Full Order Text
Final Order 1 · 06 Dec 2024 · CNR MHCC010014562024
Order Details: Notice of Motion Pdf Text: 1 NM 531-24 in Suit No. 2816-23 MHCC010014562024 IN THE BOMBAY CITY CIVIL COURT AT MUMBAI NOTICE OF MOTION NO. 531 OF 2024 IN S. C. SUIT NO. 2816 OF 2023 Mr. Jiyaddin Siddiqui ] ….Applicant In the matter between Hariba Tamanna Waghmare ] ….Plaintiff V/s. Janabai Appasaheb Waghmare and Ors. ] ....Defendants. Appearances : Learned Adv. Upadhyay for the plaintiff. Learned Adv. Arvind Taral for defendant Nos. 1 and 2. Learned Adv. Rushikesh Munde a/w Adv. Tejas Bhattacharya for the defendant No.4/SRA. Learned Adv. Saurabh Chitnis for defendant No. 5 CORAM : HIS HONOUR JUDGE SHRI. V. S. KHOT (C.R.NO.09) DATE : 06th DECEMBER, 2024. ORAL ORDER 1. The applicant/defendant No.5 has taken this notice of motion for rejection of plaint under Order 7 Rule 11(d) of C.P.C., 1908 and for staying the suit till decision of the notice of motion. -- 1 of 7 -- 2 NM 531-24 in Suit No. 2816-23 2. The facts pleated by the applicant can be epitomized as under ; The applicant/defendant No.5 contended that the plaintiff has instituted this suit for declaration that the plaintiff is entitled for PAA and injunction restraining defendant Nos. 1 and 2 from creating third party interest. The plaintiff has claimed various reliefs which is barred under Section 42 of Maharashtra Slum Areas Act, 1971. The Grievance Redressal Committee, SRA, Appellate Authority and the Competent Authority are having jurisdiction to determine the reliefs sought by the plaintiff in the suit. The plaintiff has filed this suit for declaration that plaintiff is an owner of suit premises and entitled to PAA in lieu of suit premises in SRA scheme of defendant No.6. Competent Authority has declared defendant No.1 eligible for PAA in lieu of suit premises. The appeal was filed but Appellate Authority upheld the order of Competent Authority. If the reliefs are granted then it would be effect of usurping the jurisdiction of Grievance Redressal Committee. The suit is barred by under Section 42 of Slum Act. Competent Authority is solely entitled to determine the allotment of PAA in the implementation of SR Scheme, therefore, suit is clearly barred as violative to Section 42 by Slum Act, 1971. The suit cannot go further and liable to be dismissed under Order 7 Rule 11 (d) of C.P.C. The defendant No.5 prays for the relief. 3. The say of the other side came to be invited. The plaintiff replied to the notice of motion and contended that he is denying all the averments, contents and contentions made in the notice of motion and supporting affidavit. It is untrue that the Grievance Redressal Committee, SRA, Appellate Authority and Competent Authority are having sole jurisdiction to determine the reliefs sought by the plaintiff in -- 2 of 7 -- 3 NM 531-24 in Suit No. 2816-23 the present suit and therefore, it is barred under Section 42 of Slum Act, 1971. The relief of declaration can be granted by the Civil Court. The jurisdiction of Civil Court is not barred under Section 42 of Slum Act. The application for rejecting the plaint is liable to be dismissed. In several citations, the Hon’ble Bombay High Court opined that the litigant having the grievance of the civil nature has a right to institute the Civil suit in Competent Civil Court unless its cognizance is either expressly or impliedly barred by any Statute. If any private dispute arises between the parties in view of their joint possession or any dispute arises in view of joint occupation of plaintiff with his family and/or alone, Civil Court is only competent to decide the dispute because the SRA or the Competent Authority cannot adjudicate such dispute. The plaintiff is praying for rejection of the application. 4. In view of rival contentions of the suitor, following points arise for my determination and I have recorded my findings subject to the reasons as mentioned hereinafter ; Sr. No. POINTS FINDINGS 1. Whether the defendant No.5 proves that the suit is barred under Section 42 of SRA Act ? In the Negative. 2. Whether the plaint is liable to be rejected under Order 7 Rule 11 (d) of C.P.C. for lack of jurisdiction ? In the Negative. 3. What order? As per the final order R E A S O N S AS TO POINT NOs. 1 to 3 : 5. This notice of motion is filed by the defendant No.5 for -- 3 of 7 -- 4 NM 531-24 in Suit No. 2816-23 rejecting the plaint under Order 7 Rule 11 (d) of C.P.C. as being barred by Section 42 of Slum Act, 1971. It is the contention of the defendant No.5 that the suit cannot go further as prayers are barred under Section 42 of Slum Act. The prayers only can be entertained by the authority created under Slum Act. He prayed for the rejection of the plaint. The plaintiff on the contrary submitted that, suit can go further and needs to be adjudicated. The civil Court is having jurisdiction to decide the prayers made by the plaintiff. He prayed for the rejection of the notice of motion. Perused all the material. Heard both the counsels at length. Perusal of the case papers make it clear that this suit is filed for declaration and injunction. The suit is instituted against two private parties and MHADA. It is contention of the defendant No.5 that suit is barred under the provisions of Section 42 of Slum Act. The prayer clause made in the plaint is required to be seen. The prayer clause makes it clear that there are prayers vide prayer clause (a) to (h). Prayer clause (a) shows that the plaintiff is seeking the declaration that plaintiff is an absolute owner of suit premises. He is also seeking the declaration that the defendant Nos. 1 and 2 have no right, title in respect of suit premises. Likewise, he is also praying the remedy/relief in the form of injunction against defendant Nos. 1 and 2 from creating third party interest. These prayers are made with the prayer in respect of PAA. The perusal of the prayer clause (c) makes it clear that some of the prayers are hit by Section 42 of Slum Act, 1971. It is equally true that the prayer of declaration of ownership and title as well as injunction against creating third party interest only can be entertained by the Civil Court and not by the authorities created under the Slum Act, 1971. The suit is not completely hit by Section 42 of Slum Act. The declaration and injunction only can be granted by the Civil Court and not by any other authority. The rest of the suit may be problematic in -- 4 of 7 -- 5 NM 531-24 in Suit No. 2816-23 view of Section 42 of the Slum Act. It is the legal principle that plaint cannot be rejected partly. The plaint either can be rejected fully or nor at all. In this case, the suit cannot be partly rejected in view of above said legal provision/principle. In such circumstances, it appears that the plaint cannot be rejected. In view of above said observations, this aspect goes against notice of motion taken by the defendant No.5. 6. The prayer clause and contentions made in the plaint and submissions of the parties make it clear that the notice of motion is taken for rejecting the plaint but prayer clause makes it clear that some prayers only can be entertained by Civil Court. Therefore, the plaint cannot be rejected. The suit at the most can be said to be hit by Section 42 partly. But part rejection of plaint is impermissible, therefore, notice of motion is required to be turned down. During the course of arguments, the counsel for plaintiff relied upon the following citations : I. In case of Ashok B Nirgudkar Vs. Sudhadra P. Nirgudkar, in LAWS (BOM) 2013-4-112 dated 09.04.2013 ; II. In case of Abdul Sattar Haji Usman and Anr. Vs. The Archbishop Of Bombay And Ors., in LAWS (BOM) 2016-4-17 dated 12.04.2016 ; III. In case of Bansnarayan Sitaprasad Patel Vs. Sairam Co. Operative Housing, in LAWS (BOM) 2013-8-141 dated 26.08.2013 ; The following legal principles can be deduced from those citations : i) The prayer of declaration only can be entertained by the Civil Court. The basic claim has to be seen and if it is within the competence of Civil Court then the Civil Court has the jurisdiction. The litigation of civil nature has to be tried by the Civil Court unless cognizance is expressly or impliedly barred. -- 5 of 7 -- 6 NM 531-24 in Suit No. 2816-23 ii) The Court should try all the suits unless barred. iii) The main dispute between the parties is concerning the title of the suit property then Civil Court is certainly having the jurisdiction. iv) When the fraud against the State is pleaded, the suit is clearly maintainable on the basis of pleadings of the plaint. v) The Civil Court has jurisdiction to entertain and try the suit where private dispute arises between the parties in view of joint possession of a premises. The above mentioned legal principles can be deduced. 7. The facts and circumstances of this case and the facts and circumstances of the citations filed are different and those are not very beneficial. Those citations are the guiding stars but those are not directly having any influence over the suit in hand. In this case, the prayer cause (a) to (c) clearly shows that some prayers are ought to be tried/considered by the Civil Court. The plaint cannot be rejected partly. In such circumstances, notice of motion is having no fate. Hence, my answer to point Nos. 1 and 2 are in negative and for point no. 3, I am inclined to pass the following order resulting in dismissal of notice of motion. O R D E R 1. Notice of Motion No. 531 of 2024 in suit No. 2816 of 2023 stands dismissed and hereby disposed of accordingly. 2. No any order as to costs. Sd/- (V. S. KHOT) Judge, City Civil Court, Date: 06.12.2024 Gr. Bombay. Dictated on : 06.12.2024 Transcribed on : 09.12.2024 Signed on : 11.12.2024 -- 6 of 7 -- 7 NM 531-24 in Suit No. 2816-23 CERTIFIED TO BE TRUE AND CORRECT COPY OF THE ORIGINAL SIGNED JUDGMENT/ORDER.” 12.12.2024 At 12.25 P.M. Mrs. Poonam Y. Pawar UPLOAD DATE AND TIME NAME OF STENOGRAPHER Name of the Judge (With Court Room Number) HHJ SHRI. V. S. KHOT (C.R.NO.09) Date of pronouncement of Judgment/ Order 06.12.2024 Judgment/Order signed by P.O. on 11.12.2024 Judgment/Order uploaded on 12.12.2024 -- 7 of 7 --
