Final Order 1

Order Details: Notice of Motion
Pdf Text: nkok Øekad 3296@2018]
uksfVl vkWQ eks’ku Øekad 188@2020 i`”B Ø- 1 fnukad % 19-01-2026
MHCC010004752020
EkqacbZ ;sFkhy uxj fnok.kh U;k;ky;kr
nkok Øekad 3296@2018
e/khy
uksfVl vkWQ eks’ku Øekad 188@2020
Jh- Lokeh xksiky Hkkslys] -------- oknh
fo:)
Jherh panzdyk iksiV Hkkslys
vkf.k brj] -----izfroknh
odhy Jherh Lusgy txUukFk] oknhdjhrk
odhy Jh- lfr’k dqaHkkj] izfroknh Øekad 1 djhrk
odhy Jh- Mh-,e-f=osnh] izfroknh Øekad 3 djhrk
dksje % Ukxj fnok.kh U;k;k/kh’k]
lqfuy ek- ikVhy ¼U;k;ky; Ø-09½
fnukad % 19 tkusokjh] 2026
vkns’k
1- lnjpk uksfVl vkWQ eks’ku] nkok izyafcr dkGkr izfroknh
Øekad 2 x`gfuekZ.k lkslk;Vhus nkok lnfudsPkh pkoh oknhl ns.;kckcr
vkKkFkhZ eukbZ vkns'k djkok rlsp nkok lnfudsckcr oknhl dksVZ fjflOgj
Eg.kwu use.;kr ;kos ;k fouarhdjhrk oknhus nk[ky dsyk vkgs-
-- 1 of 8 --
nkok Øekad 3296@2018]
uksfVl vkWQ eks’ku Øekad 188@2020 i`”B Ø- 2 fnukad % 19-01-2026
2- oknh o izfroknhrQsZ ofdykapk ;qfDrokn fnukad 17-11-2025
jksth ekÖ;k iqokZf/kdkÚ;kauh ,sdyk rlsp izfroknh Øekad 1 rQsZ fu'kk.kh
12 oj ys[kh ;qfDrokn nk[ky dj.;kr vkyk vkgs- lnj izdj.k
vkns'kkdjhrk use.;kr vkys vlwu nkO;krhy nksUgh i{kdkjkauh ekÖ;kleksj
R;kauk izLrqr uksVhl vkWQ eks'kuoj iqUgk ;qfDrokn djko;kpk vkgs vls
dGfoys ukgh- R;keqGs] oknh o izfroknh ;kauk iqUgk ;qfDrokn dj.;kph
la/kh vlwu ns[khy rlk ;qfDrokn dj.;kr vkyk ulY;keqGs ;k izdj.kh
nk[ky dkxni=s rlsp mijksYysf[kr ys[kh ;qfDrokn fopkjkr ?ksowu izLrqrpk
uksVhl vkWQ eks'ku fudkyh dj.;kr ;sr vkgs-
3- uksVhl vkWQ eks'ku e/khy dFkus rlsp R;kl Eg.k.ks nsrkuk
mifLFkr dj.;kr vkysys eqn~ns ;kckcr oknh o izfroknhaps dFku fopkjkr
Äsrk ekÖ;k leksj [kkyhy eqn~nk (Point) mifLFkr gksr vlwu R;kpk fu"d"kZ
eh [kkyhyizek.ks uksanfoy vkgs%
v-Ø- eqn~ns fu”d”kZ
1- ld`rn'kZuh vkiys dFku fLodkjkgZ vlwu
fouarhizek.ks vkKkFkhZ eukbZph rlsp dksVZ fjflOgj
Eg.kwu vkiY;k use.kwdhckcr nkn u fnY;kl
vkiys vifjfer uqdlku gks.kkj vlwu U;k;kps
lerksyRo vkiY;k cktqus vlY;kps oknhus fl)
dsys vkgs dk; \
---ukgh---
2- vkns'k dks.krk \ ---vafre
vkns'kkizek.ks --
-- 2 of 8 --
nkok Øekad 3296@2018]
uksfVl vkWQ eks’ku Øekad 188@2020 i`”B Ø- 3 fnukad % 19-01-2026
dkj.kfeekalk
4- eqn~nk Øekad 1 %&
nkO;kps voyksdu djrk izLrqrpk nkok gDdKkiu o vkKkFkhZ
eukbZlkBh nk[ky dj.;kr vkyk vlwu izfroknh Øekad 1 gh oknhpk e;r
HkkÅ iksiV ;kph iRuh vlY;kckcr okn ukgh- ;kf'kok;] izfroknh Øekad
2 rs 6 ;k oknhP;k cfg.kh vlwu oknhps oMhy xksiky gs fnukad
22-04-2014 jksth rlsp vkbZ Jherh ;equkckbZ gh fnukad 11-08-2014
jksth o izfroknh Øekad 1 fgps irh iksiV gs fnukad 30-04-2003 jksth
e;r vlY;kckcr ns[khy okn ukgh- ;kf'kok;] izfroknh Øekad 4 rs
6 ;kauh nkokfeGfdrhrhy vkiyk gDd oknhP;k ukos lksMwu fnY;kps
oknhps dFku vkgs- e;r iksiV o izfroknh Øekad 1 ;kauk 2 eqyxs o 1
eqyxh vlwu xksiky ;kaP;k rkC;kr uewn fBdk.kkojhy [kksyh Øekad
57@19 gksrh o R;k cnY;kr izfroknh Øekad 2@lkslk;VhekQZr ,l-
vkj-, ;kstun~okjs cka/kY;k tkr vlysY;k bekjrhrhy lnfudk Øekad
1710 xksiky Hkkslys ;kal okVi (allot) dj.;kr vkyh vkgs-
5- ojhy okn ulysY;k ckch rlsp e;r xksiky ;kP;k rkC;kr
vlysY;k [kksyh Øekad 57@19 P;k cnY;kr uO;kus cka/k.;kr
vkysY;k ,l-vkj-, ;kstus[kkyhy bekjrhrhy lnfudk Øekad 1710 e;r
xksiky Hkkslys ;kal okVi (allot) dj.;kr vkY;kph ckc fopkjkr ?ksrk
eqyr% e;r xksiky ;kP;k e`R;wosGh rsFks dks.k jkgr gksrs rlsp e;r
xksiky ;kP;k e`R;wuarj uO;k bekjrhrhy lnj lnfudk feG.;kl R;kps
okjl ik= vkgsr dk rlsp okjlkaiSdh usedk oknh gk rh lnfudk
feG.;kl ik= vkgs dk gs oknkps eqn~ns vlwu oknh o izfroknhaps dFku
fopkjkr ?ksrk R;kaP;knjE;ku ukrslaca/kakckcr okn ulY;kus xksiky
Hkkslys ;kP;k e`R;wuarj R;kph iRuh rlsp eqys o eqyh ;kauk ;ke/;s
-- 3 of 8 --
nkok Øekad 3296@2018]
uksfVl vkWQ eks’ku Øekad 188@2020 i`”B Ø- 4 fnukad % 19-01-2026
okjlkgDd izkIr gksrks ;kckcr nksUgh i{kdkjkanjE;ku [kqi eksBk okn vkgs
vls fnlwu ;sr ukgh-
6- izfroknh Øekad 1 fgP;k dFkukuqlkj izfroknh Øekad
2@lkslk;Vhus cka/kysY;k bekjrhe/;s ;k ?kMhyk oknh Lokeh Hkkslys ;kpk
v/kkZ o xksiky ;kpk eqyxk Eg.ktsp frpk irh iksiV Hkkslys ;kpk v/kkZ
fgLlk vkgs- oknhP;k dFkukuqlkj izfroknh Øekad 1 fgpk lnj lnfudse/;s
QDr 5 VDds fgLlk ;srks- ifj.kker% izfroknh Øekad 1 fgpk
nkokfeGdrhr okjlkgDd vkgs gh ckc oknhl ekU; vlY;kps ld`rn'kZuh
fnlwu ;sr vlwu izfroknh Øekad 1 lg frP;k eqykauk ,dq.k feGdrhr
fdrh VDds fgLlk ;srks gk oknkpk fo"k; vkgs-
7- izfroknh Øekad 4 rs 6 ;kauh e;r xksiky ;kps okjl ;k
ukR;kus R;kauk izkIr okjlkgDd oknhP;k ukos lksMwu fnyk fdaok dls]
izfroknh Øekad 4 rs 6 ;kauh vkiyk gDd rFkkdFkhrjhR;k lksMwu fnY;kps
oknhps dFku fLodkjkgZ vlY;kl izfroknh Øekad 4 rs 6 ;kapk rks
okjlkgDd oknh vkf.k izfroknh Øekad 1 vkf.k frph eqys ;kaP;k
ukosns[khy lksMwu fnyk vls ekukos ykxsy fdaok dls gs oknkps eqn~ns ;k
ÄMhyk mifLFkr gksr vlwu nkO;krhy dkxni=s ikgrk raVkeqDrh lferhleksj
oknhus lnj lnfudse/;s izfroknh Øekad 1 o frP;k eqykapk v/kkZ fgLlk
vlY;kps ekU; d:u lnj lnfudsP;k fdaerhP;k ,dq.k jdesP;k 50
VDds brdh jDde izfroknh Øekad 1 fgyk ns.;kps ekU; dsys gksrs- lnj
ckc ns[khy ;k ?kMhyk oknkph vlwu izLrqr uksVhl vkWQ eks'kue/;s oknhus
dsysY;k fouaR;k ikgrk ;k?kMhyk nkok lnfudsckcr e;r xksiky ;kP;k
e`R;wuarj uO;k bekjrhrhy lnfudse/;s dks.kkl okjlkgDd izkIr gksrk rlsp
oknh o izfroknh Øekad 1 ;kaps gDd rlsp rs gDd fdrh izek.kkr
-- 4 of 8 --
nkok Øekad 3296@2018]
uksfVl vkWQ eks’ku Øekad 188@2020 i`”B Ø- 5 fnukad % 19-01-2026
vkgsr ;kckcr tksi;Zar iqjkok nsowu Bjfoys tkr ukgh rksi;Zar nkok
feGdrhph pkoh vkiY;kyk feGkoh o i;kZ;kus nkok lnfudspk rkck
vkiY;kyk feGkok gh oknhph fouarh nkok izyafcr dkGkr ekU;
djrk ;s.kkj ukgh ;k ckcr izfroknh Øekad 1 rQsZ ?ks.;kr vkysyh gjdr
vfLodkjkgZ ukgh-
8- ;kmij] nkO;kdkeh izfroknh Øekad 2@lkslk;Vhus ,l-
vkj-, ;kstus[kkyh cka/kysY;k lnj bekjrhrhy lnfudk xksiky
Hkkslys ;kapk okjl ;k ukR;kus feG.;kl vki.k ik= vlY;kps gDdKkiu
dj.;kr ;kos rlsp lnj lkslk;Vhus R;k lnfudsph pkoh vkiY;kyk
ns.;kckcr lkslk;Vhfo:) vkKkFkhZ vkns'k ns.;kr ;kosr v'kh oknhus
fouarh dsY;kps fnlwu ;srs- ifj.kker% lnj uksVhl vkWQ eks'kue/;s oknhus
dsysY;k fouaR;k ikgrk nkO;kdkeh th vafre nkn (final relief) oknhus
ekxhryh vkgsr rh nkn varfje Lo:ikr (interim relief) feGkoh v'kh
uksVhl vkWQ eks'kun~okjs oknhus ekx.kh dsY;kps Li"V gksrs- ;k ifjfLFkrhr
oknh o izfroknhnjE;ku lnj lnfudsckcr mijksYysf[kr oknkps eqn~ns
fopkjkr ?ksrk oknkdjhrk uksVhl vkWQ eks'kue/;s ekx.kh dsY;kizek.ks nkok
izyafcr dkGkr oknhl varfje nkn fnY;kl nkok pky.;kiqohZp nkO;krhy
vafre fouarh eatwj dsY;klkj[ks gksbZy- ;kckcr] nsojkt fo:) LVsV vkWQ
egkjk"Vª ( Appeal (Civil) No. 2084/2004, Judgment dated 06.04.2004.
;k U;k;fu.kZ;ke/;s ukenkj loksZPp U;k;ky;kus vls EgVys vkgs dh]
"Situations emerge where the granting of an interim relief would
tantamount to granting the final relief itself. And then there may be
converse cases where withholding of an interim relief would
tantamount to dismissal of main petition itself; for, by the time the
main matter comes up for hearing there would be nothing left to be
-- 5 of 8 --
nkok Øekad 3296@2018]
uksfVl vkWQ eks’ku Øekad 188@2020 i`”B Ø- 6 fnukad % 19-01-2026
allowed as relief to the petitioner though all the findings may be in his
favour. In such cases the availability of a very strong prima facie case
___ of a standard much higher than just prima facie case, the
considerations of balance of convenience and irreparable injury
forcefully tilting the balance of case totally in favour of the applicant
may persuade the Court to grant an interim relief though it amounts to
granting the final relief itself. Of course, such would be rare and
exceptional cases. The Court would grant such an interim relief only if
satisfied that withholding of it would prick the conscience of the Court
and do violence to the sense of justice, resulting in injustice being
perpetuated throughout the hearing, and at the end the Court would
not be able to vindicate the cause of justice. Obviously such would be
rare cases accompanied by compelling circumstances, where the injury
complained of is immediate and pressing and would cause extreme
hardship. The conduct of the parties shall also have to be seen and
the Court may put the parties on such terms as may be prudent."
9- lcc] ukenkj loksZPPk U;k;ky;kpk ojhy fu.kZ; fopkjkr
Äsrk rks ;k ?kMhyk izfroknh Øekad 1 fgP;k enrhl ;sr vlwu ojhy
dkj.kkLro vkiys dFku ld`rn'kZuh fLodkjkgZ vlY;kps fl) dj.;kl
oknh vi;'kh Bjyk vkgs rlsp ojhy ifjfLFkrhr U;k;kps lerksyRo
oknhP;k cktwus ukgh- R;keqGs nkok lnfudsph pkoh izfroknh Øekad 2 ;kauh
vkiY;kyk n~;koh ;klaca/kh izfroknh Øekad 2 fo:) vkKkFkhZ eukbZ vkns'k
feG.;kl oknh ik= ukgh- ;kf'kok;] oknhus lnj lnfudslaca/kh dksVZ
fjflOgj Eg.kwu vkiyh use.kwd dj.;kr ;koh v'kk varfje vkns'kkph
fouarh dsyh vlwu nkok izyafcr dkGkr lnj lnfudsph pkoh feG.;kph
oknhph fouarh QsVkG.;kl ik= vlY;kus R;k lnfudslaca/kh dksVZ fjflOgj
-- 6 of 8 --
nkok Øekad 3296@2018]
uksfVl vkWQ eks’ku Øekad 188@2020 i`”B Ø- 7 fnukad % 19-01-2026
Eg.kwu use.kwdhckcr varfje vkns'kkph oknhph fouarh eatwj gks.;kl ik=
ukgh- lcc] ojhy dkj.kkLro lnj uksVhl vkWQ eks’ku QsVkG.;kl ik=
vlY;kus eqn~nk Øekad 1 pk fu"d"kZ ^ukgh* vlk eh ukasnfor vlwu
[kkyhyizek.ks vkns’k ikjhr djhr vkgs-
vkns'k
lnj uksVhl vkWQ eks’ku Øekad 188@2020 QsVkG.;kr ;sr vkgs-
fnukad % 19-01-2026
¼ lqfuy ek- ikVhy ½
uxj fnok.kh U;k;k/kh’k] c`gUeqacbZ
U;k;ky; Øekad 09
Jqrys[kukph rkjh[k % 19-01-2026
fyI;arj.kkph rkjh[k % 19-01-2026
Lok{kjhph rkjh[k % 21-01-2026
-- 7 of 8 --
nkok Øekad 3296@2018]
uksfVl vkWQ eks’ku Øekad 188@2020 i`”B Ø- 8 fnukad % 19-01-2026
“CERTIFIED TO BE TRUE AND CORRECT COPY OF THE ORIGINAL
SIGNED JUDGMENT/ORDER.”
Upload Date Upload Time Name of the Stenographer
21.01-2026 2.05 p.m. Mrs. Poonam Y. Pawar,
Stenographer (Grade-I)
Name of the Judge (With C.R. No.) H.H.J. SHRI. S. M. PATIL
(COURT ROOM NO.09)
Date of Pronouncement of
JUDGEMENT /ORDER
19-01-2026
JUDGEMENT /ORDER signed by
P.O. on
21-01-2026
JUDGEMENT /ORDER uploaded on 21-01-2026
-- 8 of 8 --