Full Order Text
Final Order 2 · 08 Jan 2024 · CNR DLSH010080862023
Order Details: COPY OF ORDER Pdf Text: Bail Application Nos. 2635/2023 State vs. Seema & Bail Application No. 2636/2023 State vs. Rajiv Rana FIR No. 222/2023 PS Crime BranchEast Delhi U/s 21/25/29 of the NDPS Act 08.01.2024 Present: Ms. Anju Bharti, Addl. PP for the State. IO SI Neeraj Kumar in person along with police file. Sh. Mir Akhtar Hussain, Counsel for applicants Seema and Rajeev Verma. Reply to the anticipatory bail applications of applicants Seema and Rajiv Rana filed separately. Arguments on the anticipatory bail applications heard. The Ld. Counsel for the applicants has argued that the applicants have been falsely implicated in the present case. He submitted that one Sh. Anil Kumar @ Bhola, who is father inlaw of applicant Rajiv Rana got a case registered with the CBI against Inspector Jai Bhagwan, SI Om Prakash, SI Yashpal Solanki, ASI Rupesh and Anurag who constituted infamous ANTF extortion racket and there are specific allegations against Inspector Jai Bhagwan in the said CBI case. He further submitted that the CBI has arrested ASI Rupesh red handed and there is direct involvement of the above named officials of ANTF. He further submitted that the said Anil Kumar @ Bhola, his wife and Contd… -- 1 of 10 -- 2 son have been harassed and threatened for false implication for which they also filed a writ petition in which appropriate directions have been passed by the Hon’ble High Court. He further submitted that Inspector Jai Bhagwan, ASI Om Prakash and other police officials of ANTF crime branch picked up the applicant’s (Rajiv Rana) brother and his parents including applicant Seema, the mother of applicant Rajiv Rana from their residence on 11.10.2023 and they were beaten up, tortured and pressurized to withdraw the writ petition. They again picked up the applicant’s brother (Rajiv Rana) and his family members on 13.10.2023 and again visited their house on 14.10.2023 and 15.10.2023. In this manner, they are intimidating the applicants and their family members and have started manhunt. He further submitted that applicants have submitted various complaints to higher authorities but no action has been taken against the above ANTF police officials. He further submitted that there is no admissible evidence against the applicants to connect with the crime. He further submitted that the prosecution is only relying on the disclosure statements of coaccused persons which are not admissible in law. He further submitted that the CDR and mobile locations relied upon by the prosecution will not fasten the criminal liability on the applicants and it cannot be said that there was any conspiracy amongst them for supply of heroin because the applicants and the coaccused from whom the recoveries have Contd… -- 2 of 10 -- 3 been effected are the relatives and it is not unusual if they were speaking to each other. He further submitted that no notice u/s 67 was ever issued to the applicants. He further submitted that the applicants are ready to join the investigation and therefore the protection by way of anticipatory bail may be granted. The Ld. Counsel for the applicants has filed the copy of the complaints made to the higher authorities against the officials of ANTF. He has also relied upon the order in bail applications and judgments in the cases titled as Deepak Nagia vs. State, Sarla Devi vs. State, MD Irshad vs. State, Mewa Singh vs. State of Punjab, Daljit Singh vs. State of Haryana, Toofan Singh vs. State of Tamil Nadu. Per contra, Ld. Addl. PP for the State has strongly opposed the anticipatory bail applications. She submitted that the applicants are absconding and are not available for interrogation, therefore the anticipatory bail applications itself are not maintainable. She has relied upon the judgment of Hon’ble Apex Court in Lavesh vs. State. She further submitted that the co accused namely Jyoti and Lucky from whom the recovery have been effected have disclosed about the applicants/ accused as one of the source of the supply of the illegal contraband/ heroin. She further submitted that the CDR connectivity between the applicants and the coaccused persons and their locations are also of the same place which strengthens the version given by the Contd… -- 3 of 10 -- 4 coaccused persons in their disclosure statements. She further submitted that despite service of notice u/s 67, the applicants have not joined the investigation. She further submitted that the applicants and coaccused are talking in odd hours for few seconds and it shows their complicity in commission of offence. She further submitted that the CBI case and reliance on the writ petition orders or the bail order in Deepak Nagia have no bearing with the present case which is separate FIR. She further submitted that the vague and bald allegations have been levelled against Inspector Jai Bhagwan. She further submitted that Inspector Jai Bhagwan is not the accused in the said CBI case, rather he has been made a prosecution witness by the CBI to identify the voice of ASI Rupesh who was trapped. She further submitted that applicant Seema has involvement in previous 04 criminal cases and applicant Rajeev Rana has involvement in previous 02 criminal cases. She further submitted that the anticipatory bail application of coaccused Yash Rana, who is brother of applicant Rajiv Rana and son of applicant Seema has already been dismissed by this Court in which also the similar allegations against the ANTF squad particularly Inspector Jai Bhagwan were made and there was heavy reliance on the order in the writ petition which pertained to some different FIR. She further vehemently submitted that the custodial interrogation of the applicants is required to ascertain the complete chain of Contd… -- 4 of 10 -- 5 supply, money trail and further source of contraband drugs, and therefore, she has prayed for dismissal of the anticipatory bail applications. As per prosecution case, on a secret information on 20.09.2023, coaccused Jyoti along with her son Himesh @ Lucky were apprehended by the raiding team. During search a cloth bag containing light cream colour powdery substance (heroin) was recovered which weighed 480 grams from the hands of coaccused Jyoti who was sitting behind her son Lucky @ Himesh on the motorcycle. During interrogation they disclosed that they used to procure heroin from their relatives namely Seema (the applicant), his son Boby Rana (the applicant) and Yash Rana. The Ld. Counsel for the applicants has vehemently submitted that the applicants are being falsely implicated because of complaint made by fatherinlaw of applicant Rajiv Rana in CBI against the officials of ANTF and more particularly against Inspector Jai Bhagwan. It is not disputed by the Addl. PP that a CBI case has been registered against ASI Rupesh as he was trapped however inspector Jai Bhagwan is not an accused in the said CBI case and nothing has been placed on record by the applicants that there is any accusation against Inspector Jai Bhagwan. Rather as submitted by the Addl. PP that Inspector Jai Bhagwan is a prosecution witness in the said CBI case to identify Contd… -- 5 of 10 -- 6 the voice of ASI Rupesh who is accused in the said CBI case. The applicants have also alleged that to pressurize Anil Kumar @ Bhola to withdraw the said CBI case, the applicants and their family members are being picked up, tortured and beaten up by the officials of ANTF. The applicants have alleged about the said incidents on 11.10.2023 and 13.10.2023 when the applicant’s (Rajeev Rana) brother and parents and his family members were illegally detained, beaten up and tortured by the crime branch police officials however there is no police call after the said incidents or any medical reports that they were allegedly beaten up and tortured by the crime branch police officials. Of course, the applicants have made several complaints on 25.10.2023 to the higher authorities but there is no explanation if the brother of applicant Rajiv Rana and his family members were picked from their houses, beaten up and tortured on 11.10.2023 and 13.10.2023 why no PCR call or any complaint was made immediately and why no medical examination was got done. The applicants have also referred to the bail order in Deepak Nagia vs State, but the same is in different FIR No.0077/23 and on its own facts. It has no connection with the present case FIR. In the present case, coaccused Jyoti and Lucky from whom recoveries have been effected have stated in their disclosure statements about the source of supply of the heroin by the applicants. It is also stated that they used to talk through Contd… -- 6 of 10 -- 7 whatsapp call. In this regard, the CDR connectivity is relied upon by the prosecution. The Ld. Counsel for the applicants has submitted that it is not unusual if the applicants have the CDR connectivity with the coaccused persons because they are related to each other. In the normal circumstances, it may not be unusual however as per the CDR and mobile location, the applicants along with coaccused are found to be connected on the phone call during the odd hours i.e. in the night between 12.00 midnight to 4.00 am and that too for few seconds. The said fact is corroborated by disclosure statement of coaccused Jyoti and Lucky that they used to speak through whatsapp call and they used to make ordinary call for few seconds and would disconnect after conveying the message to speak through whatsapp calls. As such, it cannot be believed that the applicants and coaccused were talking with each other at odd hours for few seconds only being relatives. Moreso, when it is not a single conversation but on various occasions. In this case, notice u/s 67 of NDPS have been served upon the applicants as the same were pasted because the applicants were not found at home and the coaccused Lucky had taken the police team to the house of the applicants. The photograph of the affixation of the notice u/s 67 is seen in the police file. The said notices have been pasted on the door of the house of the applicants on 22.09.23 and 16.10.2023 but they have not turned up for joining the investigation. The proceedings Contd… -- 7 of 10 -- 8 under Section 82 Cr.P.C. have already been initiated against the applicants. In view of the same, it is apparent that the applicants have been absconding from the process of law. They have not been joining the investigation despite service of notice u/s 67 NDPS Act on two occasions. There is disclosure statements of coaccused Jyoti and Lucky from whom 480 grams of heroin which is a commercial quantity have been recovered and they have disclosed the names of the applicants as one of the source of supply of heroin. There is CDR connectivity and mobile location of the applicants/ accused with the coaccused persons which prima facie corroborates the disclosure statements of the coaccused persons. The contentions of the false implication of the applicants because of CBI case against ASI Rupesh have no bearing with the facts of the present case and do not carry any force. It has been held in the State of Haryana vs. Samarth Kumar, 2022 live law (SC) 622 by the Hon’ble Apex Court that the High court fell into an error in granting anticipatory bail to the respondent on the ground that no recovery was effected from the respondent and that they had been implicated only on the basis of the disclosure statement of the main accused Dinesh Kumar. It was held that to grant anticipatory bail in a case of this nature is not really warranted. Contd… -- 8 of 10 -- 9 In Lalit Vohra vs. State of NCT of Delhi in Bail Application No.3458/2022, the Hon’ble Delhi High Court after placing reliance in the judgment of State of Haryana vs. Samarth Kumar did not grant the anticipatory bail on the similar facts as of the present case. In Mahesh Kumar vs. State, Govt of NCT of Delhi, Bail Application No.829/2020 also the contention was raised by the petitioner that only evidence against the petitioner was the disclosure statement of coaccused which is inadmissible in evidence and in view thereof itself the petitioner is entitled to anticipatory bail. The Hon’ble High Court did not accept the said contention and held that “This court is not inclined to grant anticipatory bail to the petitioner for the reason custodial interrogation of the petitioner is necessary to ascertain the complete chain of supply and sale of the contraband and to find out whether besides the petitioner, other people are also involved”. Accordingly, the Hon’ble High Court dismissed the anticipatory bail application. In view of the aforesaid discussions, as the custodial interrogation of the applicants/ accused is required to unearth the modus operandi of supply of heroin racket and money trail and to find out whether besides the applicants/ accused, who other people are also involved and to unearth the entire drug racket, no case is made out for grant of anticipatory bail to the Contd… -- 9 of 10 -- 10 applicants/ accused. Hence, the anticipatory bail applications are hereby dismissed. Copy dasti. (Balwant Rai Bansal) Special Judge (NDPS Act), Shahdara, Karkardooma Courts Delhi/ 08.01.2024 -- 10 of 10 --
