Full Order Text
Interim Order 4 · 12 Jan 2024 · CNR DLSH010080402023
Order Details: COPY OF JUDICIAL PROCEEDINGS Pdf Text: -1- Bail Matters No. 2630/2023 State Vs. Navneet Singh FIR No. 460/2023 PS Jyoti Nagar U/s 420/468/471/120-B/34 IPC 12.01.2024 This is an application u/s 438 Cr.PC for grant of anticipatory bail moved on behalf of the applicant/accused Navneet Singh. Present:- Sh. Sobit, Ld. Additional PP for the State. Sh. Shiv Kumar Sharma and Ms. Shivani, Ld. counsel for applicant/accused Navneet Singh. Sh. Sandeep Chaudhary, Ld. counsel for complainant along with husband of complainant. IO/ASI Patil Kumar is present today. ORDER 1. It is argued by Ld. counsel for accused that accused persons have been falsely implicated in the present case and applicant/accused and his family members i.e. Smt. Gurmeet Kaur (mother, now expired), Harman Singh (son), Amarjeet Singh, Sister Daljeet Kaur and Amrit Kaur, nephew Harsimrat Singh and Jasmeet Singh were bonafide purchasers of land measuring 0.1850 hectare situated at Narsan Khurd Pargana Manglore, Roorkee, Haridwar through registered sale deed executed by one Manvir Singh purchased in the year 2015 and registered at SR Roorkee and the applicant and his family members have paid full consideration and name of the applicant and his family members were entered into the revenue record and when they were need of money due to cancer treatment of sister of applicant, they had entered into agreement to sale with one Vikram and he paid them Rs. 10 Lakh as earnest money. It is further submitted that at the time of sale deed, the said Vikram requested them to execute sale deed in favour of Smt. Poonam Devi, who was not to know them prior to the said sale deed and after the sale deed, actual -- 1 of 4 -- -2- and physical possession had been delivered to Smt. Poonam Devi, which is acknowledged by her in sale deed and the said Poonam Devi got the property mutated in her name. Now, the said Poonam Devi in connivance with police is trying to frame the accused in a false case just to extort the money. It is submitted that police official have not given any notice u/s 41 (A) Cr.PC. 2. The bail application is opposed by Ld. APP for the State as well as Ld. Counsel for the complainant who have argued that the applicant/accused and his family members have malafidely sold the property to the complainant despite knowing this fact that same has been sold to the other person namely Sandeep by one Manvir Singh and one case was pending in the Revenue Court, Roorkee regarding the rights in the property and the mutation in the name of complainant is cancelled by the Revenue Court and when complainant sold the property to other person, then, property did not get mutated in his name and these facts came to his knowledge and he got the FIR registered against the complainant and then, complainant got registered an FIR against the applicant/accused and his family members due to the cheating committed by them and they have taken an amount of Rs. 74 lakh from the complainant. 3. IO submits that he had issued a notice u/s 41 (A) Cr.PC against the applicant/accused and his family members and they had not cooperated during investigation though they had appeared before the IO and have not supplied the proper documents and custodial interrogation of applicant/accused is required. 4. I have heard the rival contentions of the bail application and perused the record. 5. The present case was registered on complaint of one Poonam Devi who alleged that applicant/accused and his family members had cheated her of Rs. 74 Lakh and one Vikram Gujar, who -- 2 of 4 -- -3- was a property dealer and known to her husband and he told her husband to buy above said property at Roorkee and told that he was buying that property for total consideration of Rs. 74 Lakh, out of which Rs. 10 Lakh have been paid as earnest money and executed the agreement to sale with the applicant/accused and his family members and that he was not in position to arrange the rest of money and later the property was executed in the name of Poonam Devi, complainant by applicant/accused and his family members and an agreement was executed between Vikram and husband of complainant. On 24.06.2017, the property was sold to the complainant. Ld. counsel submits that a accused has cooperated in the investigation after service of notice u/s 41 (A) Cr.PC. As per the reply of the IO, agreement to sale was executed between Virender (husband of the complainant) and Vikram in the year 2016 and Rs. 16,50,000/- have been paid as earnest money and one Manvir had executed the said property in the name of Sandeep and Raj Kumar on 10.06.2016 and also to applicant/accused and his family members on 20.03.2016, thus the applicant/accused and his family members were prima-facie bonafide purchasers of the said property from Manvir and accused Manvir is the real accused, who had sold the said property to two persons and the Amarjeet had sold the property to complainant on 20.06.2017. 6. FIR is registered u/s 420/471/468/120-B/34 IPC. The offences are maximum punishable upto 7 years and in view of the guidelines of the Arnesh Kumar case, IO has served the notice upon the applicant/accused u/s 41 (A) Cr.PC and as per IO, they had joined the investigation. The investigation is dependent upon the collection of the documents and it is to be ascertained whether the applicant/accused and his family member were having knowledge of this property being a disputed one and sold to other persons and case was pending at Revenue Court at the time of executing the sale deed -- 3 of 4 -- -4- in favour of the complainant. 7. In the circumstances, the applicant/accused is directed to join the investigation and extend all the cooperation to the IO. IO has not submitted if he has given any notice u/s 91 Cr.PC to the appellant/accused for production of certain documents pertaining to case. The IO shall prepare the record of joining of investigation by accused and follow the guidelines in Amandeep Johar Vs. State of NCT of Delhi and submit a report on next date. Put up for consideration on 20.01.2024. Till then, applicant/accused Navneet Singh is not to be arrested. Copy of this order be sent to IO/SHO concerned and be given dasti to Ld. counsel for applicant/accused. (Kumar Rajat) ASJ-07/SHD/KKD Courts/Delhi 12.01.2024 -- 4 of 4 --
