Final Order 1

Order Details: Chamber summons
Pdf Text: nkok Øekad 2307@2014]
psacj leUl Øekad 855@2019 i`”B Ø- 1 fnukad % 17-09-2026
MHCC010043472019
EkqacbZ ;sFkhy uxj fnok.kh U;k;ky;kr
nkok Øekad 2307@2014
e/khy
psacj leUl Øekad 855@2019
ySyk VªsfMax fyfeVsM -----vtZnkj@
=;Lr i{kdkj
v[rj lqyrku feBk.kh -------- oknh
fo:)
nq¸;e fuca/kd o iz'kkldh; vf/kdkjh] egkjk"Vª
ljdkj vkf.k brj]
---- izfroknh
odhy Jh- ,l-,l- jsMsdj] oknhdjhrk
odhy Jh- v'kksd ikaMs lg fe=foank panq:] vtZnkj@=;Lr i{kdkj djhrk
dksje % Ukxj fnok.kh U;k;k/kh’k]
lqfuy ek- ikVhy ¼U;k;ky; Ø-09½
fnukad % 17 lIVsacj] 2026
vkns’k
- lnjps psacj leUl gs vtZnkj@=;Lr i{kdkjkrQsZ izLrqr
nkO;kdkeh oknh Øekad 2 Eg.kqu lkehy d:u ?ks.;kdjhrk nk[ky dj.;kr
vkys vkgs-
2- vtZnkj@=;Lr i{kdkjkrQsZ nk[ky dj.;kr vkysys psacj
leUl] R;kiq"B~;FkZps izfrKki= o vfrfjDr izfrKki=] nk[ky dkxni=s
-- 1 of 9 --
nkok Øekad 2307@2014]
psacj leUl Øekad 855@2019 i`”B Ø- 2 fnukad % 17-09-2026
rlsp oknhus fnysys Eg.k.ks] oknhus nk[ky dsysys izfrKki= o nkok rlsp
nkO;klkscr nk[ky dkxni=kaps voyksdu dsys- vtZnkj@=;Lr i{kdkjkrQsZ
odhy Jh- v'kksd ikaMs rlsp oknhrQsZ odhy Jh- ,l-,l-
jsMsdj ;kapk ;qfDrokn ,sdyk- rlsp] vtZnkj@=;Lr i{kdkjkrQsZ ofdykauh
nk[ky dsysyk ys[kh ;qfDrokn okpyk-
3- izLrqr nkok gk fnukad 28-02-1974 jksthP;k c{khl
i=kvk/kkjs nkok feGdrhps gLrkarj >kysys ukgh rlsp rs c{khli= eqyr%
jn~nckry vlY;kP;k gDdKkiuklkBh o lnjP;k c{khli=kph uksan.kh jn~n
dj.;kr ;koh ;kdjhrk nk[ky dj.;kr vkyk vkgs- vtZnkj@=;Lr
i{kdkjkP;k dFkukuqlkj fnukad 14-11-2011 jksthP;k fMM vkWQ
dUOgs;Uln~okjs R;kauh nkok feGdr [kjsnh dsyh vlwu nkok feGdr
gLrkarj dj.;kl ik= vlY;klaca/kh t:j rh dk;Zokgh dj.;kps lqyrku
djhe feBk.kh ;kP;k okjlkauh dcqy dsys gksrs o R;kuqlkj fnukad
28-02-1974 jksthP;k nkok feGdrhlaca/khP;k c{khli=kckcr izLrqrpk
nkok vkiY;k lkax.;ko:u rlsp vkiY;k [kpkZus oknharQsZ nk[ky dj.;kr
vkyk vlwu R;kckcr fnukad 06-08-2014 jksth vtZnkj@=;Lr
i{kdkjkP;k daiuhe/;s dke dj.kkÚ;k vfuy lksuko.ks ;kaP;k ukos oknhus
eq[kR;kji= ns[khy fygqu fnys vlwu vfuy lksuko.ks ;kauh nkO;kdkeh
izfrKki=kvk/kkjs vkiyk ljriklns[khy nk[ky dsyk vkgs- ijarq]
vtZnkj@=;Lr i{kdkjkps uqdlku Ogkos ;k gsrwus oknhl ;k ?kMhyk lnj
nkok dk<wu ?;ko;kpk vlwu oknhl r'kh ijokuxh ns.;kr vkY;kl
vtZnkj@=;Lr i{kdkjkps u Hk:u ;s.kkjs uqdlku gks.kkj vkgs- 2014
lkykiklwu izLrqr nkok vtZnkj@=;Lr i{kdkjkP;k [kpkZus pkyfo.;kr ;sr
vlwu oknhl izLrqr nkok dk<wu Äs.;kpk vf/kdkj ukgh R;keqGs
vtZnkj@=;Lr i{kdkj daiuh gh ;k nkO;kdkeh vko';d o t:jhph
-- 2 of 9 --
nkok Øekad 2307@2014]
psacj leUl Øekad 855@2019 i`”B Ø- 3 fnukad % 17-09-2026
i{kdkj vlY;kus R;kl oknh Øekad 2 Eg.kqu lkehy d:u Äs.;kr ;kos
v'kh ;k psacj leUln~okjs fouarh dj.;kr vkyh vkgs-
4- eqG oknhus lnj psacj leUlyk fnysY;k Eg.k.;ke/;s
vtZnkj@=;Lr i{kdkjkus U;k;ky;kiklwu egRokP;k ckch yiowu BsoY;k
vlwu izLrqr psacj leUl nk[ky dj.;kl dks.krsgh dkj.k ?kMys ulY;kph
gjdr ?ksrkuk fuOoG oknhl =kl ns.;kP;k gsrwus lnj psacj leUl nk[ky
dj.;kr vkY;kps dFku dsys vkgs- ;kf'kok;] nkO;kdkeh vtZnkj@=;Lr
i{kdkjkfo:) oknhus dks.krhgh fouarh dsyh ulY;kus vtZnkj@=;Lr
i{kdkj daiuh gh ;k nkO;kl vko';d o t:jhph i{kdkj ukgh- oknh gk
izLrqr nkO;klaca/kh fu.kZ; ?ks.;kl l{ke vlwu izLrqr nkO;kdkeh mifLFkr
eqn~ns ikgrk rlsp izLrqr nkok xq.kkoxq.kkaoj fudkyh dj.;klkBh
vtZnkj@=;LRk i{kdkj daiuhph nkO;kdkeh mifLFkrh vko';d ulY;kus
lnj psacj leUl [kpkZlg QsVkG.;kr ;kos v'kh oknhus fouarh dsyh vkgs-
5- izfroknh Øekad 1 ;kaP;krQsZ ns[khy lnj psacj leUlyk
Eg.k.ks nk[ky dj.;kr vkyss vlwu t:j rks vkns'k ikjhr djkok vls
dFku dj.;kr vkys vkgs-
6- ojhy ifjfLFkrhr] fnukad 28-02-1974 jksthps nkok
feGdrhps uksan.khd`r c{khli= fygqu ns.kkÚ;k lqyrku feBk.kh ;kpk oknh
gk okjl vlY;kckcr okn ukgh- rlsp] lqyrku feBk.kh ;kl oknhf'kok;
vU; okjl vlY;kps ns[khy nkO;ke/;s uewn dj.;kr vkys vlys rjh
izLrqr nkok gk QDr v[rj ;kus egkjk"Vª ljdkj rlsp nq¸;e fuca/kd o
iz'kkldh; vf/kdkjh ;kaP;k fo:) nk[ky dsyk vkgs- ;kf'kok;] lqyrku
feBk.kh gs fnukad 28-11-1999 jksth e;r >kY;kckcr okn ukgh- fnukad
-- 3 of 9 --
nkok Øekad 2307@2014]
psacj leUl Øekad 855@2019 i`”B Ø- 4 fnukad % 17-09-2026
28-02-1974 jksthps uksan.khd`r c{khli= lqyrku feBk.kh ;kus deyk
panokuh ;kaP;k ukos fygqu fnys vlwu rs jn~n dj.;kr ;kos v'kh
nkO;kdkeh fouarh dj.;kr vkyh vlwu vtZnkj@=;Lr i{kdkj daiuhP;k
dFkukuqlkj e;r lqyrku djhe feBk.kh ;kps okjlkauh fnukad 14-11-2011
jksth nkok feGdrhps uksan.khd`r fMM vkWQ dUOgs;Ul fygqu fnys vlwu
fnukad 28-02-1974 ps uksan.khd`r c{khli= jn~n d:u ?ks.;kph
tckcnkjh e;r lqyrku ;kP;k okjlkauh fLodkjyh gksrh o R;kpkp Hkkx
Eg.kqu izLrqrpk nkok nk[ky dj.;kr vkY;kps vtZnkj@=;Lr i{kdkj
daiuhps dFku vkgs-
7- ojhy ckch fopkjkr ?ksrk] izLrqr vtZnkj@=;Lr i{kdkj ;kauh
oknh Øekad 2 Eg.kqu R;kauk nkO;kdkeh lkehy gks.;kph ijokuxh feGkoh
v'kh fouarh djrkuk oj mYys[k dsY;kizek.ks fnukad 28-02-1974 jksthps
uksan.khd`r c{khli= o fnukad 14-11-2011 jksthps uksan.khd`r fMM vkWQ
dUOgs;Ul ;kpk R;kauh vk/kkj ?ksrY;kps Li"V gksrs- fnukad 28-02-1974
jksthps uksan.khd`r c{khli= jn~n dj.;kdjhrk izLrqr nkok gk fnuakd
06-08-2014 jksth nk[ky dj.;kr vkyk vlwu vtZnkj@=;Lr i{kdkj
daiuhP;k ukos R;kiwohZp lqyrku djhe feBk.kh ;kP;k okjlkauh fnukad
14-11-2011 jksth uksan.khd`r fMM vkWQ dUOgs;Ul fygqu fnY;kps
vtZnkj@=;Lr i{kdkj daiuhps dFku fopkjkr ?ksrk e;r lqyrku djhe
feBk.kh ;kP;k okjlkauh izLrqr nkok nk[ky dj.;kiwohZp nkok
feGdrhlaca/kh mijksYysf[kr fnukad 14-11-2011 jksthpk nLr fygqu
fnY;kps vtZnkj@=;Lr daiuhP;k dFkukn~okjs Li"V gkssrs-
8- ojhy ifjfLFkrhr] eqyr% fnukad 14-11-2011 jksthP;k
rFkkdFkhr nLrkvk/kkjs vtZnkj@=;Lr i{kdkj ;kauh vktrkxk;r e;r
-- 4 of 9 --
nkok Øekad 2307@2014]
psacj leUl Øekad 855@2019 i`”B Ø- 5 fnukad % 17-09-2026
lqyrku ;kP;k okjlkafo:) nkok feGdrhlaca/kh dks.krhgh nkn ekxhrY;kps
vtZnkj@=;Lr i{kdkj daiuhps dFku ukgh- lnj ckc fopkjkr ?ksrk]
vtZnkj@=;Lr i{kdkj daiuhrQsZ ofdykauh ;qfDroknknjE;ku psacj
leUle/khy eqn~n;kl vuql:u ;qfDrokn djrkuk vk;dj vf/kfu;ekrhy
rjrqnhuqlkj nkok feGdrhlaca/kh lqyrku feBk.kh ;kal lqV feGkoh ;k
mn~ns'kkus fnukad 28-02-1974 jksthps c{khli= r;kj dj.;kr vkys gksrs
o T;k mn~ns'kkdjhrk rs c{khli= r;kj dj.;kr vkys rks mn~ns'k ikgrk
R;k c{khli=kvk/kkjs deyk fgyk dks.krsgh gDd izkIr >kys ulY;kps R;kauh
lkaxhrys-
9- ;k ?kMhyk] fnukad 28-02-1974 jksthps mijksYysf[kr
c{khli= gjdrhoj izyafcr Bso.;kr vkys gksrs o rs fnukad
28-09-2003 jksth uksanfo.;kr vkY;kps vtZnkj@=;Lr i{kdkjkrQsZ
ofdykauh ;qfDroknknjE;ku lkaxhrysyh ckc rlsp izLrqr nkO;kdkeh oknhps
dFku gs ijLijk'kh lqlaxr vlY;kps ld`rn'kZuh fnlwu ;sr vlwu eqyr%
oj uewn dsY;kizek.ks vtZnkj@=;Lr i{kdkj daiuh gh nkok feGdrhoj
vkiyk gDd gk fnukad 14-11-2011 jksthP;k fMM vkWQ dUOgs;Uln~okjs
lkaxr vlY;kps fnlwu ;sr vlY;kus izLrqr nkok gk R;kuarj Eg.ktsp
fnukad 06-08-2014 jksth nk[ky dj.;kr vkY;kus rlsp izLrqr pascj
leUle/;s izLrqr nkok vtZnkj@=;Lr i{kdkjkP;k [kpkZuh nk[ky dj.;kr
vkyk vlwu R;kckcr vtZnkj@=;Lr i{kdkjkP;k daiuhPks vf/kdkjh vfuy
lksuko.ks ;kaP;k ukos eq[kR;kji= fygqu ns.;kr vkys vlwu R;kauh oknhrQsZ
izfrKki=kvk/kkjs ljriklns[khy nk[ky dsY;kps vtZnkj@=;Lr i{kdkj
daiuhps dFku fopkjkr ?ksrk izLrqr nkO;klaca/kh iw.kZr% ekfgrh
vtZnkj@=;Lr i{kdkj daiuhl gksrh gs fuOoG izLrqr psacj leUle/khy
etdwj vkgs rlk fopkjkr ?ksrk Li"V gksrs-
-- 5 of 9 --
nkok Øekad 2307@2014]
psacj leUl Øekad 855@2019 i`”B Ø- 6 fnukad % 17-09-2026
10- ojhy ifjfLFkrhr] nkok feGdrhckcrps rFkkdFkhr fMM vkWQ
dUOgs;Ul gs vtZnkj@=;Lr i{kdkjkP;k ukos dj.;kr vkY;kuarj lnjpk
nkok nk[ky dj.;kr vkyk vkgs gh ckc ;k ?kMhyk egRokph vlwu
vtZnkj@=;Lr i{kdkjkrQsZ ofdykauh ;qfDroknknjE;ku lnj nkO;kr oknh
Øekad 2 Eg.kqu lkehy gks.;kph ijokuxh vtZnkj@=;Lr i{kdkjkl feG.ks
vko';d vlY;kps lkaxrkuk R;kauh Ogh-ukjk;.k jsM~Mh fo:) vfuy
ukjk;.ku vkf.k brj] MANU/AP/0830/2008 ;k ukenkj vka/kzizns'k mPp
U;k;ky;kP;k U;k;fu.kZ;kpk vk/kkj ?ksryk- ijarq] lfork v:.k >kacjs oxSjs
fo:) eaftjh izkstsDVl~ izk-fyfeVsM oxSjs] Writ Petition No. 1227/2015,
Judgment dated 20.08.2026, ;k U;k;fu.kZ;ke/;s nkok nk[ky
dj.;kr ;s.;kiwohZ nkok feGdrhps gLrkarj >kys vlY;kl =;Lr
i{kdkjkl oknh Eg.kqu lkehy gksrk ;sbZy dk; ;kckcr ukenkj ckWEcs mPp
U;k;ky;kus vls EgVys vkgs dh] "14. Order I of Rule 10 grants power to
the court to add a party as plaintiff when it is found that the suit is
instituted in the name of the wrong person through a bona fide mistake
and that, to determine the real matter of the dispute, it is necessary to
substitute or add the name of the plaintiff. In the present case, no such
bona fide mistake has been pleaded for adding a third party as a co-
plaintiff. Sub-rule (2) of Rule 10 of Order I empowers the court to strike
out or add a party. The said sub-rule provides that a party can be added
if it appears to the court to be just and proper to add a party for a
factual and complete adjudication upon and settlement of all the
questions involved in the suit. Thus, the assignment in favour of the
third party cannot be a ground to add the party as a co-plaintiff by
relying upon Order I Rule 10, as the assignment is prior to the date of
filing of the suit." 15. Contingencies regarding the assignment of rights
pendente lite are covered under Order XXII Rule 10 of the CPC.
-- 6 of 9 --
nkok Øekad 2307@2014]
psacj leUl Øekad 855@2019 i`”B Ø- 7 fnukad % 17-09-2026
However, such a contingency did not arise in the present case. Hence,
the only consideration is whether the prayer to add the third party as a
co-plaintiff falls within the scope and reasons provided under Order I
Rule 10 of the CPC.or to the filing of the suit."
11- ukenkj ckWEcs mPp U;k;ky;kpk mijksYysf[kr U;k;fu.kZ;
ikgrk oj uewn dsY;kizek.ks vtZnkj@=;Lr i{kdkj daiuhP;k ykHkkr
vlysys fMM vkWQ dUOgs;Ul gs fnukad 14-11-2011 jksthps vlwu
R;kuarj izLrqr nkok gk fnukad 06-08-2014 jksth nk[ky dj.;kr
vkY;kus rlsp lnjpk nkok vkiY;k [kpkZus nk[ky dj.;kr vkY;kps
vtZnkj@=;Lr i{kdkj daiuhps dFku fopkjkr ?ksrk mijksYysf[kr ukenkj
vka/kzizns'k mPp U;k;ky;kPkk U;k;fu.kZ; vtZnkj@=;Lr i{kdkj daiuhP;k
enrhl ;sr ulwu mijksYysf[kr ckWEcs mPp U;k;ky;kpk U;k;fu.kZ; eqG
oknhP;k enrhl ;srks-
12- ;kf'kok;] vtZnkj@=;Lr i{kdkjkph fouarh fopkjkr ?ksrk]
nkO;kdkeh fnukad 28-02-1974 jksthP;k c{khli=klaca/kh nkn ekx.;kr
vkyh vlwu izLrqr vtZnkj@=;Lr i{kdkj daiuhl oknh Øekad 2 Eg.kqu
lkehy dsY;kl vtZnkj@=;Lr i{kdkj daiuhl oknh Eg.kqu R;k
c{khli=klaca/kh nkn ekxrk ;sbZy dk gk ns[khy iz'u mifLFkr gksrs- fnukad
28-02-1974 jksthP;k c{khli=kl vtZnkj@=;Lr i{kdkj daiuh gh
i{kdkj ukgh- R;keqGs R;kckcr oknhus nkO;kdkeh T;k fouaR;k dsY;k vkgsr
R;ke/;s lkehy dj.;kr ;kos gh vtZnkj@=;Lr i{kdkj daiuhph fouarh
ekU; djrk ;s.kkj ukgh gk oknhrQsZ ofdykapk ;qfDrokn vfLodkjkgZ ukgh-
-- 7 of 9 --
nkok Øekad 2307@2014]
psacj leUl Øekad 855@2019 i`”B Ø- 8 fnukad % 17-09-2026
13- lcc] oj uewn dkj.kkLro vtZnkj@=;Lr i{kdkj daiuhps
dFku vkgs rls fopkjkr ?ksrk oknh Øekad 2 Eg.kqu nkO;kdkeh lkehy
d:u ?ks.;kph R;kaph fouarh ekU; gks.;kl ik= ukgh rlsp izLrqr nkok
nk[ky dj.;kr ;s.;kiwohZp rFkkdFkhr fMM vkWWQ dUOgs;Ul gs
vtZnkj@=;Lr i{kdkj daiuhP;k ykHkkr dj.;kr vkY;kus mijksYysf[kr
ukenkj ckWEcs mPp U;k;ky;kpk U;k;fu.kZ; ikgrk vtZnkj@=;Lr i{kdkj
daiuhph fouarh ekU; gks.;kl ik= ukgh- ifj.kker% lnj psacj leUl
QsVkG.;kl ik= vlY;kus eh [kkyhyizek.ks vkns’k ikjhr djhr vkgs-
vkns'k
psacj leUl Øekad 855@2019 QsVkG.;kr ;sr vkgs-
fnukad % 17-09-2026
¼ lqfuy ek- ikVhy ½
uxj fnok.kh U;k;k/kh’k] c`gUeqacbZ
U;k;ky; Øekad 09
Jqrys[kukph rkjh[k % 17-09-2026
fyI;arj.kkph rkjh[k % 17-09-2026
Lok{kjhph rkjh[k % 17-09-2026
-- 8 of 9 --
nkok Øekad 2307@2014]
psacj leUl Øekad 855@2019 i`”B Ø- 9 fnukad % 17-09-2026
“CERTIFIED TO BE TRUE AND CORRECT COPY OF THE ORIGINAL
SIGNED JUDGMENT/ORDER.”
Upload Date Upload Time Name of the Stenographer
17.09.2026 5:45 p.m. Mrs. Poonam Y. Pawar,
Stenographer (Grade-I)
Name of the Judge (With C.R. No.) H.H.J. SHRI. S. M. PATIL
(COURT ROOM NO.09)
Date of Pronouncement of
JUDGEMENT /ORDER
17.09.2026
JUDGEMENT /ORDER signed by
P.O. on
17.09.2026
JUDGEMENT /ORDER uploaded on 17.09.2026
-- 9 of 9 --