Full Order Text
Final Order 2 · 08 Oct 2024 · CNR MHCC010008722024
Order Details: Notice of Motion Pdf Text: NM 326/24 in SU 3113/19 1 C.R.8 MHCC010008722024 IN THE BOMBAY CITY CIVIL COURT AT BOMBAY NOTICE OF MOTION NO. 326 OF 2024 IN SUIT NO. 3113 OF 2019 Helan Anthony Sabastian and Anr. ] ...Plaintiffs. Versus MHADA ]…Defendant. Appearances: Adv. Holambe Patil for plaintiff. None for defendant/MHADA. CORAM : V.G. RAGHUWANSHI JUDGE, (C.R.NO.08) DATE : 08/10/2024 ORAL ORDER 1. Perused notice of motion, affidavit in support thereof. Heard learned counsel for plaintiff. This notice of motion is taken for restoring notice of motion No.4667/2019 to its original stage at which it was on 17.08.2022. 2. It is contention of plaintiff that, she and her husband filed the suit challenging notice dated 14.11.2019. It was alleged by defendant No.2 that, plaintiff and her husband carried unauthorised construction. Defendant No.2 called upon plaintiff remove said construction. Defendant No.2 threatened to demolish suit premises if plaintiffs failed to remove it. Pending hearing and disposal of suit, plaintiff’s took out -- 1 of 4 -- NM 326/24 in SU 3113/19 2 C.R.8 notice of motion no.4667/2019 for interim and ad-interim reliefs restraining defendants from demolishing suit premises. The Hon’ble Court directed to both parties to maintain status-quo by order dated 02.12.2019. Advocate A.A. Jain used to appear for plaintiffs. Plaintiff No.2 and advocate A.A. Jain were attending said matter time to time. 3. Unfortunately, plaintiff No.2 passed away on 19.08.2020 during pandemic. Plaintiff No.1 was in grief and shock due to sudden demise of her husband. She was not in position to attend the Court. She learnt that, Adv. Jain was attending the matter. Plaintiff had filed another suit in respect of suit premises and engaged Adv. Holambe Patil in that case. That suit came for hearing and plaintiff No.1 appeared in that suit for cross examination on 30.10.2023. At that time, plaintiff remembered about this suit. Therefore, she tried to contact Adv. Jain. He was not receiving calls for about 8-9 days. Eventually, he received call of plaintiff on 24.11.2023. He informed plaintiff that, he suffered heart attack during pandemic and was admitted in hospital several times. He was unable to attend Court and due to serious illness, he stopped practice. He told plaintiff that, during that period he lost his mobile phone and therefore, he was unable to contact plaintiff. The entire record in his office was destroyed due to white ants and water leakages in his office. He advised plaintiff to engage another lawyer and get certified copies of the file. Accordingly, plaintiff engaged Adv. Holambe Patil, got certified copies and filed this notice of motion for restoring notice of motion No.4667/2019. 4. Defendant were served but they did not appear. Therefore, this notice of motion was heard ex-parte. I have heard learned counsel for plaintiff. He reiterated contents of this notice of motion and prayed for -- 2 of 4 -- NM 326/24 in SU 3113/19 3 C.R.8 restoring the notice of motion. Having regards to the circumstances prevailing and reasons mentioned in the affidavit, I think discretion needs to be exercised in favour of plaintiff. The plaintiff has assigned sufficient reason for not appearing before court and not taking steps. Accordingly, I pass following order: Order 1. Notice of Motion No.326 of 2024 is allowed. 2. Order dt.17.08.2022 dismissing notice of motion No.4667/2019 is set aside and said notice of motion is restored to file of this Court to its original stage at which it was on 17.08.2022. 3. Notice of Motion No.326 of 2024 is disposed off accordingly. Date : 08/10/2024. (Shri. V.G. Raghuwanshi) Judge City Civil Court, Gr. Mumbai. -- 3 of 4 -- NM 326/24 in SU 3113/19 4 C.R.8 “CERTIFIED TO BE TRUE AND CORRECT COPY OF THE ORIGINAL SIGNED JUDGMENT/ORDER.” UPLOAD DATE AND TIME NAME OF STENOGRAPHER 14/10/2024 & 12.03 P.M. Mrs. Shravanti Karre Name of the Judge (With Court room no.) Shri V.G. Raghuwanshi (Court Room No.08) Date of Pronouncement of JUDGMENT/ORDER 08/10/2024 JUDGMENT/ORDER signed by P.O. on 09/10/2024 JUDGMENT/ORDER uploaded on 14/10/2024 -- 4 of 4 --
