Skip to main content
Commercial Suit

Anand Chhaganlal ThakkarVsIndiabulls Housing Finance Ltd. +1 more

CNR MHCC01001030202031-COURT 31 ADDL SESSIONS JUDGE
Fort, City Civil Court
Mumbai · Maharashtra (MH)
PENDING

TrustJury record updated 27 Sept 2026

Case Overview

Registration Number
100063/2020
Registration Date
28 Jan 2020
Case Stage
FOR TAKING STEPS

Advocates

3

Parties

3

Acts & Sections

1
Protection of Women from Domestic Violence Act · Sec 9

Case Timeline

Newest first82 dates/groups
Case ongoingFinal outcome awaited ···

18 Aug 2026

1 record
Court Proceeding

Adv. Reshma Salunkhe for plaintiff present. Adv. Shreya Gupte i/b Hedgehog LLP and Fox for defendant No.1 present through VC and prayed for time to take…

Next purpose: FOR TAKING STEPS
Read full proceeding
Business: Adv. Reshma Salunkhe for plaintiff present.
Adv. Shreya Gupte i/b Hedgehog LLP and Fox for defendant No.1 present through VC and prayed for time to take steps.
O- Time granted.
Matter stands Adj to [date withheld]  for steps.
Next Purpose: FOR TAKING STEPS

03 Jul 2026

1 record
Court Proceeding

Adv. Sanjay Manek for plaintiff present. Adv. Soumya Udasi for defendant No.1 present and tendered registered Ch/Sum 1128/2026 along with supporting…

Next purpose: FOR TAKING STEPS
Read full proceeding
Business: Adv. Sanjay Manek for plaintiff present.
Adv. Soumya Udasi for defendant No.1 present and tendered registered Ch/Sum 1128/2026 along with supporting affidavit. TOR.
Adv. Nitin Kamble for defendant No.2 present.
Kept back for order on Ch/Sum and NM.
ORDER IN CHAMBER SUMMONS NO.1128/2026
        The chamber summons is filed the defendant No.1 seeking to correct the amount in the examination-in-chief affidavit from Rs.2,63,90,644.97 to Rs.48,39,237.18. By filing reply the same is strongly objected. Heard Adv. Udasi for defendant No.1 and Adv. Manek for plaintiff. According to Adv. Udasi the correction occurred due to typographical mistake which needs to be corrected. Whereas Adv. Manek submitted that by way of the said chamber summons, the defendant No.1 is seeking amendment in the evidence affidavit which is not at all permitted. When query was raised with Adv. Udasi about provision in CPC or in the BSA regarding amendment in the evidence affidavit, she was unable to point out any provision. As per my view there is no any provision in seeking correction/amendment in the evidence affidavit. In Arun Bhika Mahale V/s Ishwarlal Onkar Marathe, 2013/MHLJ Online 44, the Honble High Court at held that in some circumstances where the parties realizes some errors in the affidavit in lieu of examination-in-chief, he is entitled to lead further examination-in-chief or can also filed an affidavit. But the Court can not order deletion of any portion of the said affidavit. In view of the said view, I am of view that the only thing the defendant No.1 can do is filed and additional examination-in-chief affidavit. Therefore, the present chamber summons is devoid of any merit. IN the result I proceed to pass following order.
ORDER
    1. The Chamber Summons 1128/2026 is dismissed with costs.

    2. The Chamber Summons 1128/2026 is disposed of.
       ORDER IN NOTICE OF MOTION NO.6833/2025
     The Notice of Motion is filed to lead secondary evidence by relying on the photocopies of the original documents. By filing reply if any strongly objected. Heard Adv. Udasi for defendant No.1 and Adv. Manek for plaintiff. According to Adv. Udasi the defendant NO.1 want to rely on the photocopies of the original made by mechanical process which is mentioned in Exh.8. The same are not with him. Whereas Adv. Manek vehemently opposed the said submission on the ground that the proposed photocopies Exh.8 is not filed along with the Notice of Motion. Therefore, the prayer made in the name is vague and without particular. Before going into the merit of the NM, the question is whether an application /NM is required to lead secondary evidence. On this point, the Honble Bombay High Court in Parasanbai Dhanraj Jai and Ors. vs. Sunanda Madhukar Jadhav, 203-CRA82-16.DOC observed
I have recently set out the law on this and I will say so briefly once again either secondary evidence is led or it is not led. Either the provisions of Section 65 are met or they are not met. No permission of a Court is required to lead evidence of any kind. No judge in the subordinate judiciary to this High Court will hereafter will insist on any such application under any circumstances whatsoever. I do not think I can put it in any clearer terms than this. Any such order is wholly illegal and liable to be set aside. A copy of this order is not to be circulated to every Civil Judge in the State of Maharashtra. There is absolutely no question of an application, whether styled as an interim application or a MARJI application, for permission to lead secondary evidence. The Court cannot refuse that permission, and it cannot insist on an application for any such permission.
Further in Shaikh Aftab Ahmed and ors V/s Bhimrao and ors. (MANU/MH/2743/2021) it was held, that permission to lead secondary evidence without the leave of the court and without an application can be allowed if the same finds place in the pleading or in the evidence. The Honble Apex Court in Dhanpat v/s Sheo Ram (2020) 16 S.C.C 209, held there is no need to file an application to lead secondary evidence if sufficient foundation is led in pleading or in the evidence. If, the observation made in the above referred authorities taken into consideration the practice of insisting applicant to file an application to lead secondary evidence  is deprecated.  At the most the same can be pleaded in the evidence affidavit under Order 18 of the C.P.C. Considering the same, I am of the view that, the present NM is not tenable. At the most, the defendant No.1 can incorporate the same in his evidence affidavit, if his desire so, in the result, I proceed to following order
ORDER
    1. The Notice of Motion 6833/2025 is dismissed with costs.

    2. The Notice of Motion 6833/2025 is disposed of.

Matter stands Adj to [date withheld] for steps.
Next Purpose: FOR TAKING STEPS

07 May 2026

1 record
Court Proceeding

P.O. IS ON LEAVE.

Next purpose: CHAMBER SUMMONS
Read full proceeding
Business: P.O. IS ON LEAVE.
Next Purpose: CHAMBER SUMMONS

09 Apr 2026

1 record
Court Proceeding

Adv. Sanjay Manek for plaintiff present. Adv. Shreya Gupte i/b Hedgehog and Fox for defendant No.1 present. Advocate for defendant No.1 filed draft…

Next purpose: CHAMBER SUMMONS
Read full proceeding
Business: Adv. Sanjay Manek for plaintiff present.
Adv. Shreya Gupte i/b Hedgehog and Fox for defendant No.1 present.
       Advocate for defendant No.1 filed draft Chamber Summons along with supporting affidavit. TOR.
O. Leave is granted to register the same.
Copy be served on other side.
Matter stands Adj to [date withheld] for tendering registered Ch/Sum.
Next Purpose: CHAMBER SUMMONS

09 Mar 2026

1 record
Court Proceeding

Adv. Reshma Salunkhe i/b S. T. Manek and Co. for plaintiff p resent. Adv. Shreya Gupte i/b Hedgehog and Fox LLP for defendant No.1 present. Defendant No.1…

Next purpose: NM ARGUMENTS
Read full proceeding
Business: Adv. Reshma Salunkhe i/b S. T. Manek and Co.  for plaintiff p resent.
Adv. Shreya Gupte i/b Hedgehog and Fox LLP for defendant No.1 present.
       Defendant No.1 paid costs Rs.10,000/- to advocate for plaintiff.
Matter stands Adj to [date withheld] for argument on NM.
Next Purpose: NM  ARGUMENTS

12 Feb 2026

1 record
Court Proceeding

Adv. Reshma Salunkhe for plaintiff present. Adv. Pranjali Khemnar for defendant no.1 present through VC. Advocate for defendant no.1 requested for time to…

Next purpose: COMPLIANCE
Read full proceeding
Business: Adv. Reshma Salunkhe for plaintiff present.
Adv. Pranjali Khemnar for defendant no.1 present through VC.
Advocate for defendant no.1 requested for time to argue NM on reason that defendant no.1 want to move chamber summons for amendment. It a suit of year 2020. Defendant no.1 filed evidence affidavit and compilation of documents on 16.09.2025. It appears defendant no.1 was always aware that original documents are not defendant no.1. defendant no.1 has consumed too much time in taking appropriates steps promptly. Hence, adjournment is granted on cost of Rs. 10,000/- to be paid to plaintiff on or before next date.
Matter stands Adj to [date withheld] for compliance.
Later on at 12.05.2026
Adv. Kiran Goswami for defendant no.2 present through VC.
Next Purpose: COMPLIANCE

05 Jan 2026

1 record
Court Proceeding

Adv. Reshma Salunkhe i/b S. T. Manek and Co. for plaintiff present. Adv. Nishtha Garhwal i/b Hedgehog and Fox LLP for defendant No.1 present. Adv.…

Next purpose: NM ARGUMENTS
Read full proceeding
Business: Adv. Reshma Salunkhe i/b S. T. Manek and Co. for plaintiff present.
Adv. Nishtha Garhwal i/b Hedgehog and Fox LLP for defendant No.1
present.
Adv. Shreyashi Panda for defendant No.2 present through VC.
    Advocate for defendant No.1 tendered the registered Notice of Motion No.6833/2025 along with affidavit in support. TOR
Exh.33 Reply to NM No.6833/2025 filed by plaintiff.
Copy is served on defendant No.1.
Matter stands Adj to [date withheld] for argument on NM 6833/2025.
Next Purpose: NM  ARGUMENTS

21 Nov 2025

1 record
Court Proceeding

Adv. Reshma Salunkhe i/b S. T. Manek and Co. for plaintiff present. Adv. Shreya Gupte for defendant No.1 present through VC. Adv. Shreyashi Panda for…

Next purpose: NOTICE OF MOTION
Read full proceeding
Business: Adv. Reshma Salunkhe i/b S. T. Manek and Co. for plaintiff present.
Adv. Shreya Gupte for defendant No.1 present through VC.
Adv. Shreyashi Panda for defendant No.2 present through VC.
Kept back. Later on at 01.15 pm
Same appearance for plaintiff and defendants.
        Plaintiff closed evidence on 21-06-2024. Defendant No.1 fild evidence affidavit at Exh.31 and compilation of documents at Exh.32. For two dates, suit was posted for further examination in chief and marking of documents of defendant No.1. On backdrop of this, Advocate for defendant No.1 filed draft Notice of Motion along with affidavit in support. TOR.
O. Leave is granted to register the same.
Copy is served on plaintiff.
Matter stands Adj to [date withheld]  for tendering registered NM/ reply by plaintiff on NM.
Next Purpose: NOTICE OF MOTION

27 Oct 2025

1 record
Court Proceeding

Adv. Reshma Salunkhe i/b S. T. Manek and Co. for plaintiff present. None present for defendant. Kept back for further examination in chief and marking of…

Next purpose: RECORDING EVIDENCE
Read full proceeding
Business: Adv. Reshma Salunkhe i/b S. T. Manek and Co.  for plaintiff present.
None present for defendant.
Kept back for further examination in chief and marking of documents of defendant.
Court is busy in Judgment Com Suit 213/2023, 156/2022 and order on NM 406/2025, Hence, matter stands Adj to [date withheld] for further examination in chief.
Next Purpose: RECORDING EVIDENCE

16 Sept 2025

1 record
Court Proceeding

Adv. Reshma Salunkhe i/b S. T. Manek and Co for plaintiff present. Adv. Pranjali Khemnar for defendant No.1 present. Exh.31 Evidence affidavit of…

Next purpose: RECORDING EVIDENCE
Read full proceeding
Business: Adv. Reshma Salunkhe i/b S. T. Manek and Co for plaintiff present.
Adv. Pranjali Khemnar for defendant No.1 present.
Exh.31  Evidence affidavit of defendant witness No.1.
O. Read and recorded.
Exh.32 Compilation of documents filed by defendant No.1.
O. Read and recorded.
Copies served on other side.
Matter stands Adj to [date withheld] for further examination in chief and marking of documents.
Next Purpose: RECORDING EVIDENCE

Additional Case Details

Additional Case Details
Filing Number: 101201/2020
Filing Date: 27-01-2020
First Hearing Date: 31st January 2020
Court Number And Judge: 31-COURT 31  ADDL SESSIONS JUDGE

TrustJury presents public court-record information for legal discovery and reference. Record availability and detail can vary by source and case.