Final Order 1

Order Details: Copy of Judgment
Pdf Text: ,l-lh- nkok Øekad 122@2020 --1-- U;k;fu.kZ;] fnukad 14-07-2026
MHCC010001572020 nk[ky fnukad % 04-01-2020
uksan.kh fnukad % 08-01-2020
fudky fnukad % 14-07-2026
dkyko/kh % 06&o- 06&e- 12&fn-
uxj fnok.kh U;k;ky;] eqacbZ ;sFkhy U;k;ky; Øekad 09
¼ lqfuy ek- ikVhy] uxj fnok.kh U;k;k/kh’k ½
,l-lh-nkok Øekad 122@2020
¼U;k;fu.kZ;kpk fnukad % 14@07@2026½ fu’kk.kh & 17
Jherh feuy lat; fHkaxkMsZ]
o;% 45 o”kZs]
iRrk% :e uacj 401 o 704] fiz;n’kZuh dks-vkW-gkS-
lks- fy-] l[kkjke iokj ekxZ] djh jksM] eqacbZ&400
013- -------- oknh
fo:)
egkjk”Vª x`gfuekZ.k o {ks= fodkl izkf/kdj.k]
,e-ch-vkj-vkj cksMZ ekQZr]
x`g fuekZ.k Hkou] dyk uxj okanzs ¼iwoZ½] eqacbZ&
400 051- ---- izfroknh
odhy Jh- lkxj dkacGs] oknhdjhrk
odhy Jh-Ogh-,l-[kksczkxMs] izfroknh@EgkMk djhrk
U;k;fu.kZ;
¼ fnukad 14-07-2026 jksth ikjhr ½
EgkMk vf/kfu;ekP;k dye 95 ¼v½ uqlkj nkok feGdrhrqu
oknhl csn[ky dj.;kckcr izfroknhauh lq: dsysyh dkjokbZ csdk;ns'khj
vlY;kps gDdKkiu dj.;kr ;kos rlsp dk;ns'khj ekxkZpk voyac
-- 1 of 10 --
,l-lh- nkok Øekad 122@2020 --2-- U;k;fu.kZ;] fnukad 14-07-2026
dsY;kf'kok; izfroknhauh nkok feGdrhrwu oknhl csn[ky d: u;s v'kk
fujarj eukbZlkBh o nkok feGdrhph dk;ns'khj rkcsnkj vlysY;k oknhl
izfroknhauk nkok feGdrhrwu csn[ky djrk ;s.kkj ukgh v'kk
gDdKkiuklkBh izLrqrpk nkok nk[ky dj.;kr vkyk vkgs-
2- oknhps dFku FkksMD;kr [kkyhyizek.ks %&
fiz;n'kZuh lgdkjh gkS-lkslk;Vh fyfeVsM] djh jksM] eqacbZ ;k
bekjrhrhy [kksyh Øekad 401 o 704 ;k feGdrh nkok fo"k; vlwu
R;kl ;kiq<s lks;hlkBh ^nkok feGdrh* vls lacks/kys vkgs- dkekBhiqjk]
rsjkoh xYyh ;sFkhy bekjrhrhy rGetY;kojhy [kksyh Øekad 1 o 2 ;k
feGdrh rqdkjke ekyo.kdj ;kP;klg oknhP;k rkC;kr gksR;k- rh bekjr
jkg.;kyk;d u jkfgY;kus izfroknhauh rqdkjke ekyo.kdj ;kl uksVhl
ikBowu R;k feGdrhapk rkck ekfxryk o R;kuqlkj R;k feGdrhapk rkck
izfroknhauk ns.;kr vkY;kuarj R;k cnY;kr nkok feGdrhapk rkck fnukad
21-12-2009 jksthP;k i=kn~okjs oknhl ns.;kr vkyk vkgs- oknhus lnj
feGdrhps okVi gks.;kdjhrk rlsp esaVsuUliksVh izfroknhadMs o fiz;n'kZuh
lgdkjh x`gfuekZ.k lkslk;VhdMs osGksosGh t:j R;k jdek tek dsY;k
vlwu nkok feGdrh oknhP;k rkC;kr vkgsr- nkok feGdrhckcrph eqG
dkxni=s izfroknhaP;k rkC;kr vlwu fnukad 01-01-2020 jksth izfroknharQsZ
oknhyk uksVhl ikBowu EgkMk vf/kfu;ekP;k dye 95 ¼v½ ¼3½ uqlkj nkok
feGdrhrwu csn[ky dj.;kpk iz;Ru izfroknhadMwu dj.;kr vkyk vlwu
lnj uksVhl csdk;ns'khj vkgs- lnj uksVhlvk/kkjs oknhdMwu nkok feGdrhpk
rkck izfroknh gs vukf/kdkjkus ?ks.;kP;k iz;Rukr vlwu oknh gh nkok
feGdrhph dk;ns'khj rkcsnkj vkgs- dks.kR;kgh dk;ns'khj ekxkZpk voyac
dsY;kf'kok; nkok feGdrhapk rkck izfroknhauk oknhdMwu ?ksrk ;s.kkj ukgh-
lcc] EgkMk vf/kfu;ekP;k dye 95 ¼v½ uqlkj nkok feGdrhrqu oknhl
-- 2 of 10 --
,l-lh- nkok Øekad 122@2020 --3-- U;k;fu.kZ;] fnukad 14-07-2026
csn[ky dj.;kckcr izfroknhauh lq: dsysyh dkjokbZ csdk;ns'khj vlY;kps
o nkok feGdrhph dk;ns'khj rkcsnkj vlysY;k oknhl izfroknhauk nkok
feGdrhrwu csn[ky djrk ;s.kkj ukgh v'kk gDdKkiukph fouarh djrkuk
dk;ns'khj ekxkZpk voyac dsY;kf'kok; izfroknhauh nkok feGdrhrwu oknhl
csn[ky d: u;s v'kk fujarj eukbZph oknhus fouarh dsyh vkgs-
3- izfroknhauk nkO;kps leUl feGkY;kuarj ofdykaekQZr gtj
gkssowu ns[khy izfroknhauh dSfQ;r u fnY;keqGs fnukad 17-10-2022
jksthP;k vkns'kkuqlkj lnj nkok izfroknhfo:) foukdSfQ;r pky.;kpk
vkns'k ikjhr dj.;kr vkyk-
4- oknhrQsZ odhy Jh- lkxj dkacGs ;kapk rksaMh ;qfDrokn ,sdyk
rlsp R;kauh fu'kk.kh 15 o 16 oj nk[ky dsysyk ys[kh ;qfDrokn okpyk-
izfroknhrQsZ odhy ;qfDroknklkBh xSjgtj jkfgys-
5- oknhus vkiY;k dFkukiq"B~;FkZ eq[kR;kj lat; xtkuu
fHkaxkMsZ ;kaph lk{k fu'kk.kh 05 oj Äsryh vlwu fu’kk.kh 07 oj fnukad
30-03-2013 jksth lat; fHkaxkMsZ ;kP;k ukos fygqu fnysys eq[kR;kji=]
fu’kk.kh 08 oj oknhP;k ukos ikBfo.;kr vkysys eqG i= o izfroknharQsZ
ikBfo.;kr vkysY;k oknhP;k ukos vlysY;k Hkj.kkikoR;k] fu’kk.kh 09
oj izfroknhus oknhl ikBfoysY;k rkck i=kph o rkck ikorhph izr]
fu’kk.kh 10 oj oknhus fnysys i= rlsp nkok feGdr fjdkeh dj.;kph
uksVhl] fu’kk.kh 11 oj oht fcykph izr] fu’kk.kh 12 oj EgkMk
vf/kfu;ekP;k dye 95 ¼v½ uqlkj fnukad 23-12-2019 jksth izfroknhauh
oknhl ikBfoysyh uksVhl nk[ky dsys vkgs-
-- 3 of 10 --
,l-lh- nkok Øekad 122@2020 --4-- U;k;fu.kZ;] fnukad 14-07-2026
6- izLrqr nkok oknh Jherh feuy lat; fHkaxkMsZ fgus Lor%P;k
lghus ofdykaekQZr nk[ky dsyk vlwu oknhus nkO;kdkeh vkiyk iRrk gk
nkok feGdrhapk n'kZfoyk vkgs- oj mYys[k dsY;kizek.ks oknhus frps
eq[kR;kj lat; xtkuu fHkaxkMsZ ;kaP;kekQZr nkO;kdkeh rksaMh iqjkok fnyk
vlwu fu'kk.kh 7 oj R;kckcr fnukad 30-03-2013 jksthps eq[kR;kji=
nk[ky dsys vkgs- fu'kk.kh 7 ojhy eq[kR;kji= gs fnukad 30-03-2013
jksthps vlwu R;ke/;s oknh gh ekSts is<s] rkyqdk&fpiGq.k] ftYgk&jRukfxjh
;sFks okLrO;kl vlY;kps uewn vlwu eq[kR;kji= fygqu ?ks.kkj lat; fHkaxkMsZ
gs ns[khy ekSts is<s ;k xkog jkgr vlY;kps R;ke/;s uewn vkgs-
7- ;kf'kok;] lat; fHkaxkMsZ ;kauh fu'kk.kh 5 ojhy ljriklke/;s
rs oknhps eq[kR;kj vlY;kps lkaxrkuk oknh gh R;kaph iRuh vlY;kps
rlsp ik;k'kh laca/khr O;k/kheqGs fryk pky.ks ok mHks jkg.ks 'kD; ulY;kus
frP;k orhus eq[kR;kj Eg.kwu vki.k iqjkok nsr vlY;kps lat; fHkaxkMsZ ;kus
ljriklke/;s uewn dsys vkgs-
8- ojhy ifjfLFkrhr] fu'kk.kh 5 ojhy lat; fHkaxkMsZ ;kapk
ljrikl ikgrk R;kauh nkok feGdrhckcr R;kauk FksVi.ks dks.kR;k ckch
ekfgr vkgsr rlsp nkok feGdrhckcr R;kauh oknhdMwu dks.krh ekfgrh ?
ksryh o R;k ekfgrh vk/kkjs ljriklkrhy dks.krk etdwj rs lkaxr
vkgsr ;klkscrp fuOoG nk[ky dkxni=kvk/kkjs rs ljriklkrhy dks.krk
etdwj lkaxr vkgsr ;kf'kok;] 2013 lkyh fygqu ns.;kr vkysY;k nkok
feGdrhlaca/khP;k eq[kR;kji=kvk/kkjs R;kauh oknhP;k orhus eq[kR;kj Eg.kwu
dks.krs d`R; dsys ;kckckr usedsi.kkus dks.krkgh etdwj lkafxryk ulY;kps
Li"V gksrs-
-- 4 of 10 --
,l-lh- nkok Øekad 122@2020 --5-- U;k;fu.kZ;] fnukad 14-07-2026
9- mijksYysf[kr ckch fopkjkr ?ksrk] lat; fHkaxkMsZ ;kus fu'kk.kh 7
ojhy eq[kR;kji=kvk/kkjs oknhP;k orhus fu'kk.kh 5 oj izfrKki=kn~okjs
fnysyk iqjkok oknhP;k orhus iqjkok Eg.kwu fopkjkr ?ksrk ;sbZy dk; gk
iz'u mifLFkr gksrks- R;klaca/kh eq[kR;kj/kkjdkus U;k;ky;kleksj iqjkok
fnY;kl R;krhy dks.kR;k ckch iqjkok Eg.kwu fopkjkr ?ksrk ;srhy ;klaca/kah
tkudh o'knso Hkkstokuh fo:) baMqlbaM c¡d fyfeVsM] AIR 2005
SUPREME COURT 439 ;k U;k;fu.kZ;ke/;s ukenkj loksZPp U;k;ky;kus
" The question whether the appellants have any independent source of
income and have contributed towards the purchase of the property from
their independent income can be only answered by the appellants
themselves and not by the mere holder of Power of Attorney from them.
The Power of Attorney holder does not have the personal knowledge of
the matter of the appellants and therefore, he can neither depose on his
personal knowledge nor can he be cross-examined on those facts which
are to be personal knowledge of the principal. Order III, Rules 1 and 2
C.P.C., empowers the holder of Power of Attorney to "act" on behalf of
the principal. In our view, the work "acts" employed in Order III, Rules 1
and 3 C.P.C., confines only in respect of "acts" done by the Power of
Attorney holder in exercise of power granted by the instrument. The
term "acts" would not include deposing in place and instead of the
principal. In other words, if the Power of Attorney holder has rendered
some "acts" in pursuance to Power of Attorney, he may depose for the
principal in respect of such acts, but he cannot depose for the principal
for the acts done by the principal and not by him. Similarly, he cannot
depose for the principal in respect of the matter which only the
principal can have a personal knowledge and in respect of which the
principal is entitled to be cross-examined." vls EgVys vkgs-
-- 5 of 10 --
,l-lh- nkok Øekad 122@2020 --6-- U;k;fu.kZ;] fnukad 14-07-2026
10- ojhy ifjfLFkrhr] eqyr% izLrqr nkok oknhus Lor%P;k lghus
fnukad 04-01-2020 jksth nk[ky dsyk vlwu fu'kk.kh 7 ojhy
mijksYysf[kr eq[kR;kji= gs R;kiwohZp Eg.kts fnukad 30-03-2013 jksth
fygqu fnY;kph ckc fopkjkr ?ksrk lnj eq[kR;kji= oknhus lat;
fHkaxkMsZ ;kP;k ukos fygqu fnys R;k fno'kh izLrqr nkok nk[ky dj.;kr
vkyk uOgrk gs Li"V gksrs-
11- ;kf'kok;] lat; fHkaxkMsZ ;kus fu'kk.kh 5 ojhy
ljriklknjE;ku lkaxhrY;kizek.ks oknh gh ik;kP;k O;k/kheqGs U;k;ky;kr
gtj jkgq 'kdr ukgh o R;keqGs frus lnj eq[kR;kji= fygqu fnys vls
lat; fHkaxkMsZ ;kps dFku vlys rjh rs eq[kR;kji= fnukad 30-03-2013
jksthps o izLrqr nkok fnukad 04-01-2020 jksth nk[ky dj.;kr vkY;kus
izLrqr nkok nk[ky rkj[ksl fdaok nkO;kdkeh rksaMh iqjkok ns.;kP;k rkj[ksl
oknh gh mijksYysf[kr dkj.kkLro U;k;ky;kr gtj jkg.;kl vleFkZ gksrh
gs lat; fHkaxkMsZ ;kps dFku fLodkjkgZ ukgh-
12- ;kf'kok;] fu'kk.kh 7 ojhy eq[kR;kji=kps voyksdu djrk
eqyr% rs eq[kR;kji= izLrqr nkok nk[ky dj.;kr ;s.;kiwohZ oknhus lat;
fHkaxkMsZ ;kaP;k ukos fygqu fnys vlwu R;ke/;s tjh nkok feGdrhapk mYys[k
dj.;kr vkyk vlyk rjh nkok feGdrhlaca/kh U;k;ky;kr okn fuekZ.k
>kY;kl R;kdkeh eq[kR;kji= fygqu ns.kkj feuy fHkaxkMsZ ;kaP;korhus
U;k;ky;kr rksaMh iqjkok ns.;kpk vf/kdkj feuy fHkaxkMsZ ;kauh lat; fHkaxkMsZ
;kauk fnyk gksrk dk; gk iz'u mifLFkr gksrks-
13- ojhy eqn~n;kckcr fu'kk.kh 7 ojhy eq[kR;kji= ikgrk
R;ke/;s nkok feGdrhackcr djko;kP;k dkeklaca/kh mYys[k vlwu R;ke/;s
fo'ks"kr% ^lnj lnfudkackcr dks.krkgh U;k;ky;hu okn fuekZ.k >kY;kl
-- 6 of 10 --
,l-lh- nkok Øekad 122@2020 --7-- U;k;fu.kZ;] fnukad 14-07-2026
odhy use.ks] odhy Qh Hkj.ks] dkxni=a lknj dj.ks] oxSjs vOoy
dksVkZiklwu v[ksjP;k dksVkZi;Zar djkoh ykx.kkjh loZ rh dkes dj.ks* vlk
etdwj uewn vlwu lnj eq[kR;kji=ke/;s nkok feGdrhalaca/kh U;k;ky;kr
nkok nk[ky dj.;kr vkY;kl R;k nkO;kdkeh vkiY;k orhus rksaMh iqjkok
ns.;kpk vf/kdkj oknh feuy fHkaxkMsZ ;kauh lat; fHkaxkMsZ ;kauk fnY;kckcr
dks.krkgh mYys[k ukgh-
14- ifj.kker% izLrqr nkO;krhy oknh feuy ;kaP;korhus fu'kk.kh 5
ojhy izfrKki=kv/kkjs rksaMh iqjkok ns.;kpk vf/kdkj lnj eq[kR;kji=kvk/kkjs
oknh feuy ;kauh lat; fHkaxkMsZ ;kauk fnyk ulY;kus lat; xtkuu
fHkaxkMsZ ;kauh oknhP;k orhus nk[ky dsysys fu'kk.kh 5 ojhy izfrKki= gs
oknhrQsZ nkO;krhy dFkukiq"B~;FkZ rksaMh iqjkok Eg.kwu fLodkjkgZ ukgh-
15- ;kmij] oknkdjhrk fu'kk.kh 5 ojhy izfrKki= gs oknhdjhrk
iqjkok Eg.kwu okpko;kps >kY;kl lat; fHkaxkMsZ ;kauh eq[kR;kji=kvk/kkjs
nkok feGdrhckcr lnjps izfrKki= nk[ky dsys vlY;kus lat;
fHkaxkMsZ ;kauh nkok feGdrhckcr oknhpk eq[kR;kj Eg.kwu fdaok
O;DrhxrjhR;k ,[kkns d`R; dsys vlY;kl R;kckcrps lat; fHkaxkMsZ ;kaps
dFku iqjkok Eg.kwu fLodkjkgZ gksow 'kdrs- ijarq] fu'kk.kh 5 ojhy
izfrKki=kps voyksdu djrk rlsp nkO;krhy dFkukiq"B~;FkZ nk[ky dj.;kr
vkysyh fu'kk.kh 8 rs 12 ojhy dkxni=s ikgrk rh dkxni=s oknh feuy
fHkaxkMsZP;k ukos vlwu rh dkxni=s vfLrRokr ;s.;kckcr fdaok R;k
dkxni=ke/;s uewn fofo/k jdekackcr rlsp rFkkdFkhr rkck ikorhckcr
lat; fHkaxkMsZ ;kapk nkok feGdrhlaca/kh O;ogkjkckcr FksV lgHkkx
vlY;kpk dks.krkgh etdwj fu'kk.kh 5 ojhy ljriklke/;s uewn ulY;kus
oj uewn dsY;kizek.ks oknkdjhrk fu'kk.kh 5 ojhy izfrKki= iqjkok Eg.kwu
-- 7 of 10 --
,l-lh- nkok Øekad 122@2020 --8-- U;k;fu.kZ;] fnukad 14-07-2026
fopkjkr ?;ko;kps >kY;kl eq[kR;kj Eg.kqu lat; fHkaxkMsZ ;kaps dFku
oknhP;k dFkukl iqjkok Eg.kqu iq"Vh ns.kkjs ukgh-
16- ojhy ifjfLFkrhr] oknhus vkiY;k dFkukiq"B~;FkZ lat; fHkaxkMsZ
;kaP;k fu'kk.kh 5 ojhy izfrKki=kf'kok; vU; rksaMh iqjkok fnyk ukgh-
ifj.kker% oj uewn dsY;kizek.ks fu'kk.kh 8 rs 12 ojhy dkxni=s rlsp
nkO;krhy izfroknhfo:)ps dFku fl) dj.kkjk iqjkok oknhus fnyk vkgs gk
oknhrQsZ ofdykapk ;qfDrokn fLodkjkgZ ukgh-
17- nkO;krhy dFkus rlsp R;kiq"B~;FkZ nk[ky dsysyh dkxni=s
fl) dj.;kdjhrk fLodkjkgZ o fo'oklkgZ iqjkok ns.;kl oknh vi;'kh
BjY;kus dkekBhiqjk] rsjkoh xYyh ;sFkhy bekjrhrhy rG etY;kojhy
[kksyh Øekad 1 o 2 gh rqdkjke ekyo.kdj ;kaP;klg oknhP;k rkC;kr
gksrh o rh bekjr jkg.;kyk;d u jkfgY;keqGs [kksyh Øekad 1 o 2 pk
rkck rqdkjke ekyo.kdj ;kauk lksMkok ykxyk o R;kcnY;kr nkok
feGdrhapk rkck izfroknhauh oknhyk fnyk vlwu oknhus R;kckcr osGkssosGh
fofo/k jdek laca/khr lgdkjh x`gfuekZ.k lkslk;Vh rlsp EgkMk ;kaP;kdMs
tek dsY;kps fl) dj.;kl ns[khy oknh vi;'kh Bjyh vkgs-
18- rlsp] EgkMk vf/kfu;ekP;k dye 95 ¼v½ uqlkj izfroknhauh
oknhl ikBfoysyh uksVhl csdk;ns'khj vlwu R;k uksVhln~okjs nkok
feGdrhapk rkck oknhdMwu vukf/kdkjkus ?ksryk tk.;kph dkjokbZ
izfroknhadMwu dsyh tkr vlY;kps ns[khy fl) dj.;kl oknh vi;'kh
Bjyh vkgs- R;keqGs] izfroknhauh nkok feGdrhpk rkck Äs.;kdjhrk
dk;ns'khj ekxkZpk voyac djsi;Zar oknhfo:) nkok feGdrhckcr
dks.krhgh dkjokbZ d: u;s vls tjh oknhps dFku vlys rjh oj uewn
dkj.kkLro izfroknhadMwu nkok feGdrhlaca/kh dks.krhgh dk;ns'khj dkjokbZ
-- 8 of 10 --
,l-lh- nkok Øekad 122@2020 --9-- U;k;fu.kZ;] fnukad 14-07-2026
dsyh tkr ulY;kps rFkkdFkhr dFku fl) dj.;kl oknh vi;'kh Bjyh
vkgs-
19- FkksMD;kr] oj uewn dkj.kkLro nkok feGdr] R;kojhy rkck
rlsp izfroknhadMwu vukf/kdkjkus@dk;ns'khj ekxkZpk voyac u djrk nkok
feGdrhpk rkck ?ks.;kph dkjokbZ dsyh tkr vlY;kps vkiys dFku fl)
dj.;kl oknh vi;'kh BjY;kus fouarhizek.ks dks.krhgh nkn feG.;kl oknh
ik= ukgh- R;keqGs] lnj nkok QsVkG.;kl ik= vlY;keqGs] eh
[kkyhyizek.ks vkns'k ikjhr djhr vkgs %&
%% vkns’k %%
1- ,l-lh-nkok Øekad 122@2020 QsVkG.;kr ;sr vkgs-
2- oknh o izfroknhauh nkO;kpk [kpZ Lor%Pkk Lor% lkslkok-
fnukad % 14-07-2026
¼ lqfuy ek- ikVhy ½
uxj fnok.kh U;k;k/kh’k] c`gUeqacbZ
U;k;ky; Øekad 9
Jqrys[kukph rkjh[k % 14-07-2026
fyI;arj.kkph rkjh[k % 14-07-2026
Lok{kjhph rkjh[k % 14-07-2026
-- 9 of 10 --
,l-lh- nkok Øekad 122@2020 --10-- U;k;fu.kZ;] fnukad 14-07-2026
“CERTIFIED TO BE TRUE AND CORRECT COPY OF THE ORIGINAL
SIGNED JUDGMENT/ORDER.”
Upload Date Upload Time Name of the Stenographer
14.07.2026 05:40 p.m. Mrs. Poonam Y. Pawar,
Stenographer (Grade-I)
Name of the Judge (With C.R. No.) H.H.J. SHRI. S. M. PATIL
(COURT ROOM NO.09)
Date of Pronouncement of
JUDGEMENT /ORDER
14.07.2026
JUDGEMENT /ORDER signed by
P.O. on
14.07.2026
JUDGEMENT /ORDER uploaded on 14.07.2026
-- 10 of 10 --