Full Order Text
Final Order 8 · 07 Feb 2024 · CNR DLSH010080402023
Order Details: COPY OF ORDER Pdf Text: Bail Matters No. 2630/2023 State Vs. Navneet Singh FIR No. 460/2023 PS Jyoti Nagar U/s 420/468/471/120-B/34 IPC 07.02.2024 This is an application u/s 438 Cr.PC for grant of anticipatory bail moved on behalf of the applicant/accused Navneet Singh. Present:- Sh. Sobit, Ld. Additional PP for the State. Ms. Shivani, Ld. counsel for applicant/accused Navneet Singh. Sh. Sandeep Chaudhary, Ld. counsel for complainant. IO/ASI Patil Kumar is present today. ORDER 1. It is argued by Ld. counsel for applicant/accused that he has been falsely implicated in the present case along with his family members i.e. Smt. Gurmeet Kaur (mother, now expired), Harsimrat Singh, Amarjeet Singh, Sister Daljeet Kaur and Harman Singh, Jasmeet Singh and Amrit Kaur, who are bonafide purchasers of land measuring 0.1850 hectare situated at Narsan Khurd Pargana Manglore, Roorkee, Haridwar through registered sale deed executed by one Manvir Singh purchased in the year 2015 and registered at SR Roorkee and the applicant and his family members have paid full consideration. Name of the applicant and his family members were entered into the revenue record and when they were in need of money due to cancer treatment of sister of applicant, they had entered into agreement to sale with one Vikram and he paid them Rs. 10 Lakh as earnest money. It is further submitted that at the time of sale deed, the said Vikram requested them to execute sale deed in favour of Smt. Poonam Devi, who was not known to them prior to the said sale deed and after the sale deed, actual and physical possession had been -- 1 of 7 -- -2- delivered to Smt. Poonam Devi, which is acknowledged by her in sale deed and the said Poonam Devi got the property mutated in her name. Now, the said Poonam Devi in connivance with police is trying to frame the accused in a false case just to extort the money. It is submitted that police official had given any notice u/s 41 (A) Cr.PC and in compliance of the same, applicant/accused had joined the investigation and no recovery has to be effected from the accused, thus, his custodial interrogation is not required and the matter is based on documentary evidence which has been collected by the IO and no purpose would be served by keeping the accused behind the bars. Ld. Counsel further submits that IO had given notice u/s 41 A after directions of this Court and he has violated the procedure in the standing order of Commissioner of Police dt. 04.06.2020 and also violated the various guidelines of the Apex Court. 2. The bail application is opposed by Ld. APP for the State as well as Ld. Counsel for the complainant, who have argued that the applicant/accused and his family members have malafidely sold the property to the complainant despite knowing this fact that same has been sold to the other person namely Sandeep by one Manvir Singh and one case was pending in the Revenue Court, Roorkee regarding the rights in the property and the mutation in the name of complainant is cancelled by the Revenue Court and when complainant sold the property to other person, then, property did not get mutated in her name and these facts came to her knowledge and he got the FIR registered against the complainant and then, complainant got registered an FIR against the applicant/accused and his family members due to the cheating committed by them and they have taken an amount of Rs. 74 lakh from the complainant. 3. IO submits that he had issued a notice u/s 41 (A) Cr.PC to the applicant/accused and he had joined the investigation and -- 2 of 7 -- -3- custodial interrogation of applicant/accused is not required and that Amarjeet Singh was involved in the case and he had joined the investigation on 22.12.2023 and after being served notice u/s 91 Cr.PC he did not cooperate and hide the facts and on 28.12.2023, he stated that he got the possession of above said property in the year 2016, but on 19.01.2024, he stated that he has got the possession of said property at the time of Ikrarnama in the year 2010 and as per the report of Tehsildar Roorkee, a notice related to restoration was served on Amarjeet and he did not appear there and sold the property to Poonam Devi. IO further submits that the said property was sold by Amarjeet and his family members despite the knowledge that ownership of said property was sub-judice before Revenue Court of Tehsildar and Amarjeet had conspiracy with Manvir and prepared forged documents i.e. sale deed of the above said property. 4. I have heard the rival contentions of the bail application and perused the record. 5. The present case was registered on complaint of one Poonam Devi, who alleged that applicant/accused and his family members had cheated her of Rs. 74 Lakh and one Vikram Gujar, who was a property dealer and known to her husband, told her husband to buy above said property at Roorkee and told that he was buying that property for total consideration of Rs. 74 Lakh, out of which Rs. 10 Lakh have been paid as earnest money and executed the agreement to sale with the applicant/accused and his family members and that he was not in position to arrange the rest of money and later, the property was executed in the name of Poonam Devi and complainant and his family members and an agreement was executed between Vikram and husband of complainant. On 24.06.2017, the property was sold to the complainant. -- 3 of 7 -- -4- 6. As per the reply filed by the IO, a complaint was filed by Poonam Devi, R/o Ashok Nagar, Delhi, alleging that her husband Dr. Virender Kumar and Vikram Singh were close friends and there was bond of credibility between them and in the year 2016, Vikram approached them representing himself to be the owner of property at Khasra No. 112, Village Narsan Khurd Mangalore, Tehsil Roorkee, Uttarakhand, measuring 1850 Sq. meters and he wanted to sale the same for a total consideration of Rs. 74 Lakh and an agreement to sale was made and earnest money of Rs. 16,50,000/- was paid by complainant to the said Vikram by cheque and in cash and rest amount was to be paid on or before 20.02.2017, at the time of execution of sale deed. Later on, it came out that the said land did not belong to Vikram and he sold the same and did not inform the complainant and he was not the actual owner and he told that the land belonged to his known persons later and assured that he would get the sale deed executed as per the time mentioned in the agreement to sale and then, he got the land transferred through one Amarjeet Singh and his family members by virtue of registered sale deed in favour of complainant Poonam Devi in the year 2017, after taking balance money and Poonam Devi paid Rs. 74 Lakh to Vikram, Amarjeet Singh and his family members. One Manvir had executed the said property in the name of Sandeep and Raj Kumar on 10.06.2013 and also to applicant/ accused and his family members on 26.03.2016, but agreement to sale between Manvir and Amarjeet got challenged at Tehsil Roorkee on 21.09.2016 as a restoration petition filed by one Mahender Singh and Vikram was arrested on 14.12.2023, who revealed that the said property was under objection at Manglore, Roorkee, Uttarakhand and during the investigation, the said Sandeep Dixit, Sanjay Dixit and Mahender Singh had stated that Amarjeet Singh and his family members were aware of the previous sale of said property to Sandeep -- 4 of 7 -- -5- Dixit and Raj Kumar and when it came to the notice that Manvir had already sold the property, then Amarjeet had pressurized Sandeep Dixit to sale the said property to him and his family members. 7. In the present case, the property was sold to accused Amarjeet and his family members including applicant/accused by one Manvir Singh, who was proprietor of M/s Jai Shree Steel Rolling Mill on 26.03.2016 through registered sale deed and vide order of Revenue Court of Naib Tehsildar, Mangalore, Roorkee, Uttarakhand dt. 22.06.2016, the name of M/s Jai Shree Steel Rolling Mill, Roorkee through its proprietor Manvir was deleted from the record and the said property was mutated in the name of applicant/accused as well as his other family members as all had purchased 250 Sq. Yds. property each. Then, the said property was sold by the applicant/accused as well as other family members to one Poonam Devi vide registered sale deed dt. 24.06.2017 and vide order dt. 05.01.2019 of Naib Tehsildar, Roorkee, the property was mutated in the name of Poonam Devi and the name of Amarjeet Singh and others were deleted from the record. 8. An application for restoration of the said case of mutation was filed by one Mahender Singh on 19.09.2017, claiming that M/s Jai Shree Steel Rolling Mill, Roorkee had no right to sale the said property and he had prayed for cancellation of order dt. 22.06.2016, and restoring the case to its original number. The Revenue Court, Tehsildar, Roorkee vide order dt. 18.09.2021 allowed the said application and restored the case to its original number. 9. It is nowhere mentioned or apparent from the said order dt 18.09.2021 that applicant/accused or his family member were aware of the said proceedings. 10. The applicant/accused and his family members were the bonafide purchasers of the said property from Manvir, proprietor of the above said firm and Manvir is the real accused, who had sold the -- 5 of 7 -- -6- said property to two parties including applicant/accused and his family members. Applicant/accused and his family members had sold the property to the complainant on 24.06.2017 and on 22.06.2016, the said property was mutated in the name of applicant/accused and his family members, so it cannot be said at this stage that applicant/accused and his family members were aware of the proceedings at the Revenue Court and there was no objection or any order of the court when the property was transferred to complainant Poonam Devi. Further, said Poonam Devi despite knowing the fact that accused Vikram was not the owner of the property, got the property executed in her name and purchased through Registered Sale Deed from applicant/accused and his family members and also got it mutated in her name without raising any objection either with the applicant/accused and others or Vikram. The complainant filed the present FIR only after she further sold the said property which was not mutated in the name of that purchaser, who got registered a separate FIR against the complainant for which she has filed the quashing before the Hon’ble High Court. 11. FIR is registered u/s 420/471/468/120-B/34 IPC. The offences are maximum punishable up to 7 years. It is not clear from the evidence collected so far as to what documents are forged by the applicant/accused and his family members as property in question was sold only through Registered Sale Deed and mutated by order of concerned Tehsildar time to time. In view of the guidelines of the Arnesh Kumar case, IO has served the notice upon the applicant/accused u/s 41 (A) Cr.PC and he and others had joined the investigation. The investigation is dependent upon the collection of the documents and most of the documents have been collected and IO submits that he does not need custodial interrogation of applicant/accused now. Nothing is to be recovered from the applicant/ -- 6 of 7 -- -7- accused and it is also submitted that on record there was only transaction of Rs. 44 Lakh instead of Rs. 74 Lakh as claimed. No purpose would be served by sending the accused behind the bars and he has already under taken through his counsel that he is ready to join the investigation and cooperate and has already joined and cooperated the investigation and he has not misused the interim protection granted during the pendency of bail. 12. Considering the above facts and circumstances of the case and the guidelines of the Hon’ble Supreme Court regarding offences punishable up to 7 years, the anticipatory bail application of applicant/accused Navneet Singh is allowed and in the event of his arrest, IO/SHO are directed to release him on his furnishing a personal bond in the sum of Rs. 50,000/- with one surety like amount subject to following condition:- i) That the applicant/accused shall make himself available for interrogation by IO/SHO concerned as and when required. ii) That the applicant/accused shall not, directly or indirectly, make any inducement, threat or promise to any person acquainted with the facts of the case, including complainant so as to dissuade her from disclosing such facts of the court or to any police officer. iii) That the applicant/accused shall not leave India without the previous permission of the court. 13. Nothing mentioned herein shall tantamount to any expression on the merits of the case. The bail application is accordingly disposed of. Copy of this order be sent to IO/SHO concerned and dasti to the counsel for applicant/accused. (Kumar Rajat) ASJ-07/SHD/KKD Courts/Delhi 07.02.2024 -- 7 of 7 --
