Full Order Text
Final Order 1 · 10 May 2024 · CNR MHCC010020952024
Order Details: Other Pdf Text: 1 Judg. Misc. Appeal 15/2024 MHCC010020952024 Presented on : 06/02/2024 Registered on : 05/04/2024 Decided on : 10/05/2024 Duration : 00 03 04 Years Months Days IN THE COURT OF CITY CIVIL FOR GREATER BOMBAY AT BOMBAY MISCELLANEOUS APPEAL NO.15 OF 2024 Kunavaraben Raja Ravariya, of Bombay Indian Inhabitant, Age : 59 years, Occ. Housewife, residing at Room No.9, Chawl No.2, Shivkripa Welfare Association, Behind ONGC Colony, Vidyavihar (East), Mumbai - 400 077. …. Applicant Versus 1. V. P. Paithankar, The Learned Estate Officer and Senior Divisional Engineer, Central Railway, Appointed under Section 3 of Public Premises (Eviction of Unauthorised Occupants) Act, 1971 and having his Office at Annex Building, 3rd Floor, Mumbai, CSMT - 400 001. 2. The Union of India, Through Divisional Engineer (LM), Central Railway Administration. 3. The General Manager, Central Railway having his Office at Annex Building, Mumbai, Fort, CSMT - 400 001. …. Respondents -- 1 of 16 -- 2 Judg. Misc. Appeal 15/2024 CORAM : HIS HONOUR THE PRINCIPAL JUDGE, SHRI. A. SUBRAMANIAM (C.R.No.19) DATE : 10th DAY OF MAY, 2024 Appearances :- Adv. Mr. Sanket Mungale for appellant. Adv. Mr. L. K. Tripathi for respondents. ORAL ORDER 1. By the present appeal, the appellant/s is/are challenging the impugned order passed by the learned Estate Officer with regard to the properties situated at Vidyavihar. As the properties involved and the factual and legal issues involved, in these set of appeals are the same, these group of appeals is disposed of by common judgment herein. 2. The learned Estate Officer issued Show cause notice to the occupant/s/appellant/s herein on 30/05/2022. In pursuance to the Show Cause, the concerned occupant/s appeared through their advocate and submitted joint reply. The learned Estate Officer thereafter passed the impugned order. Hence, the present set of appeals. 3. Heard the learned counsel for the appellant/s. It is vehemently submitted that the procedure contemplated under the Public Premises Act is not followed. The basic principles of natural justice are violated. No grounds are stated in the notice. The order tries to bring about the grounds which are not contemplated like bonafide requirement of the railways. The Estate Officer directly issued notice without any information or documents. The property is not described in the notice. -- 2 of 16 -- 3 Judg. Misc. Appeal 15/2024 The documents, plans, etc. are referred to by the learned Estate Officer which are not part of record. The copies were never supplied or inspection given to the present appellants. Considering the same, the learned Estate Officer directly issued the notice and directly passed the order. The present appellants are residing there since last more than 40 years and various contentions have been taken which would require evidence and factual ascertainment which has not been done by the learned Estate Officer. Considering the same, the order be set aside and appeals be allowed. 4. Heard learned counsel for the railways. It is contended that the notice mentions unauthorised occupation and thus grounds are available. The learned Estate Officer has considered the office record of railways before issuing of notice and has considered the plan and maps available with railways. This is valid ground and valid support to the order of the learned Estate Officer. Apparently, from the reply itself, it is clear cut admitted that the land is of railways. There is no authorisation shown and thus appellants are liable to be evicted. Considering the nature and summary nature of the proceedings, the notice has to be construed liberally. There is no contention taken that the description is incorrect or the premises of the appellants is not identifiable. There is no dispute of description of the property. No documents have been submitted to the Estate Officer by the appellants. There is no requirement as no defence is made out and hence the learned Estate Officer has rightly allowed the applications and passed the impugned order. Same should be confirmed. -- 3 of 16 -- 4 Judg. Misc. Appeal 15/2024 5. Perused the impugned order and Record and Proceedings. Considered the submissions. Following points arise for my determination and I answer the same as under, for the reasons stated herein after : Sr. No. Points Findings 1) Whether proper procedure has been followed by the learned Estate Officer? In the negative. 2) Whether the appellant/s can be said to be unauthorized occupant/s? Does not survive. 3) Whether the impugned order requires interference? In the affirmative. 4) What order ? As per final order. REASONS : AS TO POINT NO.1 :- 6. Considering the manner in which the learned Estate Officer has dealt with the matter, it would be first appropriate for me to consider the provisions of the Public Premises (Eviction of Unauthorized Occupants) Act and the procedure contemplated therein. 7. The Public Premises Act is a Special Act enacted with a view to evict unauthorised occupants of public premises without any delay. The said Act is self-contained Act containing definitions as well as procedures to be followed in deciding the issue. Necessary rules are also framed. An Estate Officer is appointed to decide the issue and pass orders on merits. 8. The provisions of the P.P. Act first contemplates and defines public premises which is not required to be gone into this appeal. -- 4 of 16 -- 5 Judg. Misc. Appeal 15/2024 9. The important concept to be considered is the definition of unauthorized occupation as contemplated under section 2(g) of the P.P. Act. It contemplates occupation of the premises without authority or continuance of occupation after the permission to occupy has expired or determined. Thus, unauthorized occupation contemplates two eventualities:- 1) that a person is a stark trespasser or unauthorised occupant and 2) that he entered authorisedly but subsequently, because of determination or breach, his occupation has become unauthorized. Different procedure is contemplated and required for both these categories. The amendment to the Act also contemplates in addition to ‘Unauthorised Occupation’, other categories namely Temporary occupation, Residential Occupation, Unauthorised Construction . This classification is seen to be considered in AIR 2008 SC 876(1) [New India Assurance Co. Ltd. v. Nusli Neville Wadia and others as under : “26. The occupants of public premises may be trespassers, or might have breached the conditions of tenancy, or have been occupying the premises as a condition of service, but were continuing to occupy the premises despite cessation of contract of service. 27. However, there may be another class of tenants who are required to be evicted not on any of the grounds mentioned hereinbefore but inter alia on the ground, which requires proof of the fairness and reasonableness on the part of the landlord which may include requirement for its own use and occupation.” 10. The Public Premises Act also contemplates different kinds of proceedings. Section 3A contemplates eviction from temporary occupation and it relates to persons who are given occupation of the premises for a temporary period. Section 3B contemplates eviction of unauthorised -- 5 of 16 -- 6 Judg. Misc. Appeal 15/2024 occupation from residential accommodation. The residential accommodation is defined in section 2(fa) and implies a person who is in occupation on the basis of license for a fixed tenure or for the period he holds office. Section 5(B) contemplates order of demolition of unauthorized construction. 11. Section 5 deals with the eviction of unauthorised occupants in general. Section 5(A) deals with the power to remove unauthorised construction on public premises. Section 7 deals with power to require payment of rent or damages of unauthorised occupation period. 12. Section 5 has to be read with section 4 of the P.P. Act. Section 4 contemplates that whenever an Estate Officer has ‘information’ that any person is in unauthorised occupation of the public premises he can issue show cause notice on his satisfaction. Section 4(1)(A) contemplates that if the Estate Officer knows or has reasons to believe that a person is in unauthorised occupation, he can issue a notice directly. Thus, it contemplates that the Estate Officer has knowledge or has reason to believe or has information of such ‘unauthorised occupation’. These are factual aspects and considering the same, I firmly believe that the Estate Officer has to make out reasoned grounds under these provisions to start the proceedings. If there is any information given and it is oral, he can take it in writing and pass further orders which may satisfy section 4(1). If he has own knowledge or reason to believe as contemplated under section 4(1)(A), then this knowledge or reasons should be incorporated by the concerned learned Estate Officer before proceeding with issuance of -- 6 of 16 -- 7 Judg. Misc. Appeal 15/2024 notice. This is more important as the party who has to answer the notice should have grounds or knowledge on the basis of which the eviction is claimed from him. In the present case, there is no information, knowledge or reason to believe associated seen from the Record and Proceedings. The said reasons are seen in the final order which contemplates existence of some expansion plan of the railways. For the purpose of this appeal, it is not question of dispute that the property is of railways. 13. Section 4(2) is a second important provision which contemplates that the notice which is issued by the learned Estate Officer, on the basis of such information, personal knowledge or reasons to believe, should specify the grounds on which the order of eviction is proposed to be made. Thus, the reasons of having the information or specific knowledge or reasons to believe, are to be somewhere related to the grounds stated in the eviction show cause notice. It is mandatory for the learned Estate Officer to consider that the grounds are such that mandate eviction and only when such serious breach or Bonafide requirement is made out that such notice under section 4 can be issued by the learned Estate Officer. Thus, his satisfaction is of material importance and the grounds thus become more important. Useful reference can be taken from AIR 2008 SC 876(1) [New India Assurance Co. Ltd. v. Nusli Neville Wadia and another :- “24. Where an application is filed for eviction of an unauthorized occupant it obligates the Estate Officer to apply his mind so as to enable him to form an opinion that the respondent is a person who has been in unauthorized occupation of the public premises and that he should be evicted.” -- 7 of 16 -- 8 Judg. Misc. Appeal 15/2024 14. In the present case, the notice unfortunately does not mention any grounds. Although there is a title “GROUNDS” in the notice (as per format in rules), it does not state so and no grounds are mentioned underneath it. 15. There is mention of ‘unauthorised occupation’ beforehand but as pointed out, the law contemplates that reasons should be assigned to why ‘unauthorised occupation’. Unauthorised occupation of which of two categories and why are necessary, it is necessary for the answering party to understand which of the two categories, the appellants belong. It is necessary to answer properly if the State considers the answering person as a stark unauthorised occupant or it considers the said person to have breached or the occupation permission is determined or for bonafide requirement. Without these specific details and grounds of breach or facts of determination or bonafide requirement not being stated, it would be a vague notice. 16. In the present case, as no grounds are mentioned, the proceedings get vitiated and entire order gets vitiated , so much so that no proper opportunity is available to the person to whom notice is addressed to deal with any of the allegations, as there are no allegations levied in the said notice. 17. Not the least, for effective implementation of the order and/or identification of the property, the property should be specifically defined. There is no property described in the notice. I believe this would lead to -- 8 of 16 -- 9 Judg. Misc. Appeal 15/2024 further issues when the matter/orders are to be executed as there is no specific description of the property. Needless to say, in the present case, at least, there is, I believe, no description available to the describe the properties properly. This is another lacuna in the present case as regard to section 4 notice is concerned. 18. Section 5 of the P.P. Act contemplates an inquiry. Once some reasons are assigned, objecting to the relief of eviction, it is duty bound to the learned Estate Officer to consider if the cause is existing or not. It also contemplates a personal hearing to be given and thereafter satisfaction is to be recorded. It is now well settled that different procedure is contemplated in case of the two categories of unauthorised occupants. Firstly, if it is a stark unauthorised occupancy, then the burden is on such occupant to show his authorisation or his entitlement to continue to remain in property and thereafter it is the question of rebuttal by the State. In the second category of breach or determination or bonafide requirement, the State has to show the breach or determination and the rebuttal lies with the occupant as held in AIR 2008 SC 876(1) [New India Assurance Co. Ltd. v. Nusli Neville Wadia and others : “ 28…..In the latter category of cases the landlord would be required to establish not only the bona fide need …. 30. When an application for eviction is based on such grounds, which require production of positive evidence on part of the landlord, in our opinion, it would be for it to adduce evidence first; ….. 31. There may be a case where the tenant may take a defence which discloses no prima facie case in which event the Estate Officer may ask him to lead evidence. But there may be cases where the ground of eviction, having regard to the defence taken by the occupants, may be required to be gone into -- 9 of 16 -- 10 Judg. Misc. Appeal 15/2024 34. Procedure laid down for recording evidence is stated in the Rules. The Estate Officer being a creature of the statute must comply the same. When a notice is issued, the occupant of the public premises would not only be entitled to show cause but would also be entitled to produce evidence in support of the cause shown.” 19. In the present case, unfortunately, the grounds do not mention or the proceedings and the record does not mention what kind of category the occupant is and the Estate officer could not and did not consider and thus the occupant is at loss as to whether the occupant has to lead evidence or the State would be leading evidence. 20. The Ld E.O has given findings on grounds of Bonafide requirement It is necessary to point out that all through out the proceedings, it is seen that no documents are filed by the either side. In the Record and Proceedings, a chit of a plan is filed. Neither is this plan provided to the other side nor is it seen to be forming part of the record. Thus, if the applicant relies on a document, same should be provided to the other side or at least inspection should be provided of the documents that the State relies upon, in the proceedings. Post hearing, the other documents available on record of the railways or the State, cannot be considered. 21. The principles of fairness is held in AIR 2008 SC 876(1) [New India Assurance Co. Ltd. v. Nusli Neville Wadia and others as under : “CONCEPT OF FAIRNESS 35. The procedural aspect as to who should lead evidence first, thus may have to be determined on the basis of the issues -- 10 of 16 -- 11 Judg. Misc. Appeal 15/2024 arising in the matter. When we say so, we do not mean that the procedure involved being a summary one, the issues are required to be specifically framed but that which is the principal issue(s) between the parties must be known to the Estate officer. 36. Thus under the Public Premises (Eviction of Unauthorized Occupants) Act, 1971 the occasion would arise for multi-level inquiry: Primary inquiry will be to arrive at a conclusion on unauthorized occupant; and intermediate inquiry would be as to the eviction of unauthorized occupant. 38. The statute, although, does not require a lengthy hearing or a lengthy cross-examination but the noticee should be given an opportunity to file an effective show cause. An effective show cause can be filed when eviction is sought for a specified ground and the occupants must know the particulars in relation thereto. 44. If some facts are to be proved by the landlord, indisputably the occupant should get an opportunity to cross-examine. The witness who intends to prove the said fact has the right to cross-examine the witness. This may not be provided by under the statute, but it being a part of the principle of natural justice should be held to be indefeasible right 48. Section 5 of the Act, on a plain reading, would place the entire onus upon a noticee. It, in no uncertain terms, states that once a notice under Section 4 is issued by the Estate Officer on formation of his opinion as envisaged therein it is for the noticee not only to show cause in respect thereof but also adduce evidence and make oral submissions in support of his case. Literal meaning in a situation of this nature would lead to a conclusion that the landlord is not required to adduce any evidence at all nor it is required even to make any oral submissions. Such a literal construction would lead to an anomalous situation because the landlord may not be heard at all. It may not even be permitted to adduce any evidence in rebuttal to the one adduced by the noticee nor it would be -- 11 of 16 -- 12 Judg. Misc. Appeal 15/2024 permitted to advance any argument. Is this contemplated in law? The answer must be rendered in the negative. When a landlord files an application, it in a given situation must be able to lead evidence either at the first instance or after the evidence is led by the noticee to establish its case and/ or in rebuttal to the evidence led by the noticee. 49. The literal interpretation of the statute, if resorted to, would also lead to the situation that it would not be necessary for the landlords in any situation to plead in regard to its need for the public premises. It could just terminate the tenancy without specifying any cause for eviction. 50. Except in the first category of cases, as has been noticed by us hereinbefore, Sections 4 and 5 of the Act, in our opinion, may have to be construed differently in view of the decisions rendered by this Court. If the landlord being a State within the meaning of Article 12 of the Constitution of India is required to prove fairness and reasonableness on its part in initiating a proceeding, it is for it to show how its prayer meets the constitutional requirements of Article 14 of the Constitution of India. For proper interpretation not only the basic principles of natural justice have to be borne in mind, but also principles of constitutionalism involved therein. With a view to read the provisions of the Act in a proper and effective manner, we are of the opinion that literal interpretation, if given, may give rise to an anomaly or absurdity which must be avoided. So as to enable a superior court to interpret a statute in a reasonable manner, the court must place itself in the chair of a reasonable legislator/ author. So done, the rules of purposive construction have to be resorted to which would require the construction of the Act in such a manner so as to see that the object of the Act fulfilled; which in turn would lead the beneficiary under the statutory scheme to fulfill its constitutional obligations as held by the court inter alia in Ashoka Marketing Ltd (supra).” 22. The present proceedings are Quasi Civil proceedings and considering the same, it is expected that although the Estate Officer is an -- 12 of 16 -- 13 Judg. Misc. Appeal 15/2024 employee of the railways, he has to deal with it without prejudice and independently. The learned Estate Officer or the procedure is only to expedite the process and not to make it one sided. It does not imply that the concerned Estate Officer can use his own knowledge of facts or his access to documents of the department and rely upon them to pass the order. Whatever documents the State or the concerned department wants to rely upon, should be placed on record of the proceedings and also provided to other side with right of rebuttal. 23. In the present case, apparently, it appears that if this would have been done, there would have been less chance to oppose the proceedings. Thus, on this count, that the learned Estate Officer did not carry out proper procedure or proper opportunity and considered extraneous evidence, has vitiated the entire proceedings. The plans, documents, property record, all relied upon in the order, and in addition thereto, the requirement of the railways being considered, is not based on any documents filed during the proceedings and thus this inquiry process also gets vitiated as a result thereof. This causes serious prejudice to the rights of the parties. 24. Apparently, in the reply itself, the appellants have made out ground that the notice and the proceedings do not give particulars or details for them to reply properly. I believe it should have been considered by the learned Estate Officer and considered these aspects accordingly. Thus, in my view, the learned Estate Officer has not followed the process pre-issuance of notice, has not stated grounds and description of property -- 13 of 16 -- 14 Judg. Misc. Appeal 15/2024 in the notice, has considered extraneous evidence while passing the order and thus entire process of proceedings and inquiry proceedings before the learned Estate Officer stands vitiated. Hence, I answer point no.1 accordingly. AS TO POINT NO.2 : 25. Having considered point no.1, that the proceedings are vitiated, it would certainly be improper for this court to the consider grounds on merits. Apparently, there are two grounds raised – one is of adverse possession and second is of promise made of alternate accommodation. As regards adverse possession, I consider it to be a weak ground which may not really survive the test of trial or inquiry but subject to the evidence that could be lead in that regard. As regards the so called promise made by the government, allegedly, through its minister, same could require consideration in that regard. In such circumstances, the inquiry would be required to be held with regard to the nature of defence made and having given no opportunity again, this proceeding fails. Thus I refrain myself from answering this issue and considering the same I hold it as does not survive. AS TO POINT NO.3 :- 26. The learned Estate Officer has failed to follow the procedure pre-section 4 notice, failed to issue proper notices, failed to follow procedure of inquiry and breached the principles of natural justice which has vitiated the entire proceedings and thus the impugned order requires interference and hence, I pass the following order :- -- 14 of 16 -- 15 Judg. Misc. Appeal 15/2024 ORDER 1. Miscellaneous Appeal is partly allowed. 2. The order passed by the learned Estate Officer is hereby set aside. The matter is remitted back to the learned Estate Officer to proceed from the facts, stage of collection of information. 3. Fresh Notices would require to be issued U/s.4 of the Public Premises (Eviction of Unauthorized Occupants) Act. 4. The learned Estate Officer is requested to complete the proceedings within nine months of receipt of the order. 5. The parties to co-operate for early disposal of the cases before the Learned Estate Officer. 6. All the pending interim application/s, if any, is/are disposed off. 7. All the rights and contentions of the parties are kept open. 8. Record and Proceedings be sent back to the Respondents. 9. Appeal is disposed off accordingly. DATE : 10.05.2024 (A.SUBRAMANIAM) PRINCIPAL JUDGE CITY CIVIL COURT, MUMBAI. (JO CODE MH01711). Dictated & Transcribed on : 10/05/2024 Signed on : 22/05/2024 -- 15 of 16 -- 16 Judg. Misc. Appeal 15/2024 CERTIFIED TO BE TRUE AND CORRECT COPY OF THE ORIGINAL SIGNED JUDGMENT/ORDER Name of Stenographer : Mrs. Varsha D. Chowdhri Name of the Judge HHPJ Shri Anil Subramaniam (C.R.No.19) Date of Pronouncement of Order 10th May, 2024 Order signed by P.O. on 22nd May, 2024 Order uploaded on 22nd May, 2024 -- 16 of 16 --
