Full Order Text
Interim Order 1 · 15 Feb 2025 · CNR MHCC010024272025
Order Details: Notice of Motion Pdf Text: 1 Ad-interim in Draft NM IN THE BOMBAY CITY CIVIL COURT AT MUMBAI AD-INTERIM ORDER IN DRAFT NOTICE OF MOTION IN L.C. SUIT NO.419 OF 2025 Jadavji Deraj Chheda ….Plaintiff. V/s. 1. Brihan Mumbai Municipal Corporation of Greater Mumbai and Anr.. ..Defendants. Appearance : Adv. Sagar Batavia for the plaintiff. Adv. Bibhishan Sutar for the defendant/BMC. CORAM : HIS HONOUR JUDGE SHRI. V. S. KHOT (C.R.NO.06) DATE : 15th February, 2025. ORAL ORDER 1. The plaintiff has filed this notice of motion for issuance of injunction against the defendants and by the way of oral request, the plaintiff is pressing for ad-interim injunction against the defendants. 2. The plaintiff contended that he is a tenant of one house bearing No.2, Second floor, Room No.11, Mogal Lane, Behind Mahim Bazar Post Office, Mahim, Mumbai. The defendants are Municipal Corporation for Gr.Mumbai and its officer. The tenant is Jadavaji Cheeda is original holder of Room No.11 and he is in possession since 1972. The above mentioned house i.e. Room No.11 is the subject matter of the suit and shall be referred as “ suit property” hereinafter. -- 1 of 7 -- 2 Ad-interim in Draft NM 3. The defendants have issued one notice on 16.04.2024 and called the plaintiff for hearing on 29.04.2024. On 27.07.2024 they have issued one notice u/s. 353 of the MMC Act stating therein that illegal work is going on. The plaintiff has not carried out any illegal work. There is no structural changes carried out by the plaintiff. The notice issued by the BMC is wrong. The BMC again issued notice dated 19.12.2024 u/s 351, 352, 352A 354 of the MMC Act, 1888 and stated therein that there is contravention to provisions of MMC Act. On 25.01.2025 the BMC has passed the speaking order wherein the BMC authority branded one wall and bathroom as a unauthorized and directed the plaintiff to remove the said work within 15 days. The notice structure is not illegal. The notice structure is required to be protected. The speaking order passed is against the natural justice. The plaintiff has applied for sanction plan. But sanction plan has been not provided by the BMC. The plaintiff has not carried out any illegal construction. He has not made any alteration. The notice is bad at law. The injunction be issued against the BMC restraining the BMC from demolishing the notice structure. 4. Say of the other side came to be invited. The other side filed the affidavit and submitted that there is no statutory pre-suit notice issued and suit is bad in view of Section 515A of the MMC Act. There is no cause of action arose. The suit is not maintainable. The plaintiff is challenging the notice which is impermissible. The notice of motion deserves to be rejected. 5. In view of rival contentions, the following points arise for my determination and I have recorded my findings subject to the reasons as mentioned hereinafter. -- 2 of 7 -- 3 Ad-interim in Draft NM Sr. No. POINTS FINDINGS 1. Whether the plaintiff Is having prima- facie case, the balance of convenience and irreparable loss in his favour? In the Negative 2. Whether the plaintiff is entitled for getting the ad-interim injunction in his favour? In the Negative. 3. What order? As per the final order R E A S O N S AS TO POINT Nos.1 to 3. 6. The plaintiff came with the case that the BMC has issued the notice and speaking order against him. The plaintiff is a tenant. He has not carried out any alteration. There is no unauthorized construction and notice is wrong. The plaintiff has applied for sanction plan. But, sanction plan has not been provided by the BMC. The speaking order is passed against the natural law. The injunction be issued against the defendants. The defendants in equal vehemence submitted that the plaintiff has changed the MHADA plan and carried out illegal constructions. There is no authorization to the construction. The construction is liable to be demolished. The notice of motion is untenable and be rejected. 7. The plaintiff has filed this notice of motion for injunction and ad-interim injunction. The record of the case shows that the BMC has passed the speaking order wherein one wall and bathroom have been shown as unauthorizedly constructed. It is also apparent that the speaking order is issued after the perusal of the inspection report -- 3 of 7 -- 4 Ad-interim in Draft NM wherein inspection was carried out by the BMC engineer. The BMC engineer also detected unauthorized construction. The plaintiff has not shown any authorization to the unauthorized construction pointed out by the BMC in the speaking order. The plaintiff has not filed any sanction plan in this case. No permission is filed by the plaintiff’s side. The plaintiff contended that he has filed RTI application before the BMC for providing sanctioned plan. The plaintiff is duty bound to produce the authorization for the construction as he is preying for ad-interim injunction. It is the duty of the person claiming the injunction to prove that his construction is authorized/ legal. In this case, no authorization is shown by the plaintiff regarding the construction shown in the speaking order as unauthorized. This point goes against the plaintiff’s case. 8. The perusal of the record shows that the defendants/BMC has issued the letters to the plaintiff and asked him to come to meeting and show authorization for the construction. It is also apparent that BMC has carried out the inspection prior to issuance of notice and speaking order. The BMC has observed the procedure mandated in MMC Act, 1888. It cannot be said that the BMC has violated the natural law or provisions of the MMC Act. The BMC has also filed the photographs of the notice structure. 9. During the course of arguments the BMC has shown one map of MHADA for the entire building. The engineer of the BMC has stated that bathroom and room is shifted to some other place. The counsel for the BMC invited my attention to the map annexed with the notice, wherein it is shown that the bathroom is shifted to other place and wall is created near the balcony. The structure shown in the map -- 4 of 7 -- 5 Ad-interim in Draft NM annexed with the notice does not find place in MHADA MAP. It is prima- facie visible that the construction mentioned in the speaking order is unauthorized. 10. The plaintiff has applied for the injunction and he is duty bound to prove the authorization. He has not cited any document showing that the notice structure is legal. In such circumstances, it cannot be said that the plaintiff is having prima-facie case in his favour. Therefore, I hold that the plaintiff failed to prove the prima-facie case. 11. As far as the balance of convenience and irreparable loss is concerned, the balance of convenience and irreparable loss do not arise in favour of plaintiff. The above discussion show that the construction is unauthorized. The balance of convenience cannot tilt in favour of person who is having unauthorized construction. The irreparable loss cannot arise in favour of person if his unauthorized construction is razed/removed. The point of balance of convenience and irreparable loss do not arise in favour of the plaintiff. 12. The prima-facie case, balance of convenience and irreparable loss do not arise in favour of plaintiff. The plaintiff is not entitled to ad-interim protection. His prayer for ad-interim protection is liable to be rejected. In view of above said reasons, I am inclined to pass the following order resulting in rejection of the ad-interim prayer for injunction. ORDER 1. The prayer for ad interim injunction stands rejected. 2. No any order as to costs. -- 5 of 7 -- 6 Ad-interim in Draft NM 3. The notice of Motion be argued finally as early as possible. 4. The Notice of motion be registered. (V. S. KHOT) Judge, City Civil Court, Date: 15.02.2025 Gr. Bombay. Dictated on : 15.02.2025 Transcribed on : 15.02.2025 Signed on : -- 6 of 7 -- 7 Ad-interim in Draft NM CERTIFIED TO BE TRUE AND CORRECT COPY OF THE ORIGINAL SIGNED JUDGMENT/ORDER.” 17/02/2025 At 01.00 p.m. UPLOAD DATE AND TIME Name of the Judge (With Court Room Number) HHJ SHRI. V. S. KHOT (C.R.NO.06) Date of pronouncement of Judgment/ Order 15.02.2025 Judgment/Order signed by P.O. on 15.02.2025 Judgment/Order uploaded on 17.02.2025 -- 7 of 7 --
