. 1709/2013, dtd. 17.07.2013. On the other hand, ld. Advocate for the plaintiff relied upon the cases Yogesh Megaji Gada V/s. MCGM, in WP No.2243 Of 2013, dtd. 10.04.2014, Abdul Karim Ahmed Mansoori V/s. MCGM, in WP (Lodg.) No.2237 Of 2013, dtd. 13.09.2013, Maya Shrikant Sawant Desai Vs. The Chief Secretary Govt. of Goa, in FA No. 67 Of 2014, dtd. 25.02.2015, MCGM Vs. Rajendra Phulchand Gupta, in AFO (ST). No. 16017 Of 2021, dtd. 26.02.2022, Sarina Esmeralada Lopez Vs. Vijay Goverdhandas Kalantri, in CRA No. 448 Of 2013, dtd. 16.01.2015 and on Vadilal Maganlal Trevadia V/s. BMC, 2021 (1) Mh.L.J. 157. He contended that by this suit, as this plaintiff is assailing propriety of the said notice and the Order as a nullity, this Court has jurisdiction to try the suit. He also invited my attention to para 30 of the plaint, touching to such nullity. It goes to reveal that as per the plaintiff, without considering his reply, the Order came to be passed and the suit premises existed prior to 1949. Thus, it was  a nullity. However, barring his assertions, the record is silent to infer  this position. It is in addition of the fact that he did not chose to test the said notice and the Order before any Court of law. That apart, bare perusal of notice goes to show that it was issued mainly on 3 reasons viz. the additions/alterations to the existing ground floor structure, construction of 1st floor and for change of user. Suffice it to say that there is no iota of material to justify notice structure, even as on date. I have gone through the ratio laid in the above cited cases. With all respects, I am in complete agreement with the same. Obviously, if the plaintiff could, at least prima facie, manifest the alleged nullity of the said notice and the Order, there was scope for considering such aspect of the matter on the trial. However, as referred earlier, the material particulars on this issue are lacking on the record and there had been inaction on behalf of the plaintiff himself, barring his right to ask for this relief. Consequently, at this stage, there is no reason even to apparently infer the alleged nullity and, therefore, jurisdiction of this Court to entertain the suit on the backdrop of Section 515A of the MMC Act. Again, in the matter of Vadilal Maganlal Trevadia, Cited Supra, earlier permission to carry  construction was granted by the Office of the MCGM and later on, it was targeted on the ground that the same was not in consonance with the earlier permission. In that scenario, the initial burden was placed on the MCGM to prove its own assertions. However, this is not the position in the present matter.
    03.	Before I conclude, bare perusal of the affidavit in support of the list of documents (Exhibit 6) go to reveal that having received the complaint, the suit site was inspected by the Office of MCGM, the notice was issued and after considering the plaintiff’s reply, the Speaking Order came to be passed. Thus, the defendant seems to have followed the due process of law and, therefore, most probably, even the plaintiff did not prefer to question the said notice and the Order. Be that as it may, the suit is apparently time barred and in view of the ratio laid in case of Abdul Razzak, Cited Supra, issue of jurisdiction of this Court also goes to root of the matter. Consequent thereto, I am not inclined to grant any ad-interim relief in favour of the plaintiff. Hence, the Order :-
    1.	The prayer for grant of ad-interim relief is refused.
    2. 	The plaintiff to argue on the point of jurisdiction of this Court 	to try and entertain the suit.
    At this stage, Advocate for the plaintiff filed application for granting status quo. Taken on record. It is marked as Exhibit 7. O- Other side to say. Say filed. Heard. Ld. Advocate for the plaintiff relied upon the case of Kranti Mohan Guruprasad Mehtra V/s. Fatehchand Vasuram Behal, MANU/MH/0217/1982. Heard both the sides.
    O-While passing the above Order, I expressed my opinion that the suit is apparently barred by the limitation and there is, at least at this juncture, nothing to assume nullity of the earlier notice and the Speaking Order. Consequently, even the aspect of jurisdiction of this Court goes to the root of this matter, in view of Section 515A of the MMC Act. That apart, the record is silent to assume authenticity of the structure. In the circumstances, there seems no reason to grant status-quo, as asked for, specially when such protection was never granted in favour of the plaintiff. I have also gone the ratio laid in the case of Kranti Mohan, Cited Supra. However, in view of the above said reasons, in my respectful submission, it is not appealing to the present set of facts. Hence, the prayer for granting status-quo for a period of four weeks, cannot be considered. In the result, the application (Exhibit 7) is rejected.
    Authenticated copy of this roznama be supplied to both the parties.
    Adjourned for tendering registered NM/NM Reply/writ of summons to 26.06.2025
    Next Purpose: NM REPLYREJOINDER

    Additional Case Details

    Additional Case Details
    Filing Number: 104846/2025
    Filing Date: 24-03-2025
    First Hearing Date: 25th March 2025
    Court Number And Judge: 4-COURT 04 ADDL SESSIONS JUDGE

    TrustJury presents public court-record information for legal discovery and reference. Record availability and detail can vary by source and case.