Full Order Text
Final Order 1 · 03 Oct 2023 · CNR MHCC010028772023
Order Details: Notice of Motion Pdf Text: Order on Notice of Motion No. 982 of 2023 1 MHCC010028772023 IN THE BOMBAY CITY CIVIL COURT FOR GREATER MUMBAI NOTICE OF MOTION NO.982 of 2023. IN S. C. SUIT NO.1092 of 2017. Captain Lalit Kumar Wahi ...Applicant/ Defendant. In the matter of :- The Board of Trustees of the Port of Bombay ..Plaintiff V/s. Captain Lalit Kumar Wahi ..Defendant. Appearances :- Adv.Yasmin Sarang for plaintiff Adv. Nivedita Pandey h/f Adv Ramesh Pandey for defendant. Coram : U. C. Deshmukh. C.R. No.: 59. -- 1 of 4 -- Order on Notice of Motion No. 982 of 2023 2 Date : 03/10/2023 ORAL ORDER This Notice of Motion is moved by the defendant to permit him to file written statement. 2. The defendant contends that he does job as a pilot in Dubai since year 2014. Hence, he was not present in India. He came to know from his friend about the suit, thereafter, he appointed an advocate to represent him. He specifically contends that he sought copy of plaint and documents annexed with it. However, there was a delay to serve the copy of plaint and documents. Consequently, there is delay to file written statement. Therefore, prayed to allow Notice of Motion 3. In reply, it is contention of the plaintiff that it is not aware as to the job of the defendant. The suit and other suits against defendant’s friend are instituted in the year 2017. Therefore, the defendant was aware as to the institution of the suit. It is specifically contention of the plaintiff that it had supplied copy of plaint along with documents which were kept in envelop. Therefore, it is not at the fault for want of service of documents and plaint to the defendant. Hence, prayed to reject the Notice of Motion. 4. So far as the fact that the defendant is does job in Dubai is not categorically denied by the plaintiff. The fact that defendant was not served with the plaint and documents by way of regular mode is also undisputed. It is contention of the plaintiff that it has instituted the suits against the colleague of the defendant and defendant in same year from -- 2 of 4 -- Order on Notice of Motion No. 982 of 2023 3 whom the defendant claims to have knowledge of the suit. Hence, it is submission of the plaintiff that the Notice of Motion is filed to delay the proceedings. 5. The defendant has filed affidavit in support of his contention. He was also executed letter of authority in favour of the one Keshav Gupta which fortify contention of defendant that he is pilot in Dubai. Therefore, there is substance in submission of the defendant that he was outside of the India. He could not get the knowledge of the summons of the plaint. It is fact that the defendant is not served with the summons as per regular mode of service of summons. Considering matter involved in the suit and deciding the matter on merit, it is just and proper to allow the defendant to file written statement on record. 6. However, the contention of the defendant that he came to know as to institution of the suit from his friend Asit Kumar Rai, who was working in Mumbai Port Trust. He could not file affidavit of Asit Kumar Rai in support of his contention. In absence of affidavit of other proof to support his contention ensue cost. The plaintiff has filed the suit in the year 2017. Considering span of duration undergone since institution of the suit, it is just and proper to allow Notice of Motion on cost of Rs.7,000/-. In the result following order is passed : ORDER 1. Notice of Motion No.982 of 2023 is allowed in terms of prayer clause (a) and (b) subject to cost of Rs.7,000/- payable within a month of the order. 2. On deposit of aforesaid cost, Rs.5,000/-(Rs. Five Thousand Only) be paid to the Plaintiff and remaining amount of Rs. -- 3 of 4 -- Order on Notice of Motion No. 982 of 2023 4 2,000/-(Rs. Two Thousand Only) be credited towards DLSA, Mumbai. 3. On payment of aforesaid cost, the defendant to file written statement forthwith without fail. 4. Notice of Motion No.982 of 2023 is disposed off accordingly. (Dictated and Pronounced in open Court). (U.C.Deshmukh) Judge, City Civil and Sessions Court Date.:03.10.2023 Greater Bombay (CR 59). Declared on : 03.10.2023 Dictated on : 03.10.2023 Transcribed on : 10.10.2023 Checked on :10.10.2023 Signed on : CERTIFIED TO BE TRUE AND CORRECT COPY OF THE ORIGINAL SIGNED JUDGMENT/ORDER” 11.10.2023 at 0.00 -p.m. Mrs. P.R.Wagh UPLOAD DATE AND TIME NAME OF STENOGRAPHER Name of the Judge (with Court Room No.) HHJ SHRI.U.C.Deshmukh,(C.R.No.59) Judge.,City Civil & Sessions Court, Date of pronouncement of /Order 03.10.2023 Order signed by P.O. on 11.10.2023 order uploaded on 11.10.2023 -- 4 of 4 --
