Full Order Text
Final Order 1 · 18 Sept 2023 · CNR MHCC010014692023
Order Details: Copy of Judgment Pdf Text: MHCC010014692023 Received on :: 06.02.2023 Registered on :: 07.02.2023 Decided on :: 18.09.2023 Duration :: Y-00:M-07:D-12: Exhibit :: IN THE COURT OF CITY CIVIL FOR GREATER BOMBAY AT BOMBAY MISC. APPEAL NO.06 OF 2023 Shri Raju Laxman Bali Age : 54 years, Occ.: Service, R/at : Government Quarter No. FQ 09, Gat No.2, Aarey Dairy Quarters, Goregaon(East), Mumbai-65 ... Appellant Versus 1. The competent Authority, Brihanmumbai, having its office at 404, 4th Floor, New D.D. Building, Old Custom House, S.B.S. Road, Fort, Mumbai-1 2. Chief Executive Officer, Aarey Dairy Goregaon(East) Mumbai-65. ... Respondents CORAM : H.H.THE PRINCIPAL JUDGE SHRI. A.SUBRAMANIAM(C.R.No.19) DATED : 18th SEPTEMBER, 2023 Ld.Adv. Ashish Gaikwad a/w Adv.Anjali Kolapkar for appellant. Ld.Adv. M.B. Jadhav for respondents. ORAL JUDGMENT 1. By the present appeal, the appellant is challenging the order passed by the learned Competent Authority dated 12.01.2023 in Eviction Proceedings No.25948 of 2022 . The appeal is said to be preferred against the same before the Principal Secretary and accordingly it is said to be disposed off by order dated 16.12.2022. -- 1 of 7 -- :Page 2 of 7: JUDGMENT IN MISC.APPEAL.6/2023 2. It is the case of the Government that one Laxman Savla Bali was working in Fire Brigade Department and was allotted quarter namely Gat No.2, FQ Room No.09, Aarey Dairy Quarters, Goregaon(E), Mmbai. He retired and he applied for compassionate appointment of his son namely Raju Laxman Bali present appellant on 03.09.1997. ULP came to be preferred bearing No.171 of 1998 and the learned Industrial Court held that till the son is given appointment on the compassionate ground, the quarter should not be vacated. The said Laxman Bali kept the premises from 28.07.1997 and accordingly proceedings came to be initiated and directions were issued for recovery of Rs.46,580/- and accordingly a sum of Rs.3,500/- p.m. is being deducted from pension from May 2022 for a period of 14 months thereof. There is contention that Raju Laxman Bali is staying in the allotted premises on his father and is not paying charges and other dues. The quarter bearing No.FQ Room no.9 is allotted to Raju Laxman Bali from the date of his appointment retrospectively, but he has not accepted the same. He has placed a board that the quarter is sealed and is preferring different applications and RTI applications and is trying to mislead other government employees and is also trying to malin the name of the government and officers. There is no recovery of the house rent, service charges and hence it is necessary that the premises be vacated and accordingly arrears also be recovered. 3. The said notice was served. Accordingly notice is seen to be issued on 13.12.2022 and accordingly he had preferred appeal before the Principal Secretary. The Principal Secretary rejected the contention by order dated 16.12.2022. Thereafter, the -- 2 of 7 -- :Page 3 of 7: JUDGMENT IN MISC.APPEAL.6/2023 impugned order has been passed on 12.01.2023. Hence present appeal. 4. Heard learned Counsel for the appellant. He submitted that there were proposals forwarded for compassionate appointment and ULP proceedings were preferred under which the occupation was protected. He further submitted that the order was challenged before the Hon’ble High Court and Writ Petition was withdrawn on 21.01.2013. The appointment was made belatedly on 07.02.2013. Because of such delay, the appellant should not suffer, the occupation is protected as per the notice. There is allotment of the quarters. No inquiry is held. Earlier proceedings not considered. Hence, appeal be allowed. 5. Heard government pleader. He vehemently submitted that the order is against the appellant. Notice has been issued. No reply filed, charges are not paid. He is defaulter and occupying the premises without any right. 6. Heard both the sides. Perused the impugned order, appeal memo, record and proceedings and considered the submissions, following points arise for my consideration and I answer the same as under for the reasons stated hereinafter; Sr. Nos POINTS FINDINGS 1 Whether the proper procedure has been followed? :: In the negative 2 Whether the appellant can be said to be unauthorized occupant? :: Does not arise 3 Whether the appellant is entitled for damages? :: Does not arise 4 Whether the impugned order requires interference? :: In the Affirmative 5 What order? :: As per final order -- 3 of 7 -- :Page 4 of 7: JUDGMENT IN MISC.APPEAL.6/2023 REASONS As to point No.1: 7. The record and proceedings filed shows that the proposal for eviction was submitted on 03.10.2022. Show cause was issued on 31.10.2022. Reply has been given claiming the compliance of various documents required to file as reply to show cause. The copies are seen to be supplied. Apparently, on perusal of the entire proceedings, there is no hearing taken place and only exchange of pleadings has taken place. I believe the provisions of the Bombay Public Premises Eviction Act contemplates a personal hearing with right to defence. 8. In the present case prima facie the proposal for eviction contemplates (a) that the possession of the quarter was with one Laxman Savala Bali and the said possession of quarter was protected by the order of the Hon’ble Industrial Court and even the PP Act proceedings were rejected with only damages being awarded. The period of damages is till February 2013. The present applicant is said to be appointed thereon namely on 12.02.2013. The proposal for the eviction also shows that the same quarter has been allotted to concern Raju Laxman Bali appellant with retrospective effect from the date of his appointment in service. The documents filed with the present proceedings show that the concerned authority prayed for deduction of the charges of the salary and same has not been granted by the learned Competent Authority. All these circumstances clearly show that arguable case or defence has been made out. The allegations of willful default in payment has to be considered by the concerned learned Competent Authority. I believe there is total lack of application of mind by the learned -- 4 of 7 -- :Page 5 of 7: JUDGMENT IN MISC.APPEAL.6/2023 Competent Authority. The learned Competent Authority has incorrectly considered the proceedings No.25256 which relates to late Laxman that has no concern in the present proceedings. It is alleged that the amount of rent, service charges, water and electricity charges are not paid. The specific demand has to be shown. So called amount alleged is said to be deposited with the government/department pending the appeal. All these aspects will have to be gone by the concerned authority as to whether there is specific denial to pay the amount or whether there is mistake in the process of deduction of use, if any. The appellant will deposit the balance service charges, electricity charges and occupation charges be deposited as per demand. It shall be condition precedent for the appellant to deposit all arrears before the Competent Authority as condition precedent for hearing his defence. 9. In view of above, it is seen that no proper points have been considered and there is no proper consideration with regard to the rights as well as no proper hearing is seen to be given by the learned Competent Authority as contemplated by law. In such circumstances, I am inclined to remand the matter for fresh hearing. Hence, I answer point no.1 in negative. As to Point Nos.2 & 3: 10. Considering the above grounds, same does not arise and the learned Competent Authority to decide the same accordingly. Hence, I answer these points accordingly. As to Point no.4: 11. As the learned Competent Authority has not followed due procedure and also not considered the relevant issues involved in -- 5 of 7 -- :Page 6 of 7: JUDGMENT IN MISC.APPEAL.6/2023 the present proceedings, the present appeal is required to be allowed. Hence, I pass the following order. O R D E R 1. Misc.Appeal No.6 of 2023 is partly allowed. 2. The order passed by the Competent Authority in Eviction Proceeding No.25948 of 2022 dated 12.01.2023 is hereby set aside and the matter is remanded back to the learned Competent Authority for fresh hearing. 3. The parties to appear before the learned Competent Authority on 16.10.2023 and the respondent to file detail reply to the allegations in notice on or before 31.10.2023. 4. The learned Competent Authority to permit personal hearing to both the sides. 5. The learned Competent Authority can consider the facts of the case on the basis of the documentary evidence filed on record, if any. 6. It is condition precedent that the appellant will pay all arrears including water charges, service charges and electricity charges as condition precedent for placing his defence and consideration of his defence. 7. The learned Competent Authority to decide the matter uninfluenced by the observations made hereinbefore as regards the matter arising. 8. R & P be sent back to the Respondents. 18/09/2023 (A.SUBRAMANIAM) PRINCIPAL JUDGE, CITY CIVIL COURT, MUMBAI. (JO CODE MH01711) Dictated on Transcribed on Signed by HHJ on :: :: :: 18/09/2023 18/09/2023 18/09/2023 -- 6 of 7 -- :Page 7 of 7: JUDGMENT IN MISC.APPEAL.6/2023 “CERTIFIED TO BE TRUE AND CORRECT COPY OF THE ORIGINAL SIGNED JUDGEMENT/ORDER” UPLOAD DATE TIME NAME OF STENOGRAPHER 20/09/2023 5.00p.m. B.R.HATEKAR (S.G.) Name of the Judge HH THE PRINCIPAL JUDGE SHRI A.SUBRAMANIAM (CR No.19) Date of Pronouncement of Judgment/Order. 18.09.2023 Judgment/order signed by P.O on 18.09.2023 Judgment/order uploaded on 20.09.2023 -- 7 of 7 --
