Full Order Text
Final Order 1 · 03 Apr 2024 · CNR MHCC010020492024
Order Details: Other Pdf Text: ... 1 ... MHCC010020492024 Presented on : 05.02.2024 Registered on : 21.02.2024 Decided on : 03.04.2024 Duration : 00 01 27 Years Months Days IN THE COURT OF CITY CIVIL FOR GREATER BOMBAY AT BOMBAY MISCELLANEOUS APPLICATION (DELAY) NO. 42 OF 2024 IN MISCELLANEOUS APPEAL (ST) NO. 1570 OF 2024 Pravina Jayesh Kamdar of Bombay Indian Inhabitant, Age : 64 years, Occ. House Wife, residing at Room No.5, Chawl No.3, Shivkripa Welfare Association, Behind ONGC Colony, Vidyavihar (East), Mumbai – 400 077. …. Applicant Versus 1. V. P. Paithankar, The Learned Estate Officer and Senior Divisional Engineer, Central Railway, Appointed under Section 3 of Public Premises (Eviction of Unauthorised Occupants) Act, 1971 and having his Office at Annex Building, 3rd Floor, Mumbai, CSMT - 400 001. 2. The Union of India, Through Divisional Engineer (LM), Central Railway Administration. 3. The General Manager, Central Railway having his Office at Annex Building, Mumbai, Fort, CSMT - 400 001. …. Respondents -- 1 of 5 -- ... 2 ... CORAM : HIS HONOUR THE PRINCIPAL JUDGE, SHRI. A. SUBRAMANIAM C.R.NO.. : 19 DATE : 03rd DAY OF APRIL, 2024 Appearances :- Adv. Sanket Mungale a/w Adv. Rashmi Joshi, Adv. Jay Joshi and Adv. Manan Shah i/b I. R. Joshi & Co. for applicant. Adv. L. K. Tripathi, for respondents. ORAL ORDER 1. By the present application, the applicant/appellant is praying for condonation of delay in appeal against the impugned order passed by the Ld. Estate Officer under provisions of the Public Premises Act. 2. It is the case of the applicant that the order was served on 29.12.2023 and it was nearly cyclostyle order. It is further contended that no proper show cause notice was issued and other compliances were absent. The legal advice given was to prefer one appeal by invoking provisions of Order-I Rule-8 of CPC and accordingly appeal was preferred of one Padma Joshi. The application under Order-I, Rule-8 was not allowed by the Court with a view that separate appeals are required to be filed and hence it took further time to prefer separate appeals and hence there is delay of 26 days. The delay is because of above genuine legal advice and further legal action. The applicants were diligent in prosecuting the appeals and hence delay be condoned. 3. The said application is opposed by the railways denying that any reasons is made out. The provisions of Public Premises Act are not applicable with regard to extension of limitation. In such circumstances, applications are not maintainable the reasons -- 2 of 5 -- ... 3 ... assigned is not valid and there is negligence and also no proper prosecution of the appeal, hence appeal be dismissed and by rejecting the application. 4. Heard both the sides who reiterated the contentions stated above. 5. As regards the application under Order-I, Rule-8 of CPC and orders passed therein are part of record. It is further part of record that as a result thereof set of 54 appeals/applications are filed. I find that the appeals were genuinely prosecuting the case so much so that the appeals are affirmed immediately between 15th to 20th January, 2024 except a couple of matters. It is really surprising that in such matter involving the roof over head of around 60 tenaments, the appeals came to be filed between 03rd to 06th of February, 2024. Thus the delay does not appear to be on part of the appellants who have done everything in their capacity to prefer the appeal. In such circumstances the reasons assigned constitute special grounds and compelling grounds as contemplated in proviso to Section-9 of the Public Premises Act. In such circumstances the other aspect is that the period of appeal starts from publication of order and publication is by affixing it on the premises as contemplated u/s.5 of the Public Premises Act. Same is not said to be complied. In such circumstances the application is required to be allowed. As all the set of applications involve common issues and similar period of delay, they are disposed off by this common order. Copy of the order be kept separately in all applications. Hence I pass the following orders :- O R D E R 1. Misc. Application is allowed. 2. The appeal be registered as per rules. -- 3 of 5 -- ... 4 ... 3. Appeals be placed on 15.04.2024. 4. Earlier order, if any, to continue till that date. DATE : 03.04.2024. (A.SUBRAMANIAM) PRINCIPAL JUDGE CITY CIVIL COURT, MUMBAI. (JO CODE MH01711). Dictated on : 03.04.2024. Signed on : 30.04.2024. -- 4 of 5 -- ... 5 ... “CERTIFIED TO BE TRUE AND CORRECT COPY OF THE ORIGINAL SIGNED JUDGEMENT/ORDER” UPLOAD DATE TIME NAME OF STENOGRAPHER 30/04/2024 5:30 p.m. B.R.HATEKAR (S.G.) Name of the Judge HH THE PRINCIPAL JUDGE SHRI A.SUBRAMANIAM (CR No.19) Date of Pronouncement of Judgment/Order. 03.04.2024 Judgment/order signed by P.O on 30.04.2024 Judgment/order uploaded on 30.04.2024 -- 5 of 5 --
