Full Order Text
Final Order 1 · 01 Aug 2019 · CNR MHCC010018492018
Order Details: Other Pdf Text: Noting : 01/08/2019 1 C. R. No. 01 01/08/2019 SU-1458/17 CORAM : H.H.J.SHRI M. S. AZMI (C. R. NO. 01) Adv. Kanojia for plaintiff present. Adv. Hussain h/f Adv. Vahid for defendants present. The Ld. counsel for the defendants, on instructions, made the statement that the defendants, after re-development, on getting the possession of the premises will not create third party interest or part with possession in any manner whatsoever pending the disposal of the suit. In view of the candid statement made by the Ld. Counsel for the defendants the Notice of Motion 2767/17 needs no consideration hence it is disposed of accordingly. The Ld. counsel for the defendants submitted that they have not committed the breach of the order of this court and have not created third party interest in the suit premises and have not parted with the possession to the third party. The possession was handed over for the development of the building and after the redevelopment the defendants would get the vacate possession of the flat as per the development agreement. Plaintiff on the instructions submitted that the plaintiff is interested in prosecuting the suit on merits and at this stage does not wish to press the NM for contempt without prejudice to his right. In view of the same the NM No. 463/18 is disposed of. The Ld. counsel for both the parties to note the order. Matter is adjourned for framing of issues to 24.9.2019. Judge *************************** 01/08/2019 CORAM : H.H.J.SHRI M. S. AZMI (C. R. NO. 01) -- 1 of 13 -- Noting : 01/08/2019 2 C. R. No. 01 SU-7034/02 Exh. 33 Exh. 34 Adv. Saurabh Dhuri for plaintiff present. Adv. Ashok Dhanuka for defendant no. 2 present. Affidavit of evidence of DW-2 Deepak Eknath Dhawan. Compilation of documents filed on behalf of defendant no. 2. Adjourned for admissibility of documents to 5.9.2019. Judge 01/08/2019 SU-7243/04 CORAM : H.H.J.SHRI M. S. AZMI (C. R. NO. 01) Adv. Kothari for plaintiff present. Adv. G. R. Mishra for defendant present. The Ld. counsel for the plaintiff submitted that plaintiff has not filed account statement and same will not be filed. Matter is adjourned for cross examination of PW-1 to 13.9.2019. Judge 01/08/2019 SU-1074/15 CORAM : H.H.J.SHRI M. S. AZMI (C. R. NO. 01) Adv. Shweta Satardekar for plaintiff present. Adv. Jadhav for defendant present. Adjourned for framing issues to 9.10.2019. Judge 01/08/2019 SU-1763/15 CORAM : H.H.J.SHRI M. S. AZMI (C. R. NO. 01) None present. Adjourned for framing issues to 10.10.2019. Judge 01/08/2019 SU-848/16 CORAM : H.H.J.SHRI M. S. AZMI (C. R. NO. 01) Adv. Varkhat for plaintiff present. Adv. Suraj Gupte for defendant present. Adjourned for framing issues to 11.10.2019. Judge 01/08/2019 SU-7808/85 Exh. 46 CORAM : H.H.J.SHRI M. S. AZMI (C. R. NO. 01) Adv. Preeti Shah for plaintiff present. Adv. Memon for defendant nos. 4(a) present. Adv. Shobhna Waghmare for defendant no. 2 present. Adjournment application filed by Ld. Advocate for plaintiff. O-The advocate for plaintiff submitted that she is suffering from leg injury. Considering the same, adjournment is granted. Adjourned for arguments to 19.8.2019. Judge 01/08/2019 CORAM : H.H.J.SHRI M. S. AZMI (C. R. NO. 01) -- 2 of 13 -- Noting : 01/08/2019 3 C. R. No. 01 EA-276/13 Adv. Lambade for JD present. The Ld. counsel for the JD submitted that the matter is likely to be settled. Talks are going on. Adjourned for settlement to 19.9.2019. Judge *********************************** -- 3 of 13 -- Noting : 01/08/2019 4 C. R. No. 01 01/08/2019 SU-948/13 Exh. 20 Exh. 21 CORAM : H.H.J.SHRI M. S. AZMI (C. R. NO. 01) Adv. Anita Wakchoure for plaintiff present. Adv. Jyoti Pande for defendant present. Further cross of PW-1 completed. List of document filed by the defendant. Adjourned for further evidence of plaintiff to 16.9.2019. LO at 1.55 pm. Application filed on behalf of plaintiff for issuance of witness summons. O-Read application. Heard. Issue witness summons to Mr. Surykant Dinkar Nalawade on payment of process fees Adjourned for further evidence of plaintiff to 16.9.2019. Judge 01/08/2019 SU-934/14 CORAM : H.H.J.SHRI M. S. AZMI (C. R. NO. 01) Adv. Pereira for plaintiff present. Defendant no. 2 present. Last chance is granted to the defendants for hearing on NM. Adjourned for NM hearing to 26.9.2019. Judge 01/08/2019 SU-1158/14 CORAM : H.H.J.SHRI M. S. AZMI (C. R. NO. 01) Adv. Sandhya for plaintiff present. Adv. Kachare for defendants present. Court is busy in other matters and even otherwise the counsel for the plaintiff sought adjournment as senior counsel is unwell. Matter is adjourned for NM hearing to 27.9.2019 Judge 01/08/2019 SU-588/19 CORAM : H.H.J.SHRI M. S. AZMI (C. R. NO. 01) Adv. Sawant for plaintiff present. Adv. Zubin Dalal and Adv. Vipul Bilve for defendant present. Court is busy in final hearing in SU-9650/90 and recording evidence in time bound matter. Adjourned for NM hearing to 28.8.2019. Judge 01/08/2019 SU-4541/11 CORAM : H.H.J.SHRI M. S. AZMI (C. R. NO. 01) Adv. Shah for plaintiff present. None present for defendant. NM is tendered by defendant. Put NM for dismissal order. Adjourned for dismissal of NM to 27.9.2019. Judge -- 4 of 13 -- Noting : 01/08/2019 5 C. R. No. 01 01/08/2019 SU-2789/15 CORAM : H.H.J.SHRI M. S. AZMI (C. R. NO. 01) Adv. Shah for plaintiff present. None present for defendant. NM is tendered by defendant. Put NM for dismissal order. Adjourned for dismissal of NM to 27.9.2019. Judge 01/08/2019 SU-3335/11 CORAM : H.H.J.SHRI M. S. AZMI (C. R. NO. 01) Adv.Sailee Gharpure for plaintiff present. Adv. Sailee Apte for defendant no. 4 present. Adjourned for NM hearing to 24.9.2019. Judge 01/08/2019 SU-945/19 CORAM : H.H.J.SHRI M. S. AZMI (C. R. NO. 01) None present for plaintiff. Adjourned for affidavit of service of writ of summons to 4.10.2019. Judge 01/08/2019 SU-133/15 CORAM : H.H.J.SHRI M. S. AZMI (C. R. NO. 01) None present. Adjourned for framing issues to 11.10.2019. Judge 01/08/2019 SU-884/17 CORAM : H.H.J.SHRI M. S. AZMI (C. R. NO. 01) None present. Last chance is granted. Adjourned for affidavit of service to 9.10.2019. Judge 01/08/2019 SU-4536/09 Exh. 19 Exh. 20 Exh. 21 CORAM : H.H.J.SHRI M. S. AZMI (C. R. NO. 01) Adv. Tripathi for plaintiff present. Adv. Vaishnava for defendant no. 1 present. Further cross examination of PW-1 partly recorded. Document dated 29.10.2004. Letter dated 11.12.2008. Letter dated 11.12.2008. Adjourned for further cross examination of PW-1 to 20.8.2019. Judge 01/08/2019 SU-1236/14 CORAM : H.H.J.SHRI M. S. AZMI (C. R. NO. 01) Adv. Savithri for plaintiff present. Adv. Agarwal for defendant no. 2 present. Cross examination of PW-3 and PW-4 completed. Adjourned for recording evidence to 3.8.2019. Judge -- 5 of 13 -- Noting : 01/08/2019 6 C. R. No. 01 01/08/2019 SU-4512/11 CORAM : H.H.J.SHRI M. S. AZMI (C. R. NO. 01) Adv. Tiwari for plaintiff present. Adv. Sawant for defendant present. Adv. for plaintiff filed affidavit of service of reply to counter reply of applicants in NM 1288/19. Reply to the rejoinder filed by the plaintiff. TOR. The Ld. counsel for the original defendant wish to file counter reply to the affidavit filed by the plaintiff. Adjourned for reply to 1.10.2019. Judge 01/08/2019 St. no. 6102/09 Exh. 4 CORAM : H.H.J.SHRI M. S. AZMI (C. R. NO. 01) Adv. Mangesh Nalawade for plaintiff present. Adv. Punekar for defendant nos. 2 and 3 present. Vakalatnama filed on behalf of defendant nos. 2 and 3. Plaintiff filed registered NM No. 2487/19 TOR. Adjourned for reply to NM to 24.9.2019. Judge 01/08/2019 SU-7431/96 (Disp. Off) Exh. 28 CORAM : H.H.J.SHRI M. S. AZMI (C. R. NO. 01) Adv. Samdhani for plaintiff present. Adv. Verma for applicant in NM present. The applicant filed application for withdrawal of NM No. 3383/2018. The contention of the applicant is that the applicant has filed the suit for possession in Bombay City Civil Court Borivali Division and therefore does not wish to pursue the present Notice of Motion. The plaintiff has given no objection subject to cost. In view of the unconditional withdrawal by the applicant, it is expedient to pass following order. ORDER 1. Notice of Motion No. 3383/2018 is disposed of as withdrawn. 2. No order as to cost Judge 01/08/2019 SU-8801/95 CORAM : H.H.J.SHRI M. S. AZMI (C. R. NO. 01) By precepie Adv. Menezes for plaintiff present. Draft chamber summons tendered by the plaintiff. Leave is granted. Matter is already adjourned to 8.8.2019. Adjourned for affidavit of service of chamber summons and reply to Chamber summons to 8.8.2019. Judge -- 6 of 13 -- Noting : 01/08/2019 7 C. R. No. 01 01/08/2019 SU-1368/19 CORAM : H.H.J.SHRI M. S. AZMI (C. R. NO. 01) Plaintiff in person present. Adv. Chirag Gandhi for defendant present. Court is busy in final hearing in SU-9650/90 and recording evidence in time bound matter. Adjourned for hearing on Notice of Motions to 5.8.2019. Judge 01/08/2019 SU-2082/16 CORAM : H.H.J.SHRI M. S. AZMI (C. R. NO. 01) Matter is transferred from Court Room no. 9. None present. Adjourned for reply to chamber summons to 11.10.2019. Judge 01/08/2019 SU-336/19 CORAM : H.H.J.SHRI M. S. AZMI (C. R. NO. 01) By precepie . Adv. Shaliesh Dubey for deft. no.1 present. Reply to NM filed by defendant no. 1. TOR. Matter is already adjourned to 17.9.2019. Judge 01/08/2019 SU-7545/06 Exh. 11 Exh.12 Exh. 13 CORAM : H.H.J.SHRI M. S. AZMI (C. R. NO. 01) Adv. Rohit Mahadik for plaintiff present. Adv. Sanam Jain for defendant no. 1 present. The reply of the defendant no. 1 filed on previous date to the report of Court Receiver is marked as Exh. 11. Report from the Collector of Stamp, Mumbai received. It is marked as Exh. 12. KB LO Adv. Karandikar for plaintiff present. Adv. Sanam Jain for defendant no. 1 present. Adv. Rajesh Patil for defendant nos. 2 to 8 present. Plaintiff filed say to the Court receiver report No. 87/19. Adjourned for hearing on report of court receiver report no. 87/19 to 17.9.2019. Judge ********************************** -- 7 of 13 -- Noting : 01/08/2019 8 C. R. No. 01 01/08/2019 SU-1182/17 Exh. 6 Exh. 7 CORAM : H.H.J.SHRI M. S. AZMI (C. R. NO. 01) None present for plaintiff. Defendant no. 1 present. Vakalatnama of advocate Faria filed on behalf of defendant no. 1. O-Seen and filed. Application filed Read application. Heard. In the interest of justice the NM is kept for hearing. Adjourned for NM hearing to 19.9.2019. Judge 30/07/2019 SU-2912/15 CORAM : H.H.J.SHRI M. S. AZMI (C. R. NO. 01) By precepie. Adv. Raees for plaintiff present. Adv. for defendant no. 2 present. Adv. Navin Parekh, Adv. Niranjan Bhadang, Adv. Aditya Thakkar, Adv. M. S. Federal, Adv. Murtuza Federal, Adv. Pauloni Mehta, Adv. Madhavi Doshi and Adv. Dinkar Desai for defendant no. 1 present. Adv. Chandana Salgaonkar for deft. no. 2 present. Plaintiff tendered registered NM 2622/2019. Additional affidavit filed by the plaintiff. Heard Ld. Advocate for plaintiff and defendant no. 1 on adinterim order. Adjourned for adinterim order to 31.7.2019. Judge 01/08/2019 Commercial Suit No. 27/19 CORAM : H.H.J.SHRI M. S. AZMI (C. R. NO. 01) Adv. Reis for plaintiff present. Court is busy in final hearing in SU-9650/90 and recording evidence in time bound matter. Adjourned for order on NM to 3.8.2019. Judge 01/08/2019 SU-9650/90 Argument CORAM : H.H.J.SHRI M. S. AZMI (C. R. NO. 01) Adv. Agarwal for plaintiff present. Adv. Chitnis for deft. no. 6 present. Heard further argument of Ld. Advocate for defendant no. 6 partly. Adjourned for further argument to 8.8.2019. Judge 01/08/2019 EA 280/19 CORAM : H.H.J.SHRI M. S. AZMI (C. R. NO. 01) Adv. Agarwal for DH present. Court is busy in final hearing in SU-9650/90 and recording evidence in time bound matter. Adjourned for hearing on maintainability of the Execution Application to 8.8.2019. Judge -- 8 of 13 -- Noting : 01/08/2019 9 C. R. No. 01 01/08/2019 M. A. 22/19 Hearing CORAM : H.H.J.SHRI M. S. AZMI (C. R. NO. 01) Adv. Agarwal for applicant present. Court is busy in final hearing in SU-9650/90 and recording evidence in time bound matter. Adjourned for hearing to 8.8.2019. Judge 01/08/2019 M. A. 23/19 Hearing CORAM : H.H.J.SHRI M. S. AZMI (C. R. NO. 01) Adv. Agarwal for applicant present. Court is busy in final hearing in SU-9650/90 and recording evidence in time bound matter. Adjourned for hearing to 8.8.2019. Judge 01/08/2019 EA-52/18 CORAM : H.H.J.SHRI M. S. AZMI (C. R. NO. 01) None present. Adjourned for hearing on maintainability of execution application to 8.8.2019. Judge 01/08/2019 EA-763/13 CORAM : H.H.J.SHRI M. S. AZMI (C. R. NO. 01) Adv. Mehul Shah for Decree Holder present. FRSR following order is passed on Chamber Summons NO. 1299/2019. 1. Chamber Summons No.1299/2019 is allowed in terms of prayer clause (a). 2. The Decree Holder to deposit necessary charges with the department for taking the bailiff and for the police protection. 3. Bailiff to follow the procedure at the time of handing over the possession. 4. Chamber Summons is disposed of accordingly. ____________________________________________ Adjourned for compliance to 17.9.2019. Judge *********************************** -- 9 of 13 -- Noting : 01/08/2019 10 C. R. No. 01 01/08/2019 SU-2068/19 CORAM : H.H.J.SHRI M. S. AZMI (C. R. NO. 01) Matter is pertaining to C. R. No. 4 Adv. Asad Bukhari I/b Adv. Viral Bhatia for plaintiff present. Court is busy in final hearing In SU-9650/90 and recording evidence in time bound matter. Adjourned for order on ad-interim to 2.8.2019. Judge 01/08/2019 SU-2069/19 CORAM : H.H.J.SHRI M. S. AZMI (C. R. NO. 01) Matter is pertaining to C. R. No. 4 Adv. Asad Bukhari I/b Adv. Viral Bhatia for plaintiff present. Court is busy in final hearing In SU-9650/90 and recording evidence in time bound matter. Adjourned for order on ad-interim to 2.8.2019. Judge 01/08/2019 SU-2070/19 CORAM : H.H.J.SHRI M. S. AZMI (C. R. NO. 01) Matter is pertaining to C. R. No. 4 Adv. Asad Bukhari I/b Adv. Viral Bhatia for plaintiff present. Court is busy in final hearing In SU-9650/90 and recording evidence in time bound matter. Adjourned for order on ad-interim to 2.8.2019. Judge 01/08/2019 SU-2071/19 CORAM : H.H.J.SHRI M. S. AZMI (C. R. NO. 01) Matter is pertaining to C. R. No. 4 Adv. Asad Bukhari I/b Adv. Viral Bhatia for plaintiff present. Court is busy in final hearing In SU-9650/90 and recording evidence in time bound matter. Adjourned for order on ad-interim to 2.8.2019. Judge 01/08/2019 SU-2072/19 CORAM : H.H.J.SHRI M. S. AZMI (C. R. NO. 01) Matter is pertaining to C. R. No. 4 Adv. Asad Bukhari I/b Adv. Viral Bhatia for plaintiff present. Court is busy in final hearing In SU-9650/90 and recording evidence in time bound matter. Adjourned for order on ad-interim to 2.8.2019. Judge 01/08/2019 SU-2073/19 CORAM : H.H.J.SHRI M. S. AZMI (C. R. NO. 01) Matter is pertaining to C. R. No. 4 Adv. Asad Bukhari I/b Adv. Viral Bhatia for plaintiff present. Court is busy in final hearing In SU-9650/90 and recording evidence in time bound matter. Adjourned for order on ad-interim to 2.8.2019. ***** *** Judge 01/08/2019 SU-581/19 CORAM : H.H.J.SHRI M. S. AZMI (C. R. NO. 01) None present. Court is busy in other matters. Adjourned for order to 2.8.2019. -- 10 of 13 -- Noting : 01/08/2019 11 C. R. No. 01 Judge 01/08/2019 SU-453/18 CORAM : H.H.J.SHRI M. S. AZMI (C. R. NO. 01) Adv. Jain for plaintiffs present. None present for defendants. The ld. counsel for the plaintiffs filed two case laws and advanced argument. None present on behalf of defendants. Matter is adjourned for submission on behalf of defendants on case laws and order on NM No. 1035/18 and reply to NM filed by the defendant to 8.8.2019 LO Advocate Sakina for defendant no. 2 present. Def. no. 2 tendered registered NM no. 2796/19 Adjourned for submission on behalf of defendants on case laws and order on NM No. 1035/18 and reply on NM no. 2796/19 to 8.8.2019. Judge 01/08/2019 SU-3004/18 Exh. 5 CORAM : H.H.J.SHRI M. S. AZMI (C. R. NO. 01) Adv. Chougule for plaintiff present. Adv. Ankur Sheth for defendant no. 4 present. Adv. Choudhari for defendant nos. 2 and 3 present. The Ld. Counsel for the defendant The defendant no. 4 tendered written Statement cum reply to NM. O- R and R. The Ld. counsel for the deft. nos. 2 and 3 submitted that defendant nos. 2 and 3 are not served with the writ of summons and would file the written statement. Earlier order if any to continue till next date. Adjourned for NM hearing to 1.10.2019. LO Adv. S. K. Electriwala for defendant no. 1 present. Judge *************************** 01/08/2019 SU-8249/84 Admissibility Exh. 45 CORAM : H.H.J.SHRI M. S. AZMI (C. R. NO. 01) Adv. Vasudeo for plaintiff present. Adv. Niranjan Parekh for defendant nos. 7 and 9 to 18 present Advocate for plaintiff filed application for production of -- 11 of 13 -- Noting : 01/08/2019 12 C. R. No. 01 Exh. 46 Exh. 47 Exh. 48 Exh. 49 Exh. 50 Exh. 51 Exh. 52 Exh. 53 Exh. 54 Exh. 55 Exh. 56 Exh. 57 Exh. 58 Exh. 59 Exh. 60 Exh. 61 medical certificate. O- Production is allowed. Heard. The document at sr. no .1 is admitted document and therefore it is marked as Exhibit. The document at sr. no. 2, 4, 6, 7, 9, 10, 16 and 29 are the typed copy of the letter issued by the advocate for the plaintiff. The plaintiff has filed the additional evidence to the effect that the original is with the advocate for defendant and he has given notice to the said advocate for production of the same. The evidence is given that the letters at above serial number were issued on the instruction of the PW-1. In this circumstances these letters are marked as exhibits accordingly. The document at sr. nos. 3, 5 and 8 are original, the document at sr. no. 11 is endorsed copy of the letter, the document at serial no. 12 is original, the document at serial number 13 is endorsed copy, the document at serial nos. 14 and 15 are original letters and therefore they are marked as exhibits accordingly. The document at sr. no. 7, 17 to 28 and 30 to 37 were already marked as exhibit in NM 945/91 and accordingly they are referred by the same exhibit. The NM in which the compilation of the document of NM vide Exh. 5 be attched with this compilation. The document at sr. no. 38 and 39 are admitted and therefore marked as exhibit 62 and 63. Certificate issued by Registrar of Firms for the plaintiffs. Copy of letter addressed by plaintiffs advocate to Dhruve Liladhar and co. Letter addressed plaintiffs advocate to Dhruve Liladhar and co. Letter addressed plaintiffs advocate to Dhruve Liladhar and Co. Office copy of the letter addressed plaintiffs advocate to Dhruve Liladhar and co. Copy of letter addressed by plaintiffs advocate to Dhruve Liladhar and co. Office copy of letter addressed plaintiffs advocate to Dhruve Liladhar and co. Office copy of the letter addressed by plaintiffs advocate to Dhruve Liladhar and co. Original letter addressed by Dhruve Liladhar and co., to M/ s Mahimtura and co. Original letter addredssed by Dhruve Liladhar and col, to M/s Mahimtura and co. Original letter addressed by Dhruve Liladhar and co., to M/ s Mahimtura and co. Endorsed copy of the letter addressed by plaintiffs advocate to plaintiffs and original addressed to Dhruve Liladhar and co. Original letter addressed by Dhruve Liladhar and co., to M/ s Mahmtura and co. Office copy of letter addressed by plaintiffs advocate to Dhruve Liladhar and co. and duly akcnowledged. Original letter addressed by Dhruve Liladhar and col, to M/ s Mahmtura and col. Original letter of cancellation by Dhruve Liladhar and col, to M/s Mahimtura and col, -- 12 of 13 -- Noting : 01/08/2019 13 C. R. No. 01 Exh. 62 Exh. 63 Exh. 64 Copy of order passed by His Lordship Justice R. G. Ketkar in first appeal. Copy of order passed by Hon'ble Supreme Court in SLP No. 2884/16. Copy of the letter addressed pliantiffs advocate to Dhruve Liladhar and co. Adjourned for cross examination of PW-1 to 20.8.2019. Judge 01/08/2019 SC-45/14 @ 162/14 Exh. 83 CORAM : H.H.J.SHRI M. S. AZMI (C. R. NO. 01) APP Arote for State absent. Accused nos. 1, 2 and 6 on bail absent. Accused no. 3 already discharged Accused nos. 4, 5, 7, 8, 9, 10 and 11 on bail present. Adv. Nawale for accused no. 11 present. Adv. Joseph for accused no. 7 present. PI Thorat present. PSI Sawant and PSI Borade attached to Sewree Police Station present. The co-accused informed that accused no. 6 had expired. The officer present is directed to submit the report and copy of the death certificate, if any, of the accused no. 6. Exemption application filed by Adv. Bhumkar on behalf of accused no. 2. O-Granted for today. Adjourned for hearing on discharge applications to 31.8.2019. Judge 01/08/2019 SU-5873/06 CORAM : H.H.J.SHRI M. S. AZMI (C. R. NO. 01) None present. Court is busy in other matters. Adjourned for order on Exh. 12 to 8.8.2019. Judge Completed. -- 13 of 13 --
