Full Order Text
Final Order 1 · 07 May 2024 · CNR MHCC010011832024
Order Details: Notice of Motion Pdf Text: ..1.. IN THE BOMBAY CITY CIVIL COURT FOR GREATER MUMBAI NOTICE OF MOTION NO.462 OF 2024 IN SUIT NO.734 OF 2021 (CNR NO.MHCC01-001183-2024) Mrs. Hansaben Manilal Panchal ).. Plaintiff. V/s. The MHADA and Anr. ).. Defendants. Appearances :- Ld. Adv. Mr. Shivam Mishra h/f. Adv. Kamlesh Tiwari for plaintiff. Ld. Adv. Ms. Harshida Darji h/f. Adv. Kandekar for defendant Nos.1 to 3/MHADA. Ld. Adv. Mr. K. K. Jadhav for defendant No.5. CORAM : HIS HONOUR JUDGE V. V. PATIL COURT ROOM NO.09 DATE : 7th MAY, 2024. ORDER Plaintiff has taken out present Notice of Motion for passing temporary order of injunction restraining defendants, from dispossessing or throwing the plaintiff from exclusive use and occupation of suit premises without any due process of law. 2. In short, it is the case of the plaintiff that she is in exclusive use and occupation of room No.3, on the ground floor, Madhav Bhavan situated at 94-B-Ward No.GS-2309 (I), N. M. Joshi Marg, Lower Parel, -- 1 of 9 -- ..2.. Mumbai – 400 013 (hereinafter referred to as ‘Suit Premises’ and property alongwith Madhav Bhavan referred as ‘Said Property’) since last 30 years alongwith other family members. The rent bill is in joint name of the Ushaben Panchal though the plaintiff is in exclusive use and occupation of the said premises. Defendant No.4 through their architect submitted a proposal for redevelopment of said Madhav Bhavan vide its letter dated 11.12.2008 under DC Rule 33(7) and sought NOC of defendant Nos.2 and 3. Accordingly, defendant No.2 issued ‘No Objection’ Certificate to defendant No.4 for redevelopment of the said property. The plaintiff was shocked and surprised after knowing that her name in the column of occupant has been mentioned alongwith Smt. Ushaben Shantilal Panchal and Jaikishan D. Mistry which is factually incorrect. After going through the record list of tenant/occupants the plaintiff found that the name of the plaintiff who is original tenant and occupant of the said room No.3 was present at the time of inception and also submitted required documents but inadvertently, the office bearer of defendant Nos.1 to 3 failed and neglected to note down the presence of the plaintiff and her family who are in exclusive use and occupation of room No.3. The plaintiff is using the said premises as a residential premises since, 1995. 3. Defendant Nos.1 to 3 also issued public notice dated 10.07.1998 pertaining to the said property and suit property. In the said public notice, name of plaintiff and defendant No.5 was shown as tenant and in the occupant column, it is shown blank and use of the suit premises was mentioned as residential. In the column of occupant in the NOC dated 20.06.2009, defendant No.1 has deliberately failed and -- 2 of 9 -- ..3.. neglected to record the name of plaintiff in the column of occupant though plaintiff is in exclusive use and occupation of the suit premises. Plaintiff after knowing that factually incorrect list have been prepared by defendant Nos. 1 to 3 immediately wrote letter to the defendant and asked to rectify their mistake. The plaintiff apprehends that defendant No.4, their servants and agents, in collusion with the officers of defendant Nos.1 to 3 may evict the plaintiff from suit premises. Hence, plaintiff has constrained to file present suit for declaration that she is in exclusive use and occupation of the suit premises. By the said Notice of Motion, plaintiff prayed for passing interim injunction against defendants. Consequently, plaintiff prayed for allowing Notice of Motion. 4. Defendant No.5 has filed Affidavit-in-Reply to Notice of Motion and strongly opposed the same. It is submitted that admittedly, suit premises room No.3 is tenanted premises. The rent receipts are standing in the joint names of Hansaben Patel (Plaintiff) and Ushaben Patel (Defendant No.6). Plaintiff has not came to the Court with clean hands and has opposed the suit on false facts. Plaintiff, with her family members including her husband, are residing in room No.3 which is rented premises. Defendant No.5 is occupying room Nos. 3 to 5, Upper Floors as well as room No.2 which premises are rented premises, rent receipts of which are standing in the joint names of defendant No.5, defendant No.6 and the plaintiff. It is submitted that Shri. Dayaram Mistry and his wife Taraben Mistry had four sons viz. Manilal, late Shantilal, Jay krishna (Defendant No.5) and Pankaj. The family is carpenter (Mistry/Sutar). The family was residing on First floor, Bara -- 3 of 9 -- ..4.. Chawl, Sun Mill Compound, Tulsipipe Road, Lower Parel, Mumbai. Father and mother expired and two brothers Manilal Panchal, the husband of plaintiff and Shantilal Panchal put their surname as ‘Panchal’ while defendant No.5 put his surname as ‘Mistry’. The mother Taraben was residing with 3 brothers as 4th brother Pankaj had acquired premises at Mulund and then shifted to Valsad and never got participated with the family. After death of father, three brothers acquired room No.A-41 on tenanted basis and thereafter acquired premises No.A-36 on tenanted basis and somewhere in the year 1967, they acquired premises room No.2 in the name of defendant No.5 on tenanted basis. Thus, all brothers acquire separate tenanted premises from the common funds, but the family was joint till then. 5. By this period, since the family was increasing, the three brothers first acquired room No.3 in the joint names of Smt. Hansaben and Ushaben. At that time, this defendants was bachelor. Thereafter, in the year 1982, adjoining premises i.e. room No.4 was acquired by 3 brothers in the joint name of Ushaben, Hansaben and Jay Krishna i.e. defendant No.5. Said premises Nos. 3 and 4 were commercial premises and there was upper premises. At the same time, the family acquired room No.3 and 4 of the upper floor i.e. room No.3 and 4 in the name of Hansaben, Jay Krishna Mistry, wife of defendant No.5. 6. The work of carpentery was carried out in room No.3 and 4 and upper floor area was used for storing the articles. Somewhere in the year 1992, the property situated at Madhav Bhavan Compound wherein room No.A-41 and A-46 were situated was taken for redevelopment by -- 4 of 9 -- ..5.. MHADA authorities. After vacating the said rooms for redevelopment, with mutual decision between all the 3 families, Room No.3 was used as carpentry workshop while room No.4 was used jointly by Shantilal and the plaintiff with their families and upper floor room i.e. Room No.3/4, upper floor was occupied by defendant No.5 and his family members. However, access continued to all the family members in all the three premises i.e. Room No.3 and 4, upper floor 3/4. Since, Room No.3 was used for carpentry work during day time, defendant No.5 was using Room No. 2 for personal and work purpose, while during night, any of the family members were using the said room for sleeping. Later, in the year 2008 with mutual understanding with plaintiff and Shantilal i.e. defendant No.5, plaintiff and his family moved to Room No.3, Shantilal and his family moved to Room No.4 and defendant No.5 continued to occupy upper floor Room No.3/4. As it stands today, ground floor Room No.3 is being used by Manilal, the husband of plaintiff and his family. Ground floor room No.4 is being used by family members of Shantilal and entire upper floor portion i.e. room No.3/4 is used by the family members of defendant No.5. Therefore, the contention of the plaintiff is totally false that she is in exclusive possession of room No.3. Since, plaintiff has concealed all the above facts from the Court and also concealed fact that defendant o.5 is in possession of the suit property, she is not entitled to any of the relief as claimed. Hence, it is prayed that Notice of Motion be dismissed. 7. Perused the Notice of Motion & Affidavit-in-support of Notice of Motion as well as reply filed by advocate for defendant No.5 and 6. The following points arise for my determination and I have -- 5 of 9 -- ..6.. recorded my findings to each of them for the reasons stated below :- Sr. No. POINTS FINDINGS 1. Whether the plaintiff has made out prima facie case in her favour ? In the Negative. 2. Whether balance of convenience lies in favour of plaintiff ? In the Negative. 3. Whether irreparable loss will be caused to the plaintiff, if present Notice of Motion is not allowed ? In the Negative. 4. What order? As per the final order R E A S O N S AS TO POINT No.1 to 3: 8. As point Nos.1 to 3 are interlinked with each other, I am discussing them together to avoid repetition. 9. Heard Ld. Advocate for both the sides. It is argued on behalf of plaintiff that plaintiff is in exclusive use and occupation of room No.3. However, in the NOC issued by MHADA in 2009 and tenancy list at serial No.3, name of defendant No.5 is shown as occupant. Name of plaintiff in the column of occupant has been mentioned alongwith defendant No.5 and defendant No.6. It is submitted that how name of defendant No.5 can be included by MHADA without any documentary evidence. Defendant No.5 has no concern with the suit premises and he was never occupant of the suit premises and he is not entitled for permanent alternate accommodation. -- 6 of 9 -- ..7.. 10. As against this, it is argued by Ld. Advocate for defendant No.5 that since defendant No.5 was found occupying the room No.3, alongwith plaintiff and defendant No.6, their names were shown as occupant in the tenanted/occupant list prepared by MHADA. The plaintiff is seeking rectification of Annexure-II i.e. list of tenants annexed with NOC dated 20.06.2009. However, suit is not maintainable before this Court. Plaintiff is praying for declaration that she is tenant of the suit premises. In view of the matter, the present suit is not maintainable within jurisdiction of this Court. 11. It appears from the rival contentions and documents produced on record that plaintiff has not came before Court with clean hands and has suppressed material fact. Plaintiff has even not disclosed the relationship between the parties. It is submitted on behalf of plaintiff that how name of third person can be included by MHADA in the tenant/occupant list. However, plaintiff has not disclosed that defendant No.5 are brothers of plaintiff’s husband. Defendant No.5 has given in detail the rights acquired by all the brothers in their respective properties. According to defendant, as per mutual understanding between the brothers, ground floor Room No.3 is being used by plaintiff, ground floor Room No.4 is being used by defendant No.6 and entire upper portion i.e. Room No.3/4 is being used by defendant No.5 and defendant is having payment receipts of municipal license fees, rent receipts as well as electricity bills of all the 3 premises i.e. Room No.3, 4 and upper Room No.3/4, some of which are annexed with their reply which fortifies the contention of defendant. Further more, the MHADA, by following regular procedure has prepared the list of tenant/occupant -- 7 of 9 -- ..8.. wherein names of defendant No.5, 6 and plaintiff were noted as occupant. Therefore, it can be prima facie seen that, plaintiff, defendant No.5 and defendant No.6 are in possession of the suit premises. Therefore, the contention of the plaintiff can not be believed that she was in exclusive use and occupation of the suit premises. Since, defendant Nos. 5 and 6 are also in possession of the suit premises, plaintiff can not be seek injunction against them as prayed. Thus, for all the above reasons, I hold that plaintiff has failed to make out prima facie case for grant of reliefs in the Notice of Motion. Balance of conveyance also does not lie in favour of plaintiff. In such circumstances, no irreparable loss will be caused to the plaintiff, if reliefs as claimed in the Notice of Motion are not allowed. As against this, defendant will definitely suffer irreparable loss, if prayer in the Notice of Motion are granted. Hence, I answer point Nos. 1 to 3 in the negative and hold that Notice of Motion is devoid of merits and is liable to be dismissed. In the result, I proceed to pass the following order :- ORDER Notice of Motion No. 462 of 2024 in Suit No.734 of 2021 stands rejected and disposed of accordingly. (Order dictated & pronounced in open Court) (V. V. PATIL) Judge, City Civil Court, Dated : 07.05.2024 C.R. No.09, Gr. Mumbai. -- 8 of 9 -- ..9.. Dictated on : 07.05.2024 Transcribed on : 10.05.2024 Signed on : 10.05.2024 “Certified to be true and correct copy of the original signed order”. 10.05.2024 at about 16.30 p.m. (Manisha D. Hirole) Stenographer (Grade-I.) Court Room No.09, Gr. Mumbai. Name of the Hon'ble Judge : HHJ MR. VAIBHAV V. PATIL (C.R.NO.09) Date of pronouncement of Order : 07.05.2024 Order signed by Hon'ble Judge on : 10.05.2024 Order uploaded on : 10.05.2024 -- 9 of 9 --
