Full Order Text
Final Order 1 · 21 Apr 2025 · CNR MHCC010013772025
Order Details: Copy of Judgment Pdf Text: ... 1 … Order in Misc. Appeal 08 of 2025 MHCC010013772025 Presented on : 28.01.2025 Registered on : 29.01.2025 Decided on : 21.04.2025 Duration : 00 02 24 Years Months Days Exh.9 IN THE COURT OF CITY CIVIL FOR GREATER BOMBAY, AT BOMBAY MISCELLANEOUS APPEAL NO. 08 OF 2025 IN DYP/NCHC(P)/SHOP/13 (CNR NO. MHCC010013772025) Smt. Mukesh Devi Ahlawat Aged : 52 years, Occ : business R/at : Ground Floor, House No.16, Building-A, Naval Civilian Housing Colony, L.B.S. Marg, Kanjurmarg (W), Mumbai 400 078. …. Appellant Versus 1 2 The Union of India Through the Secretary, Ministry of Defence, Government of India, Parliament Street, New Delhi 110 001. Admiral Superintendent Naval Dockyard, Lion Gate, Mumbai 400 023. …. Respondents CORAM : HIS HONOUR THE PRINCIPAL JUDGE, SHRI A.SUBRAMANIAM C.R.NO.. : 19 DATE : 21st DAY OF APRIL, 2025 Appearances :- Adv. Armaan Grewal i/b M/s. N. N. Vaishnawa and Co., Ld. Counsel for appellant. Adv. Shriram Redij, Ld. Counsel for respondent. -- 1 of 11 -- ... 2 … Order in Misc. Appeal 08 of 2025 ORAL ORDER 1. By present appeal, appellants are challenging the impugned order dated 20.01.2025 passed by the Learned Estate Officer in DYP/NCHC(P)/SHOP/13. 2. It is the case of the Union of India that the appellant is an allottee in respect of Shop No.8 at Naval Civilian Housing Colony, Kanjurmarg (W), Mumbai 400 078. It is further contended that inspite of period of occupation expired, the appellant herein has not vacated the premises and that the appellant herein has no legal right to hold on said premises and hence is unauthorized occupant of the said premises. 3. The appellant herein replied to said notice contending that the premises were allotted and that appellant is in use and occupation of premises since 01.08.2011 on Leave and License basis. The applicant was the lone qualified applicant and held professional tailoring license and the term of license was 11 months which expired on 30.04.2012. Thereafter, fresh agreement was being executed and same continued till December 2023. Renewal was requested by letter dated 31.12.2023. Initially, agreement was executed for a period of 11 months, thereafter, it was reduced to 6 months and agreement on 19.008.2023 was just for 74 days and thereafter, it is only for three months. There is no reason assigned for reduction of the term. The revision is because of the suit No. 2733 of 2023 filed by appellants with regard to Shop No.2 and thus, the respondents are behaving in unreasonable manner. Other shop occupants continue to enjoy the licenses. The business has been conducted to the satisfaction of customers, officers and regular payments have been made. The appellant is providing school uniforms, -- 2 of 11 -- ... 3 … Order in Misc. Appeal 08 of 2025 house uniforms, belts, shoes, etc to the schools and also to the officer or Sailors in vicinity. This is specialized stock. It is further contended that the Union requested to keep stock of these items ready and hence as stock of above Rs.50 lakhs for schools and Rs.20 Lakhs of Naval uniforms. The notice has been issued as direct consequence of legal proceedings and there are at-least nine vacant shops which are not allotted for several years. There is also a Government Policy which contends provisions on allotment of shop to spouse of an ex-servicemen and the appellant is spouse and dependent of an ex-serviceman. Considering same, it is pointed out that proceedings should be dismissed. The stock be taken by the Union at fair market value or permitted to continue till all the stock is sold out. The Estate Officer conducted hearing and after hearing both the sides passed the order of eviction. Hence, present appeal. 4. Heard both the sides. Considered their submissions. Perused the appeal memo, record and proceedings and considered the submissions Following points arise for my consideration and I answer the same as under for the reasons stated hereinafter; Sr. No. POINTS FINDINGS 1. Whether the appellant can be said to be unauthorized occupant ? :: In the affirmative. 2. Whether the impugned order requires any interference ? :: In the negative. 3. What order ? :: As per final order. REASONS As to Point No.1 -- 3 of 11 -- ... 4 … Order in Misc. Appeal 08 of 2025 5. The aspect of execution of Leave and License agreement and their period is not disputed by the appellant. It is also not disputed that no fresh leave and License agreement has been entered into or is subsisting at the time when the notice and proceedings under Public Premises Act were initiated. It is further necessary to point out that in such circumstances, the provisions of Public Premises Act contemplates that if a person exceeds the permitted period, is to be treated as unauthorized occupancy. Thus, on the face of it, appellant is an unauthorized occupant. 6. In such circumstances, it is for the appellant to show further cause for occupation. There are two circumstances pointed out (a) that appellant is allottee and not a licensee, (b) that renewal is a norm and hence there should be automatic renewal & (c) balance stock in trade. 7. As regards, nature of occupation, there is contention is put up which is the defence of Section 55 of the Maharashtra Rent Control Act. I shall consider this legal issue firstly before proceeding with other factual aspects. The provisions of Section 55 of Maharashtra Rent Control Act have been placed to protect the tenant by restraining the landlord from executing any unregistered document. 8. Much was harped upon by respondent that the aspect that Maharashtra Rent Control Act will not be applicable. The law laid down is clear that except aspect of dispossession and aspects that are covered under the Public Premises Act, the provisions of other general laws/ special rent control provisions could be applicable to such premises. It is necessary to point out that the premises being Central Government premises are also excluded from the -- 4 of 11 -- ... 5 … Order in Misc. Appeal 08 of 2025 provisions of Maharashtra Rent Control Act. Section 55 of the Maharashtra Rent Control Act comes with unique opening which contemplates that “Notwithstanding anything contained in this Act or any other law for the time being in force”. Thus, even the provisions of exclusion of the Premises is not applicable and considering same, and hence the provisions of Maharashtra Rent Control Act namely provisions of Section 55 will be squarely applicable. Considering also that the provisions of Section 55 of Maharashtra Rent Control Act are in no way in conflict or contrary to provisions of Public Premises Act or dealing with any of the process or powers under Public Premises Act, provisions of Section 55 of Maharashtra Rent Control Act will be applicable. 9. Sub-section 1 of section 55 of Maharashtra Rent Control Act contemplates that every agreement of leave of licensee or letting of any premises shall be registered. Sub-section 2 of Section 55 of Maharashtra Rent Control Act contemplates that “the Landlord shall get it registered and in absence of written registered agreement, the contention of the tenant about the terms and conditions subject to which a premises has been given to him by landlord on leave and license or have been let to him shall prevail, unless proved otherwise”. 10. The Judgment of Anwar Noormohammed Pirani V/s Santosh Gajanan Naskulwar (2020(6) Mh.L.J) holds that provisions of Section 55 of the Maharashtra Rent Control Act override the provisions of the Registration Act and registration of said agreement is mandatory. 11. In such circumstances, one has to consider the provisions of Subsection 2 of Section 55 of the Maharashtra Rent Control Act. It gives right to tenant to claim terms as ststed by him to be -- 5 of 11 -- ... 6 … Order in Misc. Appeal 08 of 2025 correct, inspite of execution/non execution of unregistered leave and license agreement. It is so only if he claims it and it is not so automatically. It is for the occupier to claim such right that the premises was let out on a particular set of terms favourable to the occupant. 12. Thus, one has to consider whether the present appellant has invoked the protection or right contemplated under Section 55 (2) of Maharashtra Rent Control Act. If reply to the notice dated 05.12.2024, reply to proceedings dated 21.12.2024, affidavit of evidence filed before Ld. Estate Officer is considered, at no moment of time or in no words does the appellant claims that premises was let out to the appellant. It contemplates that leave and license agreement were executed and as per clause in the said agreement, it is to be renewed. If that is the case, the appellant has not raised any claim of letting or any other beneficial terms for occupying the premises. 13. The word of “allotment” of premises was highlighted as a beneficial term. Allotment of premises can be of various terms and conditions which includes leave and license, letting out temporary occupation, etc. Thus, it does not help the case of appellant any further or imply permanent allotment. On considering all these facts and circumstances, the appellant can have no help from invoking Section 55 of Maharashtra Rent Control Act. 14. The affidavit of evidence is filed lastly by the present appellant and hence I shall consider it to be a most thought over reply to proceedings as contemplated. The appellant contemplates that appellant applied to competent authority for renewal of license. Once there is a provision or procedure established for renewal it -- 6 of 11 -- ... 7 … Order in Misc. Appeal 08 of 2025 implies that earlier agreement has elapsed or determined as lapsed by efflux of time. 15. The challenge of non renewal of the agreement is on the basis and it is alleged mala-fides on account of civil suit being filed. Apparently, if one considers sequence of events, present appellant is occupying the said premises since the year 2011 i.e. for about 14 years thereof. Number of agreements have been executed on further similar terms entered into. 16. The aspect that the agreement was executed for only 74 days was highlighted. It is necessary to point out that there was delay in execution of agreement and hence balance days agreement was executed. Even then, thereafter agreements were executed on three occasions of which no grievance is made. There is no grievance made of agreements earlier executed for 11 months and then for 6 months and then for 3 months or for 74 days at one instance. Thus, if one considers all these circumstances, the execution of agreement is accepted and its terms are accepted. 17. If one considers the last paragraph , even the appellant does not intend to continue occupation but is only worried about the stock in trade. I shall consider the facts of this stock in trade at subsequent place hereinafter but suffice to say, even the appellant is not intending to continue the business . Thus, if one considers all these facts and circumstances, the aspect of leave of license agreement being accepted and its term being ended, the appellant is unauthorized occupant of the said premises. 18. Third aspect with regard to stock has to be considered. Again, portion of leave and license agreement as regards nature of conducting the business is not disputed. It is necessary to point out that these premises are in defence areas and hence additional -- 7 of 11 -- ... 8 … Order in Misc. Appeal 08 of 2025 security or additional clauses with regard to conduct of business incorporated therein are seen. There is also restriction with regard to nature of business to be carried. All along, nature of business to be carried on is a “ladies tailoring”. One fails to understand as to how readymade clothes , socks, uniform articles fall within the definition of “Ladies Tailoring” and no explanation is given in that regard. The stock list only relates to such readymade articles. Thus not related to permitted use. 19. There is a clause which contends that the Union or Naval authorities can make certain conditions with regard to stock being kept and what articles to be placed. Clause 18 (8) contemplates that the licensee shall be liable to procure, store and maintain equipment stores, products or things for the purpose of agreement at his own cost and risk and shall not claim any compensation, concession from licensor for any reasons mentioned therein and the licensee shall consult the licensor before procuring any equipment, stores, products, things, and get them approved. 20. Thus, (a) The shop premises was not let out for selling of any uniforms, dresses readymade articles as contemplated by the appellant, (b) the appellant never requested or prayed for permission for stocking these articles, (c) respondents of naval authorities never consented for nor accepted any request nor did they direct, maintenance of such stock or minimum stock as stated by the appellants. 21. It is thus, just a contention put to pressurize naval authorities into continuing with occupation and to show that authorities would have to pay huge compensation or bear loss for said stock. I think, this is a moonshine defence taken up by the appellant and -- 8 of 11 -- ... 9 … Order in Misc. Appeal 08 of 2025 ought to be rejected forthwith. 22. The appellant conducted business for more than 14 years and has earned profit thereby. It is at her own risk, cost and consequences that she had to deal with her business and accordingly she has dealt with it. If she maintains stock beyond her selling power, she has to blame herself for the same. Hence, I do not consider this as a ground for reject the claim of unauthorized occupancy. Hence, I answer Point No.1 in the affirmative. As to Point No.2 23. Having considered these circumstances, another issue with regard to policy of Naval Authorities of allotment of shops was raised. One of the contentions raised in reply is relating to it and accordingly it has been considered by the Learned Estate Officer. It is not ground for eviction. Even E.O. pointed out that the appellant can consider to apply under new policy and it will be allotted on its own merits. Therefore, it was consideration of defence raised and not consideration of ground of eviction. Thus, having considered this Ld. Estate Officer has clearly pointed out that the appellant herein is an unauthorized occupant having overstayed her occupation beyond period of agreement and hence findings of Ld. Estate Officer cannot be found fault with. Hence, I answer Point No.2 in the negative. 24. Having considered all these circumstances, it is also part of record that appellant is spouse of ex-serviceman. The aspect of stock being existing is not denied by the naval authorities although liability is denied. In such circumstances, I intend to give a small extended period to vacate. Hence, I pass the following order. -- 9 of 11 -- ... 10 … Order in Misc. Appeal 08 of 2025 O R D E R 1. Misc. Appeal No.08 of 2025 is hereby dismissed. 2. The appellant/s to handover possession of said premises on or before 30.06.2025. Time is granted to the appellant/s to vacate the premises till 30.06.2025 subject to appellant/s filing an undertaking before this Court within 4 weeks from today that the appellant/s is/are in physical occupation of the premises and that appellant/s will not create any third party interest in the said property and further appellant/s will honour the order of the Learned Competent Authority on its attaining finality. 3. If the appellant fails to give or honour the undertaking given to this Court, the possession be recovered as per impugned order by following due process of law. 4. Inform the concerned Learned Competent Authority. 5. Record and Proceedings be sent back to respondents. 6. Misc. Appeal No.08 of 2025 is disposed off accordingly. 7. All Miscellaneous applications, if any, are disposed off accordingly. DATE : 21.04.2025 (A.SUBRAMANIAM) PRINCIPAL JUDGE CITY CIVIL COURT, MUMBAI. (JO CODE MH01711). Dictated on : 21.04.2025. Transcribed on : 21.04.2025. Checked on : 30.04.2025. Signed by HHJ on : 30.04.2025. -- 10 of 11 -- ... 11 … Order in Misc. Appeal 08 of 2025 "CERTIFIED TO BE TRUE AND CORRECT COPY OF THE ORIGINAL SIGNED JUDGMENT/ORDER" UPLOAD DATE AND TIME NAME OF STENOGRAPHER (Grade-III) DATE : 30.04.2025 at 05.58p.m Mr. Mohit M. Patange Name of the Judge (with Court no.) : SHRI A.SUBRAMANIAM. C.R.NO.19. Date of pronouncement of judgment/order : 21.04.2025 Judgment/order signed by the P.O. on : 30.04.2025 Judgment/order uploaded on : 30.04.2025 -- 11 of 11 --
