Full Order Text
Order 5 · 22 Jan 2025 · CNR DLSH010076572024
Order Details: COPY OF ORDER Pdf Text: Punjab National Bank vs. Sanjeev Moses Davidson CNR No.: DLSH01-007657-2024 Misc. DJ No. 980/2024 22.01.2025 Present : Mr. B.K. Mishra, Ld. Counsel for the non-applicant / plaintiff ( through Video Conferencing). Mr. Atul Chaturvedi, Ld. Counsel for the applicant / defendant. O R D E R 1. The defendant filed an application under Order 9 Rule 13 of ‘ The Code of Civil Procedure, 1908’ ( Hereinafter referred to as ‘CPC’) seeking setting aside of ex-parte decree dated 20.10.2023. 2. The defendant also filed an application under Section 5 of ‘ The Limitation Act, 1963’ for condonation of delay in filing of the said application and another application under Section 151 CPC for stay of the execution proceedings. 3. Ld. Counsel for the defendant contended that the defendant could not file written statement or defend the suit as he was attending his ailing wife since 7-8 years. He contended that the defendant’s wife is in a state of coma and therefore, the defendant could not defend the suit. 4. On the other hand, Ld. Counsel for the plaintiff contended that the defendant was duly served with the summons of the suit on 07.10.2022 and thereafter, his counsel appeared before the Court on 21.11.2022. 1 of 5 -- 1 of 5 -- 5. Ld. Counsel for the plaintiff contended that thereafter, the defendant neither filed written statement nor appeared leading to closure of his right to file written statement, vide order dated 19.12.2022. He contended that the application for setting aside the decree barred by limitation. He contended that the defendant has not furnished any sufficient cause which prevented him from appearing before the Court to contest the suit. 6. On 27.07.2022, the plaintiff instituted a suit for recovery of Rs. 5,74,412/- alongwith pendente- lite and future interest @ 11.40% per annum against the defendant on the averments that the plaintiff sanctioned and disbursed loan of Rs. 5,00,000/- to the defendant on 10.03.2017. However, the defendant did not repay the loan and the said loan account was declared ‘ Non-Performing Asset’ on 30.06.2019. The plaintiff issued demand notice dated 10.02.2020 and loan recall notice dated 03.08.2020 to the defendant. 7. The summons issued by this Court to the defendant was served on 07.10.2022. Thereafter, Ld. Counsel for the defendant appeared before the Court on 21.11.2022. However, the defendant neither filed written statement nor appeared. Therefore, the Court closed right of the defendant to file written statement, vide order dated 19.12.2022. 8. During evidence, the plaintiff examined Mr. Balbir Singh Narang, Senior Manager as PW-1. 2 of 5 -- 2 of 5 -- 9. This Court, vide judgment dated 20.10.2023, decreed the suit with cost and passed an ex-parte decree against the defendant in the sum of Rs. 5,33,017/- alongwith interest @ 6% per annum w.e.f. 01.09.2020 till realization. 10. It is apposite to refer Order 9 Rule 13 CPC, as under: “13. Setting aside decree ex parte against defendants In any case in which a decree is passed ex parte against a defendant, he may apply to the court by which the decree was passed for an order to set it aside; and if he satisfies the court that the summons was not duly served, or that he was prevented by any sufficient cause from appearing when the suit was called on for hearing, the court shall make an order setting aside the decree as against him upon such terms as to costs, payment into court or otherwise as it thinks fit, and shall appoint a day for proceeding with the suit: PROVIDED that where the decree is of such a nature that it cannot be set aside as against such defendant only it may be set aside as against all or any of the other defendants also: [PROVIDED FURTHER that no court shall set aside a decree passed ex parte merely on the ground that there has been an irregularity in the service of summons, if it is satisfied that the defendant had notice of the date of hearing and had sufficient time to appear and answer the plaintiff’s claim Explanation: Where there has been an appeal against a decree passed ex parte under this rule, and the appeal has been disposed of on any ground other than the ground that the appellant has withdrawn the appeal, no application shall lie under this rule of setting aside the ex parte decree.” 3 of 5 -- 3 of 5 -- 11. The Court can set-aside a decree passed ex- parte on the ground that the defendant was not duly served with the summons or the defendant was prevented by any sufficient cause from appearing when the suit was called on for hearing. 12. The case of the defendant is that he could not appear and contest the suit as he was attending his bed-ridden wife. In that regard, he filed invoices dated 04.01.2024, 19.10.2024, 19.11.2024 and 04.12.2024 regarding purchase of certain medical instruments. He filed two photographs in order to demonstrate medical condition of his wife. 13. Though there is no document on record pertaining to ailment and treatment of his wife for the period from 21.11.2022 to 31.12.2023, there are certain documents pertaining to purchase of medical equipments in the year 2024. 14. Though the defendant has not filed sufficient and credible material for seeking setting aside of ex- parte decree, however, the defendant should be accorded an opportunity to contest the suit on merits and to prove his defence. 15. Laws of pleading are based on natural justice. It must be the endeavor of the Court to provide just and reasonable opportunity to every party to prosecute / defend its case. It has always been emphasized that the cases should be ‘ adjudicated’ rather ‘ terminated’. The Courts must allow light to come from any corner which can enable it to decide the lis and generate confidence in the parties that they were afforded real opportunity to prosecute / contest the case. 4 of 5 -- 4 of 5 -- 16. In view of the medical condition of wife of the defendant, as argued, photographs and invoices of surgical equipments, this Court is of the considered opinion that the defendant should be given an opportunity to defend the suit. However, the defendant must be put to certain terms, in view of the nature of the material pertaining to the grounds furnished by him. 17. As regards contention that the application under Order 9 Rule 13 CPC barred by limitation, it can be stated that the reasons, as aforesaid, are also germane to the application seeking condonation of delay. Accordingly, the application under Section 5 of ‘ The Limitation Act, 1963’ is allowed and delay in filing of the application for setting aside of the ex-parte decree is condoned. 18. The application under Order 9 Rule 13 CPC seeking setting aside of ex-parte decree dated 20.10.2023 is allowed and ex-parte judgment and decree dated 20.10.2023 are set-aside subject to deposit of cost of Rs. 25,000/- with the plaintiff within two weeks from today. The cost, so imposed, be deposited with the plaintiff and a receipt thereof be shown to the Court. To come up for further proceedings on 06.02.2025. Sanjay Sharma-II DJ (Commercial Court)-03 Shahdara, KKD, Delhi NK 22.01.2025 5 of 5 -- 5 of 5 --
