Skip to main content
CHAMBER SUMMONS

Mr. Sunil Chhabinath MauryaVsMCGM And Anr

CNR MHCC0100369720234-COURT 04 AD-HOC JUDGE
Fort, City Civil Court
Mumbai · Maharashtra (MH)
CASE DISPOSED
Contested--ALLOWED
Decision Date: 31st July 2024

TrustJury record updated 14 Oct 2026

Case Overview

Registration Number
100643/2023
Registration Date
03 Apr 2023

Advocates

1

For Petitioner

For Respondent

    Not available

    Parties

    2

    Acts & Sections

    1
    CODE OF CIVIL PROCEDURE · Sec 9

    Case Timeline

    Newest first10 dates/groups
    Case disposedCompletion recorded

    31 Jul 2024

    2 records
    Court Proceeding

    None present for plaintiff Counsel Adv Gajanan Shinde for defendant/BMC present Following order is passed on Ch/S No. 412/2023 O R D E R 1. The plaintiff…

    Read full proceeding
    Business: None present for plaintiff
    Counsel Adv Gajanan Shinde for defendant/BMC present
    Following order is passed on Ch/S No. 412/2023
    O R D E R
    1.     The plaintiff has taken out this Ch/S under order 6 rule 17 of CPC for amendment in the plaint. The ch/s is supported by affidavit. It is contended that the plaintiff has challenged notice u/s 354-A of Mumbai Municipal Corporation Act ( MMC Act)  The suit structure is very old and the Erstwhile owner Mr. Hiranand Permanand through Architect submitted application for repairs in the year 1970. After diligent search the plaintiff came to know about the proposal for repairs of the notice structure. The document is relevant to decide question involved in the suit. Hence plaintiff has taken out present ch/s for amendment. The plaintiff is seeking permission to add Para 18–C and insert contention in respect of repairs permission.
    2.  Defendant/BMC opposed application stating that corporation has issued notice to excavation work. The plaintiff has filed ch/s No. 1696/2022 for amendment and same has been made absolute. Then again he has filed another ch/s No. 643/2023, which is pending and later he has filed present ch/s. The plaintiff is delaying the proceeding, therefore ch/s be dismissed.
    4.     Heard Adv. for the parties. Perused Ch/s, affidavit in support thereof and documents on record.
    5.     The plaintiff has taken out the Ch/s for amendment in the plaint. The plaintiff stated that the earlier owner has submitted application for repairs  of notice structure in the year 1970 and during the search he found documents of permission. The document is relevant to decide the legality of the structure. The present suit has been filed to challenge notice issued by defendant/BMC u/s 354 A of MMC Act alleging that the plaintiff has started excavation work, it is contention of plaintiff that notice structure is existence since long. Thus the proposed amendment appears to be just and necessary for complete and effective adjudication of dispute.  The suit is at pre-trial stage. The nature of the suit is not likely to be changed as a result of amendment as such no injustice or irreparable loss would be caused to the other side.  The object and purpose of order 6 Rule 17 of CPC is that the Court should make all endeavors to avoid multiplicity of the litigation and to set arrest controversy in same suit. Thus in order to decide controversy between the parties in same suit, it will be justifiable to allow plaintiff to amend the plaint.
    5.  It is well settled that the amendment of pleading at pretrial stage should be normally allowed if no any prejudice or injustice is caused to the other side and if the proposed amendment is necessary for complete and effective adjudication of the controversy involved in the suit and the nature of the Suit is not likely to be changed as result of the amendment. Hon’ble Apex Court in the matter of LIC V/s Sanjeev Builders Pvt. Ltd. and Anrs. (Civil Appeal No. 5909/2022 ) held that all the amendment are to be allowed which are necessary for determining real question in controversy provided it does not cause injustice and prejudice to other side and this is mandatory as per provision of order 6 Rule 17 of the Civil Procedure Code.
    6.  In the circumstance Ch/S deserves to be allowed. Hence, I pass following order-
    O R D E R
    1.   Chamber Summons is made absolute in terms of prayer clause (a).
    2. Plaintiff to carry out necessary amendment within  two weeks.
    3. Copy of amended plaint be served upon other side.
    4. Ch/S  stands disposed of accordingly.
    Following order is passed on Ch/S No. 643/2023.
    O R D E R
    1.     The plaintiff has taken out this Ch/S under order 6 rule 17 of CPC for amendment in the plaint. The ch/s is supported by affidavit. It is contended that the plaintiff has challenged notice u/s 354-A of Mumbai Municipal Corporation Act ( MMC Act)  The suit structure is very old. The plaintiff has carried out repairs and before that they have made application dated 14.07.2022. At the time of filing suit the plaintiff inadvertently did not share the correct house number and contention as to the application for repair.  Therefore  the plaintiff has taken out present ch/s for amendment.  The plaintiff is seeking permission to add Para – 1-(a) to (e) in the plain and incorporate contention regarding correct house number and application dated 14.07.2022.
    2.  Defendant/BMC opposed application by filing reply dated 03.04.2023, denied contention in the ch/s. it is further stated that contention in the ch/s are false and incorrect. Therefore ch/s deserve to be dismissed with cost.
    3.     Heard Adv. for the parties. Perused Ch/S, affidavit in support thereof and documents on record.
    4.     The plaintiff has taken out the Ch/S for amendment in the plaint. It is stated by the plaintiff that the notice has been issued to the Block No. 147/239 but house number of the notice structure 147/292. It is further stated that the plaintiff is seeking permission to incorporate contention in respect of application for repair work dated 14.07.2022 and approved plan for repair permission granted by BMC shows existence of structure.
    5.   The present suit has been filed to challenge notice issued by defendant/BMC u/s 354-A of MMC Act alleging that the plaintiff has started excavation work, it is contention of plaintiff that notice structure is existence since long. Thus the proposed amendment appears to be just and necessary for complete and effective adjudication of dispute.  The suit is at pre-trial stage. The nature of the suit is not likely to be changed as a result of amendment as such no injustice or irreparable loss would be caused to the other side.  The object and purpose of order 6 Rule 17 of CPC is that the Court should make all endeavors to avoid multiplicity of the litigation and to set arrest controversy in same suit. Thus in order to decide controversy between the parties in same suit, it will be justifiable to allow plaintiff to amend the plaint.
    6.  It is well settled that the amendment of pleading at pretrial stage should be normally allowed if no any prejudice or injustice is caused to the other side and if the proposed amendment is necessary for complete and effective adjudication of the controversy involved in the suit and the nature of the Suit is not likely to be changed as result of the amendment. Hon’ble Apex Court in the matter of LIC V/s Sanjeev Builders Pvt. Ltd. and Anrs. (Civil Appeal No. 5909/2022 ) held that all the amendment are to be allowed which are necessary for determining real question in controversy provided it does not cause injustice and prejudice to other side and this is mandatory as per provision of order 6 Rule 17 of the Civil Procedure Code.
    7.  In the circumstance Ch/S deserves to be allowed. Hence, I pass following order-
    O R D E R
    1.   Chamber Summons is made absolute in terms of prayer clause (a).
    2. Plaintiff to carry out necessary amendment within two weeks.
    3. Copy of amended plaint be served upon other side.
    4. Ch/S  stands disposed of accordingly.
    Counsel Adv Gajanan Shinde requested time to file reply to NM. Time is granted.
    Adjd  to 20.08.2024  for  Compliance /NM Reply
    Nature Of Disposal: ALLOWED
    Disposal Date: 31-07-2024
    Final Order 1

    Order Details: Other Pdf Text: 21 Dt:31.07.2024 SU 2190/22 CORAM : H.H.J. SHRI S.H. SALUNKHE ( C.R. No. 04 ) None present for plaintiff Counsel Adv Gajanan Shinde for defendant/BMC present Following order is passed on…

    Read Full Order →

    09 Jul 2024

    1 record
    Court Proceeding

    Adv. Kudalkar for plff. present. Advocate Gajanan Shinde defendant/BMC present and requested time to file say to N.M. Hence, time is granted. Heard…

    Next purpose: CH/S ORDERS
    Read full proceeding
    Business: Adv. Kudalkar for plff. present.
    Advocate Gajanan Shinde defendant/BMC present and  requested time to file say to N.M.
    Hence, time is granted.
    Heard advocates for the parties in Ch.S.No.412/23 and Ch./S.No. 643/23.
    Adjd  to 31.07.2024 for order on both Ch./S. and N.M. Reply.
    Next Purpose: CH/S ORDERS

    13 Jun 2024

    1 record
    Court Proceeding

    Advocate Vaibhavi Pawar h/f Kudalkar for plaintiff present and requested adjournment. Counsel Adv. Gajanan Shinde a/w Advocate Waghmare for defendant/BMC…

    Next purpose: C/S HEARING
    Read full proceeding
    Business: Advocate Vaibhavi Pawar h/f Kudalkar for plaintiff present and requested adjournment.
    Counsel Adv. Gajanan Shinde a/w Advocate Waghmare      for defendant/BMC present.
    Counsel Adv for deft/BMC opposed adjournment on ground that Hon’ble Bombay High Court has dismissed AFO, therefore present become infructuous. adv for plaintiff submitted that she has to take instruction from client and seeking short date.
    Adjd  to 09.07.2024  for ch/s and NM Hearing
    Next Purpose: C/S  HEARING

    14 Mar 2024

    1 record
    Court Proceeding

    Advocate Jain h/f Kudalkar for plaintiff present and seeks time to argue ch/s. Advocate Jyoti Patil- Mhatre for defendant/BMC present. Adjd to 13.06.2024…

    Next purpose: C/S HEARING
    Read full proceeding
    Business: Advocate Jain h/f Kudalkar for plaintiff present and seeks time to argue ch/s.
    Advocate Jyoti Patil- Mhatre for defendant/BMC present.
    Adjd  to 13.06.2024   for Hearing on NM and both Ch/s.
    Next Purpose: C/S  HEARING

    22 Feb 2024

    1 record
    Court Proceeding

    As Court is busy in hearing Ad-interim, NM Part heard matter and dictating HCTB NM Order, Board discharged and matter adjourned. Adjd to 14.03.2024 for…

    Next purpose: C/S HEARING
    Read full proceeding
    Business: As Court is busy in hearing Ad-interim, NM Part heard matter and dictating HCTB NM Order, Board discharged and matter adjourned.
    Adjd  to   14.03.2024   for Ch/s Hearing
    Next Purpose: C/S  HEARING

    30 Nov 2023

    1 record
    Court Proceeding

    Advocate Darshan Jain h/f Kudalkar for plaintiff present. Counsel Adv Gajanan Shinde a/w Advocate Mhatre for defendant/BMC present. keep back Later on…

    Next purpose: NM FOR HEARING
    Read full proceeding
    Business: Advocate Darshan Jain h/f Kudalkar for plaintiff present.
    Counsel Adv Gajanan Shinde a/w Advocate Mhatre for defendant/BMC present.
    keep back
    Later on 3.25 p.m
    Same appearance
    On oral request of Adv for plaintiff, matter adjourned.
    Adjd  to 22.02.2024    for  NM and both ch/s Hearing
    Next Purpose: NM FOR HEARING

    19 Oct 2023

    1 record
    Court Proceeding

    Advocate Vaibhavi Pawar h/f Kudalkar for plaintiff present. Counsel Adv. Gajanan Shinde a/w Advocate Mhatre for defendant/BMC present and has given say on…

    Next purpose: NM FOR HEARING
    Read full proceeding
    Business: Advocate Vaibhavi Pawar h/f Kudalkar for plaintiff present.
    Counsel Adv. Gajanan Shinde a/w Advocate Mhatre for defendant/BMC present and has given say on ch/s No. 412/2023 hence matter adjourned for NM and both Ch/s Hearing
    Adjd  to   30.11.2023  for  NM and both Ch/s Hearing
    Next Purpose: NM FOR HEARING

    17 Aug 2023

    1 record
    Court Proceeding

    Court is on leave

    Next purpose: C/S HEARING
    Read full proceeding
    Business: Court is on leave
    Next Purpose: C/S  HEARING

    04 Jul 2023

    1 record
    Court Proceeding

    Po Court is on leave

    Next purpose: C/S HEARING
    Read full proceeding
    Business: Po Court is on leave
    Next Purpose: C/S  HEARING

    03 Apr 2023

    1 record
    Court Proceeding

    Adv. Kudalkar for plaintiff present and tendered CS No. 643/2023. Counsel Adv. Gajanan Shinde with Adv. Mhatre defendant/ BMC present and tendered reply…

    Next purpose: C/S HEARING
    Read full proceeding
    Business: Adv. Kudalkar for plaintiff present and tendered CS No. 643/2023.
    Counsel Adv. Gajanan Shinde with Adv. Mhatre defendant/ BMC present and tendered reply to C/S. 643/2023 and requested time to file reply C.S. no.412/2023.
    O- Time granted.
    Officer Mr. Devendra Pawar, Junior Engineer, B and F department, (T- Ward), BMC is present.
    F.R.S.R. following order on N/M No. 3972/2022  is passed -
    O R D E R
    N.M. No. 3972/2022 is dismissed.
    L.O.
    Adv. for plaintiff tendered application for extension of ad-interim relief for a period of Six weeks,TOR and marked as Exh-7. O- Other side to say.
    Adv. for defendant has given say on Exh-7. Heard both side on Exh-7.
    ORDER BELOW EXH-7
              The Plaintiff filed the application for extension of ad-interim relief for a period of Six weeks. It contended that plaintiffs intended to challenge the order of this court dismissing the suit. Time is required to file appeal by obtaining certified copies and if ad-interim protection is not extended there is possibility of demolition of structure.
               The Corporation opposed application stating that, this court has rejected NM on merit. Structure is illegal and if stay is granted and any untowards incident happens who will be responsible.
           The plaintiff intended to challenge the order rejecting NM. The appeal is statutory right of the party. It is apprehended by plaintiff that if ad-interim protection is not extended there is possibility of demolition of notice structure and object of filing suit and appeal will be defeated. The ad-interim protection was granted during the pendency of NM, hence Ad-interim protection extended for 3 weeks.
    Adjd. To 04/07/2023 for hearing of C/S No. 643/23 and reply to C.S. NO. 412/2023 by defendant and W.S..
    Next Purpose: C/S  HEARING

    Additional Case Details

    Additional Case Details
    Filing Number: 103742/2023
    Filing Date: 03-04-2023
    First Hearing Date: 03rd April 2023
    Decision Date: 31st July 2024
    Court Number And Judge: 4-COURT 04 AD-HOC JUDGE

    TrustJury presents public court-record information for legal discovery and reference. Record availability and detail can vary by source and case.