Final Order 1

Order Details: Copy of Judgment
Pdf Text: ,l-lh- nkok Øekad 447@2019 --1-- U;k;fu.kZ;] fnukad 31-07-2026
MHCC010014062019 nk[ky fnukad % 04-02-2019
uksan.kh fnukad % 20-02-2019
fudky fnukad % 31-07-2026
dkyko/kh % 07&o- 05&e- 27&fn-
uxj fnok.kh U;k;ky;] eqacbZ ;sFkhy U;k;ky; Øekad 09
¼ lqfuy ek- ikVhy] uxj fnok.kh U;k;k/kh’k ½
,l-lh-nkok Øekad 447@2019
¼U;k;fu.kZ;kpk fnukad % 31@07@2026½ fu’kk.kh & 59
csosU;w baÝk izkstsDVl~ izk;OksV fyfeVsM]
iRrk % 9 vWUM 10] vkfn gkÅl] iksrqZxht ppZ
fo:)] xks[kys jksM ¼mRrj½] nknj] eqacbZ& 400
028- -------- oknh
fo:)
1- x.kir ukjk;.k dne]
2- mes’k x.kir dne]
iRrk % :e uacj 304] frljk etyk] rqylh n’kZu
dks-vkW-gkS-lkslk;Vh fy- IykWV uacj 312@313]
lsDVj&6] ljlksGss xkao] us:G] uoh eqacbZ& 400
706-
3- egkjk”V x`gfuekZ.k o {ks=fodkl izkf/kdj.k]
iRrk % x`gfuekZ.k Hkou] okanzs ¼iwoZ½] eqacbZ& 400
051- ---- izfroknh
odhy Jh- tks,y fMlqtk lg odhy Jh- vk;Ogj fMlqtk] odhy ih-
QukaZMst o odhy Jherh :ikyh flax] oknhdjhrk
odhy Jh- jktho eVdj] izfroknh Øekad 1 o 2 djhrk
odhy Jh- ds-,u-dkansdj] izfroknh Øekad 3@EgkMk djhrk
-- 1 of 26 --
,l-lh- nkok Øekad 447@2019 --2-- U;k;fu.kZ;] fnukad 31-07-2026
U;k;fu.kZ;
¼ fnukad 31-07-2026 jksth ikjhr ½
fnukad 26-10-2047 jksthP;k djkjkrhy vV Øekad 12 ps
mYya?ku >kY;kus rks djkj jn~n >kY;kps gDdKkiu dj.;kr ;kos rlsp
izfroknh Øekad 3 ;kauh ik= HkkMsd:aP;k ;knhrwu izfroknh Øekad 1 o
2 ;kaps uko deh djkos v'kk vkKkFkhZ eukbZlkBh izLrqrpk nkok nk[ky
dj.;kr vkyk vkgs-
2- oknh daiuhps dFku FkksMD;kr [kkyhyizek.ks %&
oknh daiuh gh fofo/k feGdrh fodflr dj.;kpk O;olk; djhr
vkgs- izHkknsoh] eqacbZ ;sFkhy okdMh pkG] i=k'ksM ;sFkhy rGetY;kojhy
[kksyh Øekad lh&21 {ks= 7-37 pkSjl ehVj ;k feGdrhps izfroknh
Øekad 1 o 2 gs HkkMsd: vlwu MsOgyiesaV daVªksy :Yl] 1991 P;k
dye 33 ¼7½ uqlkj lnj feGdr oknh daiuhus iqufoZdklkdjhrk ?ksryh
vlwu izfroknh Øekad 3 EgkMkdMhy ik= HkkMsd:aP;k ;knhe/;s izfroknh
Øekad 1 o 2 ;kaps uko uewn ulY;kus dk;eLo:ih i;kZ;h fuoklO;oLFkk
feG.;kl izfroknh Øekad 1 o 2 gs ik= uOgrs- ijarq] izfroknhauh dsysY;k
fouarhuqlkj rlsp izfroknh Øekad 1 o 2 gs Fkdhr HkkMsjDde ns.;kl
r;kj >kY;kus lkslk;VhP;k lnL;kalkscr ,d=kr >kysY;k cSBdhr
BjY;kizek.ks izfroknh Øekad 1 o 2 ;kaps ukao EgkMkdMhy ik=
HkkMsd:aP;k ;knhe/;s lekfo"V dj.;kps Bjys- R;kl vuql:u fnukad
26-10-2017 jksth izfroknh Øekad 1 o 2 ;kauh jn~n u djrk ;s.kkjh
laerh rlsp fodkl djkj oknh daiuhP;k ukos fygqu fnyk vlwu vU;
vVhalg R;k djkjkiklwu 12 efgU;kr loZ Fkdhr ns; jdek oknhauk ns.;kps
izfroknh Øekad 1 o 2 ;kauh dcqy dsys rlsp eqnrhr izfroknh Øekad 1
-- 2 of 26 --
,l-lh- nkok Øekad 447@2019 --3-- U;k;fu.kZ;] fnukad 31-07-2026
o 2 gs u okxY;kl vkiys HkkMsd:ps gDd ?kjekyd@fodkldkP;k ukos
lksMwu ns.;kps o R;k ;kstuse/;s dk;eLo:ih i;kZ;h fuoklO;oLFkk
feG.;kl vki.k ik= jkg.kkj ukgh vls izfroknh Øekad 1 o 2 ;kauh
dcqy dsys gksrs-
3- oS;fDrd fodkl djkjkosGh izfroknh Øekad 1 o 2 ;kauh
oknhauk :i;s 50]000@& brdh jDde fnyh vlwu HkkM~;kiksVhP;k moZfjr
jdesckcr rhu /kukns'k fnys gksrs ijarq] izfroknh Øekad 1 o 2 ;kaP;k
[kkR;kr /kukns'k oV.;kbrdh jDde ulY;kP;k dkj.kkLro rs /kukns'k oknh
daiuhdMs ijr vkys- izfroknh Øekad 1 o 2 ;kauh fnukad 10-02-2018
jksth lnj [kksyhpk rkck oknh daiuhl fnyk vlwu dcqy dsY;kizek.ks
moZfjr :i;s 16]70]000@& brdh jDde izfroknh Øekad 1 o 2 ;kauh
oknh daiuhl fnyh ukgh- R;keqGs] djkjkrhy vVh o 'krhZuqlkj
dk;eLo:ih i;kZ;h fuokl O;oLFkk Eg.kwu lnj ;kstuse/;s lnfudk
feG.;kl izfroknh Øekad 1 o 2 gs ik= ukghr- R;k dkj.kkeqGs izfroknh
Øekad 1 o 2 ;kauh izfroknh Øekad 3 ;kauk osGksosGh i= fygqu oknh
daiuhl =kl ns.ks lq: dsys vlwu R;kpkp Hkkx Eg.kwu izfroknh Øekad
3 ;kaP;kdMwu fnukad 19-11-2018 jksth oknh daiuhl uksVhl izkIr >kyh
vkgs-
4- oj uewn dkj.kkLro fnukad 26-10-2017 jksthpk djkj jn~n
>kyk vlwu ik= HkkMsd:aP;k ;knhrwu izfroknh Øekad 1 o 2 ;kaph ukaos
izfroknh Øekad 3 ;kauh deh dj.ks vko';d vkgs- oknh daiuhus
R;kdjhrk vfHk"ksd dSyklizlkn ekyik.kh ;kauk oknh daiuhP;k orhus nkok
nk[ky dj.;kl vf/kdkj fnys vlwu fnukad 26-10-2047 jksthP;k
djkjkrhy vV Øekad 12 ps izfroknh Øekad 1 o 2 ;kaP;kdMwu mYya?ku
>kY;kus rks djkj jn~n >kY;kps gDdKkiu dj.;kr ;kos rlsp izfroknh
-- 3 of 26 --
,l-lh- nkok Øekad 447@2019 --4-- U;k;fu.kZ;] fnukad 31-07-2026
Øekad 3 ;kauh ik= HkkMsd:aP;k ;knhrwu izfroknh Øekad 1 o 2 ;kaps uko
deh djkos v'kk vkKkFkhZ eukbZph oknh daiuhus fouarh dsyh vkgs-
5- izfroknh Øekad 1 o 2 ;kauh ;k nkO;krhy uksVhl vkWQ
eks'ku Øekad 1480@2019 dkeh fnysys Eg.k.ks vkiY;krQsZ dSfQ;r
Eg.kwu okp.;kr ;kos vls dGfoY;kus lnj Eg.k.;kl fu'kk.kh Øekad 8
ns.;kr vkyh- izfroknh Øekad 1 o 2 ;kauh fnukad 26-10-2017 jksthP;k
djkjkrhy vVhapk Hkax dsY;kps oknh daiuhps dFku ukdkjrkuk oknh o lnj
izfroknhanjE;ku ?kjekyd o HkkMsd:ps ukrs vlY;kus izLrqr nkok ;k
U;k;ky;kleksj pky.;kl vik= vlY;kps dFku dsys vkgs- rlsp] fnukad
26-10-2017 jksthP;k djkjkrhy vVhaps mYya?ku >kY;kps oknh daiuhps
dFku ikgrk izfroknh Øekad 1 o 2 ;kaps lnj feGdrhrhy HkkMsd:ps
gDd laiq"Vkr vkY;kps ns[khy oknh daiuhps dFku vlY;kus izLrqr nkok
pkyowu fudkyh dj.;kpk vf/kdkj ;k U;k;ky;kl ulY;kps EgVys
vkgs- ;kf'kok;] izfroknh Øekad 3 ;kauh R;kapsdMhy ik=
HkkMsd:aps ;knhrwu izfroknh Øekad 1 o 2 ;kaph ukaos deh dj.;kph
fouarh oknh daiuhus nkO;kdkeh dsyh vlwu MsOgyiesaV daVªksy :Yl]
1991 P;k dye 33 ¼7½ e/khy rjrqnh ikgrk EgkMk vf/kfu;ekuqlkj
use.;kr vkysY;k izkf/kd`r vf/kdkÚ;kdMs oknh daiuhus nkn ekx.ks
vko';d vkgs- rlsp] fnukad 11-07-2006 jksthP;k oknh daiuh o
okdMh pkG leUo; lferh ;kaP;knjE;ku >kysY;k djkjkpk vk/kkj oknh
daiuhus ?ksryk vlY;kus t:j rs ble nkO;kdkeh vko';d i{kdkj vlwu
R;kauk nkO;kdkeh i{kdkj dj.;kr u vkY;keqGs vkgs R;k Lo:ikr nkok
pky.;kl vik= vkgs- rlsp] izfroknh Øekad 1 o 2 ;kauh HkkM~;kph
jDde R;k R;k osGP;k ?kjekydkauk osGksosGh vnk dsyh vlwu izfroknh gs
lnj [kksyh Øekad lh&21 ps dk;ns'khj HkkMsd:@rkcsnkj vkgsr- oknh
-- 4 of 26 --
,l-lh- nkok Øekad 447@2019 --5-- U;k;fu.kZ;] fnukad 31-07-2026
daiuhdMwu lnj bekjrhP;k iqufoZdklkckcr dks.krhgh dk;Zokgh dsyh tkr
ulwu iqufoZdklknjE;ku cka/k.;kr ;ko;kP;k bekjrhe/;s i;kZ;h fuokl
O;oLFkk gksowu feG.;kl izfroknh Øekad 1 o 2 gs ik= vkgsr-
R;kckcrpk djkj oknh daiuhus lnj izfroknhaP;k ykHkkr fygqu fnyk
vlY;kus rks oknh daiuhoj ca/kudkjd vkgs- lnj izfroknhaph Qlo.kwd
d:u oknh daiuhus :i;s 50]000@& pk /kukns'k Fkdhr HkkMsjDdekaiSdh
dkgh jDdekadjhrk o feGdr djkiksVh ?ksryk vlwu izLrqr izfroknhauk
[kksV~;k [kVY;kdkeh xqarfo.;kpk oknh daiuhpk iz;Ru vkgs- oknh
daiuhdMwu Fkdhr HkkM~;kiksVh rlsp Fkdhr feGdr djkiksVh :i;s
22]00]000@& brD;k jdesph voktoh ekx.kh dj.;kr vkyh vlwu
fuOoG izfroknh Øekad 1 o 2 ;kapk HkkMsd:pk gDd rlsp
iqufoZdklknjE;ku feG.kkÚ;k Qk;n~;kaiklwu oafpr Bso.;kpk izfroknh
daiuhpk gsrw vkgs- EgkMkdMwu feGkysY;k uk gjdr nk[kY;kuqlkj rlsp
R;kuarjP;k ok<ho eqnrhe/;s ns[khy oknh daiuhus cka/kdke lq: dsys ukgh-
lcc] [kksV~;k etdwjkpk nkok nk[ky dj.;kr vkyk vlwu ojhy
dkj.kkLro lnj nkok pky.;kl vik= vlY;kus rlsp fouarhizek.ks
dks.krhgh nkn feG.;kl oknh ik= ulY;kus lnj nkok QsVkG.;kr ;kok
v'kh izfroknh Øekad 1 o 2 ;kauh fouarh dsyh vkgs-
6- nkO;kps leUl izkIr >kY;kuarj izfroknh Øekad 3 rQsZ odhy
Jh- ds-,u-dkansdj gs gtj >kys ijarq] izfroknh Øekad 3 rQsZ nkO;kl
dSfQ;r nk[ky dj.;kr vkyh ukgh-
7- ojhy ifjfLFkrhr nksUgh i{kkps dFku fopkjkr Äsrk] ekÖ;k
iqokZf/kdkÚ;kauh fu’kk.kh Øekad 12 oj [kkyhy eqn~ns fuf’pr dsys vlwu
R;k eqn~n~;kapk dkj.kkalg fu”d”kZ eh [kkyhyizek.ks ukssanfor vkgs %&
-- 5 of 26 --
,l-lh- nkok Øekad 447@2019 --6-- U;k;fu.kZ;] fnukad 31-07-2026
v-Ø- eqn~ns fu”d”kZ
1- fnukad 26-10-2017 jksthP;k djkjkrhy vV Øekad
12 ps mYya?ku >kY;kus rks djkj jn~n >kY;kps
oknhus fl) dsys vkgs dk; \
---ukgh---
2- fnukad 26-10-2017 jksthpk djkj jn~n >kY;kus
izfroknh Øekad 3 EgkMkus HkkMsd:aP;k ;knhrhy
izfroknh Øekad 1 o 2 ;kaps uko deh dj.ks
vko';d vlY;kps oknhus fl) dsys vkgs dk; \
---ukgh---
3- vko';d R;k blekauk i{kdkj dj.;kr vkys
ulY;kP;k dkj.kkLro nkok pky.;kl vik= vkgs
dk; \
---ukgh---
4- oknh vkf.k izfroknh Øekad 1 o 2 ;kapsrhy
Äjekyd HkkMsd:aps ukrs fopkjkr ?ksrk ;k
U;k;ky;kleksj lnjpk nkok pky.;kl vik= vkgs
dk;\
--ukgh---
5- fnukad 26-10-2017 jksthP;k djkjkrhy
e/;LFkhckcrP;k (Arbitration) vV Øekad 5 uqlkj
lnjpk nkok ;k U;k;ky;kl pkyowu fudkyh
dj.;kpk vf/kdkj vkgs dk;\
--ukgh---
6- EgkMk vf/kfu;ekP;k dye 173 uqlkj nkokiwoZ
uksVhl ikBfo.;kr vkyh ulY;kP;k dkj.kkLro nkok
pky.;kl vik= vkgs dk;\
--ukgh---
7- fouarhizek.ks nkn feG.;kl oknh ik= vkgs dk;\ --ukgh---
8- vkns'k vkf.k gqdqeukek dks.krk\ vaafre
vkns'kkizek.ks
-- 6 of 26 --
,l-lh- nkok Øekad 447@2019 --7-- U;k;fu.kZ;] fnukad 31-07-2026
dkj.kfeekalk
8- oknh daiuhus vkiY;k dFkukiq"B~;FkZ dSyklizlkn
ekyik.kh ;kaph lk{k fu'kk.kh 14 oj Äsryh vlwu fu’kk.kh 16 oj fnukad
15-02-2018 jksthP;k lapkyd eaMGkP;k Bjkokph izr] fu’kk.kh 17 oj
fnukad 21-06-2022 jksthP;k Bjkokph izr] fu’kk.kh 18 oj fnukad
14-09-2005 oknh daiuhP;k LFkkiuk izek.ki=kph izr] fu’kk.kh 19 oj
fnukad 18-03-2013 jksthps izfroknh Øekad 3 ;kauh fnysys uk gjdr
izek.ki= rlsp EgkMkP;k HkkMsd:aph ;knh] fu’kk.kh 20 oj fnukad
31-10-2014 jksthps ifjf’k”V&2 rlsp oknh o ekrqJh QkrekckbZ dfje
feL=h pWfjVscy VªLV ;kae/khy dUOgs;Ul MhM] fu’kk.kh 21 oj fnukad
29-06-2017 izfroknhauh oknh daiuhl fnysys i=] fu’kk.kh 22 o 23
oj fnukad 07-10-2017 o 25-10-2017 jksthps cSBdhps dk;Zo`Rr]
fu’kk.kh 24 oj fnukad 26-10-2017 jksthps jn~n u gks.kkjs laerhi=]
fu’kk.kh 25 oj fnukad 26-10-2017 jksthpk oS;fDrd fodkl djkj]
fu’kk.kh 26] 26&v] 27] 27&v] 28 o 28&v oj fnukad
15-11-2018 o 25-01-2019] fnukad 30-11-2018 o 28-01-2019
rlsp fnukad 15-12-2018 o 28-01-2019 jksthps c¡d esekslg izfroknh
Øekad 1 us oknh daiuhP;k ukos fnysys /kukns'k] fu’kk.kh 29 o 29&v
oj Nk;kfp=s rlsp fnukad 10-02-2018 jksthph rkck ikorh] fu’kk.kh 30
oj fnukad 23-02-2018 jksthps EgkMkus oknhl ikBfoysys i=] fu’kk.kh
31 oj fnukad 27-02-2018 jksthps oknh daiuhus EgkMkyk fnysys mRrj]
fu’kk.kh 32 o 33 oj fnukad 06-03-2018 o fnukad 21-03-2018
jksthps oknh daiuhus EgkMkyk ikBfoysys i=] fu’kk.kh 34 o 35 oj
fnukad 22-06-2017 jksthps izfroknh Øekad 3 ;kauh fnysys uk gjdr
izek.ki= rlsp EgkMkP;k 15 HkkMsd:aph ;knh] fu’kk.kh 36 oj fnukad
28-10-2020 jksthps izfroknh Øekad 3 ps eqnr ok<hps uk gjdr
-- 7 of 26 --
,l-lh- nkok Øekad 447@2019 --8-- U;k;fu.kZ;] fnukad 31-07-2026
izek.ki=] fu’kk.kh 37 o 38 oj fnukad 28-10-2020 o 28-03-2022
jksthps izfroknh Øekad 3 rQsZ lq/kkjhr uk gjdr izek.ki=] fu’kk.kh 39 o
40 oj fnukad 12-04-2023 o 25-04-2024 jksthps izfroknh Øekad 3
ps eqnr ok<hps uk gjdr izek.ki=] fu’kk.kh 41 oj fnukad 19-11-2018
izfroknh Øekad 3 ;kauh oknh daiuhl ikBfoysys i=] fu’kk.kh 42 oj
fnukad 22-11-2018 jksthps oknhus izfroknh Øekad 3 ;kaP;k fuoklh
dk;Zdkjh vfHk;ark ;kauk ikBfoysys i=] fu’kk.kh 43 oj fnukad
14-01-2019 jksthps oknhus EgkMkP;k eq[;kf/kdkjh ;kauk ikBfoysys i=]
fu’kk.kh 44 oj fnukad 30-03-2019 jksthph oknhus nknj iksyhl Bk.;kr
tek dsysY;k dkxni=kaph ;knh] fu’kk.kh 45] 46 o 49 oj fnukad
04-04-2019] 26-04-2019 jksth oknhus ofj”B iksyhl fujh{kd] nknj
iksyhl Bk.ks ;kauk ikBfoysys i=] fu’kk.kh 47 oj fnukad 17-05-2019
jksthps ofj”B iksyhl fujh{kd] nknj iksyhl Bk.ks ;kauh oknh daiuhl
ikBfoysys i=] fu’kk.kh 48 oj fnukad 20-05-2019 oknhps ofj”B
iksyhl fujh{kd] nknj iksyhl Bk.ks ;kauk ikBfoysys mRrj gh dkxni=s
nk[ky dsyh vkgsr-
9- izfroknh Øekad 1 ;kauh nkO;kdkeh rksaMh iqjkok n~;ko;kps
ulY;kps fu'kk.kh 55 ojhy iqjf'kln~okjs dGfoys-
10- oknh daiuhrQsZ odhy Jh- tks,y fMlqtk o izfroknh Øekad
1 vkf.k 2 rQsZ odhy Jh- jktho eVdj ;kapk ;qfDrokn ,sdyk- rlsp
R;kauh vuqØes fu'kk.kh 56 o fu’kk.kh 57 oj nk[ky dsysyk
ys[kh ;qfDrokn okpyk- rlsp izfroknh Øekad 3 rQsZ odhy Jh- ds-,u-
dkansdj ;kapk rksaMh ;qfDrokn ,sdyk-
-- 8 of 26 --
,l-lh- nkok Øekad 447@2019 --9-- U;k;fu.kZ;] fnukad 31-07-2026
eqn~nk Øekad 3 %&
11- izLrqr nkO;kl vko';d R;k blekauk i{kdkj dj.;kr vkys
ulY;kus izLrqr nkok vkgs ;k Lo:ikr pky.;kl vik= vlY;kph gjdr
izfroknh Øekad 1 o 2 rQsZ ?ks.;kr vkyh vkgs- nkO;kP;k ifjPNsn 6 e/;s
fnukad 26-10-2017 jksthP;k djkjkpk mYys[k djrkuk nkO;kP;k ifjPNsn
4 e/;s eqyr% izfroknh Øekad 1 o 2 ;kaph ukaos izfroknh Øekad 3 ;kauh
r;kj dssysY;k izekf.kr HkkMsd:aP;k ;knhr lekfo"V uOgrh vlk mYys[k
vlwu nkO;kP;k ifjPNsn 5 e/;s izfroknh Øekad 1 o 2 rlsp x`gfuekZ.k
lkslk;VhP;k dk;Zdkjh eaMGkrhy lnL;kauh ,d=kr cSBdhnjE;ku dsysY;k
fouarhuqlkj izfroknh Øekad 1 o 2 ;kaph ukos izekf.kr HkkMsd:aP;k ukos
lekfo"V dj.;kps Bjys vls uewn dj.;kr vkys vkgs-
12- ;k ifjfLFkrhr izfroknh Øekad 1 o 2 ;kauh nkO;kl
vko';d R;k blekauk i{kdkj dj.;kr vkys ulY;kph gjdr ?ksrkuk
fu'kk.kh 8 ojhy dSfQ;rP;k ifjPNsn 3 e/;s "The defendant states that,
the present suit is bad in law for not joining necessary parties to the
suit. The defendant states that, plaintiff rely upon the terms and
conditions of Agreement dated 11.07.2006 executed by and between
the Wakdi Chawl, Samanway Samiti." vls uewn dj.;kr vkys vkgs-
ijarq] dSfQ;re/;s dks.krs ble nkO;kl vko';d i{kdkj vkgsr ;kpk
ukokfu'kh mYys[k dj.;kr vkysyk ukgh-
13- lcc] fnukad 26-10-2017 jksthP;k djkj fdaok fnukad
11-07-2006 jksthP;k djkjkckcr izfroknh Øekad 1 o 2 ;kauh
dSfQ;re/;s ojhyizek.ks gjdr ?ksryh vlyh rjh izLrqr nkO;kl dks.kR;k
O;Drh o laLFkk vko';d i{kdkj vkgsr ;kckcr dSfQ;re/;s dks.krkgh
-- 9 of 26 --
,l-lh- nkok Øekad 447@2019 --10-- U;k;fu.kZ;] fnukad 31-07-2026
mYys[k dsyk ulY;kus rlsp oj uewn dsY;kizek.ks izfroknh Øekad 1 o 2
;kauh nkO;kdkeh dks.krkgh iqjkok fnyk ulY;kus izLrqr nkO;kdkeh fnukad
26-10-2017 jksthpk oknh daiuh o izfroknh Øekad 1 vkf.k 2 ;kaP;k
njE;ku >kysyk djkj o izfroknh Øekad 3 ;kaP;kdMhy izekf.kr
HkkMsd:aP;k ;knhckcr oknh daiuhus dsysY;k fouaR;k fopkjkr ?ksrk nkO;kl
vko';d R;k blekauk i{kdkj dj.;kr u vkY;keqGs izLrqr nkok vkgs ;k
Lo:ikr pky.;kl vik= vlY;kckcr izfroknh Øekad 1 o 2 ;kaP;krQsZ
?ks.;kr vkysyh gjdr fLodkjkgZ ukgh- lcc] eqn~nk Øekad 3 pk fu"d"kZ
^ukgh* vlk eh uksanfor vkgs-
eqn~nk Øekad 4 %&
14- oknh daiuh o izfroknh Øekad 1 o 2 ;kaP;knjE;ku ?kjekyd
o HkkMsd:ps ukrs vlY;keqGs rlsp izfroknh Øekad 3 EgkMkdMhy
izekf.kr HkkMsd:aP;k ;knhrhy izfroknh Øekad 1 o 2 ;kaph ukos deh
dj.;kckcr vkKkFkhZ eukbZph oknh daiuhrQsZ dj.;kr vkysyh fouarh
ikgrk lnj nkok y?kqokn U;k;ky;kleksj pky.;kl ik= vlwu lnjpk nkok
pkywu fudkyh dj.;kpk vf/kdkj ;k U;k;ky;kl ulY;kph gjdr
izfroknh Øekad 1 o 2 rQsZ ?ks.;kr vkyh vkgs-
15- izfroknh Øekad 1 o 2 rQsZ ofdykauh
vkiY;k ;qfDroknkiq"B~;FkZ ujgjh panz¸;k dank fo:) fgjsu nketh xkyk
vkf.k brj] Civil Revision Application No. 162/2023 alongwith Interim
Application No. 2521/2023, Judgment dated 27.06.2024 o fo'oukFk
X;kuck pksjxs fo:) n E;qfufliy dkWiksZjs'ku vkWQ xzsVj eqacbZ vkf.k brj]
Appeal From Order No. 1235/2012, Judgment dated 17.12.2012 ;k
U;k;fu.kZ;kapk vk/kkj ?ksryk- ;kmyV] oknhrQsZ ofdykauh ;qfDroknknjE;ku
-- 10 of 26 --
,l-lh- nkok Øekad 447@2019 --11-- U;k;fu.kZ;] fnukad 31-07-2026
fu'kk.kh 25 ojhy djkjkps Lo:i o R;kvk/kkjs oknh daiuhus nkO;kdkeh
dsysY;k fouaR;k ikgrk izLrqr nkok gk ?kjekyd o HkkMsd: ;kaP;k njE;ku
HkkMs fu;a=.k vf/kfu;ekrhy rjrqnhuqlkj nk[ky dj.;kr vkyk vkgs vls
Eg.krk ;s.kkj ukgh R;keqGs izLrqr nkok ;k U;k;ky;kleksj pky.;kl ik=
vlY;kps lkaxhrys-
16- ojhy ifjfLFkrhr] nkO;kP;k ifjPNsn 2 o 3 e/;s oknh daiuh
gh okdMh pkG] izHkknsoh ;sFkhy lnj feGdrhph ekyd vlwu izfroknh
Øekad 1 o 2 ;kaP;k rkC;krhy [kksyh Øekad lh&2 ph ?kjekyd
vlY;kps rlsp izfroknh Øekad 1 o 2 gs R;k feGdrhps HkkMsd:
vlY;kps uewn dj.;kr vkys vkgsr- ijarq] oj mYys[k dsY;kizek.ks lnj
feGdrhP;k iqufoZdklkdjhrk dj.;kr vkysY;k fnukad 26-10-2017
jksthP;k djkji=kckcr oknh daiuhl nkn ekxko;kph vlwu nkO;kdkeh
dj.;kr vkysY;k fouaR;k ikgrk nkok feGdrhps ?kjekyd ;k ukR;kus
HkkMsd: fo:) HkkMs fu;a=.k vf/kfu;ekrhy rjrqnhuqlkj oknh daiuhus ;k
U;k;ky;kleksj izLrqr nkO;kn~okjs nkn ekfxryh vkgs vls Eg.krk ;s.kkj
ukgh gk oknh daiuhrQsZ ofdykapk ;qfDrokn fLodkjkgZ vkgs- lcc] oknh
daiuh vkf.k izfroknh Øekad 1 o 2 ;kaP;krhy ?kjekyd o HkkMsd:ps
ukrs fopkjkr ?ksrk ;k U;k;ky;kl izLrqr nkok pkyowu fudkyh dj.;kpk
vf/kdkj ulY;kph izfroknh Øekad 1 o 2 rQsZ mifLFkr dj.;kr vkysyh
gjdr vfLodkjkgZ vkgs- ifj.kker% izfroknh Øekad 1 o 2 rQsZ ofdykauh
vkiY;k ;qfDroknkiq"B~;FkZ vk/kkj ?ksrysys mijksYysf[kr U;k;fu.kZ; izfroknh
Øekad 1 o 2 ;kaP;k enrhl ;sr ulY;kpk oknh daiuhrQsZ
ofdykapk ;qfDrokn fLodkjkgZ vkgs- ifj.kker% eqn~nk Øekad 4 pk fu"d"kZ
^ukgh* vlk eh uksanfor vkgs-
-- 11 of 26 --
,l-lh- nkok Øekad 447@2019 --12-- U;k;fu.kZ;] fnukad 31-07-2026
eqn~nk Øekad 5 %&
17- fnukad 26-10-2017 jksthP;k oknh daiuh vkf.k izfroknh
Øekad 1 o 2 ;kapsrhy djkjkrhy vV Øekad 5 e/;s oknh daiuh vkf.k
izfroknh Øekad 1 o 2 ;kaP;k njE;ku dks.kR;kgh Lo:ikpk okn mifLFkr
>kY;kl rks okn e/;LFkkekQZr lksMowu ?ks.;kps uewn vlwu lnj djkjkn~okjs
BjY;kizek.ks oknh daiuhus lnjpk okn e/;LFkkleksj (Arbitrator) ?ksowu tk.ks
vko';d gksrs o fnukad 16-10-2017 jksthP;k djkjkrhy lnj vV ikgrk
;k U;k;ky;kl lnjpk nkok pkyowu fudkyh dj.;kpk vf/kdkj ulY;kph
gjdr izfroknh Øekad 1 o 2 ;kaP;k rQsZ ?ks.;kr vkyh vkgs-
18- fu'kk.kh 25 oj fnukad 26-10-2017 jksthpk djkj vlwu
lnj djkjkps voyksdu djrk R;krhy “VI MISCELLANEOUS- 1....., 2......,
3....., 4....., 5. If any dispute arises between the parties hereto in respect
of this agreement and/or in connection with any claim by one against
the 30 other and/or with regard to the interpretation of any of the
clauses of this Agreement, then the same will be referred to arbitration
of a common arbitrator if agreed upon failing which, to two arbitrators
one to be appointed by each party to the dispute and the arbitration will
be governed by the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 and/or any
other law for the time being in force.” vlk etdwj uewn vkgs-
19- lnj etdwj ikgrk lnj djkj fdaok lnj djkjkps i{kdkj
vl.kkÚ;k blekanjE;ku rlsp djkjkrhy etdwjkP;k vFkkZckcr okn
mifLFkr >kY;kl lnj djkj dj.kkÚ;k oknh daiuh vkf.k izfroknh Øekad
1 o 2 ;kaP;k laerhus use.;kr vkysY;k e/;LFkkdMs fdaok
e/;LFkkckcr ,der u >kY;kl oknh daiuhus rlsp izfroknh Øekad 1 o
2 ;kauh useysY;k izR;sdh ,d Eg.ktsp ,dq.k 2 e/;LFkkadMs rks okn
-- 12 of 26 --
,l-lh- nkok Øekad 447@2019 --13-- U;k;fu.kZ;] fnukad 31-07-2026
nk[ky d:u The Arbitration and conciliation Act, 1996 e/khy
rjrqnhuqlkj rks okn fudkyh d:u ?ks.;kps Bjys gksrs gs fnlwu ;srs-
20- oj uewn ifjLFkrhr] oknh daiuhrQsZ
ofdykauh ;qfDroknknjE;ku izfroknh Øekad 1 o 2 ;kauh lnj djkjkrhy
vV Øekad 5 ckcr uksVhl vkWQ eks'kuyk fnysY;k Eg.k.;ke/;s o
uarjP;k dSfQ;re/;s ojhyizek.ks gjdr ?ksryh vlyh rjh R;kckcr nkok
pky.;kl vik= vlY;klaca/kh vktrkxk;r ;k U;k;ky;kleksj dks.krkgh
uksVhl vkWQ eks'ku nk[ky dsyk ukgh rlsp nkO;kdkeh
vafre ;qfDroknkosGh lnjpk eqn~nk izfroknh Øekad 1 o 2 ;kaP;krQsZ
ofdykauh mifLFkr dsyk vlwu oknh daiuhrQsZ rksaMh iqjkok ns.;kr vkyk
rlsp dkxni=s nk[ky dj.;kr vkyh vlwu oknh daiuhrQsZ laca/khrkpk
myVrikl ns[khy izfroknh Øekad 1 o 2 ;kaP;k rQsZ ?ks.;kr vkyk o
R;kuarj nkO;kP;k vafre VII;kr lnj gjdr ?ks.;kr vkY;kph ckc
fopkjkr ?ksrk nkO;kP;k izØh;sfo"k;h (Procedure) ;k ÄMhyk izfroknh Øekad
1 o 2 ;kauk v'kh gjdr ?ksrk ;s.kkj ukgh vls lkaxhrys-
21- ;kmyV] izfroknh Øekad 1 o 2 ;kauh ;qfDroknk njE;ku
izfroknh Øekad 1 o 2 rQsZ ojhyizek.ks gjdrhpk eqn~nk mifLFkr dj.;kr
vkyk vlwu oknh daiuh o izfroknh Øekad 1 o 2 ;kapsrhy ?kjekyd o
HkkMsd:ps ukrs fopkjkr ?ksrk e/;LFk use.;kckcr fu'kk.kh 25 ojhy
djkjkrhy vVheqGs oknh daiuh o izfroknh Øekad 1 o 2 ;kaP;krhy okn
e/;LFkkl (Arbitrator) fudkyh dk<rk vkyk ulrk vls lkaxhrys-
22- ojhy ifjfLFkrhr] oknh o izfroknhrQsZ ofdykapk ;qfDrokn
Äsrk tjh fu'kk.kh 8 ojhy dSfQ;re/;s Arbitration clause ckcr eqn~nk
-- 13 of 26 --
,l-lh- nkok Øekad 447@2019 --14-- U;k;fu.kZ;] fnukad 31-07-2026
mifLFkr dj.;kr vkyk vlyk rjh vktrkxk;r izfroknh Øekad 1 o 2
rQsZ lnj gjdrhlaca/kh nkok pkyowu fudkyh dj.;kpk vf/kdkj ;k
U;k;ky;kl ulY;kckcr dks.krkgh uksVhl vkWQ eks'ku nk[ky dj.;kr
vkyk ulY;kus rlsp] nksUgh i{kkps dFku fopkjkr ?ksowu fnukad
26-02-2024 jksth fu'kk.kh 12 ojhy eqn~ns fuf'pr dj.;kr vkys vlwu
oknh daiuhrQsZ dSyklizlkn ekyik.kh ;kapk ljrikl fnukad 09-10-2024
jksthP;k izfrKki=kvk/kkjs nk[ky dj.;kr vkyk vkgs- rlsp R;kuarj fnukad
14-01-2026 o 26-02-2026 jksth izfroknh Øekad 1 o 2 rQZs
dSyklizlkn ekyik.kh ;kapk myVrikl ?ks.;kr vkyk o R;kuarj izfroknh
Øekad 1 o 2 ;kauh nkO;kdkeh rksaMh iqjkok n~;ko;kpk ulY;kps
iqjf'kln~okjs dGfo.;kr vkY;kuarj izLrqr nkok vafre ;qfDroknklkBh
use.;kr vkyk- lcc] fuOoG uksVhl vkWQ eks'kuyk fnysY;k
Eg.k.;ke/;s@dSfQ;re/;s ojhyizek.ks izfroknh Øekad 1 o 2 rQsZ gjdr
?ks.;kr vkyh vlyh rjh oj uewn dsY;kizek.ks vafre ;qfDroknkosGh
R;kckckr gjdr mifLFkr dj.;kr vkY;kph ckc fopkjkr ?ksrk izLrqr
nkO;kP;k izR;sd VII;koj izfroknh Øekad 1 o 2 gs lkehy >kys vlwu
djkjkrhy Arbitration clause eqGs ;k U;k;ky;kleksj izLrqr nkok
pky.;kl vik= vlY;kph gjdr izfroknh Øekad 1 o 2 rQsZ ?ks.;kr
vkyh ulY;kps Li"V gksrs- ifj.kker% lsaVy os;jgkmflax dkWiksZjs'ku] eqacbZ
fo:) QksVZikWbZaV vkWVkseksfVo izk-fy- eqacbZ- W.P. No. 4614/2009, Judgment
dated 16.12.2009 ;k U;k;fu.kZ;ke/;s ukenkj ckWEcs mPp U;k;ky;kus vls EgVys vkgs
dh] The Court of Small Causes has the exclusive jurisdiction to try and
decide the case covered by Section 41(1) of the Presidency Small
Causes Courts Act and that mere existence of Arbitration Agreement
between the parties as well as non-obstante clause in Section 5 of the
Arbitration Act does not oust exclusive jurisdiction of the Court of Small
Causes. lcc] lnj U;k;fu.kZ; ikgrk R;ke/;s tsOgk ,[kknh feGdr
-- 14 of 26 --
,l-lh- nkok Øekad 447@2019 --15-- U;k;fu.kZ;] fnukad 31-07-2026
fo'ks"k dk;n~;kus lajf{kr dsysyh vlrs R;kosGh HkkMsd:laca/khpk]
HkkMsd:l ns.;kr vkysY;k feGdrhrwu HkkMsd:l csn[ky dj.;kckcr
oxSjslaca/khpk okn e/;LFkkn~okjs lksMfork ;s.kkj ukgh ;klaca/khps fujh{k.k
ikgrk lnj U;k;fu.kZ; oknh daiuhP;k enrhl ;sr vlwu fu'kk.kh 25
ojhy fnukad 26-10-2017 jksthP;k djkjkrhy Arbitration clause
fopkjkr ?ksrk izLrqr nkok pkyowu fudkyh dj.;kpk vf/kdkj ;k
U;k;ky;kl ulY;kckcr izfroknh Øekad 1 o 2 rQsZ ?ks.;kr vkysyh
gjdr izfroknh Øekad 1 o 2 ;kauh lksMwu fnY;kps eku.ks vko';d
vlY;kpk oknh daiuhrQsZ ofdykapk ;qfDrokn fLodkjkgZ vkgs- lcc] oj
uewn dkj.kkLro izfroknh Øekad 1 o 2 rQsZ Äs.;kr vkysyh mijksYysf[kr
gjdr vfLodkjkgZ vkgs- R;keqGs] eqn~nk Øekad 5 pk fu"d"kZ ^ukgh* vlk
eh uksanfor vkgs-
eqn~nk Øekad 6 %&
23- EgkMk vf/kfu;ekP;k dye 173 uqlkj izfroknh Øekad 3
EgkMk ;kauk nkokiwoZ uksVhl ns.;kr u vkY;keqGs nkok pky.;kl vik=
vlY;kph gjdr izfroknh izfroknh Øekad 1 o 2 ;kauh ?ksryh vkgs- oj
uewn dsY;kizek.ks izfroknh Øekad 3 gs ofdykaekQZr nkO;kdkeh gtj >kys
ijarq] R;kauh dSfQ;r nk[ky dsyh ukgh-
24- okLrfodr% EgkMk vf/kfu;e] 1976 P;k dye 173 e/khy
rjrqn ikgrk R;kuqlkj Notice to suit against Authority, etc.- No person
shall commence any suit against the Authority or against any member
of the Authority or of any Board or of any Panchayat or any officer or
servant of the Authority or Panchayat or any person acting under the
orders of the Authority or Board, or Panchayat for anything done or
purporting to have been done in pursuance of this act (including any
-- 15 of 26 --
,l-lh- nkok Øekad 447@2019 --16-- U;k;fu.kZ;] fnukad 31-07-2026
contract thereunder), without giving the Authority, member, officer or
servant or person two months previous notice in writing of the intended
suit and of the cause thereof, nor after six months from the date of the
act complained of."
25- ojhy rjrqn ikgrk] EgkMk vf/kfu;e] 1976 P;k dye 173
e/khy uksVhl ckcrph gjdr izfroknh Øekad 3 ;kauk ?ksrk vkyh
vlrh- ;kf'kok;] nkok nk[ky dj.;kr ;s.;kiwohZP;k izfroknh Øekad 3
P;k vf/kdkÚ;kauh dsysY;k dks.kR;kgh d`R;kckcr nkO;kdkeh nkn ekx.;kr
vkysyh ukgh- ijarq] izekf.kr HkkMsd:aph ;knh izfroknh Øekad 3 ;kapsdMs
vlwu nkok feGdrh'kh laca/khr R;k ;knhrwu izfroknh Øekad 1 o 2 ;kaps
uko deh dj.;kps funsZ'k izfroknh Øekad 3 ;kauk ns.;kr ;kosr v'kh
oknh daiuhrQsZ nkO;kdkeh fouarh dj.;kr vkyh vkgs- lnj fouarh ikgrk
rh fouarh oknh daiuh vkf.k izfroknh Øekad 1 o 2 ;kaP;k njE;ku
>kysyk fnukad 26-10-2017 jksthpk djkj jn~n dj.;kph oknh daiuhus
dsysyh fouarh eatwj dj.;kr vkY;kl izfroknh Øekad 3 fo:) oknh
daiuhus dsysyh fouarh fopkjkr ?ksrk ;sbZy-
26- ifj.kker% mijksYysf[kr ckc fopkjkr ?ksrk] EgkMk vf/kfu;e]
1976 P;k dye 173 uqlkjP;k uksVhl ckcrph gjdr izfroknh Øekad 1
o 2 ;kauh ?ksryh vlyh rjh r'kh gjdr izfroknh Øekad 3 EgkMk ;kauh
Äsryh ulY;kus oknh daiuhus izfroknh Øekad 3 ;kauk lnj rjrqnhuqlkj
nkokiwoZ uksVhl ikBfoY;kps oknh daiuhps dFku ulys rjh R;k dkj.kkLro
lnj nkok pky.;kl vik= vlY;kph izfroknh Øekad 1 o 2 ;kauh
Äsrysyh gjdr fLodkjkgZ ukgh- lcc] eqn~nk Øekad 6 pk fu"d"kZ ^ukgh*
vlk eh uksanfor vkgs-
-- 16 of 26 --
,l-lh- nkok Øekad 447@2019 --17-- U;k;fu.kZ;] fnukad 31-07-2026
eqn~nk Øekad 1 o 2 %&
27- ojhy nksUgh eqn~ns ,desdkar xqarys vlY;kus R;kaps fu"d"kZ
eh ,df=ri.ks uksanfor vkgs- fu'kk.kh 25 ojhy fnukad 26-10-2017
jksthP;k oknh daiuh vkf.k izfroknh Øekad 1 o 2 ;kaP;k njE;ku >kysY;k
djkjkrhy vV Øekad 12 ps mYya?ku izfroknh Øekad 1 o 2 ;kauh
dsY;kus lnj djkj jn~n >kY;kps oknh daiuhps dFku vlwu lnj djkj jn~n
>kY;kus izfroknh Øekad 3 ;kaP;kdMhy izekf.kr HkkMsd:aP;k ;knhrhy
HkkMsd: Eg.kwu izfroknh Øekad 1 o 2 ;kaP;k ukokph vlysyh uksan
izfroknh Øekad 3 ;kauh deh dj.;kckcr izfroknh Øekad 3 ;kaP;kfo:)
funsZ'k ns.;kr ;kosr v'kh ns[khy fouarh oknh daiuhrQsZ dj.;kr vkyh
vkgs-
28- nkO;kdkeh fnukad 26-10-2017 jksthpk djkj izfroknh Øekad
1 o 2 ;kauh oknh daiuhP;k ykHkkr fygqu fnY;kps oknh daiuhps dFku
vlwu R;k djkjkrhy vV Øekad 12 pk Hkax izfroknh Øekad 1 o
2 ;kaP;kdMwu >kY;kps oknh daiuhps dFku vkgs- fu'kk.kh 8 ojhy
dSfQ;r/;s oknh daiuh vkf.k izfroknh Øekad 1 o 2 ;kaP;k njE;ku
fnukad 26-10-2017 jksth fu'kk.kh 25 ojhy djkj >kY;kph ckc
ukdkj.;kr vkysyh ukgh- ;kf'kok;] rlk djkj >kY;kckcr oknh daiuhrQsZ
lk{khnkj dSyklizlkn ekyik.kh ;kauh fu'kk.kh 14 ojhy ljriklknjE;ku
lkaxhrys vlwu izfroknh Øekad 1 o 2 rQsZ ofdykauh dSyklizlkn
ekyik.kh ;kaP;k ?ksrysY;k myVriklknjE;ku ns[khy fu'kk.kh 25 ojhy
djkj ukdkj.;kr vkyk ukgh- lcc] fnukad 26-10-2017 jksth oknh
daiuh vkf.k izfroknh Øekad 1 o 2 ;kaP;k njE;ku fu'kk.kh 25 ojhy
djkj >kY;kps oknh daiuhus fl) dsys vkgs-
-- 17 of 26 --
,l-lh- nkok Øekad 447@2019 --18-- U;k;fu.kZ;] fnukad 31-07-2026
29- vls vlys rjh] oknh daiuhrQsZ lk{khnkj dSyklizlkn
ekyik.kh ;kauh fu'kk.kh 25 ojhy djkj voS/k vlY;kps dcqy dsys vlwu
izfroknh Øekad 1 o 2 gs Fkdhr HkkM~;kph jDde ns.;kl pqdY;kl nkok
feGdrhrhy HkkMsd:ps gDd R;kauh lksMwu fnysys ukghr vls dcqy
dsY;kus fu'kk.kh 25 ojhy djkjkvk/kkjs nkO;kdkeh dj.;kr vkysY;k
fouaR;k eatwj gks.;kl ik= ulY;kps izfroknh Øekad 1 o 2 rQsZ ofdykauh
;qfDroknknjE;ku lkaxhrys-
30- ;kmyV] fu'kk.kh 25 ojhy djkj izfroknh Øekad 1 o
2 ;kauk ekU; vlY;kus rlsp Fkdhr jdek izfroknh Øekad 1 o 2 ;kauh
oknh daiuhl ns.;kps ekU; d:u fu'kk.kh 26 rs 28 ojhy /kukns'k
izfroknh Øekad 1 o 2 ;kauh oknh daiuhl fnys ijarq] rs /kukns'k
oV.;kdjhrk tek dj.;kr vkys vlrk u oVrk ijr vkY;kus fu'kk.kh
25 ojhy djkjkrhy vV Øekad 12 ps mYya?ku@Hkax izfroknh Øekad 1 o
2 ;kauh dsY;kps oknh daiuhus fl) dsY;kps oknh daiuhrQsZ
ofdykauh ;qfDroknknjE;ku lkaxhrys-
31- ojhy ifjfLFkrhr] fu'kk.kh 25 ojhy djkjkckcr oknh
daiuhrQsZ lk{khnkj dSyklizlkn ekyik.kh ;kauh ljriklknjE;ku nkO;ke/;s
mifLFkr eqn~n~;kl vuql:u ckch lkaxhrY;k vlY;k rjh izfroknh Øekad 1
o 2 rQsZ ?ks.;kr vkysY;k myVriklknjE;ku R;kauh fu'kk.kh 25 ojhy
djkj gk oS/k ulY;kps Li"Vi.ks lkaxhrys- ;kf'kok;] fu'kk.kh 25 ojhy
djkjke/;s uewn dsysY;k HkkMsjdesiksVhP;k :i;s 22]00]000@& brD;k
jdeslaca/kh vkiY;kyk ekfgrh vlY;kps lkaxrkuk 2014 lkyh ekfld
HkkMs fdrh gksrs gs ;k?kMhyk lkaxrk ;s.kkj ulY;kps R;kauh
lkaxhrys- ;kf'kok;] Fkdhr HkkMsjDde u fnY;kl izfroknh Øekad 1 o 2
gs nkok feGdrhrhy vkiyk HkkMsd:pk gDd lksM.;kl r;kj
-- 18 of 26 --
,l-lh- nkok Øekad 447@2019 --19-- U;k;fu.kZ;] fnukad 31-07-2026
vlY;kckcr fu'kk.kh 25 ojhy djkjke/;s uewn dj.;kr vkY;kps oknh
daiuhps dFku vlys rjh R;kl foijhr ckc lk{khnkj dSyklizlkn
ekyik.kh ;kauh myVriklknjE;ku lkaxhrys-
32- izfroknh Øekad 1 o 2 ;kauh fu'kk.kh 25 ojhy djkjkuqlkj
Fkdhr HkkMsjDde ns.;kl rs pqdY;kl HkkMsd:ps gDd R;kauh lksMwu fnys
uOgrs vls lk{khnkj dSyklizlkn ekyik.kh ;kauh myVriklknjE;ku
lkaxhrys- ;kf'kok;] myVriklknjE;ku iq<s fu'kk.kh 25 ojhy djkjkl
oknh daiuhP;k lapkydkaP;k cSBdhe/;s eatwjh ns.;kr vkyh gksrh vls
lkaxrkuk oknh daiuhP;k lapkydkaP;k cSBdhph rh rkjh[k lkaxrk ;s.kkj
ulY;kps R;kauh lkaxhrys-
33- ;kf'kok;] oj mYys[k dsY;kizek.ks izfroknh Øekad 3
EgkMkdMhy izekf.kr HkkMsd:aP;k ;knhrhy HkkMsd: Eg.kwu izfroknh Øekad
1 o 2 ;kaps uksan vlysys ukao jn~n dj.;kckcr izfroknh Øekad 3 ;kauk
funsZ'k ns.;kph oknh daiuhph fouarh vkgs- izfroknh Øekad 1 o 2 rQsZ
ofdykauh ;qfDroknknjE;ku nkok feGdr gh i=k'ksM okdMh pkGpk Hkkx
vlwu R;kpk iqufoZdkl dj.;kdjhrk izfroknh Øekad 3 ;kauh oknh daiuhl
uk gjdr izek.ki= fnY;kph ckc fopkjkr ?ksrk oknh daiuh gh izfroknh
Øekad 3 EgkMkps izfrfu/kh vlY;kps Li"V gksrs o R;keqGs] oknh daiuh o
izfroknh Øekad 3 gs fHkUu ulY;kus izfroknh Øekad 3 ;kaP;kfo:) oknh
daiuhl dks.krhgh nkn ekxrk ;s.kkj ukgh vls lkaxhrys-
34- R;kckcr R;kauh ;qfDRkoknknjE;ku oknh daiuhrQsZ lk{khnkj
dSyklizlkn ekyik.kh ;kaP;k myVriklkpk vk/kkj ?ksryk-
dSyklizlkn ;kauh myVriklknjE;ku izfroknh Øekad 3 EgkMk ;kauh
fnysY;k uk gjdr izek.ki=kvk/kkjs vki.k dke djr vlY;kps lkaxhrys-
-- 19 of 26 --
,l-lh- nkok Øekad 447@2019 --20-- U;k;fu.kZ;] fnukad 31-07-2026
rlsp] izfroknh Øekad 1 o 2 ;kaph ukaos izekf.kr HkkMsd:aP;k ;knhrwu
oxG.;kckcr oknh daiuhus izfroknh Øekad 3 ;kaP;kdMs dks.krkgh vtZ
fnyk ulY;kps lkaxhrys- ;kf'kok;] izfroknh Øekad 1 x.kir ;kps ukao]
ik= HkkMsd:aP;k ;knhe/;s fnukad 22-06-2017 jksth izFker% vkys vlwu
rh ;knh 2017 lkyhp izekf.kr dj.;kr vkY;kps dSyklizlkn ;kauh
lkaxhrys-
35- izekf.kr ;knhrhy izfroknh Øekad 1 ;kP;k ukokP;k >kysY;k
uksanhl oknh daiuhus ;k nkO;kdkeh vkOgku fnY;kps lk{khnkj
dSyklizekn ;kauh myVriklknjE;ku lkaxhrys vlys rjh oj uewn
dsY;kizek.ks fuOoG fu'kk.kh 25 ojhy djkji=krhy vVhaP;k mYya?kukvk/kkjs
r'kh fouarh oknh daiuhrQsZ dj.;kr vkY;kps Li"V gksrs- rlsp] izekf.kr
HkkMsd:ackcrpk fu.kZ; ,e-ch-vkj-vkj-ch- ;kaP;kekQZr ?ksryk tkrks vls
lkaxrkuk R;kckcr ,e-ch-vkj-vkj-ch- ;kaP;kdMs vtZ nk[ky dj.ks
vko';d vlwu R;kl vuql:u ,e-ch-vkj-vkj-ch- P;k vf/kdkÚ;kauh nkok
feGdrhl HksV fnY;kps ns[khy R;kauh lkaxhrys-
36- ojhy ckch fopkjkr ?ksrk] izLrqr nkO;kdkeh fnukad
26-10-2017 jksthP;k T;k fu'kk.kh 25 ojhy djkji=kpk vk/kkj oknh
daiuhrQsZ ?ks.;kr vkyk vkgs rks djkj oS/k ulY;kps oknh daiuhps
dk;Zdkjh lapkyd vlysY;k lk{khnkj dSyklizlkn ekyik.kh ;kaps dFku
vlY;kus fu'kk.kh 25 ojhy djkjkckcrps o R;krhy vV Øekad 12 ps
mYya?ku izfroknh Øekad 1 o 2 ;kauh dsY;kps o R;keqGs rks djkj jn~n
>kY;kps rlsp R;kl vuql:u izfroknh Øekad 3 EgkMk ;kauh izekf.kr
HkkMsd:aP;k ;knhrhy izfroknh Øekad 1 o 2 ;kaps HkkMsd: Eg.kwu
vlysys ukao deh@jn~n gks.;kl ik= vlY;kps fl) dj.;kl oknh daiuh
-- 20 of 26 --
,l-lh- nkok Øekad 447@2019 --21-- U;k;fu.kZ;] fnukad 31-07-2026
vi;'kh Bjyh vkgs- lcc] eqn~nk Øekad 1 o 2 ps fu"d"kZ ^ukgh* vls eh
uksanfor vkgs-
eqn~nk Øekad 7 %&
37- oj mYys[k dsY;kizek.ks oknh daiuhus fnukad 26-10-2017
jksthP;k djkjkrhy vV Øekad 12 ps mYya?ku >kY;kus rks djkj jn~n
>kY;kps gDdKkiu dj.;kr ;kos rlsp izfroknh Øekad 3 ;kauh ik=
HkkMsd:aP;k ;knhrwu izfroknh Øekad 1 o 2 ;kaps uko deh djkos v'kk
vkKkFkhZ eukbZph fouarh dsyh vkgs ijarq eqn~nk Øekad 1 o 2 ps fu"d"kZ
ikgrk izfroknh Øekad 1 o 2 fo:)ps vkiys dFku fl) dj.;kl oknh
daiuh vi;'kh BjY;kus fouarhizek.ks gDdKkiukph rlsp izfroknh Øekad 3
fo:) vkKkFkhZ eukbZph nkn feG.;kl oknh daiuh ik= ukgh-
38- ;kf'kok;] izfroknh Øekad 1 o 2 rQsZ
ofdykauh ;qfDroknknjE;ku izLrqr nkok oknh daiuhrQsZ vf/kdkjizkIr blekus
nk[ky dsyk ulY;kus oknh daiuh fouarhizek.ks dks.krhgh nkn feG.;kl
ik= ulY;kps lkaxrkuk nkO;kP;k ifjPNsn 21 e/;s izLrqr nkO;koj lgh
dj.;kpk vf/kdkj oknh daiuhus vfHk"ksd dSyklizlkn ekyik.kh ;kauh
fnY;kps uewn dj.;kr vkys vlys rjh nkO;k[kkyhy izfrKki= ikgrk rs
dSyklizlkn ,l-ekyik.kh ;kaps vlY;kus vf/kdkjizkIr vfHk"ksd
dSyklizlkn ekyik.kh ;kauh oknh daiuhP;k orhus izLrqr nkok nk[ky dsyk
vkgs vls Eg.krk ;s.kkj ulY;kps R;kauh lkaxhrys- ;kf'kok;]
R;kauh ;qfDroknknjE;ku oknh daiuhrQsZ lk{khnkj dSyklizlkn
ekyik.kh ;kaP;k fu'kk.kh 14 ojhy ljriklkpk o myVriklkpk vk/kkj
Äsryk-
-- 21 of 26 --
,l-lh- nkok Øekad 447@2019 --22-- U;k;fu.kZ;] fnukad 31-07-2026
39- fu'kk.kh 14 ojhy ljriklkP;k ifjPNsn 2 e/;s vfHk"ksd
dSyklizlkn ekyik.kh gk oknh daiuhpk lapkyd vlwu fnukad
01 Qsczqokjh] 2019 jksth R;kus nkO;k[kkyh izfrKk dsY;kps rlsp
nkO;krhy etdwjkiq"B~;FkZ 'kiFki= nk[ky dsY;kps lkaxrkuk nkO;koj rlsp
nkO;k[kkyhy izfrKs[kkyh vfHk"ksd dSyklizlkn ekyik.kh ;kph lgh
vlY;kps lkaxhrys vkgs- ;kf'kok;] fnukad 15-02-2018 jksthP;k oknh
daiuhP;k lapkyd eaMGkP;k cSBdhe/;s ikjhr Bjkokn~okjs vfHk"ksd
dSyklizlkn ekyik.kh ;kauk izLrqrpk nkok nk[ky dj.;kps vf/kdkj ns.;kr
vkY;kps lkaxrkuk fnukad 15-02-2018 jksthP;k cSBdhe/;s ikjhr dj.;kr
vkysY;k Bjkokph izr nk[ky dsY;kps lkaxhrys- myVriklknjE;ku
dSyklizlkn ;kauh 2005 lkykiklwu rs oknh daiuhps lapkyd vlwu
izLrqr nkok R;kapk eqyxk vfHk"ksd ;kus nk[ky dsY;kps lkaxhrys- rlsp]
nkO;kP;k iku Øekad 14 oj vfHk"ksd ;kph lgh vlwu nkO;k[kkyh th
izfrKk dj.;kr vkyh vkgs rsFks vkiys ukao Vadfyf[kr vlY;kps R;kauh
lkaxhrys- myVriklknjE;ku] nkO;k[kkyP;k izfrKsrhy etdwjke/;s
Vadys[kuke/;s pwd >kY;kps dSyklizlkn ;kauh lkaxhrys-
40- ojhy ifjfLFkrhr] izfroknh Øekad 1 o 2 rQsZ
ofdykauh ;qfDroknknjE;ku oknh daiuhus lapkyd eaMGkP;k rFkkdFkhr
cSBdhe/;s ikjhr dj.;kr vkysY;k rFkkdFkhr BjkokP;k nkok nk[ky
djrkuk gtj dsysY;k izrhe/;s rlsp fu'kk.kh 16 ojhy izrhe/;s fHkUUk
etdwj vlY;kps lkaxhrys- nkok nk[ky djrkuk oknh daiuhrQsZ iku
Øekad 85 oj Exh-"Q" ;k Øekadkus fnukad 15-02-2018 jksthP;k
lapkydkaP;k cSBdhe/;s ikjhr Bjkokph Nk;kafdr izr nk[ky dj.;kr
vkyh vlwu R;ke/;s “Extract of Minutes of meeting of Bevenu Infra
Projects Private Limited held at SHOP NO. 9 & 10, ADI HOUSE, OPP.
-- 22 of 26 --
,l-lh- nkok Øekad 447@2019 --23-- U;k;fu.kZ;] fnukad 31-07-2026
PORTUGUSE CHURCH, GOKHALE ROAD (NORTH), DADAR, MUMBAI
400 028. ON 15/02/2018 AT 2.30 P.M. “Resolved that Mr. Abhishek K.
Malpani, authorized signatory of the Company be and hereby
authorized to sign, verify,…………………………..steps.” vlk etdwj
uewn vlwu fu'kk.kh 16 ojhy Bjkokph izr ikgrk R;ke/;s “Extract of
Minutes of meeting of Bevenu Infra Projects Private Limited held at
SHOP NO. 9 & 10, ADI HOUSE, OPP. PORTUGUSE CHURCH, GOKHALE
ROAD (NORTH), DADAR, MUMBAI 400 028. ON 15/02/2018 AT 2.30
P.M. “Resolved that Mr. Abhishek K. Malpani, authorized signatory of
the Company be and hereby authorized to sign, verify,
…………………………..steps.” vlk etdwj uewn vkgs- fnukad
15-02-2018 jksth oknh daiuhP;k lapkydkaph nkO;kP;k iku Øekad 85
oj Exh-"Q" ;k Øekadkus nk[ky dj.;kr vkysY;k rFkkdFkhr cSBdhrhy
ikjhr Bjkokf'kok; vU; cSBd gksowu vU; Bjko ikjhr dj.;kr vkY;kps
oknh daiuhps dFku ukgh- R;keqGs] fnukad 15-02-2018 jksthP;k
lapkydkaP;k rFkkdFkhr cSBdhosGh ikjhr BjkokP;k ,dk izrhe/;s lnj
nkok nk[ky d:u pkyfo.;kps vf/kdkj vfHk"ksd ds- ekyik.kh ;kauk
ns.;kr vkY;kpk o BjkokP;k vU; izrhe/;s R;kizdkjps vf/kdkj
dSyklizlkn ,l-ekyik.kh ;kauk ns.;kr vkY;kpk etdwj ikgrk fnukad 15-
02-2018 jksthP;k rFkkdFkhr cSBdhnjE;ku vfHk"ksd ekyik.kh ;kauk dh
dSyklizlkn ekyik.kh ;kauk nkok nk[ky dj.;kps vf/kdkj ns.;kr vkys gs
fLodkjkgZ o fo'oklkgZ iqjkok nsowu fl) dj.;kl oknh daiuh gh vi;'kh
BjY;kpk izfroknh Øekad 1 o 2 ;kapk ;qfDrokn vfLodkjkgZ ukgh-
ifj.kker% ojhy dkj.kkLro ns[khy nkO;kdkeh fuekZ.k >kysyk nks"k
fuokj.;kckcr oknh daiuhrQsZ vktrkxk;r dks.krhgh rtoht dsyh xsyh
ulY;kus R;kvk/kkjs oknh daiuhps dFku fLodkjkgZ ulY;kpk o R;keqGs
-- 23 of 26 --
,l-lh- nkok Øekad 447@2019 --24-- U;k;fu.kZ;] fnukad 31-07-2026
fouarhizek.ks dks.krhgh nkn feG.;kl oknh ik= ulY;kpk izfroknh Øekad
1 o 2 rQsZ ofdykapk ;qfDrokn vfLodkjkgZ ukgh- lcc] oknh daiuhrQsZ
ofdykauh vkiY;k ;qfDroknkiq"B~;FkZ vk/kkj ?ksrysys fnihdk rukoMs vkf.k
brj fo:) eqacbZ fcYMhax fjis;j vWUM fjdUlVªD'ku cksMZ vkf.k brj] Writ
Petition (L) No. 28861/2024, order dated 04.11.2025, bLVsyk QukZafMl
uh bLVsyk QukZafMl fo:) Lo.kZ gk;jkbt dUlVªD'ku vkf.k brj] Writ
Petition No. 2329/2019, Order dated 04.05.2023, EgkMk fo:)
Jherh :fDe.kh jkepanz vacjs vkf.k brj] Appeal from Order No.
67/2010, Order dated 09.03.2010, Jhjke ctjaxhyky /kksch vkf.k brj
fo:) EgkMk vkf.k brj] Appeal From Orde (st) No. 13797/2011 with
Civil Application (st) No. 13798/2011, Order dated 11.05.2011 gs
U;k;fu.kZ; ojhy dkj.kkLro oknh daiuhP;k enrhl ;sr ulY;kpk
izfroknh Øekad 1 o 2 rQsZ ofdykapk ;qfDrokn vfLodkjkgZ ukgh-
R;keqGs] eqn~nk Øekad 7 pk fu"d"kZ ^ukgh* vlk eh uksanfor vkgs-
41- FkksMD;kr] oj uewn dkj.kkLro fnukad 25-10-2017 jksthP;k
djkjkckcr rlsp izfroknh Øekad 3 ;kaP;kdMhy izekf.kr
HkkMsd:aP;k ;knhrhy izfroknh Øekad 1 o 2 ;kaP;k ukaokckcr oknh daiuh
gh vkiys dFku fl) dj.;kl vi;'kh BjY;keqGs fouarhizek.ks dks.krhgh
nkn feG.;kl ik= ulY;kus lnj nkok QsVkG.;kl ik= vkgs- R;keqGs] eh
[kkyhyizek.ks vkns'k ikjhr djhr vkgs %&
-- 24 of 26 --
,l-lh- nkok Øekad 447@2019 --25-- U;k;fu.kZ;] fnukad 31-07-2026
%% vkns’k %%
1- ,l-lh-nkok Øekad 447@2019 QsVkG.;kr ;sr vkgs-
2- oknh o izfroknhauh nkO;kpk [kpZ Lor%Pkk Lor% lkslkok-
fnukad % 31-07-2026
¼ lqfuy ek- ikVhy ½
uxj fnok.kh U;k;k/kh’k] c`gUeqacbZ
U;k;ky; Øekad 9
Jqrys[kukph rkjh[k % 31-07-2026
fyI;arj.kkph rkjh[k % 31-07-2026 o 01-08-2026
Lok{kjhph rkjh[k % 01-08-2026
-- 25 of 26 --
,l-lh- nkok Øekad 447@2019 --26-- U;k;fu.kZ;] fnukad 31-07-2026
“CERTIFIED TO BE TRUE AND CORRECT COPY OF THE ORIGINAL
SIGNED JUDGMENT/ORDER.”
Upload Date Upload Time Name of the Stenographer
01.08.2026 01:40 p.m. Mrs. Poonam Y. Pawar,
Stenographer (Grade-I)
Name of the Judge (With C.R. No.) H.H.J. SHRI. S. M. PATIL
(COURT ROOM NO.09)
Date of Pronouncement of
JUDGEMENT /ORDER
31.07.2026
JUDGEMENT /ORDER signed by
P.O. on
01.08.2026
JUDGEMENT /ORDER uploaded on 01.08.2026
-- 26 of 26 --