Full Order Text
Final Order 1 · 20 Oct 2022 · CNR MHCC010022452021
Order Details: Ex-parte Judgement Pdf Text: 1 Judgment in Commercial Suit No. 1091/2021 Lodged on : 22.02.2021 Admitted on : 01.07.2021 Decided on : 20.10.2022 Duration : Y M D 1 7 28 COMMERCIAL SUIT NO. 1091 OF 2021 CNR NO. : MHCC010022452021 Exh.28 IDBI Bank Limited A company incorporated and registered under the Indian Companies Act, 1956 and also a banking company under Section 5(c) of Banking Regulation Act of 1949, having its registered office at IDBI Tower, WTC Complex, Cuffe Parade, Mumbai 400 005 and having one of its branches amongst other places at 485, West View Coop. Hsg. Soc. Ltd., Veer Savarkar Marg, Prabhadevi, Mumbai – 400 025. … Plaintiff Versus 1. M/s. Hadeed Tours and Travels, Prop. Saba Khan, Having address at Room No. 7, Gohar Khan Chawl, Sqtrs Colony, Near Andheri Plot, Jogeshwari, Mumbai – 400 060. 2. Ms. Saba Khan, female, adult, Indian Inhabitant, Having address at Room No. 7, Gohar Khan Chawl, Sqtrs Colony, Near Andheri Plot, Jogeshwari, Mumbai – 400 060. -- 1 of 11 -- 2 Judgment in Commercial Suit No. 1091/2021 3. Mr. Junaid Akhtar Sayeed Ahmad, male, adult, Indian Inhabitant, Having address at Room No. 5, Murshad Bldg, Near Vivek School, Querishi Nagar, Kurla East, Mumbai 400 070. ...Defendants Appearance: Mrs. A.W. Barve, Advocate for Plaintiff. Defendants exparte. CORAM : SHRI. A.S.SALGAR ADHOC JUDGE, (C.R.NO.31) DATED : 20th OCTOBER 2022 J U D G M E N T (Delivered on : 20.10.2022) The plaintiff has filed the present suit for the recovery of the amount of Rs.7,20,496/ from the defendants along with future interest at the rate of 11.40% per annum from the date of filing of the suit till realization. The brief facts of the plaintiff's case is as under: 2. The plaintiff is company incorporated and registered under the Companies Act, 1956 and also a banking company under Section 5(c) of Banking Regulation Act of 1949, having its registered office at Cuffe Parade, Mumbai and one of its branch is at Prabhadevi, Mumbai. The defendant no. 1 is the borrower who had approached the plaintiff bank for Term Loan to purchase of car to be used as Taxi. The defendant no. 2 is the Proprietor of defendant no. 1 and guarantor and the defendant no. 3 is the guarantor who guaranteed the repayment of the Term Loan. The defendant no. 1 applied for Term Loan of Rs.7,00,000/ vide its application dated 26.10.2015 for the purchase of -- 2 of 11 -- 3 Judgment in Commercial Suit No. 1091/2021 car to be used as Taxi. The defendant no. 2 submitted Proforma Invoice dated 10.10.2015 by Ritu Automobiles Ltd. The defendant no. 1 submitted Registration Certificate of Establishment of M/s. Hadeed Tours and Travels dated 11.09.2015 wherein defendant no. 2 is shown as employer. The plaintiff sanctioned Term Loan under Small Road and Water Transport Operators scheme of Rs. 7,00,000/ vide sanction letter dated 30.10.2015. To secure the repayment of the said Rs.7,00,000/, the defendants executed the documents on 30.10.2015 namely Demand Promissory Note, Declaration and Hypothecation cum Loan Agreement. The defendant nos. 2 and 3 signed Common Guarantee Deed dated 30.10.2015. The defendant no. 1 also submitted Margin Money Receipt from Ritu Automobiles Pvt. Ltd. with respect to Hyundai Xcent Car. The defendant no. 1 submitted receipt towards balance payment dated 11.11.2015 for Rs.7,00,000/ with respect to the said car. Defendant no. 1 also submitted Debit Note. The defendant no. 1 made default in payment. Hence, on 16.12.2017, the plaintiff addressed Demand Notice to the defendant no. 1 and demanded to clear the outstanding amount. Even after several reminders, the defendant no. 1 neglected and failed to clear the outstanding amount. A Demand Notice was also addressed to the defendant no. 1 on 15.02.2018. The defendant no. 1 committed default in repayment of installments. Ultimately, the account of the defendant no. 1 has been classified as NPA on 08.02.2018. The plaintiff further submitted that the defendant nos. 1 to 3 have committed breaches of the terms and conditions on which the credit facilities were granted. Hence, the plaintiff was constrained to file the present suit for the recovery of the amount of Rs.7,20,496/ along with interest at the rate of 11.40% per annum from all the defendants. -- 3 of 11 -- 4 Judgment in Commercial Suit No. 1091/2021 3. The suit summons was issued to defendant nos. 1 and 2 through R.P.A.D. The defendant nos. 1 and 2 refused to receive the same. The defendant nos. 1 and 2 failed to appear before the Court. Hence, as per order passed dated 17.02.2022, the suit is proceeded ex parte against the defendant nos. 1 and 2. The suit summons was issued to the defendant no. 3 through paper publication in newspapers namely “Free Press Journal” and “Navshakti”. It was duly served to the defendants. The defendants failed to appear before the Court. Hence, the suit was proceeded Exparte against the defendants as per order dated 23.08.2022. 4. In support of the pleading, the plaintiff bank has examined its Branch Manager namely Rameshwar Taktode at Exh.4. The plaintiff also placed on record the documentary evidence at Exh.6 to 25 i.e. Exh.6 is the application for Term Loan by the defendant no. 1, Exh.7 is the Proforma Invoice dated 10.10.2015, Exh.8 is the copy of Registration Certificate of establishment of M/s. Hadeed Tours and Travels dated 11.09.2015. Exh.9 is the Sanction Letter dated 30.10.2015, Exh. 10 is the Demand Promissory Note for Rs. 7,00,000/, Exh.11 is the Demand Promissory Note delivery letter dated 30.10.2015, Exh. 12 is the Declaration, Exh.13 is the hypothecation cum loan agreement, Exh.14 is the Common Guarantee Deed, Exh.15 is the Margin Money Receipt bearing no. 2460, Exh.16 is the receipt dated 11.11.2015 for Rs.7,00,000/, Exh.17 is the Tax Invoice dated 11.11.2015 for Rs.6,66,300/, Exh.18 is the Debit Note for Rs. 55,275/, Exh.19 is the copy of Demand Notice dated 16.12.2017, Exh.20 is the Demand Notice dated 15.02.2018, Exh.21 is the Recall Notice dated 17.03.2018 by the plaintiff, Exh.22 is the Invocation of guarantee notice -- 4 of 11 -- 5 Judgment in Commercial Suit No. 1091/2021 dated 05.04.2018 addressed by the plaintiff to the defendant no. 1; Exh.23 is the Invocation of guarantee notice dated 05.04.2018 addressed by the plaintiff to the defendant no. 2, Exh.24 is Invocation of guarantee notice dated 05.04.2018 addressed by the plaintiff to the defendant no. 3 and Exh.25 is the Particulars of Claim with Statement of Account. The evidence closure pursis of the plaintiff is at Exh.27. 5. From the above facts and circumstances, following points arise for my determination and I have recorded my finding against each of them with the reasons to follows: POINTS FINDING 1) Whether plaintiff bank proves that an amount of Rs.7,20,496/ is outstanding from the defendants? In the affirmative. 2) Whether plaintiff bank proves that the defendants have failed to repay the said loan amount of Rs.7,20,496/? In the affirmative 3) Whether plaintiff bank is entitled to recover an amount of Rs.7,20,496/ from the defendants? If yes, at what rate of interest? In the affirmative. At the rate of 11.40% per annum. 4) What order and decree? Suit is decreed with costs. R E A S O N S 6. Heard Learned Advocate Mrs. A.W. Barve for Plaintiff at length. -- 5 of 11 -- 6 Judgment in Commercial Suit No. 1091/2021 7. According to the plaintiff, the defendants have obtained the loan on 30.10.2015. The defendants have made last payment on 10.10.2017. The suit was filed by the plaintiff on 22.02.2021. The Statement of Account filed on record by the plaintiff shows that the defendants have made last payment of Rs.13,899/ on 10.10.2017. The plaintiff also filed the Mediation Application on 02.01.2020 and thereafter he filed the suit on 22.02.2021. If the aforesaid period is calculated, it is crystal clear that the suit filed by the plaintiff is within limitation. As to point nos. 1 to 3 8. According to the plaintiff, the defendant no. 1 has obtained the loan of Rs.7,00,000/ for purchasing Hyundai Xcent Car and defendant nos. 2 and 3 signed the Guarantee Deed. The defendant nos. 2 and 3 also executed various documents in favour of the plaintiff bank. The defendant nos. 1 to 3 have committed the breaches of the terms and conditions on which the credit facility was granted. According to the plaintiff, the total amount of Rs.7,20,496/ is outstanding from the defendants. At the outset, it is to be noted that the suit is not contested by any defendants. The defendants have failed to file Written Statement on record. Therefore, it can be said that the averments made in the plaint were not denied or disputed by the defendants. Therefore, it can be said that the averments were deemed to be admitted by the defendants. 9. In support of the pleading, the plaintiff has examined its Branch Manager namely Rameshwar Taktode at Exh.4. This witness has deposed in support of the suit claim. His evidence is in consonance with -- 6 of 11 -- 7 Judgment in Commercial Suit No. 1091/2021 the averments made in the plaint. He has reiterated the contents in the plaint. According to this witness, the defendant no. 1 is the borrower who had approached the plaintiff bank for a Term Loan. Defendant no. 2 is the Proprietor of the defendant no. 1 and guarantor and defendant no. 3 is also guarantor, who has guaranteed the repayment of the Term Loan. The defendant no. 1 applied for Term Loan of Rs.7,00,000/ for the purpose of car. He also deposed that the plaintiff bank sanctioned the said loan as per sanction letter dated 30.10.2015. In order to secure the loan, the defendants executed the documents namely Demand Promissory Note, Declaration and hypothecation cum loan agreement. The defendant nos. 2 and 3 also signed Deed of Guarantee dated 30.10.2015. The defendant no. 1 also submitted Margin Money Receipt. The defendant no. 1 also submitted Tax Invoice with respect to Hyundai Xcent Car. The defendant no. 1 also submitted Debit Note. He also submitted that the defendant no. 1 made default in payment. Even after several reminders, the defendant no. 1 neglected and failed to clear the outstanding amount. Ultimately, the account of the defendant no. 1 has been classified as NPA. According to this witness, the total amount of Rs.7,20,496/ is outstanding from the defendants. The aforesaid oral evidence of the plaintiff is not subjected to cross examination. The defendants failed to conduct the crossexamination of the plaintiff. Therefore, the oral evidence of the plaintiff is remained unchallenged. Therefore, I have no reason to disbelieve the version of the plaintiff. 10. The oral evidence of the plaintiff is supported by documentary evidence. Exh.6 is the loan application dated 26.10.2015 which is submitted by the defendant no. 1. The said loan application bears the signature of the defendant no. 1. Exh.7 is the Proforma -- 7 of 11 -- 8 Judgment in Commercial Suit No. 1091/2021 Invoice of the car. As per Sanction letter dated 30.10.2015 at Exh.9 the loan was granted to the defendant no. 1 under the terms and conditions. The Demand Promissory Note at Exh.10 also shows that the defendant no. 1 has executed the said Demand Promissory Note in favour of the plaintiff bank. The Declaration at Exh.12 also shows that the defendant has executed the said Declaration in favour of the plaintiff bank in connection of loan. The hypothecation cum loan agreement at Exh.13 shows that the defendants have executed the documents in favour of the plaintiff bank. Exh.14 is the Deed of Guarantee which is executed by the defendants in favour of the plaintiff and thereby defendant nos. 2 and 3 were agreed to act as a Guarantor for the said loan. It is also seen from the record that as per the Demand Notice at Exh.20 and 21, the plaintiff has sent notice to the defendants and called upon them to pay the outstanding amount. No reply was sent to the said notice The aforesaid documentary evidence tendered by the plaintiff was remained unchallenged. The defendants have failed to pay the outstanding amount. The Statement of Account at Exh.25 also shows that an amount of Rs.7,20,496/ is outstanding from the defendants. The plaintiff bank has maintained the said Statement of Account in the regular course of business of the bank. These entries were maintained properly by the bank. The aforesaid oral as well as documentary evidence tendered by the plaintiff was not challenged by the defendants. Hence, I have no reason to disbelieve the documentary evidence tendered by the plaintiff. 11. In the present case, the plaintiff bank by adducing oral as well documentary evidence sufficiently established that the total amount of Rs.7,20,496/ is outstanding from the defendants. Therefore, -- 8 of 11 -- 9 Judgment in Commercial Suit No. 1091/2021 the plaintiff is entitled to recover the said amount from the defendants along with interest. Admittedly, the defendant nos. 2 and 3 are the guarantors of the said loan. They have signed the Deed of Guarantee in favour of the plaintiff bank. Therefore, they are also liable to pay the outstanding amount to the plaintiff. 12. So far as rate of interest is concerned, the plaintiff has claimed interest at the rate of 11.40% per annum on the principal amount. The Sanction letter at Exh. 9 also shows that the agreed rate of interest between the parties is at the rate of 11.40% per annum. The Demand Promissory Note as well Hypothecation cum loan Agreement also shows the agreed rate of interest is 11.40% per annum. Hence, the plaintiff bank is entitled to recover the said amount of Rs.7,20,496/ along with interest at the rate of 11.40% from all the defendants. Hence, my finding as to point Nos.1 to 3 in the affirmative. As to point no. 4 13. In view of my finding as to point nos. 1 to 3, the suit is liable to be decreed with cost. Accordingly, I answer point no. 4 and proceed to pass the following order : ORDER 1) Commercial Suit No. 1091 of 2021 is decreed with costs. 2) The defendants are jointly and severally liable to pay an amount of Rs.7,20,496/ (Rs. Seven Lakhs Twenty Thousand Four Hundred and Ninety Six Only) to the plaintiff bank alongwith interest at the rate of 11.40% per annum on the principal amount of Rs.7,00,000/ -- 9 of 11 -- 10 Judgment in Commercial Suit No. 1091/2021 from the date of filing of the suit till realization. 3) Defendants shall bear the cost of the suit. 4) Court fee, if any, be refunded to the plaintiff as per rule. 5) Decree be drawn up accordingly. (Judgment pronounced in the open Court) Dated : 20.10.2022 (A.S. Salgar) Adhoc Judge, City Civil Court Gr. Mumbai. Dictated on : 20.10.2022 Typed on : 20.10.2022 -- 10 of 11 -- 11 Judgment in Commercial Suit No. 1091/2021 CERTIFIED TO BE TRUE AND CORRECT COPY OF THE ORIGINAL SIGNED JUDGMENT/ORDER” UPLOAD DATE TIME NAME OF STENOGRAPHER 21.10.2022 12.15 p.m. Prachi Y. Potdar Stenographer – Grade I Name of the Judge HHJ Shri. A.S. Salgar (C.R.NO. 31) Date of Pronouncement of Judgment/Order. 20.10.2022 Judgment/order signed by P.O on 21.10.2022 Judgment/order uploaded on 21.10.2022 -- 11 of 11 --
