Full Order Text
Interim Order 9 · 16 Apr 2025 · CNR DLSH020072092023
Order Details: COPY OF ORDER Pdf Text: FIR No. 77/23 PS Vivek Vihar State v. Sajid and Anr. Page No.1 of 7 IN THE COURT OF MS. SWATI SHARMA, CHIEF JUDICIAL MAGISTRATE SHAHDARA, KKD, DELHI JUDGMENT U/S 355 Cr.PC CNR No.DLSH020072092023 a Serial No. of the case : FIR No.77/2023, PS Vivek Vihar Cr. Case No.4028/23] b Date of the commission of the offence : 20.02.2023 c Name of the Complainant : Ms. Beena Bansal d Name of Accused person and his parentage and residence : 1) Sajid S/o Sh. Sabir R/o Natko Wali Gali, Sheed Nagar, Ghaziabad, UP. 2) Suhail S/o Sh. Kafeel R/o H.No.547, Gali No.5, Purana Mustafabad, Delhi. e Offence complained of : 356/379/34 IPC f Plea of the Accused and his examination (if any) : Not guilty. g Final Order : Acquitted h Order reserved on : 16.04.2025 i Order pronounced on : 16.04.2025 BRIEF REASONS FOR THE DECISION Factual matrix and trial proceedings -- 1 of 7 -- FIR No. 77/23 PS Vivek Vihar State v. Sajid and Anr. Page No.2 of 7 1. Briefly stated the facts of the Prosecution case are that on 20.02.2023 at about 01:05 pm infront of Sanatan Dharam Mandir, B Block, Main Road, Surajmal Vihar, Delhi within the jurisdiction of PS Vivek Vihar, both accused persons in furtherance of their common intention snatched the Gold chain (weight 15 gm) belonging to complainant Ms. Beena Bansal by using criminal force on the person of complainant without her consent from her possession. In this background, a case was registered against the Accused persons for the offences punishable u/s 356/379/34 IPC. 2. Chargesheet in this matter was filed in the court on 13.07.2023 for the offences u/s 356/379/34 IPC against accused persons whereupon Cognizance was taken in this matter and the Accused persons were summoned in the court to face trial. After their appearance in the Court, copies of documents were supplied to the Accused persons in compliance of section 207 Cr.P.C. 3. Accordingly, vide order dated 05.09.2023, charge was duly served upon the Accused persons under section 356/379/34 IPC. Charge was read over and explained to Accused persons to which they pleaded not guilty and claimed trial. Thereafter, matter was taken up for recording of prosecution evidence. 4. In order to bring home the guilt of the Accused, Prosecution examined one witness as follows:- PW1 Complainant Beena Bansal The witness identified and exhibited the following documents on court record: -- 2 of 7 -- FIR No. 77/23 PS Vivek Vihar State v. Sajid and Anr. Page No.3 of 7 Ex.PW1/A Statement of complainant recorded by the police It is pertinent to note that in total 11 witnesses had been cited by the Prosecution including one public witnesses i.e. the complainant Beena Bansal. All the remaining 10 witnesses cited by Prosecution are formal witnesses. It is vital to mention here that the star witnesses to this case was the PW Beena Bansal and she witnessed the entire incident. To the utter dismay of Prosecution, the prime Prosecution witness turned hostile and even though she admitted the incident, she failed to identify the Accused persons in the court. 5. After recording of the testimony of the public witnesses in this matter, it was observed that she failed to provide any support to the Prosecution case as she failed to identify the Accused persons. The other witnesses even if examined by the prosecution could not have lend any support to the prosecution case as they were not an eye witness to the case and only could have deposed regarding the investigation conducted by them. In these circumstances, the recording of testimony of the remaining witnesses i.e. other police witnesses, was dispensed with as they were not witnesses to facts and could have only deposed with respect to the process of investigation. Upon perusal of testimonies of the prosecution witnesses as above-mentioned, it was observed that no substantial evidence against the Accused persons has been brought by them on record. 6. Therefore, since no incriminating evidence or circumstance was found against the Accused persons, recording of their statements under section 313 Cr.P.C. was also dispensed -- 3 of 7 -- FIR No. 77/23 PS Vivek Vihar State v. Sajid and Anr. Page No.4 of 7 with. Accused persons preferred not to lead any evidence in their defence and therefore, the matter was taken up for hearing of final arguments, which were duly addressed by Ld. Counsel for the Accused persons as well as Ld. APP for the State. 7. With respect to the above stated trial proceedings in this matter, reference may be made to a Division Bench judgment of the Hon’ble Delhi High Court passed in the case of Govind & Ors vs. The State (Govt. of NCT of Delhi) [104(2003) DLT 510] wherein it was held that:- “…In cases wherein ultimate chance of conviction is very bleak or there is no prospect of the case ending in conviction in such cases no useful purpose is likely to be served by allowing a criminal Prosecution and trial to continue. It is advisable to truncate or snip the proceedings and save valuable time of the courts. The trial should not be continued only for the purpose of formally completing the proceedings to pronounce the conclusion on a future date………..” Thus, keeping in view the above said guidelines this court proceeded to expedite the matter pending for more than 02 years. Summary of arguments 8. Ld. APP for the State has vehemently argued that the Accused persons be convicted for the offences with which they have been charged as the said offences are heinous in nature and leaving them free without any penalty being imposed upon them would rather make them commit similar offences again. It is further argued by Ld. APP for the State that even though PW Beena Bansal has been unable to identify the Accused persons, it is undisputed that FIR has been registered in this matter upon a statement of complainant and therefore, Accused persons deserve to be held guilty. -- 4 of 7 -- FIR No. 77/23 PS Vivek Vihar State v. Sajid and Anr. Page No.5 of 7 9. On the other hand, Ld. Defence counsel has strongly opposed the contentions of Ld. APP for the State stating that prosecution has been unable to bring even an iota of valid evidence against the Accused persons which points out towards their guilt. It is further argued by the Ld. Counsel for the Accused persons that merely because the complainant initiated the criminal proceedings against the Accused persons in this matter, they cannot be held liable for it as eye-witnesses have filed to identify the Accused persons and all the evidence brought out in this matter is nothing but herasay. Further, it was argued that when the eye-witnesses themselves have failed to identify the Accused persons in the court, no question of establishing the guilt of the Accused persons arises. Thus, Ld. Counsel for the Accused persons has strongly pressed upon setting the Accused persons at liberty by acquitting them. 10. Accordingly, this court has heard the rival submissions advanced by the Ld. APP for State and the Ld. Counsel for the Accused persons and has also perused the entire record carefully. Brief reasons for the decision 11. At the outset, before proceeding further on to discussing the weight and relevancy of evidence led by the Prosecution, this court deems it appropriate to first highlight the cardinal principles of Criminal Jurisprudence, i.e. one, that the Accused is presumed to be innocent unless proved guilty and two, that the burden upon the Prosecution lies to the extent of proving the guilt of the Accused beyond all reasonable doubts. Thus, it is incumbent upon the Prosecution to prove all the ingredients which constitute the offence so that all reasonable doubts in the case of the Prosecution are removed. It may be noted that strongest of suspicion upon the Accused persons, does not lead -- 5 of 7 -- FIR No. 77/23 PS Vivek Vihar State v. Sajid and Anr. Page No.6 of 7 to the guilt of the Accused persons. Thus, keeping in view the above stated aspects and principles of criminal jurisprudence this court shall proceed to decide upon the innocence or guilt of the Accused persons. 12. Coming to the facts of the case, the Prosecution has cited 11 witnesses in the list of witnesses annexed with the chargesheet out of which one is prime public witnesses and rest of the witnesses cited by the Prosecution are formal witnesses, who might have played some part in the investigation but were not first hand witnesses to the alleged incident. Certainly, the guilt of the Accused persons could not have been proved by the Prosecution from the mere testimony of said formal witnesses inasmuch as, the alleged incident was never committed in their presence. 13. PW Beena Bansal has failed to identify the Accused persons in the court which comes a major blow to the Prosecution case; especially because she has resiled in the witness box. 14. As is manifest from the testimony of the prosecution witness as discussed above, it is apparent that she completely failed to provide any support to the case of the prosecution and not even a shred of evidence was brought against the Accused persons from her depositions. Thus, from the aforesaid testimony itself, the case of the prosecution was rendered full of doubts in regard to the happening the incident as such. In view of the above depositions, it is apparent that despite examining relevant eye witnesses no evidence could be brought by the prosecution against the Accused persons to link them with the commission of alleged offence. -- 6 of 7 -- FIR No. 77/23 PS Vivek Vihar State v. Sajid and Anr. Page No.7 of 7 15. It is already settled in law that the burden upon the prosecution is to bring home the guilt of the Accused persons on the basis of evidence collected during investigation and when the star witnesses to the case failed to provide requisite support to prosecution case, there remains no scope of doubt with respect to the lack of sufficient proof by the prosecution to prove the guilt of the Accused persons. Moreover, as per the tenets of criminal jurisprudence, benefit of doubt in the case of the prosecution goes to the Accused persons. Conclusion 16. Therefore, keeping in view the overall facts and circumstances of this case, this court is of the considered view that the Prosecution has failed to discharge the burden imposed upon it by law of proving the guilt of the Accused persons beyond reasonable doubts. In these circumstances, this court has no hesitation in holding that Accused namely Sajid and Suhail are not guilty for the offences U/s 356/379/34 IPC. Accordingly, the Accused persons namely Sajid and Suhail stand acquitted in the present case. ANNOUNCED IN THE OPEN COURT ON 16.04.2025 (Swati Sharma) Chief Judicial Magistrate(Shahdara) Karkardooma Courts,Delhi [This judgment contains 7 signed pages] [This judgment has been directly typed to dictation.] -- 7 of 7 --
