Final Order 1

Order Details: Copy of Judgment
Pdf Text: ,l-lh- nkok Øekad 667@2019 --1-- U;k;fu.kZ;] fnukad 04-07-2026
MHCC010027882019 nk[ky fnukad % 12-03-2019
uksan.kh fnukad % 13-03-2019
fudky fnukad % 04-07-2026
dkyko/kh % 07&o- 03&e- 24&fn-
uxj fnok.kh U;k;ky;] eqacbZ ;sFkhy U;k;ky; Øekad 09
¼ lqfuy ek- ikVhy] uxj fnok.kh U;k;k/kh’k ½
,l-lh-nkok Øekad 667@2019
¼U;k;fu.kZ;kpk fnukad % 04@07@2026½ fu’kk.kh & 27
Jh- eaxs’k panzdkar dkuMs]
o;% 43 o”kZs] O;olk; % /kank]
iRrk% :e uacj 306] 3jk etyk] e;qjh fcfYMax]
Hkokuh ‘kadj jksM] nknj ¼if’pe½] eqacbZ&400
028- -------- oknh
fo:)
1- eqacbZ bekjr nq:Lrh o iqujZpuk eaMG]
iRrk % x`gfuekZ.k Hkou] 5ok etyk] okanzs ¼iwoZ½]
eqacbZ& 400 051-
2- dk;Zdkjh vfHk;ark]
iRrk % th&mRrj foHkkx] ,e-ch-vkj vWUM vkj-ch-
lksukokyk fcfYMax] f’kansokMh] nknj] eqacbZ- ---- izfroknh
odhy Jh- ,l-,l-jsMsdj] oknhdjhrk
odhy Jh- ds-,u- dkansdj] izfroknh Øekad 1 o 2 djhrk
-- 1 of 23 --
,l-lh- nkok Øekad 667@2019 --2-- U;k;fu.kZ;] fnukad 04-07-2026
U;k;fu.kZ;
¼ fnukad 04-07-2026 jksth ikjhr ½
izfroknhauh ikBfoysyh uksVhl csdk;ns'khj vlwu oknhoj
ca/kudkjd ulY;kP;k gDdKkiuklkBh rlsp R;k uksVhluqlkj izfroknhauh
dkjokbZ d: u;s ok nkok feGdrhrwu oknhl csn[ky d: u;s v'kk
fujarj eukbZlkBh izLrqrpk nkok nk[ky dj.;kr vkyk vkgs-
2- oknhps dFku FkksMD;kr [kkyhyizek.ks %&
nknj ¼if'pe½] eqacbZ ;sFkhy Hkokuh'kadj jksMojhy ^e;qjh
fcfYMax* ;k bekjrhrhy frlÚ;k etY;kojhy [kksyh Øekad 306 gh
feGdr nkO;kpk fo"k; vlwu R;kl ;kiq<s lks;hlkBh ^nkok feGdr* vls
lacks/kys vkgs- oknhps oMhy panzdkar ;kaP;k rkC;kr f=Hkqou jLR;kojhy
[kksyh Øekad 51 gh feGdr gksrh- fodkl vkjk[kM~;kph vaeyctko.kh
djrkuk lnj bekjrhps laiknu dj.;kr vkY;kus izfroknhadMwu dk;eph
i;kZ;h fuoklO;oLFkk Eg.kwu fnukad 14-08-1986 jksth nkok feGdr
panzdkar ;kaP;k ukos okVi dj.;kr ;sowu fnukad 25-11-1988 jksth nkok
feGdrhpk rkck panzdkar ;kauk ns.;kr vkyk- izfroknhadMs panzdkar ;kauh
R;kiksVh ekfld HkkMs Eg.kwu njegk :i;s 116@& brdh jDde osGksosGh
tek dsyh vlwu nkok feGdr fjdkeh d:u ns.;kph ekx.kh izfroknhaP;k
dk;kZy;krhy nksu vf/kdkÚ;kauh fnukad 26-05-1989 jksth dsY;kus
oknhP;k oMhykauh ;k U;k;ky;kr ,l-lh-lqV Øekad 3939@1989
nk[ky dsyk o R;kdkeh rqrkZrqrZ eukbZlkBh uksVhl vkWQ eks'ku Øekad
3316@1989 nk[ky dsyk- fnukad 31-10-1989 jksth uksVhl vkWQ
eks'ku Øekad 3316@1989 dkeh vkns'k gksowu R;k nkO;kP;k
-- 2 of 23 --
,l-lh- nkok Øekad 667@2019 --3-- U;k;fu.kZ;] fnukad 04-07-2026
fudkykikosrks dk;ns'khj ekxkZpk voyac dsY;kf'kok; nkok feGdrhpk
rkck izfroknhauh ?ksow u;s v'kh rqrkZrqrZ eukbZ dj.;kr vkyh-
3- fnukad 18-11-1996 jksth oknhps oMhy e;r vlwu oknh
gk dqVaqfc;kalg nkok feGdrhr jgkr vkgs- njE;ku fnukad 28-06-2000
jksth ,l-lh-lqV Øekad 3939@1989 gk R;krhy oknhP;k xSjgtsjheqGs
dk<wu Vkd.;kr vkyk- R;kckcr ekfgrh feGkY;kuarj izLrqr oknhus rks
nkok iqUgk QSykoj ?ks.;klkBh uksVhl vkWQ eks'ku Øekad 1725@2011
nk[ky dsyk ijarq] rks uksVhl vkWQ eks'ku fnukad 21-02-2013 jksth
QsVkG.;kr vkyk- R;k vkns'kkl izFke vihykn~okjs oknhus ukenkj mPp
U;k;ky;kleksj vkOgku fnys ijarq] rs izdj.k vihy ÝkWe vkWMZj Øekad
285@2014 vls uksanfo.;kr vkys- njE;ku fnukad 23-03-2018 jksth
izfroknhadMwu EgkMk vf/kfu;ekP;k dye 95 iksVdye 3&v uqlkj rh
uksVhl oknhl izkIr >kyh- R;kl oknhus mRrj ikBfoys vlwu izfroknhadMwu
nkok feGdrhckcr dk;ns'khj ekxkZpk voyac dsyk tkr vlY;kP;k
dkj.kkLro mijksYysf[kr vihy ÝkWe vkWMZj dk<wu ?ksrY;kus fnukad
03-04-2018 jksth fudkyh dj.;kr vkys-
4- fnukad 16-01-2019 jksth izfroknhadMwu oknhl uksVhln~okjs
oknh gk nkok feGdrhrhy ?kwl[kksj vlY;kps dGforkuk nkok
feGdrhojhy vkiyk gDd fl) dj.;kl vi;'kh BjY;kps o R;keqGs
iq<hy 48 rklkr nkok feGdrhpk rkck n~;kok vls dGfo.;kr vkys-
fnukad 16-01-2019 jksthP;k uksVhle/;s dkj.ks nsowu izfroknhP;k
vf/kdkÚ;kauh vkns'k ikjhr dsY;kps fnlwu ;sr ulY;kus t:j R;k
dk;ns'khj ekxkZpk voyac izfroknharQsZ dj.;kr vkysyk ukgh-
izfroknhadMwu vukf/kdkjkus nkok feGdrhpk rkck ?ksryk tk.;kph 'kD;rk
vlwu nkok feGdrhf'kok; oknhl jkg.;kdjhrk eqacbZ ;sFks vU; feGdr
-- 3 of 23 --
,l-lh- nkok Øekad 667@2019 --4-- U;k;fu.kZ;] fnukad 04-07-2026
ukgh- oknh gk R;kps oMhykaiklwu nkok feGdrhr jkgr vlwu izfroknhadMwu
nkok feGdrhpk rkck ?ks.;kckcrph lq: vlysyh dkjokbZ csdk;ns'khj
vkgs- lcc] fnukad 23-03-2018 o fnukad 16-01-2019 jksth
izfroknhauh oknhl ikBfoysyh uksVhl csdk;ns'khj vlwu rh oknhoj
ca/kudkjd ulY;kps gDdKkiu dj.;kr ;kos rlsp ojhy nksUgh uksVhl
uqlkj izfroknhauh oknh fo:) dks.krhgh dkjokbZ d: u;s ok oknhl R;k
vk/kkjs nkok feGdrhrwu csn[ky d: u;s v'kk fujarj eukbZph oknhus
fouarh dsyh vkgs-
5- izfroknh Øekad 1 o 2 ;kauh fu'kk.kh 2&v oj fnysY;k
dSfQ;re/;s oknhus izfroknhauk nkokiwoZ uksVhl ikBfoyh ulY;kus nkok
pky.;kl vik= vlY;kph gjdr ?ksrkuk oknh o izfroknhanjE;ku nkok
feGdrhckcr dks.krsgh djkj&enkj >kys ulY;kus rlsp oknh gk nkok
feGdrhrhy ?kwl[kksj vlY;kus fouarhizek.ks dks.krhgh nkn feG.;kl oknh
ik= ulY;kps lkaxhrys vkgs- rlsp] f=Hkwou jksMojhy [kksyh Øekad 51 gh
feGdr oknhP;k ofMykaP;k rkC;kr gksrh gs dFku ukdkjrkuk R;k
[kksyhlaca/kh dks.krkgh dkxnksi=h iqjkok oknhus nk[ky dsyk ulY;kus rlsp
fnukad 14-08-1986 jksth nkok feGdr oknhP;k ofMykaP;k ukos okVi
dj.;kr vkY;kps o R;kl njegk :i;s 116@& brds HkkMs vlY;kps
rlsp fnukad 25-11-1988 jksth nkok feGdrhpk rkck ns.;kr vkY;kps
oknhps dFku ukdkjrkuk oknhP;k ofMykauh ;kiwohZ nk[ky dsysY;k
nkO;klaca/kh oknhps dFku dkxni=koj vk/kkjhr vlY;kps EgVys vkgs-
6- ;kf'kok;] oknhus vihy ÝkWe vkWMZj Øekad 285@2014 gs
izdj.k ukenkj mPp U;k;ky;krwu dk<wu ?ksrY;kuarj oknhl nkok
feGdrhlaca/kh ewG xkGk okVikps i= HkkMsikoR;k oxSjs dkxni=s nk[ky
dj.;kph la/kh izfroknhauh fnyh gksrh ijarq] R;kckcrph dks.krhgh dkxni=s
-- 4 of 23 --
,l-lh- nkok Øekad 667@2019 --5-- U;k;fu.kZ;] fnukad 04-07-2026
nk[ky dsyh ulY;kus izfroknhadMwu dk;ns'khj ekxkZpk voyac d:u nkok
feGdrhpk rkck ?ks.;kckcr dk;ns'khj dkjokbZ dj.;kr ;sr vlwu
izfroknhadMwu dj.;kr ;sr vlysyh dkjokbZ csdk;ns'khj vlY;kps oknhps
dFku pwdhps vlY;kps EgVys vkgs- ;kf'kok;] oknhdMs HkkMsikorh oxSjs
lkj[kh dkxni=s vlY;kf'kok; EgkMk vf/kfu;ekP;k dye 66 e/khy
rjrwnh ykxw gksr ulY;kps dFku djrkuk ukenkj mPp U;k;ky;kleksjhy
izdj.k vafre fudkyh >kY;kus izLrqr nkO;kl jsl tqfMdsVk ;k rRokph
ck/kk ;sr vlwu nkok vkgs ;k Lo:ikr pky.;kl vik= vlY;kus lnj
nkok QsVkG.;kr ;kok vls EgVys vkgs-
7- ojhy ifjfLFkrhr oknh o izfroknhaps dFku fopkjkr ?ksrk]
ekÖ;k iqokZf/kdkÚ;kauh fu’kk.kh 03 oj [kkyhy eqn~ns fuf’pr dsys vlwu
R;k eqn~n~;kapk dkj.kkalg fu”d”kZ eh [kkyhyizek.ks ukssanfor vkgs %&
v-Ø- eqn~ns fu”d”kZ
1- nkok feGdrhps vki.k dk;ns'khj rkcsnkj vlY;kps
oknhus fl) dsys vkgs dk; \ ---ukgh---
2- fnukad 23-03-2018 o 16-01-2019 jksth
izfroknhauh ikBfoysY;k uksVhl csdk;ns'khj vlwu
vaeyctko.khl ik= rlsp vkiY;koj ca/kudkjd
ulY;kps oknhus fl) dsys vkgs dk; \
---ukgh---
3- fouarhizek.ks gDdKkiukph o eukbZph nkn feG.;kl
oknh ik= vkgs dk; \
---ukgh---
4- vkns'k vkf.k gqdqeukek dks.krk\ vaafre
vkns'kkizek.ks
-- 5 of 23 --
,l-lh- nkok Øekad 667@2019 --6-- U;k;fu.kZ;] fnukad 04-07-2026
dkj.kfeekalk
8- oknhus vkiY;k dFkukiq"B~;FkZ Lor%ph lk{k fu'kk.kh 04 oj
Äsryh vlwu izfroknharQsZ oknhpk myVrikl ?ks.;kr vkyk ulY;kus oknhps
dFku foukvkOgkukRed jkfgys- rlsp oknhus fu'kk.kh 06 oj fnukad
14-08-1986 jksthps i=] fu’kk.kh 07 oj rhu HkkMsikoR;k] fu’kk.kh 08
oj fnukad 31-10-1990 jksth uksVhl vkWQ eks’ku Øekad 3316@1989
e/;s ikjhr dsysY;k vkns’kkph izr] fu’kk.kh 09 oj ,d=kr ,dq.k 11
Hkj.kk ikoR;k] fu’kk.kh 10 oj ,d=kr ,dq.k 04 oht fcy] fu’kk.kh 11
oj oknhps ernku vksG[ki=] fu’kk.kh 12 oj oknhps oMhy panzdkar ;kaps
ernku vksG[ki=] fu’kk.kh 13 oj f’k/kkif=dk] fu’kk.kh 14 oj ,d=kr
oj xWl izek.ki=kph xzkgd izr vkf.k Hkj.kk ikoR;k] fu’kk.kh 15 oj
fnukad 23-03-2018 jksthP;k uksVhlph Nk;kafdr izr] fu’kk.kh 16 oj
fnukad 26-03-2018 jksth oknhus izfroknhauk ikBfoysys mRrj] fu’kk.kh
17 oj fnukad 03-04-2018 jksth ukenkj ckWEcs mPp U;k;ky;kus ikjhr
dsysY;k vkns’kkph izr] fu’kk.kh 18 oj fnukad 25-06-2018 jksth oknhus
izfroknhauk ikBfoysys mRrj] fu’kk.kh 19 oj fnukad 11-09-2018 jksthps
i=] fu’kk.kh 20 oj fnukad 16-01-2019 jksthP;k uksVhlph Nk;kafdr
izr] fu’kk.kh 21 oj fnukad 22-01-2019 jksthP;k uksVhlph Nk;kafdr
izr] fu’kk.kh 22 oj fnukad 15-02-2019 jksthps i= nk[ky dsys vkgs-
izfroknharQsZ rksaMh ok ys[kh iqjkok ns.;kr vkyk ukgh- oknhrQsZ odhy
Jh- ,l-,l-jsMsdj rlsp izfroknh Øekad 1 o 2 rQsZ odhy Jh- ds-,u-
dkansdj ;kapk ;qfDrokn ,sdyk-
eqn~nk Øekad 1 o 2 %&
9- ojhy nksugh eqn~ns ,desdkar xqarys vlY;kus R;kaps fu”d”kZ
eh ,df=ri.ks ukasnfor vkgs- oj mYys[k dsY;kizek.ks oknhus fu'kk.kh 04
-- 6 of 23 --
,l-lh- nkok Øekad 667@2019 --7-- U;k;fu.kZ;] fnukad 04-07-2026
oj ljrikl fnyk vlwu nkO;ke/;s uewn ckch lkaxhrY;k- ijarq] la/kh
feGwu ns[khy izfroknh Øekad 1 o 2 rQsZ oknhpk myVrikl ?ks.;kr
vkyk ulY;kus oknhps dFku foukvkOgkukRed jkfgys- vls vlys rjh]
fu'kk.kh 03 ojhy eqn~ns ikgrk nkok feGdrhpk rks dk;ns'khj rkcsnkj
vlY;kps rlsp izfroknhadMwu fnukad 23-03-2018 o 16-01-2019
jksth ikBfo.;kr vkysY;k uksVhl csdk;ns'khj vlwu vkiY;koj ca/kudkjd
ulY;kps fl) dj.;kph tckcnkjh oknhoj vlY;kus fuOoG oknhus
fu'kk.kh 04 oj fnysyk ljrikl gk myVriklkfouk jkfgyk vlyk rjh
oknhus vkiY;k dFkukiq"B~;FkZ fnysyk dkxnksi=h iqjkok fopkjkr ?ks.ks
vko';d vlwu fuOoG oknhpk ljrikl myVriklkfouk jkfgY;kus
izfroknhfo:)ps dFku oknhus fl) dsys vkgs vls Eg.krk ;s.kkj ukgh gk
izfroknharQsZ ofdykapk ;qfDrokn vfLodkjkgZ ukgh-
10- ojhy ifjfLFkrhr] oknh o izfroknhaps dFku fopkjkr ?ksrk]
nkok feGdr oknhP;k rkC;kr vlwu oknhps oMhy panzdkar ;kauh uxj
fnok.kh U;k;ky;kr ,l-lh-lqV Øekad 3939@1989 gk nk[ky dsyk
gksrk o R;kdkeh rqrkZrqrZ eukbZlkBh uksVhl vkWQ eks'ku Øekad
3316@1989 gk nk[ky dsyk gksrk rlsp fnukad 31-10-1990 jksth
lnj uksVhl vkWQ eks'ku e/khy fouarh Øekad ^v* eatwj djrkuk izfroknhauh
EgkMk vf/kfu;ekrhy dk;ns'khj rjrwnhaps ikyu djkos vlk vkns'k ikjhr
dj.;kr vkyk- rlsp oknhps oMhy panzdkar ;kauh tkusokjh 1989
iklwuph Fkdhr HkkMs jDde fnukad 31-10-1990 iklwu iq<hy 12
vkBoM~;kr U;k;ky;kr tek d:u iq<hy vkns'kki;Zar izR;sd efgU;kP;k
10 rkj[ksi;Zar HkkM~;kph jDde U;k;ky;kr tek dj.;kps funsZ'k oknhps
oMhy panzdkar ;kauk ns.;kr vkys gksrs ;kckcr okn ukgh-
-- 7 of 23 --
,l-lh- nkok Øekad 667@2019 --8-- U;k;fu.kZ;] fnukad 04-07-2026
11- ;kf'kok;] panzdkar dkuMs ;kauh nk[ky dsysyk ,l-lh-lqV
Øekad 3939@1989 gk izyafcr vlrkuk fnukad 18-11-1996 jksth
oknhps oMhy panzdkar gs e;r >kY;kckcr rlsp R;k nkO;kdkeh oknh
xSjgtj jkg.;kP;k dkj.kkLro rks nkok fnukad 28-06-2000 jksth
U;k;ky;kus dk<wu VkdY;kckcr ns[khy okn ukgh- rlsp] ,l-lh-lqV
Øekad 3939@1989 gk nkok dk<wu Vkd.;kpk vkns'k jn~n d:u rks
nkok iqUgk QSykoj ?ks.;klkBh izLrqr oknhus uksVhl vkWQ eks'ku Øekad
1725@2011 ;k U;k;ky;kr nk[ky dsY;kckcr o rks uksVhl vkWQ eks'ku
fnukad 21-02-2013 jksth ;k U;k;ky;kus QsVkGY;kckcr ns[khy okn
ukgh-
12- ;kf'kok;] oknhus fnukad 21-02-2023 jksthP;k lnj
vkns'kkl ukenkj ckWEcs mPp U;k;ky;kleksj izFke vihy nk[ky d:u
vkOgku fnys ijarq] R;k vkns'kkfo:) izFke vihy pky.;kl ik= ulY;kus
rs izdj.k vihy ÝkWe vkWMZj ;ke/;s :ikarjhr d:u R;kl vihy ÝkWe
vkWMZj Øekad 285@2014 vls uksanfo.;kr vkY;kckcr ns[khy okn ukgh-
;kmij] izfroknhauh R;kuarj fnukad 23-03-2018 jksth fu'kk.kh 15 ojhy
uksVhl EgkMk vf/kfu;ekP;k dye 95 iksVdye 3&v uqlkj oknhl
ikBfoyh o fnukad 26-03-2018 jksthps mRrj oknhus izfroknhauk ikBfoys
;kckcr ns[khy okn ukgh-
13- rlsp] mijksYysf[kr vihy ÝkWe vkWMZj Øekad 285@2014
gs izdj.k ukenkj mPp U;k;ky;kleksj fnukad 03-04-2018 jksth vafre
pkSd'khdjhrk use.;kr vkys vlrk izLrqr oknh@vihykFkhZrQsZ ofdykauh
fnukad 23-03-2018 jksthP;k uksVhluqlkj izfroknharQsZ lq: dj.;kr
vkysY;k dkjokbZdkeh Hkkx ?ksr vlY;kps lkaxwu rs vihy fnukad
03-04-2018 jksth dk<wu ?ksrY;kckcr okn ukgh- ;kf'kok;] izfroknhauh
-- 8 of 23 --
,l-lh- nkok Øekad 667@2019 --9-- U;k;fu.kZ;] fnukad 04-07-2026
R;kuarj fnukad 16-01-2019 jksth nkO;krhy fu'kk.kh 20 ojhy uksVhl
oknhl ikBowu Rks lwpuki= izkIr >kY;kiklwu iq<hy 48 rklkr nkok
feGdrhpk rkck lqiqnZ djkok vU;Fkk EgkMk vf/kfu;ekP;k dye 95
iksVdye 3&v uqlkj dkjokbZ dsyh tkbZy vls oknhl dGfoY;kckcr
ns[khy okn ukgh-
14- ojhy okn ulysY;k ckch fopkjkr ?ksrk] oknhus nkO;kP;k
ifjPNsn 3 o 4 e/;s f=Hkwou jksM ;sFkhy [kksyh Øekad 51 gh feGdr
R;kps oMhy panzdkar dkuMs ;kaP;k rkC;kr gksrh o fodkl vkjk[kMk
jkcfo.;kdjhrk rh laiw.kZ bekjr laikfnr dj.;kr vkY;kps dFku dsys
vkgs- izfroknhauh oknhps lnj dFku ukdkjys vlwu oknh fdaok R;kps
ofMykauh laca/khr bekjrhP;k ?kjekydkus fnysY;k HkkMsikoR;k gtj dsY;k
ulY;kps dSfQ;rP;k ifjPNsn 6 e/;s uewn dsys vkgs-
15- ojhy ckc fopkjkr ?ksrk] oknhus fu'kk.kh 05 ojhy ;knhlkscr
mijksYysf[kr dkxni=s nk[ky dsyh vlyh rjh R;ke/;s oj uewn f=Hkwou
jksMojhy [kksyh Øekad 51 gh feGdr oknhps oMhy panzdkar dkuMs ;kaP;k
rkC;kr HkkMsd: gDdkus gksrh gs fl) dj.;kdjhrk dks.krhgh dkxni=s
nk[ky dsyh ukgh- fu'kk.kh 6 ojhy xkGsforj.k vkns'kke/;s [kksyh Øekad
51 pk mYys[k fnlwu ;sr vlyk rjh fu'kk.kh 6 ojhy rks vkns'k [kksVk o
cukoV vlY;kps izfroknhaps dFku vkgs- ;k ifjfLFkrhr] [kksyh Øekad 51
e/;s oknhps oMhy HkkMsd: gksrs gs fl) dj.kkjk iqjkok oknhus ns.ks
vko';d gksrs- ;klkscrp] rh [kksyh ok rh [kksyh T;k bekjrhe/;s gksrh
rh bekjr fodkl vkjk[kM~;kP;k vaeyctko.khnjE;ku laiknhr >kY;kps
ns[khy oknhl R;kckcrpk mRd`"V iqjkok nk[ky d:u fl) djrk vkys
vlrs- ijarq] R;klaca/kh ns[khy oknhus dks.krkgh dkxnksi=h iqjkok nk[ky
dsyk ukgh- R;keqGs] oj mYys[k dsY;kizek.ks tjh f=Hkwou jksMojhy [kksyh
-- 9 of 23 --
,l-lh- nkok Øekad 667@2019 --10-- U;k;fu.kZ;] fnukad 04-07-2026
Øekad 51 ckcrps ljriklkrhy oknhps dFku foukvkOgkukRed jkfgys
vlys rjh vkiY;k dFkukiq"B~;FkZ dks.krkgh fLodkjkgZ o fo'oklkgZ iqjkok
ns.;kl oknh vi;'kh BjY;kus fuOoG nkO;krhy dFku o R;kiq"B~;FkZP;k
ljriklkrhy dFkukvk/kkjs oknhus f=Hkwou jksMojhy [kksyh Øekad 51 gh
feGdr R;kP;k ofMykaP;k rkC;kr HkkMsd: gDdkus gksrh gs fl) dsys
vkgs vls Eg.krk ;s.kkj ukgh-
16- ojhy ifjfLFkrhr] dk;eph i;kZ;h fuoklO;oLFkk Eg.kwu nkok
feGdr izfroknhadMwu fnukad 14-08-1986 jksth oknhaP;k ofMykaP;k ukos
okVi dj.;kr vkY;kps oknhps dFku vlwu oknhus R;kckcr fu'kk.kh 06
ojhy xkGsforj.k vkns'k rlsp fu'kk.kh 07 ojhy HkkMsikoR;kapk vk/kkj
Äsryk vkgs- dSfQ;rP;k ifjPNsn 7 o 8 e/;s izfroknhauh oknhps ojhy
dFku Li"Vi.ks ukdkjys vlwu fnukad 14-08-1986 jksthps okVii= [kksVs
o cukoV vlY;kps dFku dsys vkgs-
17- izfroknhapk ojhy cpko fopkjkr ?ksrk] oj mYys[k dsY;kizek.ks
nkok feGdrhojhy vkiyk rkck dk;ns'khj vlY;kps fl) dj.;kph
tckcnkjh oknhoj vlY;kus okLrfodr% fnukad 14-08-1986 jksth nkok
feGdrhps okVi panzdkar dkuMs ;kaP;k ukos >kY;kps fl) dj.;kph
tckcnkjh oknhoj gksrh- fu'kk.kh 06 ojhy fnukad 14-08-1986 jksthP;k
xkGsforj.k vkns'kkpk vk/kkj oknhrQsZ ?ks.;kr vkyk vlyh rjh oj mYys[k
dsY;kizek.ks lnj xkGsforj.k vkns'k [kksVk o cukoV vlY;kps izfroknhaps
dFku fopkjkr ?ksrk] ^tk-Ø-iqa-ja@30@2892* uqlkj nkok feGdr
mijksYysf[kr [kksyh Øekad 51 P;k cnY;kr dk;eph i;kZ;h fuoklh
O;oLFkk Eg.kwu panzdkar ;kauk ns.;kr vkY;kckcr izfroknhadMhy eqG
dkxni=kaph ekx.kh nkO;kdkeh d:u R;kvk/kkjs vkiys dFku oknhl fl)
djrk vkys vlrs ijarq] rls ?kMys ukgh-
-- 10 of 23 --
,l-lh- nkok Øekad 667@2019 --11-- U;k;fu.kZ;] fnukad 04-07-2026
18- oj mYys[k dsY;kizek.ks oknhrQsZ
ofdykauh ;qfDroknknjE;ku ,l-lh-lqV Øekad 3939@1989 ;k dkeh
nk[ky uksVhl vkWQ eks'ku Øekad 3316@1989 dkeh fnukad
31-10-1990 jksth ikjhr vkns'kkP;k l-f'k-udyspk vk/kkj ?ksryk- fu'kk.kh
08 ojhy lnj vkns'kkph l-f'k-uDdy ikgrk oknhps oMhy panzdkar ;kauh
izfroknhafo:) nkok feGdrhckcr rks nkok nk[ky dsY;kps o dk;ns'khj
ekxkZpk voyac dsY;kf'kok; nkok feGdrhrwu R;kauk izfroknhauh csn[ky
d: u;s v'kk fouarhdjhrk rks uksVhl vkWQ eks'ku nk[ky dsY;kps R;krhy
etdwj ikgrk fnlwu ;srs- ;kf'kok;] oj mYys[k dsY;kizek.ks f=Hkwou
jksMojhy [kksyh Øekad 51 P;k cnY;kr nkok feGdrhps okVi vkiY;k
ukos >kY;kps ns[khy panzdkar dkuMs ;kaps R;k nkO;kdkeh dFku gksrs o
R;kuqlkj fnukad 25-11-1988 jksth nkok feGdrhpk rkck vkiY;kyk
ns.;kr vkY;kps ns[khy dFku gksrs vls lnj vkns'kkrhy etdwj ikgrk
fnlwu ;sr vlwu R;k nkO;kdkeh izfroknhauh fnukad 14-08-1986 jksthP;k
okVikP;k vkns'kkckcr rlsp fnukad 25-11-1988 jksth nkok feGdrhpk
rkck panzdkar ;kauk fnY;kckcr panzdkar ;kaps dFku ukdkjrkuk rks okVi
vkns'k rlsp R;kuarjP;k HkkMsikoR;k [kksV~;k vlwu ewG HkkMsikoR;ka'kh
R;krhy etdwj tqGr ulY;kps fnlwu ;srs vls ns[khy dFku dsys gksrs
vls fnlwu ;srs-
19- mijksYysf[kr nkO;kdkeh ld`rn'kZuh uksanfo.;kr vkysyh
fujh{k.ks gh vafre uOgrh ;kckcr okn vl.;kps dkj.k ukgh- ijarq]
oknhP;k ofMykauh nk[ky dsysY;k nkO;kdkeh ns[khy nkok feGdrhlaca/kh
nk[ky dkxni=kckcr laca/khr U;k;ky;kus 'kadk mifLFkr dsyh gksrh fuOoG
;k eqn~n~;kckcr fnukad 31-10-1990 jksthP;k vkns'kke/;s ld`rn'kZuh
fu"d"kZ uksanforkuk lnj vkns'kkP;k ifjPNsn 13 e/;s "From the
-- 11 of 23 --
,l-lh- nkok Øekad 667@2019 --12-- U;k;fu.kZ;] fnukad 04-07-2026
voluminous documents tendered by the Housing Board Authorities, it
appears prima facie that the Plaintiffs have played probably some trick
or have probably availed of some extraneous method to get into
possession of their respective suit premises. One need not have even a
close scrutiny of these documents. Even & cursory glance is sufficient to
come to the conclusion that the Plaintiffs appear to have no right to
retain the possession of these premises. The allotment letters on which
they are heavily relying at, appear to be fake and dubious. However, it
cannot be heard from the Housing Board that the Plaintiffs who are in
settled possession of their respective premises right from the year 1988
without any disturbance, can be just thrown out of the premises without
following due process of law. An inquiry has to be held as to how these
allotment letters came to be issued by the Defendants authorities, by
which officers and what was the purpose/motive behind that. If the
Plaintiffs are to be blamed, the Defendants also cannot be exonerated
having regard to the nature of the allotment letters which appear to be
prima facie authentic" vls ld`rn'kZuh fujh{k.k uksanfoY;kps fnlwu ;srs-
20- lcc] fnukad 14-08-1986 jksthP;k xkGsforj.k vkns'kkckcr
izfroknhauh mijksYysf[kr 1989 lkyh nk[ky dj.;kr vkysY;k nkO;kdkeh
'kadk mifLFkr dsY;kps o R;kl vuql:u mijksYysf[kr vkns'kke/;s
ld`rn'kZuh fu"d"kZ uksanfo.;kr vkY;kph ckc fopkjkr ?ksrk oj mYys[k
dsY;kizek.ks oknhl izLrqr nkO;kdkeh izfroknh dk;kZy;kdMhy nkok
feGdrhckcrph ewG dkxni=s ekxowu vkiys dFku fl) djrk vkys
vlrs ijarq] rls ?kMys ukgh- R;keqGs] tjh oknhps dFku foukvkOgkukRed
jkfgys vlys rjh nkO;kdkeh mRd`"V iqjkok ns.;kph la/kh oknhl
vlwuns[khy oknhus mRd`"V iqjkok u nsrk fuOoG izfroknharQsZ R;kpk
myVrikl ?ks.;kr vkyk ukgh fdaok izfroknhauh lnj dkxni=s [kksVh
-- 12 of 23 --
,l-lh- nkok Øekad 667@2019 --13-- U;k;fu.kZ;] fnukad 04-07-2026
vlY;kps n'kZfo.kkjk dkxnksi=h iqjkok lknj dsyk ukgh ;k ckchapk vk/kkj
Äsryk vlY;kus fnukad 14-08-1986 jksthP;k xkGsforj.k vkns'kkckcr
rlsp 1988 lkykrhy HkkMsikoR;kackcr vkiys dFku fl) dj.;kl oknh
vi;'kh Bjyk vkgs-
21- ;k ifjfLFkrhr] izfroknharQsZ ofdykauh
vkiY;k ;qfDroknkiq"B~;FkZ vkse izdk'k csjfy;k vkf.k brj fo:) ;qfuV
VªLV vkWQ bafM;k vkf.k brj] AIR 1983 BOMBAY 1, ;k U;k;fu.kZ;kpk
vk/kkj ?ksryk R;ke/;s Para 6 "Secondly. Ss. 61 and 62 read together
show that the contents of a document must, primarily, be proved by the
production of the document itself for the inspection of the Court. It is
obvious that the truth of the contents of the document, even prima
facie, cannot be proved by merely producing the document for the
inspection of the Court. What it states can be so established. Para 7
Thirdly, it is laid down that the writer of a document must depose to the
truth of its contents. Three judgments must be not. ed in this
connection." vls EgVys vkgs- fu'kk.kh 06 o 07 ojhy dkxni=s fl)
dj.;kdjhrk oknhrQsZ laca/khrkph lk{k ?ks.;kr vkyh ulY;kph ckc
fopkjkr ?ksrk mijksYysf[kr U;k;fu.kZ; izfroknhaP;k enrhl ;srks- ;kf'kok;]
oknhus mijksYysf[kr uksVhl vkWQ eks'kudkeh >kysY;k vkns'kkuqlkj
U;k;ky;kr HkkM~;kiksVh tek dsysY;k jdekaP;k ikoR;k fu'kk.kh 09
oj ,d=kr nk[ky dsys vlwu fu'kk.kh 10 oj ,d=kr oht fcy rlsp
fuoM.kwd vksG[ki=] f'k/kkif=dk] xWl tksM.khckcrph dkxni=s nk[ky
dsyh vkgsr- ijarq] nkok feGdrhr oknhpk rkck vlY;kckcr izfroknharQsZ
okn mifLFkr dj.;kr vkyk ulY;kus lnj rkck dk;ns'khj vlY;kps fl)
djrkuk mijksYysf[kr dkxni=s oknhP;k enrhl ;sr ukghr gk izfroknharQsZ
ofdykapk ;qfDrokn fLodkjkgZ vkgs-
-- 13 of 23 --
,l-lh- nkok Øekad 667@2019 --14-- U;k;fu.kZ;] fnukad 04-07-2026
22- oj mYys[k dsY;kizek.ks ,l-lh-lqV Øekad 3939@1989 gk
nkok oknhps oMhy panzdkar dkuMs ;kauh nk[ky dsyk o R;kdkeh nk[ky
uksVhl vkWQ eks'kudkeh fnuakd 31-10-1990 jksth ojhyizek.ks vkns'k
ikjhr >kY;kuarj fnukad 18-11-1996 jksth oknhps oMhy panzdkar ;kapk
e`R;w >kyk- ifj.kker% fnukad 28-06-2000 jksth oknh xSjgtj
jkfgY;kP;k dkj.kkLro ,l-lh-lqV Øekad 3939@1989 gk dk<wu
Vkd.;kr vkY;kps oknhps dFku vlys rjh rks nkok XkSjgtsjhP;k
dkj.kkLro dk<wu Vkd.;kiwohZp oknhps oMhy panzdkar gs e;r
>kY;kus ,l-lh-lqV Øekad 3939@1989 gk vcsV >kyk gksrk gs Li"V
gksrs-
23- ojhy ifjfLFkrhr] ,l-lh-lqV Øekad 3939@1989 gk iqUgk
QSykoj ?ks.;klkBh oknhus nk[ky dsysyk uksVhl vkWQ eks'ku o rks uksVhl
vkWQ eks'ku fnukad 21-02-2013 jksth QsVkG.;kr vkY;kuarj oknhus R;k
vkns'kkfo:) nk[ky dssysys :ikarjhr vihy ÝkWe vkWMZj Øekad
285@2014 o rs izdj.k ukenkj mPp U;k;ky;kleksj izyafcr vlrkuk
izfroknhadMwu fnukad 23-03-2018 jksthph fu'kk.kh 15 ojhy EgkMk
vf/kfu;ekP;k dye 95 iksVdye 3&v uqlkj oknhl ikBfo.;kr
vkysyh uksVhl ;k ckch fopkjkr ?ksrk oknhus fu'kk.kh 17 oj vihy ÝkWe
vkWMZj Øekad 285@2014 dkeh fnukad 03-04-2018 jksth ukenkj ckWEcs
mPp U;k;ky;kus ikjhr dsysY;k vkns'kkph [kjh uDdy nk[ky dsyh vkgs-
24- mijksYysf[kr vihy ÝkWe vkWMZj Dismissed as withdrawn
djrkuk ukenkj ckWEcs mPp U;k;ky;kus R;k vkns'kkP;k ifjPNsn 3 e/;s "In
the course of hearing, the learned Government Pleader for the
Respondent, has placed on record letter dated 2nd April, 2018
addressed to her by Estate Manager, G/North, Mumbai Building Repairs
-- 14 of 23 --
,l-lh- nkok Øekad 667@2019 --15-- U;k;fu.kZ;] fnukad 04-07-2026
and Reconstruction Board. In the said letter the Estate Manager has
stated that subsequent to dismissal of the suit, action is initiated against
the Appellants in accordance with law. In the light of the statement
made by the Estate Manager in letter dated 2nd April, 2018, the
grievance of the Appellants /Plaintiffs that he is likely to be
dispossessed without taking recourse to law, stands redressed. In view
of the said letter the learned counsel for the Appellants seeks leave to
COU withdraw the appeal with liberty to contest the proceedings
initiated by the Executive Engineer vide notice dated 23rd March, 2018.
Leave with liberty as prayed for is granted." vls uewn dsys vkgs-
ifj.kker% fnukad 23-03-2018 jksthP;k uksVhluqlkj izfroknhauh oknhfo:)
nkok feGdrhckcr th dkjokbZ lq: dsyh R;k dkjokbZe/;s lgHkkxh gksr
vlY;kps oknhrQsZ ukenkj ckWEcs mPp U;k;ky;kl dGfo.;kr vkY;kps
Li"V gksrs-
25- ojhy ckc fopkjkr ?ksrk] oknhP;k dFkukuqlkj izfroknhauh
uSlfxZd U;k;rRokpk fopkjk u djrk rlsp EgkMk vf/kfu;ekrhy rjrwnhaps
ikyu u djrk fnukad 23-03-2018 jksthph uksVhl ikBowu fnukad
16-01-2019 jksthP;k uksVhluqlkj iq<hy 48 rklkr nkok feGdrhpk
rkck ns.;kph dsysyh ekx.kh pwdhph o csdk;ns'khj vkgs-
26- fnukad 23-03-2018 jksthph fu'kk.kh 15 ojhy uksVhl
ikgrk R;ke/;s izfroknhauh nkok feGdr oknhl d/khgh forjhr dj.;kr
vkysyh ukgh o nkok feGdrhe/;s oknh gk ?kwl[kksj vlwu vuf/kd`rjhR;k
okLrO; djhr vlY;kps fun'kZukl vkys vlY;kpk mYys[k djrkuk
^lcc] vki.kkl lnj xkG~;kP;k forj.kkP;k gDdkiksVh dks.kR;kgh
U;k;ky;kus izfrdwy@LFkfxrhps vkns'k fnys vlY;kl R;k vkns'kkph izr o
-- 15 of 23 --
,l-lh- nkok Øekad 667@2019 --16-- U;k;fu.kZ;] fnukad 04-07-2026
brj iqjkos b- dkxni=s vkiY;kdMs vlY;kl----- gs lwpuki= izkIRk
>kY;kiklwu lkr fnolkP;k vkr lknj djkohr* vls oknhl dGfoY;kps
fnlwu ;srs- ;kf'kok;] lkr fnolkr dkxni=s lknj u dsY;kl vFkok
lquko.kh goh vlY;kl lkr fnolkP;k vkr R;kckcr dk;kZy;k'kh laidZ
u lk/kY;kl nkok feGdrhrhy okLrO; ?kwl[kksj vuf/kd`rjhR;k ekuwu
EgkMk vf/kfu;ekP;k dye 95 iksVdye 3&v vUo;s lDrhph
fu"dklukph dk;Zokgh dj.;kr ;sbZy vls dGfoY;kps fnlwu ;srs-
27- ojhy ifjfLFkrhr] fu'kk.kh 15 ojhy uksVhluqlkj oknhl
izfroknhauh dkxni=s nk[ky dj.;kph la/kh fnY;kph rlsp lquko.khph la/kh
fnY;kps ns[khy Li"V gksr vlwu R;kckcrph dk;Zokgh oknhdMwu gkss.ks
visf{kr gksrs R;kckcr okn vl.;kps dkj.k ukgh-
28- ojhy ckc fopkjkr ?ksrk] oknhus fnukad 23-03-2018
jksthP;k fu'kk.kh 15 ojhy lnj uksVhlyk fu'kk.kh 16 ojhy mRrj fnukad
26-03-2018 jksth fnY;kps oknhps dFku vkgs- lnj mRrjkps voyksdu
djrk mijksYysf[kr ,l-lh-lqV Øekad 3939@1989 o R;kdkeh nk[ky
uksVhl vkWQ eks'kue/;s fnukad 31-10-1990 jksth ikjhr >kysyk vkns'k]
R;kuarj ukenkj ckWEcs mPp U;k;ky;kleksj nk[ky dj.;kr vkysys vihy
ÝkWe vkWMZj Øekad 285@2014 pk mYys[k vlwu rs vihy iq<hy
vkns'kklkBh izyafcr vlY;kps oknhus izfroknhauk dGfoY;kps
fnlwu ;srs- ;kf'kok;] EgkMk vf/kfu;ekps dye 95 o dye 3&v
oknhl ykxw gksr ulY;kpk fu"d"kZ uxj fnok.kh U;k;ky;kus uksanfoyk vlwu
ukenkj mPp U;k;ky;kleksj rks eqn~nk izyafcr vlY;kus fnukad
23-03-2018 jksthph uksVhl ekxs ?ks.;kr ;koh vls oknhus izfroknhauk R;k
mRrjkn~okjs dGfoY;kps fnlwu ;srs-
-- 16 of 23 --
,l-lh- nkok Øekad 667@2019 --17-- U;k;fu.kZ;] fnukad 04-07-2026
29- oj mYys[k dsY;kizek.ks oknhps oMhy panzdkar ;kauh nk[ky
dsysyk nkok xSjgtsjhP;k dkj.kkLro dk<wu Vkd.;kr vkyk rlsp oknhus rks
nkok iqUgk QSykoj ?ks.;kdjhrk nk[ky dsysyk uksVhl vkWQ eks'ku
QsVkG.;kr vkyk o R;kuarj ukenkj ckWEcs mPp U;k;ky;kleksj fnukad
26-03-2018 jksth mijksYysf[kr vihy ÝkWe vkWMZj izyafcr vlys rjh
nkok feGdrhoj vkiyk dk;ns'khj gDd o vf/kdkj n'kZfo.kkjh dkxni=s
izfroknhadMs gtj dj.;kl oknhl vMp.k gksrh vls Eg.krk ;s.kkj ukgh-
ijarq] fu'kk.kh 16 ojhy mRrj ikgrk oknhus nkok feGdrhojhy vkiyk
dks.kR;kgh Lo:ikpk gDd fl) dj.kkjh dks.krhgh dkxni=s izfroknhadMs
fu'kk.kh 15 ojhy uksVhluqlkj ns.;kr vkysY;k la/khuqlkj gtj dsyh
ulY;kps Li"V gksrs-
30- ;kmij] oj mYys[k dsY;kizek.ks fnukad 03-04-2018
jksthP;k vkns'kke/;s ukenkj ckWEcs mPp U;k;ky;kus uksanfoysys fujh{k.k
fopkjkr ?ksrk iqUgk oknhl izfroknhadMs nkok feGdrhojhy gDd o
vf/kdkj n'kZfo.kkjh dkxni=s nk[ky dj.;kph la/kh gskrh- ijarq] oknhus
fu'kk.kh 18 ojhy fnukad 25-06-2018 jksthP;k lnfudk fu;fer
dj.;kckcrP;k fouarhi=krhy etdwj fopkjkr ?ksrk R;kuarj izfroknhadMwu
fnukad 16-01-2019 jksth fu'kk.kh 20 ojhy uksVhl ikBfo.;kr vkY;kus
lnj lnfudk fu;ferhdj.kkckcr izfroknhadMwu oknhph fouarh fopkjkr
Äsryh xsyh ulY;kps Li"V gksrs-
31- ;kf'kok;] oknhus fu'kk.kh 19 ojhy fnukad 11-09-2019
jksthP;k fuoklh dk;Zdkjh vfHk;ark] eqacbZ bekjr nq:Lrh o iqujZpuk
eaMG ;kauh mieq[; vf/kdkjh iqujZfpr xkGs eqacbZ bekjr nq:Lrh o
iqujZpuk eaMG ;kauk ikBfoysY;k i=kph oknhl izkIr >kysY;k izrhpk vk/kkj
-- 17 of 23 --
,l-lh- nkok Øekad 667@2019 --18-- U;k;fu.kZ;] fnukad 04-07-2026
?ksryk vlyk rjh nkok feGdr dk;ns'khjjhR;k oknhP;k rkC;kr vkgs gs
fl) djrkuk lnj i= oknhP;k enrhl ;sr ukgh-
32- ;kmij] fnukad 16-01-2019 jksth izfroknharQsZ oknhl
ikBfo.;kr vkysyh uksVhl csdk;ns'khj vlwu vkiY;koj ca/kudkjd
ulY;kps oknhps dFku vlwu izfroknhadMwu lnj uksVhl ikBfo.;kiwohZ
dks.krhgh oS/k dkj.ks ns.;kr vkyh ukghr ok t:j rks vkns'k ikjhr
dj.;kr vkyk ukgh vls ns[khy dFku dj.;kr vkys vkgs-
33- fu'kk.kh 20 ojhy fnukad 16-01-2019 jksthph uksVhl ikgrk
R;ke/;s ^mijksä fo"k;kP;k vuq"kaxkus lanHkkZf/ku i= Ø 1 vUo;s 'kklukP;k
x`gfuekZ.k foHkkxkus fnysY;k funsZ'kkçek.ks lanHkkZf/ku i= Ø- 2 vUo;s eq[;
vf/kdkjh@nqoiq ;kaps çkIr >kysY;k funsZ'kkuqlkj o vki.k ek- mPp
U;k;ky;kr eaMGkfo#/n nkok Ø- 285@2014 vUo;s nk[ky dsysyk nkok
ek- mPp U;k;ky;kus 03-04-2018 jksth [kkjht dsyk vkgs- rlsp lnj
xkGk rkC;kr ?ks.;kiqohZ ek- mPp U;k;ky;kP;k funsZ'kkuqlkj vkiY;k vls
funsZ'kukl vk.kwu ns.;kr ;srs dh] lanHkkZf/ku i= Ø- 2 vUo;s EgkM
vf/kfu;e 1976 ps dye 95&v ¼3½ lq/kkfjr 1998 varxZr vki.kkal
uksVhl ctko.;kr vkyh vkgs- ek- mPp U;k;ky;kP;k funsZ'kkuqlkj ;k
dk;kZy;kus lanHkkZf/ku i= Ø- 3 vUo;s uewn dsysY;k i=kuqlkj ;k
dk;kZy;ke/;s lquko.khl gtj gksÅu vki.kkal xkG~;kP;k gDdkps dkxni=
lknj dj.;kl dGfoys gksrs- rjhgh vki.k lnj lquko.kh cSBdhl gtj
gksÅu xkG~;kP;k gDdkfo"k;h dks.krsgh lcG dkxni= ;k dk;kZy;kdMs
vn;ki lknj dsysyh ukgh- lnjgw xkG~;kpk gDdkfo"k;hps dkxni= lknj
dj.;kl ;k dk;kZy;kus vki.kkal okjaokj la/kh nsÅugh vki.k gDdkps
dkxni= lknj dj.;kl fnjaxkbZ d:u VkGkVkG dsysyh vkgs- rlsp ;k
dk;kZy;kus fn- 21-06-2018 jksthP;k i=kuqlkj fn- 27-06-2018 jksth
-- 18 of 23 --
,l-lh- nkok Øekad 667@2019 --19-- U;k;fu.kZ;] fnukad 04-07-2026
vk;ksftr dsysY;k lquko.khP;k fnukadkP;k fno'kh vki.k vkiY;k
gDdkckcrps dkxni=s lknj dsysyh vkgsr- vki.k lknj dsysY;k
dkxni=kaph iMrkG.kh dsyh vlrk] ojhy xkG~;kdfjrkpk vkiyk gDd
fl/n >kysyk ulY;keqGs ek- mPp U;k;ky;kP;k vkns'kkuqlkj vki.k lnjgw
xkGk eaMGkP;k rkC;kr ns.ks ca/kudkjd vkgs- rlsp lnj xkGk eaMGkP;k
rkC;kr ?ks.;kps funsZ'k lanHkkZf/ku i= Ø- 1 o 2 vUo;s ;k dk;kZy;kl
çkIr >kysys vkgsr- ;kLro lnj xkG~;kr vki.k ?kql[kksjh d#u okLrO;
djhr vlY;kps fu"d"kZ dk<.;kr vkysys vkgs-* vls uewn vkgs-
34- lnj uksVhle/khy ^ekuuh; mPp U;k;ky;kP;k
vkns'kkuqlkj* ;k mYys[kkpk vk/kkj ?ksowu oknhrQsZ
ofdykauh ;qfDroknknjE;ku nkok feGdrhpk rkck oknhdMwu ?ks.;kckcr
ukenkj mPp U;k;ky;kus d/khgh vkns'k ikjhr dsysys ukghr vls lkaxrkuk
lnj uksVhl pwdhph o csdk;ns'khj vlY;kps lkaxhrys- oj mYys[k
dsY;kizek.ks fnukad 03-04-2018 jksthP;k ukenkj ckWEcs mPp
U;k;ky;kP;k vkns'kkrhy fujh{k.ks ikgrk oknh@vihykFkhZrQsZ ofdykauh
fnukad 23-03-2018 jksthP;k uksVhlvk/kkjs nk[ky izdj.kh vki.k Eg.k.ks
ekaMwu R;kl fojks/k dj.kkj vlY;kckcr dGfoys gksrs vls x`ghr /kjko;kps
>kY;kl oj uewn dsY;kizek.ks oknhl nkok feGdrhps okVi dk;ns'khjjhR;k
R;kP;k ofMykaP;k ukos >kY;kps rlsp oknhps oMhy gs f=Hkwou jksM ;sFkhy
[kksyh Øekad 51 e/;s HkkMsd: Eg.kwu jkgr gksrs o R;k feGdrhps laiknu
>kY;kus dk;eph i;kZ;h fuoklO;oLFkk Eg.kwu nkok feGdr oknhps oMhy
panzdkar ;kauk okVi dsY;kps fl) dj.kkjk fLodkjkgZ o fo'oklkgZ iqjkok
ns.;kph la/kh oknhl feGwu ns[khy oknhus R;kckcrph dkxni=s izfroknhadMs
lknj dsyh ulY;kph ckc fopkjkr ?ksrk] fu'kk.kh 20 ojhy uksVhl
-- 19 of 23 --
,l-lh- nkok Øekad 667@2019 --20-- U;k;fu.kZ;] fnukad 04-07-2026
csdk;ns'khj vlwu vkiY;koj ca/kudkjd ulY;kps oknhps dFku fLodkjkgZ
ukgh-
35- lcc] tjh nkok feGdr izfroknhaP;k rkC;kr ns.;kckcr
ukenkj ckWEcs mPp U;k;ky;kpk dks.krkgh vkns'k >kyk ulY;kpk oknhrQsZ
ofdykapk ;qfDrokn fLodkjyk rjh nkok feGdrhr oknh gk ?kwl[kksjh d:u
okLoR; djhr vlY;kpk izfroknh dk;kZy;krhy vf/kdkÚ;kauh uksanfoysyk
fu"d"kZ o R;kl vuql:u ikBfoysyh fu'kk.kh 20 ojhy uksVhl ;ksX;
vlY;kpk izfroknharQsZ ofdykapk ;qfDrokn fLodkjkgZ vlwu rh uksVhl
pwdhph o csdk;ns'khj vlwu rh oknhoj ca/kudkjd ukgh gs fl) dj.;kl
oknh vi;'kh Bjyk vkgs-
36- ojhy ifjfLFkrhr] oknhrQsZ ofdykauh mijksYysf[kr nksUgh
uksVhluqlkj izfroknharQsZ dj.;kr ;ko;kph dkjokbZ csdk;ns'khj
vlY;kps ;qfDroknknjE;ku lkaxrkuk lhek larks"k tk/ko fo:) egkjk"Vª
gkSflax ,fj;k MsOgyiesaV vWFkkWfjVh] 2014 (1) Mh.L.J. 284, ;k U;k;fu.kZ;kpk
vk/kkj ?ksryk- lnj U;k;fu.kZ;ke/;s "Even unauthorized occupant and/or
trespasser, someone wants to evict, the due procedure of law required
to be followed. The due procedure of law in such a situation cannot be
meant just completing the formalities of issuing show cause notice and
without giving opportunity to the parties to take unilateral decision
even declaring that the Board issued documents are
illegal/unauthorized therefore summary eviction." vls EgVys vkgs-
37- oj mYys[k dsY;kizek.ks izfroknhadMwu oknhl mijksYysf[kr nksu
uksVhl ikBowu nkok feGdrhojhy dk;ns'khj gDd o vf/kdkj fl)
dj.;kdjhrk la/kh ns.;kr vkY;kps Li"V gksr vlY;kus izfroknhadMwu nkok
-- 20 of 23 --
,l-lh- nkok Øekad 667@2019 --21-- U;k;fu.kZ;] fnukad 04-07-2026
feGdrhpk rkck oknhdMwu feG.;kph ekx.kh djrkuk dk;ns'khj ekxkZpk
voyac dsyk xsyk ukgh vls Eg.krk ;s.kkj ukgh gk izfroknharQsZ ofdykapk
;qfDrokn fLodkjkgZ vkgs- ifj.kker% oknhrQsZ ofdykauh
vkiY;k ;qfDroknkiq"B~;FkZ vk/kkj ?ksrysyk mijksYysf[kr U;k;fu.kZ; oknhP;k
enrhl ;sr ukgh-
38- lcc] nkok feGdrhps vki.k dk;ns'khj rkcsnkj vlY;kps
fl) dj.;kl rlsp izfroknhauh fnukad 23-03-2018 o fnukad
16-01-2019 jksth ikBfoysY;k uksVhl csdk;ns'khj vlwu vaeyctko.khl
ik= ulY;kckcr o vkiY;koj R;k uksVhl ca/kudkjd ulY;kps fl)
dj.;kl oknh vi;'kh Bjyk vkgs- R;keqGs] eqn~nk Øekad 1 o 2 ps
fu"d"kZ ^ukgh* vls eh uksanfor vkgs-
eqn~nk Øekad 3 %&
39- izfroknhauh fnukad 23-03-2018 o fnukad 16-01-2019
ikBfoysyh uksVhl csdk;ns'khj vlwu vkiY;koj ca/kudkjd ulY;kps
gDdKkiu dj.;kr ;kos rlsp R;k uksVhluqlkj izfroknhauh dkjokbZ d: u;s
ok nkok feGdrhrwu oknhl csn[ky d: u;s v'kk fujarj eukbZph oknhus
fouarh dsyh vlwu eqn~nk Øekad 1 o 2 ps fu"d"kZ uksanforkuk nkok
feGdrhps vki.k dk;ns'khj rkcsnkj vlY;kps rlsp izfroknhauh fnukad
23-03-2018 o fnukad 16-01-2019 jksth ikBfoysY;k uksVhl
csdk;ns'khj vlwu vaeyctko.khl ik= ulY;kckcr o vkiY;koj R;k
uksVhl ca/kudkjd ulY;kps fl) dj.;kl oknh vi;'kh BjY;kP;k
fu"d"kkZizr eh vkyks vkgs- R;keqGs] fouarhizek.ks gDdKkiukph o fujarj
eukbZph nkn feG.;kl oknh ik= ukgh- lcc] eqn~nk Øekad 3 pk fu"d"kZ
^ukgh* vlk eh uksanfor vkgs-
-- 21 of 23 --
,l-lh- nkok Øekad 667@2019 --22-- U;k;fu.kZ;] fnukad 04-07-2026
40- FkksMD;kr] oj uewn dkj.kkLro nkok feGdrhckcr o
izfroknhauh ikBfoysY;k uksVhl ckcrps vkiys dFku fl) dj.;kl oknh
vi;'kh BjY;kus fouarhizek.ks dks.krhgh nkn feG.;kl oknh ik= ukgh-
R;keqGs] lnj nkok QsVkG.;kl ik= vlY;keqGs] eh [kkyhyizek.ks vkns'k
ikjhr djhr vkgs %&
%% vkns’k %%
1- ,l-lh-nkok Øekad 667@2019 QsVkG.;kr ;sr vkgs-
2- oknh o izfroknhauh nkO;kpk [kpZ Lor%Pkk Lor% lkslkok-
fnukad % 04-07-2026
¼ lqfuy ek- ikVhy ½
uxj fnok.kh U;k;k/kh’k] c`gUeqacbZ
U;k;ky; Øekad 9
Jqrys[kukph rkjh[k % 04-07-2026
fyI;arj.kkph rkjh[k % 04-07-2026
Lok{kjhph rkjh[k % 04-07-2026
-- 22 of 23 --
,l-lh- nkok Øekad 667@2019 --23-- U;k;fu.kZ;] fnukad 04-07-2026
“CERTIFIED TO BE TRUE AND CORRECT COPY OF THE ORIGINAL
SIGNED JUDGMENT/ORDER.”
Upload Date Upload Time Name of the Stenographer
04.07.2026 05:30 p.m. Mrs. Poonam Y. Pawar,
Stenographer (Grade-I)
Name of the Judge (With C.R. No.) H.H.J. SHRI. S. M. PATIL
(COURT ROOM NO.09)
Date of Pronouncement of
JUDGEMENT /ORDER
04.07.2026
JUDGEMENT /ORDER signed by
P.O. on
04.07.2026
JUDGEMENT /ORDER uploaded on 04.07.2026
-- 23 of 23 --