Full Order Text
Final Order 1 · 14 Nov 2022 · CNR MHCC010046342021
Order Details: Copy of Judgment Pdf Text: 1 Judgment in Suit No. 22212021 MHCC010046342021 Presented on : 18062021 Registered on : 17112021 Decided on : 14112022 Duration : 1 yr, 4 mths, 26 days Exhibit : . IN THE CITY CIVIL COURT FOR GREATER BOMBAY AT BOMBAY SUIT NO. 2221 OF 2021 Smt. Supralekha Dalpath Waghela ] Age: 58, Indian Inhabitant , ] Occupation – Housewife, ] Room No. 125/B, Ground Floor, ] Municipal Chawl, Dr. E. Moses Road, ] Worli Naka, Worli, Mumbai 400 018.] ….Plaintiff Versus 1. The State of Maharashtra ] at the instance of Sr. Inspector ] of Police Worli Police Station, ] Worli, Mumbai 400 018. ] 2. Brihanmumbai Municipal ] Corporation For Greater Mumbai ] Mahapalika Marg Mumbai ] 3. WardOfficer ] G South Ward Municipal ] Corporation for Greater Mumbai ] Coram : K.P. KSHIRSAGAR Judge (Court Room No.08) Date : 14/11/2022. -- 1 of 7 -- 2 Judgment in Suit No. 22212021 Appearance: Ld Advocate Kadam for Plaintiff. Ld. Advocate Vaibhavi pawar h/f Advocate Kudalkar for Defendant No.1. Ld Advocate Chandramore for defendants No.2 & 3/MCGM. JUDGMENT This is a suit for declaration that Mr. Dalpath Manchha Waghela is dead and for mandatory injunction directing defendants to issue the death certificate of Mr. Dalpath Manchha Waghela. Plaintiff's case in brief is as under: 2) Mr. Dalpath Manchha Waghela was husband of plaintiff. Mr. Dalpath Manchha Waghela went missing since 07/01/98. In spite of the efforts to search him, he was not found. Therefore, plaintiff had lodged missing complaint on 21/3/98. Since 7/1/98 husband of plaintiff Mr. Dalpath Manchha Waghela has not been heard by plaintiff or her family members who would have heard of him, if he had been alive. After investigation the concerned police station issued certificate that Mr. Dalpath Manchha Waghela could not be found. Therefore, plaintiff prayed for declaration that her husband Mr. Dalpath Manchha Waghela is dead and for mandatory injunction directing defendants to issue death certificate of Mr. Dalpath Manchha Waghela. 3) Defendant No.2 and 3 failed to file their written statement. Therefore, suit is proceeded without written statement of defendant No.2 and 3. Defendant No.1 resisted the claim of plaintiff by filing its written statement vide Exh.7. Defendant No.1 admitted that missing complaint was lodged with the police station regarding Mr. Dalpath Manchha Waghela. It is the defence of defendant No.1 that the suit is misconceived and barred by law of limitation. -- 2 of 7 -- 3 Judgment in Suit No. 22212021 Therefore, defendant No.1 submitted that suit be dismissed. 4) From the pleadings of the parties court framed issues on Exh.8. Court has reproduced those issues below and court has recorded its decision thereon for the reasons stated thereunder: SR.NO. ISSUES DECISION 1) Whether plaintiff proves that, her husband Mr. Dalpath Manchha Waghela has not been heard for more than last 7 years by those who would naturally have heard of him if he had been alive and therefore, he has to be presumed to be dead? Proved. 2) Whether the plaintiff is entitled for the relief of declaration as prayed? Yes. 3) Whether the plaintiff is entitled for mandatory injunction as prayed? No. 4) What Order and decree? As per final order. REASONS 5) In order to prove her claim, plaintiff examined herself as P.W.1 by filling her Affidavit in lieu of examinationinchief vide Exhibit 9. Plaintiff also relied upon various documents like copy of government gazzette Exh.11, Identity Card of plaintiff issued by Election Commission of India Exh.12, Identity Card of Mr. Dalpath Manchha Waghela Exh.13, receipt of acknowledgment of registration of missing complaint Exh.14, certificate issued by Sr. PI Crime Branch Mumbai Exh.15, office copy of notice Exh.16 and 17, original -- 3 of 7 -- 4 Judgment in Suit No. 22212021 certificate issued by PI at Exh.18 etc. 6) On the other hand, defendants did not adduce any oral or documentary evidence. 7) Heard arguments advanced by Ld. Advocate for plaintiff and Ld. Advocate for defendants. As to issue no. 1: 8) In respect of fact in this issue, Smt. Supralekha Dalpath Waghela P.W.1 i.e. plaintiff vide her affidavit in lieu of examination in chief Exhibit 9 deposed in accordance with her claim. P.W.1 categorically deposed that her husband Mr. Dalpath Manchha Waghela went missing since 7/1/98. Inspite of search and lodging missing complaint her husband was not found. PW1 deposed that her husband is not heard by her or her family members who would have naturally heard of him if he had been alive. P.W.1 deposed that she had lodged the missing complaint and police has issued certificate that whereabouts of her husband cannot be traced. The documents produced and proved by the plaintiff corroborates testimony of plaintiff. Moreover, the testimony of plaintiff is not shaken in her cross examination. 9) It is also not the defence of the defendants that Mr. Dalpath Manchha Waghela is alive and he was seen or heard within last seven years. As such, there is no reason so as to disbelieve the testimony of plaintiff that her husband Mr. Dalpath Manchha Waghela has not been heard for last 7 years or more by those who would naturally have heard of him, if he had been alive. Therefore, from the matter on record this Court hold that the plaintiff proved -- 4 of 7 -- 5 Judgment in Suit No. 22212021 the fact by preponderance of probabilities that Mr. Dalpath Manchha Waghela has not been heard for last 7 years or more by those who would have naturally heard of him, if he had been alive. Therefore, presumption under Section 108 of the Indian Evidence Act will have to be raised. As the defendants did not affirm that Mr. Dalpath Manchha Waghela is alive, it will have to be presumed as per Section 108 of the Indian Evidence Act that Mr. Dalpath Manchha Waghela is dead. 10) Considering the matter on record and above discussion, Court held that plaintiff proved by preponderance of probability the fact that Mr. Dalpath Manchha Waghela has not been heard for last 7 years or more by those who would naturally have heard of him, if he had been alive and therefore he is presumed to be dead. Therefore, Issue no. 1 is answered in Affirmative. As to issues no. 2: 11) In view of affirmative finding as to point no. 1, the Court held that the plaintiff is entitled for declaration of civil death of Mr. Dalpath Manchha Waghela Therefore, point no. 2 is answered in Affirmative. As to issues no. 3: 12) Plaintiff has prayed for the relief of mandatory injunction directing the defendant to issue death certificate of Mr. Dalpath Manchha Waghela. However, presumption under Section 108 of the Indian Evidence Act is about death and there is no presumption as to the time or date of death of the person. There is no evidence on record about date of death of brother of plaintiff. Moreover, as per the provisions of the Registration of Births and -- 5 of 7 -- 6 Judgment in Suit No. 22212021 Deaths Act 1969, special procedure/remedy is provided for registration of delayed births and deaths. Therefore, in view of the provisions of the Registration of Births and Deaths Act 1969, this Court finds that there is implied bar of jurisdiction of the Civil Court for directing the defendant to register the death of Mr. Dalpath Manchha Waghela and to issue death certificate. 13) Considering the matter on record and above discussion, this Court held that the plaintiff is not entitled for the relief of mandatory injunction, as prayed. Therefore, point no. 3 is answered in negative. As to point no. 4: 14) In view of the affirmative decision as to issue nos. 1 and 2 and negative decision as to issue no.3, the suit deserves to be partly decreed with proportionate cost. Therefore, Court proceeds to pass the following order : ORDER 1. Suit is partly decreed with proportionate cost. 2. It is hereby declared that Mr. Dalpath Manchha Waghela is dead. 3. Decree be drawn up accordingly. (K.P.KSHIRSAGAR) Judge Dt.:14/11/2022. City Civil Court, Gr. Mumbai Dictated on : 14/11/2022 Typed on :16/11/2022. Checked on:17/11/2022. Corrected & Signed on : 22/11/2022. -- 6 of 7 -- 7 Judgment in Suit No. 22212021 “CERTIFIED TO BE TRUE AND CORRECT COPY OF THE ORIGINAL SIGNED JUDGMENT/ORDER.” UPLOAD DATE AND TIME NAME OF STENOGRAPHER 23/11/2022 Mrs. S.A. Shekade. Name of the Judge (With Court room no.) SHRI K.P. Kshirsagar (Court Room No.08) Date of Pronouncement of JUDGMENT/ORDER 14/11/2022 JUDGMENT/ORDER signed by P.O. on 22/11/2022 JUDGMENT/ORDER uploaded on 23/11/2022 -- 7 of 7 --
