Full Order Text
Final Order 1 · 13 Mar 2024 · CNR MHCC010006072024
Order Details: Copy of Judgment Pdf Text: MHCC010006072024 Received on :: 17.01.2024 Registered on :: 16.02.2024 Decided on :: 13.03.2024 Duration :: Y-00:M-01:D-27: Exhibit :: IN THE COURT OF CITY CIVIL FOR GREATER BOMBAY AT BOMBAY MISC.APPEAL NO.03 OF 2024 Mr. Shri Mohmad Salim Abdul Sattar Vora, Age about : 64 years. Occ: Service, R/at :Supervisor Quarters No.S-Q-3, Unit NO.22, Aarey Milk Colony, goregaon(East), Mumbai-400 065. …. Appellant/ (Org. Respdt.No.2. Versus 1. The Chief Executive Officer, having his office at Aarey Milk Colony, Goregaon(East), Mumbai – 400 065. 2. Mr. Rahil Rafiq nandolia, Unit No.31, Aarey Milk Colony, Goregaon(East), Mumbai – 400 065. 3. Competent Authority, 404,Fourth Floor, New D.D. Building, Old Custom House, S.B.S. Road, Fort, Mumbai – 400001. 4. The State of Maharashtra, Through the Government Pleader Office, Bombay City Civil Court, Mumbai. …. Respondents Org. Applicants CORAM : HIS HONOUR THE PRINCIPAL JUDGE, SHRI ANIL SUBRAMANIAM C.R.NO. . : 19 DATE : 13.03.2024 Appearances :- Ld. Adv. Neelam Morey for applicant. Ld. Adv. M. B. Jadhav for respondents. -- 1 of 4 -- Page 2 of 4 Judg. In Misc.Appeal No.3/2024 ORAL JUDGMENT 1. By the present appeal, the appellant is challenging the order passed by the Competent Authority dated 03.11.2023 in Case No.896 of 2023 (Eviction Case No.25141). 2. It is the case of the government that the original respondent no.1 was the allottee of the said quarters and the present appellant is kept a sub-tenant without any authority. Earlier order was passed and my learned predecessor by order dated 06.09.2016 in Misc. Appeal No.89 of 2015 directed hearing of the proceedings by issuing notice to the appellant. Accordingly, proceedings were heard again. In such circumstances, the learned Competent Authority after recording evidence and hearing both the sides, passed the impugned order. Hence, present appeal. 3. Heard learned counsel for the appellant and respondents. 4. Perused the impugned order, record and proceedings, considered the submissions, the following points arise for my consideration and I answer the same as under for the reasons stated hereinafter:- Sr. Nos. POINTS FINDINGS 1. Whether the appellant can be said to be unauthorized occupant? In the affirmative 2. Whether the impugned order requires an interference? In the negative 3. What order? As per final order REASONS As to Point No.1: 5. Neither parties disputed that the appellants were never granted any authority by the government to occupy the premises. The fact that this government property is not disputed. The contention of the occupant through respondent no.1 cannot legalize the said -- 2 of 4 -- Page 3 of 4 Judg. In Misc.Appeal No.3/2024 occupation. It is vehemently submitted that the rent has been paid from November 2023 to December 2024, in Appeal No.89/2015. I have to submit that this was in pursuance of the claim put forth while stay was prayed and considering the same, it cannot be a ground to make the occupation authorized or continue with the occupation. Thus, the occupation of the appellant is blatantly unauthorized. Hence, I answer the point no.1 in affirmative. As to Point no.2: 6. The Competent Authority has followed appropriate procedure and after due hearing and considering the facts of the case reached to a final adjudication in this regard. Hence, the same does not require any interference and I pass the following order. ORDER 1. Misc.Appeal No.3 of 2024 is dismissed. 2. Liberty to the parties to withdraw the amount deposited in Appeal No.89 of 2015 subject to the submissions of proper accounts, payment from impugned order passed in the said appeal and on notice to the other parties. 3. Record and Proceedings be returned. 4. Appeal is disposed off accordingly. 1. DATE : 13.03.2024 (ANIL SUBRAMANIAM) PRINCIPAL JUDGE CITY CIVIL COURT, MUMBAI. (JO CODE MH01711). Dictated on : 13.03.2024. Transcribed on : 21.03.2024. Signed on : 21.03.2024. *Note : Digi-Signer expired, hence no digital signature. -- 3 of 4 -- Page 4 of 4 Judg. In Misc.Appeal No.3/2024 “CERTIFIED TO BE TRUE AND CORRECT COPY OF THE ORIGINAL SIGNED JUDGEMENT/ORDER” UPLOAD DATE TIME NAME OF STENOGRAPHER 21/03/2024 5:30p.m. B.R.HATEKAR (S.G.) Name of the Judge HH THE PRINCIPAL JUDGE SHRI A.SUBRAMANIAM (CR No.19) Date of Pronouncement of Judgment/Order. 13.03.2024 Judgment/order signed by P.O on 21.03.2024 Judgment/order uploaded on 21.03.2024 -- 4 of 4 --
