Full Order Text
Order 1 · 28 Jan 2025 · CNR MHCC010008452025
Order Details: Notice of Motion Pdf Text: 1 Draft N.M. in L.C. Suit No. 216 of 2025 CNR: MHCC01-000845-2025 IN THE BOMBAY CITY CIVIL C0URT AT BOMBAY DRAFT NOTICE OF MOTION IN L.C. SUIT No. 216 OF 2025 1. Mr. Rajkapoor Laltaprasad Gupta & Anr. .. plaintiffs V/s. 1. The Municipal Corporation of Greater Mumbai & Ors. .. Defendants Appearance:- Adv. A. R. Pandey for for plaintiffs. Adv. Chaitnya Dalvi for defendants. CORAM : HIS HONOUR ADDL. SESSIONS JUDGE SHRI. R. S. ARADHYE CITY CIVIL COURT, GR. BOMBAY (C.R. No.05). DATE : 28/01/2025. ORDER Today, the matter is for passing order on ad-interim relief. On the last date 24/01/2025, Court heard both the sides at length. It is the contention of plaintiffs that suit properties means two flats and one commercial shop which he had purchased under the registered sale deeds executed in the year 2011 and 2012 and thereafter, in the year 2013, defendants/MCGM issued notice under Section 53 (1) of MRTP Act, 1966 to one Altaf Lakadawala and later on passed speaking order on 03/04/2013. Neither the said notice under Section 53 (1) of MRTP -- 1 of 7 -- 2 Draft N.M. in L.C. Suit No. 216 of 2025 Act, 1966 or order under Section Section 53 (6) of MRTP Act, 1966 was served upon him. But at present, in view of directions of the Hon’ble High Court issued in Writ Petition (L) No. 983 of 2013 vide order Dtd. 19/06/2013 now by way of one simple letter Dtd. 13/12/2024, defendants/MCGM has plan for demolition of notice structure/suit premises without giving any opportunity of being heard to him. If it is done so by defendants/MCGM, as per the plaintiffs, grave injustice will be caused to him and ultimately purpose of the suit will be defeated. It is, therefore, prayed by the plaintiffs that by way of interim measure, protection be granted in their favour by restraining defendants/MCGM from taking any action on the basis of notice, order and letter issued on 02/01/2013, 03/04/2013 and 13/12/2024 respectively. 2. On behalf of defendants/MCGM, advocate Chaitnya Dalvi has firstly attracted attention of the Court towards the order passed by the Hon’ble High Court in Writ Petition (L) No. 983 of 2013 Dtd. 19/06/2013 and submitted that in the said order, it is cleared that in respect of which structure of building, defendants/MCGM can take action and which portion is to be protected. It is not disputed by the defendant’s advocate that notice and order under Section 53 (1) (6) of MRTP Act, 1966 Dtd. 02/01/2013 and 03/04/2013 were not served upon the plaintiffs and recently intimated him about the proposed action by letter Dtd. 13/12/2024. With this, it is the contention of defendants/MCGM that as per the directions issued by the Hon’ble High Court, they are taking the action, so in view of this, present case is not fit wherein ad-interim relief can be granted. 3. I have gone through the documents with the plaint and -- 2 of 7 -- 3 Draft N.M. in L.C. Suit No. 216 of 2025 filed by defendants/MCGM. Of course, registered agreement of sale shows that plaintiffs have purchased the suit properties from C.A. of owner namely Altaf Lakadawala and accordingly, his name is muted in the revenue record. Defendants/MCGM has issued notice under Section Section 53 (1) of MRTP Act, 1966 for demolition of notice structure/suit premises means 1) Unauthorized construction of one additional floor i.e. 12th floor above 11th floor; 2) Sub-division of shops bearing No. 1, 2, 3 & 5 at ground floor; 3) Part portion of refuge area converted into habitable room at 8th floor. 4. However, while passing the speaking order under Section 53 (6) of MRTP Act 1966, defendants/MCGM added three structures i.e. 1) Meter Room at ground floor is converted into shop at rear side portion; 2) Fitness Centre on 2nd Floor is converted into Non- residential premises; 3) The entire building is unauthorizedly occupied without obtaining certificate from this office. 5. Both, the said notice and order have been challenged by the C.A. of the owner namely Altaf Lakadawala before the Hon’ble High Court in Writ Petition (L) No.983 of 2013 and Division Bench of Hon’ble High Court on 19/06/2013 passed the order. The relevant portion of that order is hereby reproduced as it is for the reference. -- 3 of 7 -- 4 Draft N.M. in L.C. Suit No. 216 of 2025 In view of what is stated in Clause 2 of order dated 8th May, 2013, we make it clear that it will be open for the Respondent-Municipal Corporation to take action on the basis of the notice under Section 53 (1) of the Maharashtra Regional and Town Planning Act, 1966 only in relation to the property described in the schedule thereunder. The said notice is at Exhibit A to the Petition. Apart from the said three items included in the schedule of the order under Sub section 6 of Section 53, three additional items have been included. Prima facie, we are of the view that the order under Sub-section 6 of Section 53 could have been passed only in relation to the unauthorized structures set out in notice under Sub-section-1 of Section 53. Therefore, by way of interim relief, we direct that no action shall be taken by the Municipal Corporation in respect of the following alleged irregularities/illegalities on the basis of the impugned order under Section 53(6) dated 3rd April, 2013.” 6. It is thus, clear that three items which are subsequently added by defendants/MCGM in the order under Section 53 (6) of MRTP Act, 1966, Dtd. 03/04/2013 i.e. 1) Meter Room at ground floor is converted into shop at rear side portion; 2) Fitness Centre on 2nd Floor is converted into Non-residential premises; 3) The entire building is unauthorizedly occupied without obtaining certificate from this office and those are protected by the Hon’ble High Court. On the contrary, the portion means notice structure/suit premises given in the schedule of the notice under Section 53 (1) of of MRTP Act, 1966 i.e. 1) Unauthorized construction of one additional floor i.e. 12th floor above -- 4 of 7 -- 5 Draft N.M. in L.C. Suit No. 216 of 2025 11th floor; 2) Sub-division of shops bearing No. 1, 2, 3 & 5 at ground floor; 3) Part portion of refuge area converted into habitable room at 8th floor against which it will be open for defendants/MCGM to take action and three items added in the order for which defendants/MCGM was given liberty for initiating proceeding in accordance with law. 7. No doubt, notice and order under Section 53 (1) and (6) of MRTP Act, 1966 were/are not served upon the plaintiffs, only letter Dtd. 13/12/2024 in respect of demolition is served. The plaintiffs have purchased the suit properties in the year 2011 and 2012 and thereafter, in the year 2013, defendants/MCGM have issued notice and order for demolition of notice structure/suit premises on 02/01/2013 and 03/04/2013. After that, both the notice and order have been challenged by the C.A. of owner Altaf Lakadawala before the Hon’ble High Court and in the said Writ Petition, as I have already stated, directions were issued to defendants/MCGM that it will be open for them to take action in respect of the structures mentioned in the notice. Whereas additional structures given in the order are by that time protected and given liberty for initiating appropriate action. The order passed by the Hon’ble High Court and directions issued therein are, of course, not in respect of any particular person but in respect of specific portion of the suit properties. It is unacceptable that the fact of issuance of notice and order, challenging it in the Hon’ble High Court and directions issued in the said Writ Petition are not known to the plaintiffs. What happened is that when defendants/ MCGM are kept mum and not taken any action, plaintiffs also kept silence and once the letter Dtd. 13/12/2024 is issued in respect of further action of demolition of notice structure/suit premises, he filed the present suit and taken the ground of non-service -- 5 of 7 -- 6 Draft N.M. in L.C. Suit No. 216 of 2025 of notice and order in question. Therefore, taking into consideration all facts and specific directions of the Hon’ble High Court issued in Writ Petition (L) No. 983 of 2013 on 19/06/2013, I think it that this is not a fit case in which ad-interim relief can be granted in contravention of the said directions, so, in the result, following order is passed. ORDER The prayer of the plaintiffs in respect of granting of ad- interim is hereby rejected. Date:28/01/2025. (R. S. Aradhye) Dictated on :28/01/2025. Judge, City Civil Court, Typed on :29/01/2025. Gr.Mumbai. Signed on :31/01/2025. -- 6 of 7 -- 7 Draft N.M. in L.C. Suit No. 216 of 2025 “CERTIFIED TO BE TRUE AND CORRECT COPY OF THE ORIGINAL SIGNED JUDGMENT/ORDER.” 31/01/2025. 11.56 a.m. (Santosh B. Sawant ) UPLOAD DATE AND TIME NAME OF STENOGRAPHER Name of the Judge (With Court room No.) HHJ Shri. R. S. Aradhye (C.R.No.05) Date of Pronouncement of JUDGMENT/ORDER 28/01/2025. JUDGMENT/ORDER signed by P.O.on 31/01/2025. JUDGMENT/ORDER uploaded on 31/01/2025. -- 7 of 7 --
