Full Order Text
Final Order 16 · 10 Nov 2025 · CNR DLSH010077562023
Order Details: COPY OF ORDER Pdf Text: CS 901/23 Sh. Vipin Sharma v. Sh. Jagroop Sharma and ors. Page No. 1 of 8 IN THE COURT OF SH. MOHAMMAD EHTESHAM, DISTRICT JUDGE -03, SHAHDARA DISTRICT, KARKARDOOMA COURTS, DELHI CS No. 901/2023 CNR No. DLSH01- 007756-2023 Sh. Vipin Sharma S/o Sh. Jagroop Sharma Permanent R/o House no. 1/5104, First Floor, Gali no. 4, Balbir Nagar, Shahdara, Delhi-110032 presently, residing at D-194, New Ashok Nagar, Delhi-110096. ........Plaintiffs Versus 1. Sh. Jagroop Sharma S/o lateSh. Ram Chander Sharma 2. Smt. Sheela W/o Sh. Jagroop Sharma 3. Sh. Pankaj Sharma S/o Sh. Jagroop Shara All R/o House no. 1/5104, Ground Floor, Gali no. 4, Balbir Nagar, Shahdara, Delhi-110032 ........Defendants -- 1 of 8 -- CS 901/23 Sh. Vipin Sharma v. Sh. Jagroop Sharma and ors. Page No. 2 of 8 Date of institution : 12.12.2023 Arguments on maintainability concluded on : 09.09.2024. Date of Order : 10.11.2025 Order : Plaint rejected under Order VII Rule 11(a) and (d) CPC. ORDER 1. Matter is listed today for order on maintainability of the present suit. 2. Ld. Counsel for Defendants argued that the Plaintiff filed present suit for declaration and permanent injunction claiming themselves as co-owners of the suit property bearing No. 1/5104, Gali No. 4, Shahdara, Delhi-32 wherein they claimed that the suit property was purchased by the grandfather of the plaintiff as well as defendant No.3 and the father of the defendant No. 1. 3. Ld. Counsel for Defendants further argued that the plaintiff admitted in the para No. 5 of the plaint that the grandfather of the plaintiff namely Ram Chander Sharma was having one son i.e. defendant No. 1 and three daughters namely Kiran Wati, Suraj Wati and Tarawati (sisters of the defendant No. 1) and after demise of grandfather all the four above said persons become the owner qua the suit property in 1986 and that it is further mentioned in the said para that the sisters of the defendant No. 1 namely namely Kiran Wati, Suraj Wati and Tara -- 2 of 8 -- CS 901/23 Sh. Vipin Sharma v. Sh. Jagroop Sharma and ors. Page No. 3 of 8 Wati relinquished their 3/4th share in favour of the defendant No. 1vide relinquishment deed dated 03.02.2010 and as such the defendant No. 1 got 3/4th share in the suit property in addition to 1/4th share which was co-owned separately after death of the grandfather of Plaintiff. 4. Ld. Counsel for Defendants further argued that it is well settled law that in the life time of the father, the son cannot be claimed as co-owner of the property for which the father is the absolute owner and as such the contention of the plaintiff is contrary to law and has no merits. 5. Ld. Counsel for Defendants further argued that suit of the plaintiff is without cause of action and there is no occasion when the plaintiffs become co-owner with the defendant No. 1 in the property which is in exclusively ownership of the defendant No.1. 6. Ld. Counsel for Defendants further argued that present suit does not disclose a cause of action based on any existing legal right of the plaintiff in the suit property and, on the plaint’s own averments; the claim is barred by settled law on Hindu succession and declaratory relief. 7. Ld. Counsel for Plaintiffs argued that the after the execution of the said relinquishment deed in favour of defendant no.1 by his 3 sisters qua their 3/4th share in the suit property, the defendant no. 1 became the absolute owner of only 3/4th share of the suit property. Ld. Counsel for Defendants further argued that the plaintiff along with his -- 3 of 8 -- CS 901/23 Sh. Vipin Sharma v. Sh. Jagroop Sharma and ors. Page No. 4 of 8 brother, Defendant No. 1 and Defendant No.3 being the legal heirs of Late Sh. Ram Chander Sharma, are co-owners and are entitled for the share of 1/16th each out of 1/4th share. Ld. Counsel for Defendant relied on the judgement of Hon’ble High Court of Madras passed in the case titled as S. Sampoornam vs. C. K. Shanmugan & Ors. CMP No. 13872 of 2016. 8. I have heard the learned counsel for parties. I have also perused the plaint and documents on record. 9. It is settled law that if the plaint does not disclose a cause of action or the suit appears from the statements in the plaint to be barred by law, it must be rejected Under O.VII R.11(a) & (d). 10. Perusal of Plaint revels following material averments:- i. The suit property was purchased by the plaintiffs’ grandfather (Late Sh. Ram Chander Sharma) in 1959 as a vacant plot and later constructed upon. It is thus pleaded as his self-acquired property. ii. The grandfather died intestate in 1986. He was survived by one son (Defendant No.1) and three daughters namely namely Kiran Wati, Suraj Wati and Tara Wati iii. The plaint acknowledges that the three daughters executed a relinquishment deed dated 03.02.2010 in favour of Defendant No. iv. The plaintiff (sons of Defendant No.1) claim himself to be co-owner and assert 1/16th share “out of 1/4th share and seeks a declaration that subsequent documents (an alleged 1986 agreement, a 2000 agreement, and a 2022 sale deed by defendant no.2 to defendant no.3) are null -- 4 of 8 -- CS 901/23 Sh. Vipin Sharma v. Sh. Jagroop Sharma and ors. Page No. 5 of 8 and void, with a permanent injunction. He also pleads dispossession and police complaints but does not claim possession in this suit. 11. Thus on the plaintiffs’ own showing, the suit property was the self-acquired property of his grandfather and devolved in 1986 on his Class I heirs under Sections 8 and 19 of the Hindu Succession Act, 1956 namely, his one son and three daughters, in equal shares. 12. In the case titled as ‘Harish Chander Gupta and Ors. Vs. Rakesh Gupta and Ors.’ (RFA No. 268/2006 Decided On: 17.09.2018), Hon’ble High Court of Delhi held as under:- “4.In law, an HUF comes into existence if a person inherits a property from his parental ancestors prior to 1956, and thereafter, the said property continues in the name of the person who inherited it. Upon the death of the said person, after 1956, such property would be inherited as an HUF property. The only other way an HUF can come into existence after 1956 is if a person throws his property into common hotchpotch. If a person inherits a property from his parental ancestors after 1956, then such inheritance of property is deemed to be self-acquired in his hands as held by the Supreme Court in its judgments in the cases of Commissioner of Wealth Tax, Kanpur and Others v. Chander Sen and Others, MANU/SC/0265/1986 : (1986) 3 SCC 567 and Yudhishter v. Ashok Kumar, MANU/SC/0525/1986 : (1987) 1 SCC 204.” 13. In view of the above legal position, the Plaintiffs’ claim to co-ownership on the footing of coparcenary is untenable, as the Plaint discloses no facts showing how any HUF came into existence— specifically, there is no pleading that the suit property was inherited from a parental ancestor prior to 1956 and continued as such, nor that any self-acquired property was thrown into the common hotchpotch. In absence of such foundational averments, no basis is disclosed to treat -- 5 of 8 -- CS 901/23 Sh. Vipin Sharma v. Sh. Jagroop Sharma and ors. Page No. 6 of 8 the suit property as HUF property, and the claim of coparcenary rights runs contrary to the law discussed in preceding para. 14. Property that devolves under Section 8 Hindu succession Act upon a son is his separate/absolute property and does not become coparcenary property in his hands so as to confer a birth right on his sons. This is settled by the Supreme Court in catena of judgements. Reliance can be placed on Commissioner of Wealth Tax v. Chander Sen ; 1986 SCR (3) 254. Reliance can also be placed on Uttam v. Saubhag Singh; AIR 2016 SUPREME COURT 1169. 15. In the case law of S. Sampoornam (Supra) relied on by Plaintiff, the succession opened in the year 1951 i.e. prior to the commencement of the Hindu Succession Act, 1956, therefore the facts therein are entirely different from the present suit. 16. Therefore, the plaintiffs (being grandsons) acquired no coparcenary right in the suit property merely by birth, and during the lifetime of Defendant No.1 they cannot claim that he is “co-owner” entitled to “1/16th share each” is contrary to the above law. 17. A suit for declaration requires the plaintiff to assert an existing legal character or right to property; a mere assertion of “ancestral” status without a legally cognizable title is insufficient. Declaratory relief is generally granted to quiet title where there is a cloud on an established right however in the case in hand without a -- 6 of 8 -- CS 901/23 Sh. Vipin Sharma v. Sh. Jagroop Sharma and ors. Page No. 7 of 8 disclosed legally sustainable title, the suit for declaration is not maintainable. 18. As the plaint discloses no legal estate or share in the suit property, the prayers to declare third-party documents void are not founded on any subsisting right. 19. An injunction is a consequential relief that follows a right; in the absence of disclosed title or possessory entitlement, a bare injunction against alienation cannot be granted. Where title is neither established nor pleaded on a tenable legal basis, a suit for injunction to restrain dealings with property fails at the very inception. 20. The plaint, read as a whole, does not disclose a cause of action based on any existing legal right of the plaintiff in the suit property, attracting Order VII Rule 11(a) CPC. 21. Further, in view of the settled position that property devolving under Section 8 in 1986 became the separate property of defendant no.1 and not coparcenary/HUF property, the suit claiming co-ownership by birth is barred by law, attracting Order VII Rule 11(d) CPC. 22. Thus the reliefs of declaration and permanent injunction are barred by law on the plaint’s own averments and disclose no enforceable right. 23. Consequently, the plaint, read as a whole demonstrates an illusory cause of action and is barred by law within the meaning of Order VII Rule 11(a) and (d) CPC. -- 7 of 8 -- CS 901/23 Sh. Vipin Sharma v. Sh. Jagroop Sharma and ors. Page No. 8 of 8 24. In view of the above the plaint is rejected under Order VII Rule 11(a) and (d) CPC. 25. In view of the Explanation to Section 2(2) CPC, rejection of Plaint amounts to a decree. Decree sheet be drawn accordingly. 26. Pending applications if any stands disposed off. 27. No order as to costs. File be consigned to record room. (Announced in the open court on 10.11.2025). (Mohammad Ehtesham) District Judge-03(Shahdara), Karkardooma Courts, Delhi 10.11.2025. -- 8 of 8 --
